-
On the equivalence between Sáez-Ballester theory and Einstein-scalar field system
Authors:
Israel Quiros,
Francisco Antonio Horta-Rangel
Abstract:
Here we discuss a topic that comes up more often than expected: A same theory or theoretical model arises in two different presentations which are assumed to be actually different theories so that these are independently developed. Sometimes this leads to an unwanted doubling of the results. In this paper we illustrate this issue with the example of two apparently different gravitational theories:…
▽ More
Here we discuss a topic that comes up more often than expected: A same theory or theoretical model arises in two different presentations which are assumed to be actually different theories so that these are independently developed. Sometimes this leads to an unwanted doubling of the results. In this paper we illustrate this issue with the example of two apparently different gravitational theories: (i) the (minimally coupled) Einstein-massless-scalar system and (ii) the Sáez-Ballester theory. We demonstrate that the latter is not a scalar-tensor theory of gravity, as widely acknowledged. Moreover, Sáez-Ballester theory is identified with the Einstein-massless-scalar theory. As illustrations of this identification we show that several known solutions of Sáez-Ballester theory are also solutions of the Einstein-massless-scalar system and viceversa. Cosmological arguments are also considered. In particular, a dynamical systems-based demonstration of the dynamical equivalence between these theories is given. The study of the asymptotic dynamics of the Sáez-Ballester based cosmological model shows that there are not equilibrium points which could be associated with accelerated expansion, unless one includes a cosmological constant term or a self-interacting scalar field. This is a well-known result for cosmological models which are based in the Einstein-self-interacting-scalar theory, also known as quintessence.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2023; v1 submitted 31 August, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Global asymptotic dynamics of the cubic galileon interacting with dark matter
Authors:
Roberto De Arcia,
Israel Quiros,
Ulises Nucamendi,
Tame Gonzalez,
Francisco Antonio Horta-Rangel,
Philippe Eenens
Abstract:
In this paper we perform a thorough dynamical systems analysis of the cubic galileon model non-minimally coupled to the dark matter. Three well-known classes of interacting models are considered where the energy exchange between the dark components is a function of the dark matter density and of the dark energy density: $Q_1=3αHρ_m$, $Q_2=3βρ_m\dotφ$ and $Q_3=3 εH ρ_φ$, respectively. We are able t…
▽ More
In this paper we perform a thorough dynamical systems analysis of the cubic galileon model non-minimally coupled to the dark matter. Three well-known classes of interacting models are considered where the energy exchange between the dark components is a function of the dark matter density and of the dark energy density: $Q_1=3αHρ_m$, $Q_2=3βρ_m\dotφ$ and $Q_3=3 εH ρ_φ$, respectively. We are able to show the global asymptotic dynamics of the model for the exponential potential in a homogeneous and isotropic background. The cosmological implications of the proposed scenarios are explored and it is found that, in addition to the appearance of new equilibrium configurations that do not appear neither in the non-interacting cubic galileon model nor in the interacting quintessence model, there is a significant impact of the non-minimal coupling through modification of the stability properties of the critical points. The resulting cosmological scenario provides a bigbang origin of the cosmic expansion, an early transient stage of inflationary expansion, as well as matter-scaling late time stable state of the universe, among other solutions of lesser cosmological interest. This work extends previous studies of coupled dark energy to a broader class of gravitational theories.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2023; v1 submitted 28 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Equivalence between Horndeski and beyond Horndeski theories and imperfect fluids
Authors:
Israel Quiros,
Ulises Nucamendi,
Roberto De Arcia,
Tame Gonzalez,
Francisco Antonio Horta-Rangel
Abstract:
In this paper we show that an equivalence between Horndeski and beyond Horndeski theories and general relativity with an effective imperfect fluid can be formally established. The formal equivalence is discussed for several particular cases of interest. Working in the cosmological framework, it is shown that, while the effective stress-energy tensor of viable Horndeski theories is formally equival…
▽ More
In this paper we show that an equivalence between Horndeski and beyond Horndeski theories and general relativity with an effective imperfect fluid can be formally established. The formal equivalence is discussed for several particular cases of interest. Working in the cosmological framework, it is shown that, while the effective stress-energy tensor of viable Horndeski theories is formally equivalent to that of an imperfect fluid with anisotropic stresses and vanishing heat flux vector, the effective stress-energy tensor of beyond Horndeski theories is equivalent to the one of a perfect fluid instead.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2019; v1 submitted 28 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
An issue with the classification of the scalar-tensor theories of gravity
Authors:
Israel Quiros,
Roberto De Arcia,
Ricardo García-Salcedo,
Tame Gonzalez,
Francisco Antonio Horta-Rangel
Abstract:
In the bibliography a certain confusion arises in what regards to the classification of the gravitational theories into scalar-tensor theories and general relativity with a scalar field either minimally or non-minimally coupled to matter. Higher-derivatives Horndeski and beyond Horndeski theories that at first sight do not look like scalar-tensor theories only add to the confusion. To further comp…
▽ More
In the bibliography a certain confusion arises in what regards to the classification of the gravitational theories into scalar-tensor theories and general relativity with a scalar field either minimally or non-minimally coupled to matter. Higher-derivatives Horndeski and beyond Horndeski theories that at first sight do not look like scalar-tensor theories only add to the confusion. To further complicate things, the discussion on the physical equivalence of the different conformal frames in which a given scalar-tensor theory may be formulated, makes even harder to achieve a correct classification. In this paper we propose a specific criterion for an unambiguous identification of scalar-tensor theories and discuss its impact on the conformal transformations issue. The present discussion carries not only pedagogical but also scientific interest since an incorrect classification of a given theory as a scalar-tensor theory of gravity may lead to conceptual issues and to the consequent misunderstanding of its physical implications.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2020; v1 submitted 20 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Dynamical systems analysis of the cubic galileon beyond the exponential potential and the cosmological analogue of the vDVZ discontinuity
Authors:
Roberto De Arcia,
Tame Gonzalez,
Francisco Antonio Horta-Rangel,
Genly Leon,
Ulises Nucamendi,
Israel Quiros
Abstract:
In this paper we generalize the dynamical systems analysis of the cubic galileon model previously investigated in \cite{rtgui} by including self-interaction potentials beyond the exponential one. It will be shown that, consistently with the results of \cite{rtgui}, the cubic self-interaction of the galileon vacuum appreciably modifies the late-time cosmic dynamics by the existence of a phantom-lik…
▽ More
In this paper we generalize the dynamical systems analysis of the cubic galileon model previously investigated in \cite{rtgui} by including self-interaction potentials beyond the exponential one. It will be shown that, consistently with the results of \cite{rtgui}, the cubic self-interaction of the galileon vacuum appreciably modifies the late-time cosmic dynamics by the existence of a phantom-like attractor (among other super-accelerated solutions that are not of interest in the present investigation). In contrast, in the presence of background matter the late-time cosmic dynamics remains practically the same as in the standard quintessence scenario. This means that we can not recover the cubic galileon vacuum continuously from the more general cubic quintessence with background matter, by setting to zero the matter energy density (and the pressure). This happens to be a kind of cosmological vDVZ discontinuity that can be evaded by means of the cosmological version of the Vainshtein screening mechanism.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2018; v1 submitted 7 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
On the phantom barrier crossing and the bounds on the speed of sound in non-minimal derivative coupling theories
Authors:
Israel Quiros,
Tame Gonzalez,
Ulises Nucamendi,
Ricardo García-Salcedo,
Francisco Antonio Horta-Rangel,
Joel Saavedra
Abstract:
In this paper we investigate the so called "phantom barrier crossing" issue in a cosmological model based in the scalar-tensor theory with non-minimal derivative coupling to the Einstein's tensor. Special attention will be paid to the physical bounds on the squared sound speed. The numeric results are geometrically illustrated by means of a qualitative procedure of analysis that is based on the ma…
▽ More
In this paper we investigate the so called "phantom barrier crossing" issue in a cosmological model based in the scalar-tensor theory with non-minimal derivative coupling to the Einstein's tensor. Special attention will be paid to the physical bounds on the squared sound speed. The numeric results are geometrically illustrated by means of a qualitative procedure of analysis that is based on the mapping of the orbits in the phase plane onto the surfaces that represent physical quantities in the extended phase space, that is: the phase plane complemented with an additional dimension relative to the given physical parameter. We find that the cosmological model based in the non-minimal derivative coupling theory -- this includes both the quintessence and the pure derivative coupling cases -- has serious causality problems related with superluminal propagation of the scalar and tensor perturbations. Even more disturbing is the finding that, despite that the underlying theory is free of the Ostrogradsky instability, the corresponding cosmological model is plagued by the Laplacian (classical) instability related with negative squared sound speed. This instability leads to an uncontrollable growth of the energy density of the perturbations that is inversely proportional to their wavelength. We show that independent of the self-interaction potential, for the positive coupling the tensor perturbations propagate superluminally, while for the negative coupling a Laplacian instability arises. This latter instability invalidates the possibility for the model to describe the primordial inflation.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2018; v1 submitted 12 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Brans-Dicke Galileon and the Variational Principle
Authors:
Israel Quiros,
Ricardo García-Salcedo,
Tame Gonzalez,
F. Antonio Horta-Rangel,
Joel Saavedra
Abstract:
This paper is aimed at a (mostly) pedagogical exposition of the derivation of the motion equations of certain modifications of general relativity. Here we derive in all detail the motion equations in the Brans-Dicke theory with the cubic self-interaction. This is a modification of the Brans-dicke theory by the addition of a term in the Lagrangian which is non-linear in the derivatives of the scala…
▽ More
This paper is aimed at a (mostly) pedagogical exposition of the derivation of the motion equations of certain modifications of general relativity. Here we derive in all detail the motion equations in the Brans-Dicke theory with the cubic self-interaction. This is a modification of the Brans-dicke theory by the addition of a term in the Lagrangian which is non-linear in the derivatives of the scalar field: it contains second-order derivatives. This is the basis of the so-called Brans-Dicke Galileon. We pay special attention to the variational principle and to the algebraic details of the derivation. It is shown how higher order derivatives of the fields appearing in the intermediate computations cancel out leading to second order motion equations. The reader will find useful tips for the derivation of the field equations of modifications of general relativity such as the scalar-tensor theories and $f(R)$ theories, by means of the (stationary action) variational principle. The content of this paper is specially recommended to those graduate and postgraduate students who are interested in the study of the mentioned modifications of general relativity.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2016; v1 submitted 1 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
The Chameleon Effect in the Jordan Frame of the Brans--Dicke Theory
Authors:
Israel Quiros,
Ricardo García-Salcedo,
Tame Gonzalez,
F. Antonio Horta-Rangel
Abstract:
In this paper we investigate the chameleon effect in the different conformal frames of the Brans--Dicke theory. Given that, in the standard literature on the subject, the chameleon is described in the Einstein frame almost exclusively, here we pay special attention to the description of this effect in the Jordan and in the string frames. It is shown that, in general, terrestrial and solar system b…
▽ More
In this paper we investigate the chameleon effect in the different conformal frames of the Brans--Dicke theory. Given that, in the standard literature on the subject, the chameleon is described in the Einstein frame almost exclusively, here we pay special attention to the description of this effect in the Jordan and in the string frames. It is shown that, in general, terrestrial and solar system bounds on the mass of the BD scalar field, and bounds of cosmological origin, are difficult to reconcile at once through a single chameleon potential. We point out that, in a cosmological context, provided that the effective chameleon potential has a minimum within a region of constant density of matter, the Brans--Dicke theory transmutes into general relativity with a cosmological constant, in that region. This result, however, can be only locally valid. In cosmological settings de Sitter--general relativity is a global attractor of the Brans--Dicke theory only for the quadratic potential $V(φ)=M^2φ^2$, or for potentials that asymptote to $M^2φ^2$.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2015; v1 submitted 17 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Introduction to the application of the dynamical systems theory in the study of the dynamics of cosmological models of dark energy
Authors:
Ricardo García-Salcedo,
Tame Gonzalez,
Francisco A. Horta-Rangel,
Israel Quiros,
Daniel Sanchez-Guzmán
Abstract:
The theory of the dynamical systems is a very complex subject which has brought several surprises in the recent past in connection with the theory of chaos and fractals. The application of the tools of the dynamical systems in cosmological settings is less known in spite of the amount of published scientific papers on this subject. In this paper a -- mostly pedagogical -- introduction to the appli…
▽ More
The theory of the dynamical systems is a very complex subject which has brought several surprises in the recent past in connection with the theory of chaos and fractals. The application of the tools of the dynamical systems in cosmological settings is less known in spite of the amount of published scientific papers on this subject. In this paper a -- mostly pedagogical -- introduction to the application in cosmology of the basic tools of the dynamical systems theory is presented. It is shown that, in spite of their amazing simplicity, these allow to extract essential information on the asymptotic dynamics of a wide variety of cosmological models. The power of these tools is illustrated within the context of the so called $Λ$CDM and scalar field models of dark energy. This paper is suitable for teachers, undergraduate and postgraduate students from physics and mathematics disciplines.
△ Less
Submitted 20 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
