-
Dissipative parametric resonance in a modulated 1D Bose gas
Authors:
Amaury Micheli,
Scott Robertson
Abstract:
We synthesize results of previous works to give a coherent and self-consistent account of parametric resonance in a modulated quasi-1D Bose gas in the presence of a dissipative mechanism. The resonant behaviour is shown to be largely in line with the predictions of a phenomenological model published in 2014, while the associated dissipation rate is consistent with that derived in 2022 from three-w…
▽ More
We synthesize results of previous works to give a coherent and self-consistent account of parametric resonance in a modulated quasi-1D Bose gas in the presence of a dissipative mechanism. The resonant behaviour is shown to be largely in line with the predictions of a phenomenological model published in 2014, while the associated dissipation rate is consistent with that derived in 2022 from three-wave mixing processes between the produced phonons and thermal fluctuations.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
Vortical scattering channel in an aquatic space-time
Authors:
Alessia Biondi,
Scott Robertson,
Germain Rousseaux
Abstract:
Effective field theory descriptions of surface waves on flowing fluids have tended to assume that the flow is irrotational, but this assumption is often impractical due to boundary layer friction and flow recirculation. Here we develop an effective field theory of surface waves in an incompressible, inviscid flow that includes vorticity due to shear. Our model consists of a two-layer flow: an uppe…
▽ More
Effective field theory descriptions of surface waves on flowing fluids have tended to assume that the flow is irrotational, but this assumption is often impractical due to boundary layer friction and flow recirculation. Here we develop an effective field theory of surface waves in an incompressible, inviscid flow that includes vorticity due to shear. Our model consists of a two-layer flow: an upper layer with no vorticity and a lower layer with constant vorticity. We consider linear, long-wavelength perturbations on top of such a flow, and find that these can be described by two coupled scalar fields admitting three elementary excitations, one more than the usual two found in irrotational flows. We compute the scattering coefficients pertaining to modes falling into an analogue black hole. Our approach provides a more realistic framework for simulating gravitational wave phenomena possibly with an internal structure mimicking quantum gravity effects in laboratory settings.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
On the art of designing effective space-times with free surface flows in Analogue Gravity
Authors:
Alexis Bossard,
Nicolas James,
Valentin Jules,
Johan Fourdrinoy,
Scott Robertson,
Germain Rousseaux
Abstract:
Accelerating/decelerating trans-critical flows (waterfalls/cataracts) are analogous to space-times of black holes/white fountains since the pioneering work of Sch{ü}tzhold \& Unruh in 2002. A single number is usually employed to classify trans-criticality namely the local depth Froude number which is the ratio between the local current speed and the local celerity of long gravity waves analogo…
▽ More
Accelerating/decelerating trans-critical flows (waterfalls/cataracts) are analogous to space-times of black holes/white fountains since the pioneering work of Sch{ü}tzhold \& Unruh in 2002. A single number is usually employed to classify trans-criticality namely the local depth Froude number which is the ratio between the local current speed and the local celerity of long gravity waves analogous to the light celerity. When the former reaches one, water waves are no more able to propagate upstream: the hydraulic black hole is a river of no return for them. At a higher level of understanding, two global dimensionless numbers, the upstream Froude number F r up and the obstruction ratio r up (the height of a bottom obstacle, the underlying geometry inducing the effective space-time, divided by the upstream water depth) are essential to distinguish subcritical, trans-critical and supercritical zones in the -F r up versus r up -hydraulic and nondispersive diagram. The relationship between both global parameters for transcritical flows turns out to be a peculiar limit of the behaviour of boats navigating in confined media like canals or locks with a generalized obstruction factor based on the ratio between the boat section and the canal section. Here, we revisit the classification of flows over obstacles in open water channel taking into account both effects of dispersion and scale, two neglected topics so far. For the first time, we give a complete classification of flows in an open water channel based on sub-pixel detection method measurements of the free surface supported by numerical simulations. We generalized the obstruction factor by a filling factor taking into account the maximum height of the water channel, a crucial parameter that was overlooked so far. Our ultimate purpose is to understand how to reproduce in the laboratory analogues of curved space-times from the dynamical point of view.
△ Less
Submitted 28 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
How to create analogue black hole or white fountain horizons and LASER cavities in experimental free surface hydrodynamics?
Authors:
Alexis Bossard,
Nicolas James,
Camille Aucouturier,
Johan Fourdrinoy,
Scott Robertson,
Germain Rousseaux
Abstract:
Transcritical flows in free surface hydrodynamics emulate black hole horizons and their timereversed versions known as white fountains. Both analogue horizons have been shown to emit Hawking radiation, the amplification of waves via scattering at the horizon. Here we report on an experimental validation of the hydrodynamic laws that govern transcritical flows, for the first time in a free surface…
▽ More
Transcritical flows in free surface hydrodynamics emulate black hole horizons and their timereversed versions known as white fountains. Both analogue horizons have been shown to emit Hawking radiation, the amplification of waves via scattering at the horizon. Here we report on an experimental validation of the hydrodynamic laws that govern transcritical flows, for the first time in a free surface water channel using an analogue space-time geometry controlled by a bottom obstacle. A prospective study, both experimental and numerical, with a second obstacle downstream of a first one is presented to test in the near-future the analogous black hole laser instability, namely the super-amplification of Hawking radiation by successive bounces on a pair of black and white horizons within cavities which allow the presence of negative energy modes necessary for the amplification process. Candidate hydrodynamic regimes are discussed thanks to a phase diagram based on the scaled relative heights of both obstacles and the ratio of flow to wave speed in the upstream region.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Gravitational effects of free-falling quantum vacuum
Authors:
François Couchot,
Arache Djannati-Ataï,
Scott Robertson,
Xavier Sarazin,
Marcel Urban
Abstract:
We present a model that builds ``dark matter"-like halo density profiles from free-falling zero-point vacuum fluctuations. It does not require a modification of Newton's laws, nor the existence of as-yet-undiscovered dark matter particles. The 3D halos predicted by our model are fully constrained by the baryonic mass distribution, and are generally far from spherical. The model introduces a new fu…
▽ More
We present a model that builds ``dark matter"-like halo density profiles from free-falling zero-point vacuum fluctuations. It does not require a modification of Newton's laws, nor the existence of as-yet-undiscovered dark matter particles. The 3D halos predicted by our model are fully constrained by the baryonic mass distribution, and are generally far from spherical. The model introduces a new fundamental constant of vacuum, T, having the dimensions of time. We deduce the associated formalism from some basic assumptions, and adjust the model successfully on several spiral galaxy rotation data while comparing our results to the existing analyses. We believe our approach opens up a new paradigm that is worth further exploration, and that would benefit from checks relating to other phenomena attributed to dark matter at all time and distance scales. Following such a program would allow the present model to evolve, and if successful it would make vacuum fluctuations responsible for the typical manifestations of dark matter.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Correlations on weakly time-dependent transcritical white-hole flows
Authors:
Johan Fourdrinoy,
Scott Robertson,
Nicolas James,
Alessandro Fabbri,
Germain Rousseaux
Abstract:
We report on observations made on a run of transcritical flows over an obstacle in a narrow channel. Downstream from the obstacle, the flows decelerate from supercritical to subcritical, typically with an undulation on the subcritical side (known in hydrodynamics as an undular hydraulic jump). In the Analogue Gravity context, this transition corresponds to a white-hole horizon. Free surface defor…
▽ More
We report on observations made on a run of transcritical flows over an obstacle in a narrow channel. Downstream from the obstacle, the flows decelerate from supercritical to subcritical, typically with an undulation on the subcritical side (known in hydrodynamics as an undular hydraulic jump). In the Analogue Gravity context, this transition corresponds to a white-hole horizon. Free surface deformations are analyzed, mainly via the two-point correlation function which shows the presence of a checkerboard pattern in the vicinity of the undulation. In non-gated flows where the white-hole horizon occurs far downstream from the obstacle, this checkerboard pattern is shown to be due to low-frequency fluctuations associated with slow longitudinal movement of the undulation. It can thus be considered as an artifact due to a time-varying background. In gated flows, however, the undulation is typically "attached" to the obstacle, and the fluctuations associated with its movement are strongly suppressed. In this case, the observed correlation pattern is likely due to a stochastic ensemble of surface waves, scattering on a background that is essentially stationary.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2022; v1 submitted 20 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Four-wave mixing and enhanced analogue Hawking effect in a nonlinear optical waveguide
Authors:
Scott Robertson,
Charles Ciret,
Serge Massar,
Simon-Pierre Gorza,
Renaud Parentani
Abstract:
We study in detail the scattering of light on a soliton propagating in a waveguide which has been proposed as an experimental system in which one could observe the analogue Hawking effect. When not applying the rotating wave approximation, we show that the linearized wave equation governing perturbations has the same structure as that governing phonon propagation in an atomic Bose condensate. By t…
▽ More
We study in detail the scattering of light on a soliton propagating in a waveguide which has been proposed as an experimental system in which one could observe the analogue Hawking effect. When not applying the rotating wave approximation, we show that the linearized wave equation governing perturbations has the same structure as that governing phonon propagation in an atomic Bose condensate. By taking into account the full dispersion relation, we then show that the scattering coefficients encoding the production of photon pairs are amplified by a resonance effect related to the modulation instability occurring in the presence of a continuous wave. When using a realistic example of a silicon nitride waveguide on a silica substrate, we find that a soliton of duration 10 fs would spontaneously emit about one photon pair for every cm it travels, which makes the effect readily observable. This result is confirmed by numerically solving the equation encoding the Kerr nonlinearity and governing the evolution of the full field (soliton plus perturbations). We discuss the link with previous works devoted to the analogue Hawking effect where the pair creation rates were about six orders of magnitude smaller.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2019; v1 submitted 12 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Scattering of co-current surface waves on an analogue black hole
Authors:
Léo-Paul Euvé,
Scott Robertson,
Nicolas James,
Alessandro Fabbri,
Germain Rousseaux
Abstract:
We report on what is to our knowledge the first scattering experiment of surface waves on an accelerating transcritical flow, which in the Analogue Gravity context is described by an effective spacetime with a black-hole horizon. This spacetime has been probed by an incident co-current wave, which partially scatters into an outgoing counter-current wave on each side of the horizon. The measured sc…
▽ More
We report on what is to our knowledge the first scattering experiment of surface waves on an accelerating transcritical flow, which in the Analogue Gravity context is described by an effective spacetime with a black-hole horizon. This spacetime has been probed by an incident co-current wave, which partially scatters into an outgoing counter-current wave on each side of the horizon. The measured scattering amplitudes are compatible with the predictions of the hydrodynamical theory, where the kinematical description in terms of the effective metric is exact.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2020; v1 submitted 14 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Nonlinearities induced by parametric resonance in effectively 1D atomic Bose condensates
Authors:
Scott Robertson,
Florent Michel,
Renaud Parentani
Abstract:
We present a numerical study of the dynamical effects following a sudden change of the transverse trapping frequency in an elongated Bose-Einstein condensate, which induces periodic oscillations of the radial density. At early times, we observe an exponential growth of the number of resonant longitudinal phonons, in agreement with the predictions of the Bogoliubov-de Gennes treatment. We then obse…
▽ More
We present a numerical study of the dynamical effects following a sudden change of the transverse trapping frequency in an elongated Bose-Einstein condensate, which induces periodic oscillations of the radial density. At early times, we observe an exponential growth of the number of resonant longitudinal phonons, in agreement with the predictions of the Bogoliubov-de Gennes treatment. We then observe an ordered sequence of phenomena induced by the nonlinearities of the system. The first is a loss of the nonseparability of the resonant phonon pairs. This is followed by the saturation of the exponential growth and a strong depletion of condensed atoms. Notably, these effects are well-described by effective 1D dynamics, and are hardly affected by the damping of the radial oscillations. Finally, the atomic spectrum becomes broad, featureless and almost incoherent, in agreement with experimental results. The link between this sequence of events and the preheating scenario in inflationary cosmology is striking, as is the similarity of techniques used to study them.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2018; v1 submitted 2 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Gravity waves on modulated flows downstream from an obstacle: The transcritical case
Authors:
Florent Michel,
Renaud Parentani,
Scott Robertson
Abstract:
Periodic spatial variations of some parameter arise in analogue gravity experiments aimed at detecting the analogue version of the Hawking effect in a white hole flow. Having the same spatial periodicity as low-frequency dispersive modes, they can induce resonances which significantly modify the scattering coefficients. This has been shown numerically in a previous work [X. Busch et al., Phys. Rev…
▽ More
Periodic spatial variations of some parameter arise in analogue gravity experiments aimed at detecting the analogue version of the Hawking effect in a white hole flow. Having the same spatial periodicity as low-frequency dispersive modes, they can induce resonances which significantly modify the scattering coefficients. This has been shown numerically in a previous work [X. Busch et al., Phys. Rev. D 90, 105005 (2014)], but the precise dependence of the low-frequency effective temperature on the amplitude and length of the undulation remains elusive. In this article, using the Korteweg-de Vries equation, we explicitly compute this dependence in the small-amplitude limit and find three regimes of "short", "intermediate" and "long" undulations showing different scaling laws. In the latter, the effective temperature is completely determined by the properties of the undulation, independently of the surface gravity of the analogue white hole flow. These results are extended to a more realistic hydrodynamical model in an appendix.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2018; v1 submitted 11 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Viscous dissipation of surface waves and its relevance to analogue gravity experiments
Authors:
Scott Robertson,
Germain Rousseaux
Abstract:
We consider dissipation of surface waves on fluids, with a view to its effects on analogue gravity experiments. We begin by reviewing some general properties of wave dissipation, before restricting our attention to surface waves and the dissipative role played by viscosity there. Finally, with particular focus on water, we consider several experimental setups inspired by analogue gravity: the anal…
▽ More
We consider dissipation of surface waves on fluids, with a view to its effects on analogue gravity experiments. We begin by reviewing some general properties of wave dissipation, before restricting our attention to surface waves and the dissipative role played by viscosity there. Finally, with particular focus on water, we consider several experimental setups inspired by analogue gravity: the analogue Hawking effect, the black hole laser, the analogue wormhole, and double bouncing at the wormhole entrance. Dissipative effects are considered in each, and we give estimates for their optimized experimental parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2018; v1 submitted 16 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Assessing degrees of entanglement of phonon states in atomic Bose gases through the measurement of commuting observables
Authors:
Scott Robertson,
Florent Michel,
Renaud Parentani
Abstract:
We show that measuring commuting observables can be sufficient to assess that a bipartite state is entangled according to either nonseparability or the stronger criterion of 'steerability'. Indeed, the measurement of a single observable might reveal the strength of the interferences between the two subsystems, as if an interferometer were used. For definiteness we focus on the two-point correlatio…
▽ More
We show that measuring commuting observables can be sufficient to assess that a bipartite state is entangled according to either nonseparability or the stronger criterion of 'steerability'. Indeed, the measurement of a single observable might reveal the strength of the interferences between the two subsystems, as if an interferometer were used. For definiteness we focus on the two-point correlation function of density fluctuations obtained by in situ measurements in homogeneous one-dimensional cold atomic Bose gases. We then compare this situation to that found in transonic stationary flows mimicking a black hole geometry where correlated phonon pairs are emitted on either side of the sonic horizon by the analogue Hawking effect. We briefly apply our considerations to two recent experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Controlling and observing nonseparability of phonons created in time-dependent 1D atomic Bose condensates
Authors:
Scott Robertson,
Florent Michel,
Renaud Parentani
Abstract:
We study the spectrum and entanglement of phonons produced by temporal changes in homogeneous one-dimensional atomic condensates. To characterize the experimentally accessible changes, we first consider the dynamics of the condensate when varying the radial trapping frequency, separately studying two regimes: an adiabatic one and an oscillatory one. Working in momentum space, we then show that in…
▽ More
We study the spectrum and entanglement of phonons produced by temporal changes in homogeneous one-dimensional atomic condensates. To characterize the experimentally accessible changes, we first consider the dynamics of the condensate when varying the radial trapping frequency, separately studying two regimes: an adiabatic one and an oscillatory one. Working in momentum space, we then show that in situ measurements of the density-density correlation function can be used to assess the nonseparability of the phonon state after such changes. We also study time-of-flight (TOF) measurements, paying particular attention to the role played by the adiabaticity of opening the trap on the nonseparability of the final state of atoms. In both cases, we emphasize that commuting measurements can suffice to assess nonseparability. Some recent observations are analyzed, and we make proposals for future experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2017; v1 submitted 11 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Scattering of gravity waves in subcritical flows over an obstacle
Authors:
Scott Robertson,
Florent Michel,
Renaud Parentani
Abstract:
We numerically study the scattering coefficients of linear water waves on stationary flows above a localized obstacle. We compare the scattering on trans- and subcritical flows, and then focus on the latter which have been used in recent analog gravity experiments. The main difference concerns the magnitude of the mode amplification: whereas transcritical flows display a large amplification (which…
▽ More
We numerically study the scattering coefficients of linear water waves on stationary flows above a localized obstacle. We compare the scattering on trans- and subcritical flows, and then focus on the latter which have been used in recent analog gravity experiments. The main difference concerns the magnitude of the mode amplification: whereas transcritical flows display a large amplification (which is generally in good agreement with the Hawking prediction), this effect is heavily suppressed in subcritical flows. This is due to the transmission across the obstacle for frequencies less than some critical value. As a result, subcritical flows display high- and low-frequency behaviors separated by a narrow band around the critical frequency. In the low-frequency regime, transmission of long wavelengths is accompanied by non-adiabatic scattering into short wavelengths, whose spectrum is approximately linear in frequency. By contrast, in the high-frequency regime, no simple description seems to exist. In particular, for obstacles similar to those recently used, we observe that the upstream slope still affects the scattering on the downstream side because of some residual transmission.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
The theory of Hawking radiation in laboratory analogues
Authors:
Scott Robertson
Abstract:
Hawking radiation, despite being known to theoretical physics for nearly forty years, remains elusive and undetected. It also suffers, in its original context of gravitational black holes, from practical and conceptual difficulties. Of particular note is the trans-Planckian problem, which is concerned with the apparent origin of the radiation in absurdly high frequencies. In order to gain better t…
▽ More
Hawking radiation, despite being known to theoretical physics for nearly forty years, remains elusive and undetected. It also suffers, in its original context of gravitational black holes, from practical and conceptual difficulties. Of particular note is the trans-Planckian problem, which is concerned with the apparent origin of the radiation in absurdly high frequencies. In order to gain better theoretical understanding and, it is hoped, experimental verification of Hawking radiation, much study is being devoted to laboratory systems which use moving media to model the spacetime geometry of black holes, and which, by analogy, are also thought to emit Hawking radiation. These analogue systems typically exhibit dispersion, which regularizes the wave behaviour at the horizon at the cost of a more complicated theoretical framework. This tutorial serves as an introduction to Hawking radiation and its analogues, developing the moving medium analogy for black holes and demonstrating how dispersion can be incorporated into this generalized framework.
△ Less
Submitted 11 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
Hawking radiation in the presence of high-momentum dissipation
Authors:
Scott Robertson,
Renaud Parentani
Abstract:
We study the Hawking radiation in field theories which break Lorentz invariance via dissipative effects above a certain energy scale. We assume that the additional degrees of freedom which cause dissipation are Gaussian and freely falling. The asymptotic spectrum and the correlations are extracted from the anticommutator of the radiation field. The singular behavior of the Green function found for…
▽ More
We study the Hawking radiation in field theories which break Lorentz invariance via dissipative effects above a certain energy scale. We assume that the additional degrees of freedom which cause dissipation are Gaussian and freely falling. The asymptotic spectrum and the correlations are extracted from the anticommutator of the radiation field. The singular behavior of the Green function found for relativistic fields as one point crosses the horizon is completely suppressed by dissipation. Yet, when the dissipative frequency scale is much larger than the surface gravity of the black hole, we show that the asymptotic observables acquire their standard (relativistic) vacuum expectation values. We explicitly compute the effects of dissipation on the spectrum and on the nonseparable character of the correlations when varying the dissipative scale, the extension of the near-horizon geometry, and the temperature of the environment.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Quantum entanglement due to modulated Dynamical Casimir Effect
Authors:
Xavier Busch,
Renaud Parentani,
Scott Robertson
Abstract:
We study the creation and entanglement of quasiparticle pairs due to a periodic variation of the mode frequencies of a homogeneous quantum system. Depending on the values of the parameters describing the periodic modulation, the number of created pairs either oscillates or, in a narrow resonant frequency interval, grows exponentially in time. For a system initially in a thermal state, we determine…
▽ More
We study the creation and entanglement of quasiparticle pairs due to a periodic variation of the mode frequencies of a homogeneous quantum system. Depending on the values of the parameters describing the periodic modulation, the number of created pairs either oscillates or, in a narrow resonant frequency interval, grows exponentially in time. For a system initially in a thermal state, we determine in which cases the final state is quantum mechanically entangled, i.e., where the bipartite state is nonseparable. We include some weak dissipation, expected to be found in any experimental setup, and study the corresponding reduction of the quantum entanglement. Our findings are used to interpret the results of two recent experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2014; v1 submitted 23 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Integral method for the calculation of Hawking radiation in dispersive media II. Asymmetric asymptotics
Authors:
Scott Robertson
Abstract:
Analogue gravity experiments make feasible the realisation of black hole spacetimes in a laboratory setting and the observational verification of Hawking radiation. Since such analogue systems are typically dominated by dispersion, efficient techniques for calculating the predicted Hawking spectrum in the presence of strong dispersion are required. In the preceding paper, an integral method in Fou…
▽ More
Analogue gravity experiments make feasible the realisation of black hole spacetimes in a laboratory setting and the observational verification of Hawking radiation. Since such analogue systems are typically dominated by dispersion, efficient techniques for calculating the predicted Hawking spectrum in the presence of strong dispersion are required. In the preceding paper, an integral method in Fourier space is proposed for stationary $1+1$-dimensional backgrounds which are asymptotically symmetric. Here, this method is generalised to backgrounds which are different in the asymptotic regions to the left and right of the scattering region.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Integral method for the calculation of Hawking radiation in dispersive media I. Symmetric asymptotics
Authors:
Scott Robertson,
Ulf Leonhardt
Abstract:
Hawking radiation has become experimentally testable thanks to the many analogue systems which mimic the effects of the event horizon on wave propagation. These systems are typically dominated by dispersion, and give rise to a numerically soluble and stable ODE only if the rest-frame dispersion relation $Ω^{2}(k)$ is a polynomial of relatively low degree. Here we present a new method for the calcu…
▽ More
Hawking radiation has become experimentally testable thanks to the many analogue systems which mimic the effects of the event horizon on wave propagation. These systems are typically dominated by dispersion, and give rise to a numerically soluble and stable ODE only if the rest-frame dispersion relation $Ω^{2}(k)$ is a polynomial of relatively low degree. Here we present a new method for the calculation of wave scattering in a one-dimensional medium of arbitrary dispersion. It views the wave equation as an integral equation in Fourier space, which can be solved using standard and efficient numerical techniques.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Farewell to black hole horizons and singularities?
Authors:
C. Corda,
D. Leiter,
H. J. Mosquera Cuesta,
S. Robertson,
R. E. Schild
Abstract:
We consider the fundamental issues which dominate the question about the existence or non-existence of black hole horizons and singularities from both of the theoretical and observational points of view, and discuss some of the ways that black hole singularities can be prevented from forming at a classical level, i.e. without arguments of quantum gravity. In this way, we argue that black holes cou…
▽ More
We consider the fundamental issues which dominate the question about the existence or non-existence of black hole horizons and singularities from both of the theoretical and observational points of view, and discuss some of the ways that black hole singularities can be prevented from forming at a classical level, i.e. without arguments of quantum gravity. In this way, we argue that black holes could have a different nature with respect the common belief. In fact, even remaining very compact astrophysics objects, they could be devoid of horizons and singularities. Our analysis represents a key point within the debate on the path to unification of theories. As recently some scientists partially retrieved the old Einstein's opinion that quantum mechanics has to be subjected to a more general deterministic theory, a way to find solutions to the problem of black hole horizons and singularities at a semi-classical level, i.e. without discussions of quantum gravity, becomes a fundamental framework.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2011; v1 submitted 21 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
Hawking Radiation in Dispersive Media
Authors:
Scott James Robertson
Abstract:
Hawking radiation, despite its presence in theoretical physics for over thirty years, remains elusive and undetected. It also suffers, in its original context of gravitational black holes, from conceptual difficulties. Of particular note is the trans-Planckian problem, which is concerned with the apparent origin of the radiation in absurdly high frequencies. In order to gain better theoretical und…
▽ More
Hawking radiation, despite its presence in theoretical physics for over thirty years, remains elusive and undetected. It also suffers, in its original context of gravitational black holes, from conceptual difficulties. Of particular note is the trans-Planckian problem, which is concerned with the apparent origin of the radiation in absurdly high frequencies. In order to gain better theoretical understanding and, it is hoped, experimental verification of Hawking radiation, much study is being devoted to systems which model the spacetime geometry of black holes, and which, by analogy, are also thought to emit Hawking radiation. These analogue systems typically exhibit dispersion, which regularizes the wave behaviour at the horizon but does not lend itself well to analytic treatment, thus rendering Hawking's prediction less secure. A general analytic method for dealing with Hawking radiation in dispersive systems has proved difficult to find.
This thesis presents new numerical and analytic results for Hawking emission spectra in dispersive systems. It examines two black-hole analogue systems: it begins by introducing the well-known acoustic model, presenting some original results in that context; then, through analogy with the acoustic model, goes on to develop the lesser-known fibre-optical model.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2011;
originally announced June 2011.
-
Fiber-optical analogue of the event horizon: Appendices
Authors:
Thomas G. Philbin,
Chris Kuklewicz,
Scott Robertson,
Stephen Hill,
Friedrich Konig,
Ulf Leonhardt
Abstract:
We explain the theory behind our fiber-optical analogue of the event horizon and present the experiment in detail.
We explain the theory behind our fiber-optical analogue of the event horizon and present the experiment in detail.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2007; v1 submitted 29 November, 2007;
originally announced November 2007.
-
Fiber-optical analogue of the event horizon
Authors:
Thomas G. Philbin,
Chris Kuklewicz,
Scott Robertson,
Stephen Hill,
Friedrich Konig,
Ulf Leonhardt
Abstract:
The physics at the event horizon resembles the behavior of waves in moving media. Horizons are formed where the local speed of the medium exceeds the wave velocity. We use ultrashort pulses in microstructured optical fibers to demonstrate the formation of an artificial event horizon in optics. We observed a classical optical effect, the blue-shifting of light at a white-hole horizon. We also sho…
▽ More
The physics at the event horizon resembles the behavior of waves in moving media. Horizons are formed where the local speed of the medium exceeds the wave velocity. We use ultrashort pulses in microstructured optical fibers to demonstrate the formation of an artificial event horizon in optics. We observed a classical optical effect, the blue-shifting of light at a white-hole horizon. We also show by theoretical calculations that such a system is capable of probing the quantum effects of horizons, in particular Hawking radiation.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2008; v1 submitted 29 November, 2007;
originally announced November 2007.
-
A Gedanken Experiment For Gravitomagnetism
Authors:
Stanley L. Robertson
Abstract:
A gedanken experiment implies the existence of gravitomagnetism and raises a question about what we know about the weak-field limit of the gravitomagnetic field of General Relativity.
A gedanken experiment implies the existence of gravitomagnetism and raises a question about what we know about the weak-field limit of the gravitomagnetic field of General Relativity.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2007;
originally announced May 2007.
-
Newtonian Gravity Predictions For Gravity Probe B
Authors:
Stanley L. Robertson
Abstract:
Newtonian gravity and special relativity combine to produce a gravitomagnetic precession of an orbiting gyroscope that is one fourth as large as predicted by General Relativity. The geodetic effect is the same in both cases.
Newtonian gravity and special relativity combine to produce a gravitomagnetic precession of an orbiting gyroscope that is one fourth as large as predicted by General Relativity. The geodetic effect is the same in both cases.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2005; v1 submitted 21 February, 2005;
originally announced February 2005.
-
Does The Principle Of Equivalence Prevent Trapped Surfaces From Being Formed In The General Relativistic Collapse Process?
Authors:
Darryl Leiter,
Stanley Robertson
Abstract:
It has been recently shown (Mitra,- astro-ph/9910408, astro-ph/0207056) that the timelike spherical collapse of a radiating, physical fluid in General Relativity, as seen by an interior co-moving observer at rest in the physical fluid, does not permit formation of ``trapped surfaces''. This followed from the fact that the formation of a trapped surface in a physical fluid would cause the timelik…
▽ More
It has been recently shown (Mitra,- astro-ph/9910408, astro-ph/0207056) that the timelike spherical collapse of a radiating, physical fluid in General Relativity, as seen by an interior co-moving observer at rest in the physical fluid, does not permit formation of ``trapped surfaces''. This followed from the fact that the formation of a trapped surface in a physical fluid would cause the timelike world lines of the collapsing fluid to become null at the would be trapped surface, thus violating the Principle of Equivalence in General Theory of Relativity. In this paper we generalize and extend this result by studying the problem from the point of view of the exterior Vaidya metric of a collapsing radiating fluid as seen by an exterior stationary observer, and find that the "no trapped surface condition" becomes g00 > 0 consistent with that obtained for the interior co-moving metric. Since we have shown that the Principle of Equivalence prevents trapped surfaces from being formed in collapsing, radiating objects, then true event horizons cannot exist and Galactic Black Hole Candidates (GBHC) must have physically observable intrinsic magnetic dipole moments. Because of this fact it follows (Robertson and Leiter - astro-ph/0102381, astro-ph/0208333) that GBHC can be consistently described, within the framework of General Relativity, in terms of a magneto-spheric eternally collapsing objects (MECO) without true event horizons.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2002; v1 submitted 21 November, 2001;
originally announced November 2001.
-
Evidence For Intrinsic Magnetic Moments in Black Hole Candidates
Authors:
Stanley L. Robertson,
Darryl J. Leiter
Abstract:
We present evidence that the power law part of the quiescent x-ray emissions of neutron stars in low mass x-ray binaries is magnetospheric in origin. It can be very accurately calculated from known rates of spin and magnetic moments determined from the the $\sim 10^{3 - 4}$ times brighter luminosity at the transition to the hard spectral state. This strongly suggests that the spectral state tran…
▽ More
We present evidence that the power law part of the quiescent x-ray emissions of neutron stars in low mass x-ray binaries is magnetospheric in origin. It can be very accurately calculated from known rates of spin and magnetic moments determined from the the $\sim 10^{3 - 4}$ times brighter luminosity at the transition to the hard spectral state. This strongly suggests that the spectral state transition for neutron stars is a magnetospheric propeller effect. We test the hypothesis that the similar spectral state switches and quiescent power law emissions of the black hole candidates might also be magnetospheric effects. In the process we derive proposed magnetic moments and rates of spin for them and accurately predict their quiescent luminosities. This constitutes an observational test for the physical realization of event horizons and suggests that they may not be formed during the gravitational collapse of ordinary matter.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2001; v1 submitted 21 February, 2001;
originally announced February 2001.
-
Einstein General Relativity In Bi-metric Spacetime Contains Exponential Metrics Which Dynamically Preserve Bi-metric "Light Cone Causality"
Authors:
Darryl J. Leiter,
Stanley L. Robertson
Abstract:
It is well known that Einstein General Relativity can be expressed covariantly in bi-metric spacetime, without the uncertainties which arise from the effects of gravitational energy-momentum pseudo-tensors. However the effect that the Strong Principle of Equivalence (SPOE) has on the curved and flat bi-metric spacetime tetrad structure has not been fully explored. In the context of bi-metric Gen…
▽ More
It is well known that Einstein General Relativity can be expressed covariantly in bi-metric spacetime, without the uncertainties which arise from the effects of gravitational energy-momentum pseudo-tensors. However the effect that the Strong Principle of Equivalence (SPOE) has on the curved and flat bi-metric spacetime tetrad structure has not been fully explored. In the context of bi-metric General Relativity the (SPOE) requires that: a) in the absence of gravitation due to spacetime curvature a Global Inertial Cartesian Minkowski (GICM) spacetime frame exists in which Special Relativity is valid and, b) in the presence of gravitation due to spacetime curvature a bi-metric Local Free Fall frame (LFF) must always exist. These two conditions required by the (SPOE) are then shown to imply that a symmetric gravitational potential tensor must exist in the bi-metric spacetime which is connected exponentially to the tetrad inner product between the curved symmetric tetrads and the flat background symmetric tetrads. It is then shown that this (SPOE) generated gravitational potential tensor has the property of exponentially connecting the curved metric tensor with the flat background metric tensor in a manner which allows the condition of "Light Cone Causality" (LCC) to be dynamically satisfied in the bi-metric spacetime. Substitution of this (LCC) conserving exponential metric into the bi-metric Einstein field equations, subject to an appropriate choice of tensor gauge conditions, yields an equivalent set of (LCC) conserving bi-metric Einstein field equations for the gravitational potential tensor, the full implications of which will be explored in future papers.
△ Less
Submitted 16 July, 2003; v1 submitted 8 January, 2001;
originally announced January 2001.
