Limits on the Ejecta Mass During the Search for Kilonovae Associated with Neutron Star-Black Hole Mergers: A case study of S230518h, GW230529, S230627c and the Low-Significance Candidate S240422ed
Authors:
M. Pillas,
S. Antier,
K. Ackley,
T. Ahumada,
D. Akl,
L. de Almeida,
S. Anand,
C. Andrade,
I. Andreoni,
K. A. Bostroem,
M. Bulla,
E. Burns,
T. Cabrera,
S. Chang,
H. Choi,
B. O'Connor,
M. W. Coughlin,
W. Corradi,
A. R. Gibbs,
T. Dietrich,
D. Dornic,
J. -G. Ducoin,
P. -A. Duverne,
M. Dyer,
H. -B. Eggenstein
, et al. (56 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Neutron star-black hole (NSBH) mergers, detectable via their gravitational-wave (GW) emission, are expected to produce kilonovae (KNe). Four NSBH candidates have been identified and followed-up by more than fifty instruments since the start of the fourth GW Observing Run (O4), in May 2023, up to July 2024; however, no confirmed associated KN has been detected. This study evaluates ejecta propertie…
▽ More
Neutron star-black hole (NSBH) mergers, detectable via their gravitational-wave (GW) emission, are expected to produce kilonovae (KNe). Four NSBH candidates have been identified and followed-up by more than fifty instruments since the start of the fourth GW Observing Run (O4), in May 2023, up to July 2024; however, no confirmed associated KN has been detected. This study evaluates ejecta properties from multi-messenger observations to understand the absence of detectable KN: we use GW public information and joint observations taken from 05.2023 to 07.2024 (LVK, ATLAS, DECam, GECKO, GOTO, GRANDMA, SAGUARO, TESS, WINTER, ZTF). First, our analysis on follow-up observation strategies shows that, on average, more than 50% of the simulated KNe associated with NSBH mergers reach their peak luminosity around one day after merger in the $g,r,i$- bands, which is not necessarily covered for each NSBH GW candidate. We also analyze the trade-off between observation efficiency and the intrinsic properties of the KN emission, to understand the impact on how these constraints affect our ability to detect the KN, and underlying ejecta properties for each GW candidate. In particular, we can only confirm the kilonova was not missed for 1% of the GW230529 and S230627c sky localization region, given the large sky localization error of GW230529 and the large distance for S230627c and, their respective KN faint luminosities. More constraining, for S230518h, we infer the dynamical ejecta and post-merger disk wind ejecta $m_{dyn}, m_{wind}$ $<$ $0.03$ $M_\odot$ and the viewing angle $θ>25^\circ$. Similarly, the non-astrophysical origin of S240422ed is likely further confirmed by the fact that we would have detected even a faint KN at the time and presumed distance of the S240422ed event candidate, within a minimum 45% credible region of the sky area, that can be larger depending on the KN scenario.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
Detecting electromagnetic counterparts to LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA gravitational wave events with DECam: Neutron Star Mergers
Authors:
Keerthi Kunnumkai,
Antonella Palmese,
Amanda M Farah,
Mattia Bulla,
Tim Dietrich,
Peter T H Pang,
Shreya Anand,
Igor Andreoni,
Tomas Cabrera,
Brendan O Connor
Abstract:
With GW170817 being the only multimessenger gravitational wave (GW) event with an associated kilonova (KN) detected so far, there exists a pressing need for realistic estimation of the GW localization uncertainties and rates, as well as optimization of available telescope time to enable the detection of new KNe. For this purpose, we simulate GW events assuming a data-driven, GW-motivated distribut…
▽ More
With GW170817 being the only multimessenger gravitational wave (GW) event with an associated kilonova (KN) detected so far, there exists a pressing need for realistic estimation of the GW localization uncertainties and rates, as well as optimization of available telescope time to enable the detection of new KNe. For this purpose, we simulate GW events assuming a data-driven, GW-motivated distribution of binary parameters for the LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA (LVK) fourth and fifth observing runs (O4 and O5). We map the binary neutron star (BNS) and neutron star-black hole (NSBH) properties to the optical light curves arising from r-process nucleosynthesis in the ejecta. We use the simulated population of KNe to generate follow-up observing plans, with the primary goal of optimizing detection with the Gravitational Wave Multi-Messenger Astronomy DECam Survey (GW-MMADS). We explore the dependence of KN detectability on the mass, distance, inclination, and spin of the binaries. Assuming that no BNS was detected during O4 until the end of 2024, we present updated GW BNS (NSBH) merger detection rates: $\sim 1-9$ ($2-9$) yr$^{-1}$ in O4, and $13-110$ ($18-110$) yr$^{-1}$ in O5. Of these events, we expect to detect BNS (NSBH) KNe with DECam at a per year rate of: $0-2$ ($0$) in O4, and $2-28$ ($0-3$) in O5, conditional on the uncertainty on the equation of state (EOS) and volumetric rates of the mergers. We expect the majority of BNS detections and also those accompanied by a detectable KN to produce a hypermassive NS remnant, with a significant fraction of the remaining BNSs promptly collapsing to a BH. We release our GW simulations and the depths needed to detect a significant fraction of simulated KNe to enable the astronomical community to use them in their multimessenger campaigns and analyses.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2025; v1 submitted 20 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
