-
A First Search for Prompt Radio Emission from a Gravitational-Wave Event
Authors:
Thomas A. Callister,
Marin M. Anderson,
Gregg Hallinan,
Larry R. D'addario,
Jayce Dowell,
Namir E. Kassim,
T. Joseph W. Lazio,
Danny C. Price,
Frank K. Schinzel
Abstract:
Multimessenger observations of the binary neutron star merger GW170817 have enabled the discovery of a diverse array of electromagnetic counterparts to compact binary mergers, including an unambiguous kilonova, a short gamma-ray burst, and a late-time radio jet. Beyond these counterparts, compact binary mergers are additionally predicted to be accompanied by prompt low-frequency radio emission. Th…
▽ More
Multimessenger observations of the binary neutron star merger GW170817 have enabled the discovery of a diverse array of electromagnetic counterparts to compact binary mergers, including an unambiguous kilonova, a short gamma-ray burst, and a late-time radio jet. Beyond these counterparts, compact binary mergers are additionally predicted to be accompanied by prompt low-frequency radio emission. The successful observation of a prompt radio counterpart would be immensely valuable, but is made difficult by the short delay between the gravitational-wave and prompt electromagnetic signals as well as the poor localization of gravitational-wave sources. Here, we present the first search for prompt radio emission accompanying a gravitational-wave event, targeting the binary black hole merger GW170104 detected by the Advanced LIGO and Virgo gravitational-wave observatories during their second (O2) observing run. Using the Owens Valley Radio Observatory Long Wavelength Array (OVRO-LWA), we search a $\sim900\,\mathrm{deg}^2$ region for transient radio emission within approximately one hour of GW170104, obtaining an upper limit of $2.5\times10^{41}\,\mathrm{erg}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}$ on its equivalent isotropic luminosity between 27-84 MHz. We additionally discuss plans to target binary neutron star mergers in Advanced LIGO and Virgo's upcoming O3 observing run.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
A Strong Jet Signature in the Late-Time Lightcurve of GW170817
Authors:
K. P. Mooley,
D. A. Frail,
D. Dobie,
E. Lenc,
A. Corsi,
K. De,
A. J. Nayana,
S. Makhathini,
I. Heywood,
T. Murphy,
D. L. Kaplan,
P. Chandra,
O. Smirnov,
E. Nakar,
G. Hallinan,
F. Camilo,
R. Fender,
S. Goedhart,
P. Groot,
M. M. Kasliwal,
S. R. Kulkarni,
P. A. Woudt
Abstract:
We present new 0.6-10 GHz observations of the binary neutron star merger GW170817 covering the period up to 300 days post-merger, taken with the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array, the Australia Telescope Compact Array, the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope and the MeerKAT telescope. We use these data to precisely characterize the decay phase of the late-time radio light curve. We find that the tempora…
▽ More
We present new 0.6-10 GHz observations of the binary neutron star merger GW170817 covering the period up to 300 days post-merger, taken with the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array, the Australia Telescope Compact Array, the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope and the MeerKAT telescope. We use these data to precisely characterize the decay phase of the late-time radio light curve. We find that the temporal decay is consistent with a power-law slope of t^-2.2, and that the transition between the power-law rise and decay is relatively sharp. Such a slope cannot be produced by a quasi-isotropic (cocoon-dominated) outflow, but is instead the classic signature of a relativistic jet. This provides strong observational evidence that GW170817 produced a successful jet, and directly demonstrates the link between binary neutron star mergers and short-hard GRBs. Using simple analytical arguments, we derive constraints on the geometry and the jet opening angle of GW170817. These results are consistent with those from our companion Very Long Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) paper, reporting superluminal motion in GW170817.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
A Hubble constant measurement from superluminal motion of the jet in GW170817
Authors:
Kenta Hotokezaka,
Ehud Nakar,
Ore Gottlieb,
Samaya Nissanke,
Kento Masuda,
Gregg Hallinan,
Kunal P. Mooley,
Adam. T. Deller
Abstract:
The Hubble constant ($H_0$) measures the current expansion rate of the Universe, and plays a fundamental role in cosmology. Tremendous effort has been dedicated over the past decades to measure $H_0$. Notably, Planck cosmic microwave background (CMB) and the local Cepheid-supernovae distance ladder measurements determine $H_0$ with a precision of $\sim 1\%$ and $\sim 2\%$ respectively. A $3$-$σ$ l…
▽ More
The Hubble constant ($H_0$) measures the current expansion rate of the Universe, and plays a fundamental role in cosmology. Tremendous effort has been dedicated over the past decades to measure $H_0$. Notably, Planck cosmic microwave background (CMB) and the local Cepheid-supernovae distance ladder measurements determine $H_0$ with a precision of $\sim 1\%$ and $\sim 2\%$ respectively. A $3$-$σ$ level of discrepancy exists between the two measurements, for reasons that have yet to be understood. Gravitational wave (GW) sources accompanied by electromagnetic (EM) counterparts offer a completely independent standard siren (the GW analogue of an astronomical standard candle) measurement of $H_0$, as demonstrated following the discovery of the neutron star merger, GW170817. This measurement does not assume a cosmological model and is independent of a cosmic distance ladder. The first joint analysis of the GW signal from GW170817 and its EM localization led to a measurement of $H_0=74^{+16}_{-8}$ km/s/Mpc (median and symmetric $68\%$ credible interval). In this analysis, the degeneracy in the GW signal between the source distance and the weakly constrained viewing angle dominated the $H_0$ measurement uncertainty. Recently, Mooley et al. (2018) obtained tight constraints on the viewing angle using high angular resolution imaging of the radio counterpart of GW170817. Here we obtain a significantly improved measurement $H_0=68.9^{+4.7}_{-4.6}$ km/s/Mpc by using these new radio observations, combined with the previous GW and EM data. We estimate that 15 more localized GW170817-like events (comparable signal-to-noise ratio, favorable orientation), having radio images and light curve data, will potentially bring resolution to the tension between the Planck and Cepheid-supernova measurements, as compared to 50-100 GW events without such data.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2018; v1 submitted 27 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Superluminal motion of a relativistic jet in the neutron star merger GW170817
Authors:
K. P. Mooley,
A. T. Deller,
O. Gottlieb,
E. Nakar,
G. Hallinan,
S. Bourke,
D. A. Frail,
A. Horesh,
A. Corsi,
K. Hotokezaka
Abstract:
The binary neutron star merger GW170817 was accompanied by radiation across the electromagnetic spectrum and localized to the galaxy NGC 4993 at a distance of 41+/-3 Mpc. The radio and X-ray afterglows of GW170817 exhibited delayed onset, a gradual rise in the emission with time as t^0.8, a peak at about 150 days post-merger, followed by a relatively rapid decline. To date, various models have bee…
▽ More
The binary neutron star merger GW170817 was accompanied by radiation across the electromagnetic spectrum and localized to the galaxy NGC 4993 at a distance of 41+/-3 Mpc. The radio and X-ray afterglows of GW170817 exhibited delayed onset, a gradual rise in the emission with time as t^0.8, a peak at about 150 days post-merger, followed by a relatively rapid decline. To date, various models have been proposed to explain the afterglow emission, including a choked-jet cocoon and a successful-jet cocoon (a.k.a. structured jet). However, the observational data have remained inconclusive as to whether GW170817 launched a successful relativistic jet. Here we show, through Very Long Baseline Interferometry, that the compact radio source associated with GW170817 exhibits superluminal motion between two epochs at 75 and 230 days post-merger. This measurement breaks the degeneracy between the models and indicates that, while the early-time radio emission was powered by a wider-angle outflow (cocoon), the late-time emission was most likely dominated by an energetic and narrowly-collimated jet, with an opening angle of <5 degrees, and observed from a viewing angle of about 20 degrees. The imaging of a collimated relativistic outflow emerging from GW170817 adds substantial weight to the growing evidence linking binary neutron star mergers and short gamma-ray bursts.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2018; v1 submitted 25 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
From $γ$ to Radio - The Electromagnetic Counterpart of GW 170817
Authors:
Ehud Nakar,
Ore Gottlieb,
Tsvi Piran,
Mansi M. Kasliwal,
Greg Hallinan
Abstract:
The gravitational waves from the first binary neutron star merger, GW170817, were accompanied by a multi-wavelength electromagnetic counterpart, from $γ$-rays to radio. The accompanying gamma-rays, seems at first to confirm the association of mergers with short gamma-ray bursts (sGRBs). The common interpretation was that we see an emission from an sGRB jet seen off-axis. However, a closer examinat…
▽ More
The gravitational waves from the first binary neutron star merger, GW170817, were accompanied by a multi-wavelength electromagnetic counterpart, from $γ$-rays to radio. The accompanying gamma-rays, seems at first to confirm the association of mergers with short gamma-ray bursts (sGRBs). The common interpretation was that we see an emission from an sGRB jet seen off-axis. However, a closer examination of the sub-luminous $γ$-rays and the peculiar radio afterglow were inconsistent with this simple interpretation. Here we present results of 3D and 2D numerical simulations that follow the hydrodynamics and emission of the outflow from a neutron star merger form its ejection and up to its deceleration by the circum-merger medium. Our results show that the entire set of $γ$-rays, X-rays and radio observations can be explained by the emission from a mildly relativistic cocoon material (Lorentz factor $\sim$2-5) that was formed while a jet propagated through the material ejected during the merger. The $γ$-rays are generated when the cocoon breaks out from the engulfing ejecta while the afterglow is produced by interaction of the cocoon matter with the interstellar medium. The strong early uv/optical signal may be a Lorentz boosted macronova/kilonova. The fate of the jet itself is currently unknown, but our full-EM models define a path to resolving between successful and choked jet scenarios, outputting coupled predictions for the image size, morphology, observed time-dependent polarization and light curve behavior from radio to X-ray. The predictive power of these models will prove key in interpreting the on-going multi-faceted observations of this unprecedented event.
△ Less
Submitted 20 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
A mildly relativistic wide-angle outflow in the neutron star merger GW170817
Authors:
K. P. Mooley,
E. Nakar,
K. Hotokezaka,
G. Hallinan,
A. Corsi,
D. A. Frail,
A. Horesh,
T. Murphy,
E. Lenc,
D. L. Kaplan,
K. De,
D. Dobie,
P. Chandra,
A. Deller,
O. Gottlieb,
M. M. Kasliwal,
S. R. Kulkarni,
S. T. Myers,
S. Nissanke,
T. Piran,
C. Lynch,
V. Bhalerao,
S. Bourke,
K. W. Bannister,
L. P. Singer
Abstract:
GW170817 is the first gravitational wave detection of a binary neutron star merger. It was accompanied by radiation across the electromagnetic spectrum and localized to the galaxy NGC 4993 at a distance of 40 Mpc. It has been proposed that the observed gamma-ray, X-ray and radio emission is due to an ultra-relativistic jet launched during the merger, directed away from our line of sight. The prese…
▽ More
GW170817 is the first gravitational wave detection of a binary neutron star merger. It was accompanied by radiation across the electromagnetic spectrum and localized to the galaxy NGC 4993 at a distance of 40 Mpc. It has been proposed that the observed gamma-ray, X-ray and radio emission is due to an ultra-relativistic jet launched during the merger, directed away from our line of sight. The presence of such a jet is predicted from models positing neutron star mergers as the central engines driving short-hard gamma-ray bursts (SGRBs). Here we show that the radio light curve of GW170817 has no direct signature of an off-axis jet afterglow. While we cannot rule out the existence of a jet pointing elsewhere, the observed gamma-rays could not have originated from such a jet. Instead, the radio data requires a mildly relativistic wide-angle outflow moving towards us. This outflow could be the high velocity tail of the neutron-rich material dynamically ejected during the merger or a cocoon of material that breaks out when a jet transfers its energy to the dynamical ejecta. The cocoon scenario can explain the radio light curve of GW170817 as well as the gamma-rays and X-rays (possibly also ultraviolet and optical emission), and hence is the model most consistent with the observational data. Cocoons may be a ubiquitous phenomenon produced in neutron star mergers, giving rise to a heretofore unidentified population of radio, ultraviolet, X-ray and gamma-ray transients in the local universe.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2017; v1 submitted 30 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Illuminating Gravitational Waves: A Concordant Picture of Photons from a Neutron Star Merger
Authors:
M. M. Kasliwal,
E. Nakar,
L. P. Singer,
D. L. Kaplan,
D. O. Cook,
A. Van Sistine,
R. M. Lau,
C. Fremling,
O. Gottlieb,
J. E. Jencson,
S. M. Adams,
U. Feindt,
K. Hotokezaka,
S. Ghosh,
D. A. Perley,
P. -C. Yu,
T. Piran,
J. R. Allison,
G. C. Anupama,
A. Balasubramanian,
K. W Bannister,
J. Bally,
J. Barnes,
S. Barway,
E. Bellm
, et al. (56 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Merging neutron stars offer an exquisite laboratory for simultaneously studying strong-field gravity and matter in extreme environments. We establish the physical association of an electromagnetic counterpart EM170817 to gravitational waves (GW170817) detected from merging neutron stars. By synthesizing a panchromatic dataset, we demonstrate that merging neutron stars are a long-sought production…
▽ More
Merging neutron stars offer an exquisite laboratory for simultaneously studying strong-field gravity and matter in extreme environments. We establish the physical association of an electromagnetic counterpart EM170817 to gravitational waves (GW170817) detected from merging neutron stars. By synthesizing a panchromatic dataset, we demonstrate that merging neutron stars are a long-sought production site forging heavy elements by r-process nucleosynthesis. The weak gamma-rays seen in EM170817 are dissimilar to classical short gamma-ray bursts with ultra-relativistic jets. Instead, we suggest that breakout of a wide-angle, mildly-relativistic cocoon engulfing the jet elegantly explains the low-luminosity gamma-rays, the high-luminosity ultraviolet-optical-infrared and the delayed radio/X-ray emission. We posit that all merging neutron stars may lead to a wide-angle cocoon breakout; sometimes accompanied by a successful jet and sometimes a choked jet.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
A Radio Counterpart to a Neutron Star Merger
Authors:
G. Hallinan,
A. Corsi,
K. P. Mooley,
K. Hotokezaka,
E. Nakar,
M. M. Kasliwal,
D. L. Kaplan,
D. A. Frail,
S. T. Myers,
T. Murphy,
K. De,
D. Dobie,
J. R. Allison,
K. W. Bannister,
V. Bhalerao,
P. Chandra,
T. E. Clarke,
S. Giacintucci,
A. Y. Q. Ho,
A. Horesh,
N. E. Kassim,
S. R. Kulkarni,
E. Lenc,
F. J. Lockman,
C. Lynch
, et al. (8 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Gravitational waves have been detected from a binary neutron star merger event, GW170817. The detection of electromagnetic radiation from the same source has shown that the merger occurred in the outskirts of the galaxy NGC 4993, at a distance of 40 megaparsecs from Earth. We report the detection of a counterpart radio source that appears 16 days after the event, allowing us to diagnose the energe…
▽ More
Gravitational waves have been detected from a binary neutron star merger event, GW170817. The detection of electromagnetic radiation from the same source has shown that the merger occurred in the outskirts of the galaxy NGC 4993, at a distance of 40 megaparsecs from Earth. We report the detection of a counterpart radio source that appears 16 days after the event, allowing us to diagnose the energetics and environment of the merger. The observed radio emission can be explained by either a collimated ultra-relativistic jet viewed off-axis, or a cocoon of mildly relativistic ejecta. Within 100 days of the merger, the radio light curves will distinguish between these models and very long baseline interferometry will have the capability to directly measure the angular velocity and geometry of the debris.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Radio Counterparts of Compact Binary Mergers detectable in Gravitational Waves: A Simulation for an Optimized Survey
Authors:
Kenta Hotokezaka,
Samaya Nissanke,
Gregg Hallinan,
T. Joseph W. Lazio,
Ehud Nakar,
Tsvi Piran
Abstract:
Mergers of binary neutron stars and black hole-neutron star binaries produce gravitational-wave (GW) emission and outflows with significant kinetic energies. These outflows result in radio emissions through synchrotron radiation. We explore the detectability of these synchrotron generated radio signals by follow-up observations of GW merger events lacking a detection of electromagnetic counterpart…
▽ More
Mergers of binary neutron stars and black hole-neutron star binaries produce gravitational-wave (GW) emission and outflows with significant kinetic energies. These outflows result in radio emissions through synchrotron radiation. We explore the detectability of these synchrotron generated radio signals by follow-up observations of GW merger events lacking a detection of electromagnetic counterparts in other wavelengths. We model radio light curves arising from (i) sub-relativistic merger ejecta and (ii) ultra-relativistic jets. The former produces radio remnants on timescales of a few years and the latter produces $γ$-ray bursts in the direction of the jet and orphan-radio afterglows extending over wider angles on timescales of weeks. Based on the derived light curves, we suggest an optimized survey at $1.4$ GHz with five epochs separated by a logarithmic time interval. We estimate the detectability of the radio counterparts of simulated GW-merger events to be detected by advanced LIGO and Virgo by current and future radio facilities. The detectable distances for these GW merger events could be as high as 1 Gpc. $20$--$60\%$ of the long-lasting radio remnants will be detectable in the case of the moderate kinetic energy of $3\cdot 10^{50}$ erg and a circum-merger density of $0.1 {\rm cm^{-3}}$ or larger, while $5$--$20\%$ of the orphan radio afterglows with kinetic energy of $10^{48}$ erg will be detectable. The detection likelihood increases if one focuses on the well-localizable GW events. We discuss the background noise due to radio fluxes of host galaxies and false positives arising from extragalactic radio transients and variable Active Galactic Nuclei and we show that the quiet radio transient sky is of great advantage when searching for the radio counterparts.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2016; v1 submitted 30 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
