-
Path integrals, saddle points and the beginning of the universe
Authors:
Alice Di Tucci
Abstract:
The very early universe is understood in terms of quantum field theories on curved spacetime, where the classical background spacetime is typically an FLRW cosmology and the quantum fields which propagate on it include gravitational waves and energy density fluctuations. Many open questions seem to relate to the fact that we very little understand this regime, where part of the gravitational degre…
▽ More
The very early universe is understood in terms of quantum field theories on curved spacetime, where the classical background spacetime is typically an FLRW cosmology and the quantum fields which propagate on it include gravitational waves and energy density fluctuations. Many open questions seem to relate to the fact that we very little understand this regime, where part of the gravitational degrees of freedom, and only part of them, are quantized. In this work we study this limit by assigning quantum properties both to the background universe and the fluctuations and then focusing on the limit where the background universe behaves nearly classically. The quantization is realized in the framework of quantum general relativity through Feymann's path integrals. We study the saddle point approximation of gravitational path integrals in the cases of a positive and a negative cosmological constant making use of the minisuperspace approximation focusing on the impact of different classes boundary conditions. Our main finding is that, both for the no boundary proposal and black holes in Euclidean anti-de Sitter space, the path integral needs to be defined with Neumann initial conditions. The Neumann condition is in fact necessary to recover sensible black holes thermodynamics and to stabilize the no boundary proposal. At the same time, it can be seen, in both cases, as a regularity requirement on the geometries entering the sum. The need for Neumann conditions implies that the interpretation of the no boundary wavefunction is very different from Hartle and Hawking's original intuition, since the initial expansion rate of the universe is fixed rather than its size. Our results for black holes stand in support of this implementation of the no boundary proposal, where regularity is the primary requirement and allows for a well-defined QFT in curved spacetime limit.
△ Less
Submitted 20 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Lessons for quantum cosmology from anti-de Sitter black holes
Authors:
Alice Di Tucci,
Michal P. Heller,
Jean-Luc Lehners
Abstract:
Gravitational physics is arguably better understood in the presence of a negative cosmological constant than a positive one, yet there exist strong technical similarities between the two settings. These similarities can be exploited to enhance our understanding of the more speculative realm of quantum cosmology, building on robust results regarding anti-de Sitter black holes describing the thermod…
▽ More
Gravitational physics is arguably better understood in the presence of a negative cosmological constant than a positive one, yet there exist strong technical similarities between the two settings. These similarities can be exploited to enhance our understanding of the more speculative realm of quantum cosmology, building on robust results regarding anti-de Sitter black holes describing the thermodynamics of holographic quantum field theories. To this end, we study 4-dimensional gravitational path integrals in the presence of a negative cosmological constant, and with minisuperspace metrics. We put a special emphasis on boundary conditions and integration contours. The Hawking-Page transition is recovered and we find that below the minimum temperature required for the existence of black holes the corresponding saddle points become complex. When the asymptotic anti-de Sitter space is cut off at a finite distance, additional saddle points contribute to the partition function, albeit in a very suppressed manner. These findings have direct consequences for the no-boundary proposal in cosmology, because the anti-de Sitter calculation can be brought into one-to-one correspondence with a path integral for de Sitter space with Neumann conditions imposed at the nucleation of the universe. Our results lend support to recent implementations of the no-boundary proposal focusing on momentum conditions at the "big bang".
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2020; v1 submitted 9 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
No-boundary prescriptions in Lorentzian quantum cosmology
Authors:
Alice Di Tucci,
Jean-Luc Lehners,
Laura Sberna
Abstract:
We analyse the impact of various boundary conditions on the (minisuperspace) Lorentzian gravitational path integral. In particular we assess the implications for the Hartle-Hawking no-boundary wavefunction. It was shown recently that when this proposal is defined as a sum over compact metrics, problems arise with the stability of fluctuations. These difficulties can be overcome by an especially si…
▽ More
We analyse the impact of various boundary conditions on the (minisuperspace) Lorentzian gravitational path integral. In particular we assess the implications for the Hartle-Hawking no-boundary wavefunction. It was shown recently that when this proposal is defined as a sum over compact metrics, problems arise with the stability of fluctuations. These difficulties can be overcome by an especially simple implementation of the no-boundary idea: namely to take the Einstein-Hilbert action at face value while adding no boundary term. This prescription simultaneously imposes an initial Neumann boundary condition for the scale factor of the universe and, for a Bianchi IX spacetime, Dirichlet conditions for the anisotropies. Another way to implement the no-boundary wavefunction is to use Robin boundary conditions. A sub-class of Robin conditions allows one to specify the Hubble rate on the boundary hypersurface, and we highlight the surprising aspect that specifying the final Hubble rate (rather than the final size of the universe) significantly alters the off-shell structure of the path integral. The conclusion of our investigations is that all current working examples of the no-boundary wavefunction force one to abandon the notion of a sum over compact and regular geometries, and point to the importance of an initial Euclidean momentum.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2022; v1 submitted 15 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Homogeneous Transitions during Inflation: a Description in Quantum Cosmology
Authors:
Sebastian F. Bramberger,
Alice Di Tucci,
Jean-Luc Lehners
Abstract:
The usual description of inflationary fluctuations uses the framework of quantum field theory (QFT) in curved spacetime, in which quantum fluctuations are superimposed on a classical background spacetime. Even for large fluctuations, such as those envisioned during a regime of eternal inflation, this framework is frequently used. In the present work we go one step beyond this description by quanti…
▽ More
The usual description of inflationary fluctuations uses the framework of quantum field theory (QFT) in curved spacetime, in which quantum fluctuations are superimposed on a classical background spacetime. Even for large fluctuations, such as those envisioned during a regime of eternal inflation, this framework is frequently used. In the present work we go one step beyond this description by quantising both the scalar field and the scale factor of the universe. Employing the Lorentzian path integral formulation of semi-classical gravity we restrict to a simplified minisuperspace setting by considering homogeneous transitions. This approach allows us to determine the dominant geometry and inflaton evolution contributing to such amplitudes. We find that for precisely specified initial scale factor and inflaton values (and uncertain momenta), two distinct saddle point geometries contribute to the amplitude, leading to interference effects. However, when the momenta of both scale factor and inflaton are specified with sufficient certainty, only a single saddle point is relevant and QFT in curved spacetime is applicable. In particular we find that for inflaton transitions up the potential, meaningful results are only obtained when the initial uncertainty in the inflaton value is large enough, allowing the dominant evolution to be a complexified slow-roll solution \emph{down} from a comparatively unlikely position higher up in the potential.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Quantum Incompleteness of Inflation
Authors:
Alice Di Tucci,
Job Feldbrugge,
Jean-Luc Lehners,
Neil Turok
Abstract:
Inflation is most often described using quantum field theory (QFT) on a fixed, curved spacetime background. Such a description is valid only if the spatial volume of the region considered is so large that its size and shape moduli behave classically. However, if we trace an inflating universe back to early times, the volume of any comoving region of interest -- for example the present Hubble volum…
▽ More
Inflation is most often described using quantum field theory (QFT) on a fixed, curved spacetime background. Such a description is valid only if the spatial volume of the region considered is so large that its size and shape moduli behave classically. However, if we trace an inflating universe back to early times, the volume of any comoving region of interest -- for example the present Hubble volume -- becomes exponentially small. Hence, quantum fluctuations in the trajectory of the background cannot be neglected at early times. In this paper, we develop a path integral description of a flat, inflating patch (approximated as de Sitter spacetime), treating both the background scale factor and the gravitational wave perturbations quantum mechanically. We find this description fails at small values of the initial scale factor, because \emph{two} background saddle point solutions contribute to the path integral. This leads to a breakdown of QFT in curved spacetime, causing the fluctuations to be unstable and out of control. We show the problem may be alleviated by a careful choice of quantum initial conditions, for the background and the fluctuations, provided that the volume of the initial, inflating patch is larger than $\gg H^{-1}$ in Planck units with $H$ the Hubble constant at the start of inflation. The price of the remedy is high: not only the inflating background, but also the stable, Bunch-Davies fluctuations must be input by hand. Our discussion emphasizes that, even if the inflationary scale is far below the Planck mass, new physics is required to explain the initial quantum state of the universe.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2019; v1 submitted 21 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
The No-Boundary Proposal as a Path Integral with Robin Boundary Conditions
Authors:
Alice Di Tucci,
Jean-Luc Lehners
Abstract:
Realising the no-boundary proposal of Hartle and Hawking as a consistent gravitational path integral has been a long-standing puzzle. In particular, it was demonstrated by Feldbrugge et al. that the sum over all universes starting from zero size results in an unstable saddle point geometry. Here we show that in the context of gravity with a positive cosmological constant, path integrals with a spe…
▽ More
Realising the no-boundary proposal of Hartle and Hawking as a consistent gravitational path integral has been a long-standing puzzle. In particular, it was demonstrated by Feldbrugge et al. that the sum over all universes starting from zero size results in an unstable saddle point geometry. Here we show that in the context of gravity with a positive cosmological constant, path integrals with a specific family of Robin boundary conditions overcome this problem. These path integrals are manifestly convergent and are approximated by stable Hartle-Hawking saddle point geometries. The price to pay is that the off-shell geometries do not start at zero size. The Robin boundary conditions may be interpreted as an initial state with Euclidean momentum, with the quantum uncertainty shared between initial size and momentum.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2019; v1 submitted 15 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Unstable no-boundary fluctuations from sums over regular metrics
Authors:
Alice Di Tucci,
Jean-Luc Lehners
Abstract:
It was recently shown by Feldbrugge et al. that the no-boundary proposal, defined via a Lorentzian path integral and in minisuperspace, leads to unstable fluctuations, in disagreement with early universe observations. In these calculations many off-shell geometries summed over in the path integral in fact contain singularities, and the question arose whether the instability might ultimately be cau…
▽ More
It was recently shown by Feldbrugge et al. that the no-boundary proposal, defined via a Lorentzian path integral and in minisuperspace, leads to unstable fluctuations, in disagreement with early universe observations. In these calculations many off-shell geometries summed over in the path integral in fact contain singularities, and the question arose whether the instability might ultimately be caused by these off-shell singularities. We address this question here by considering a sum over purely regular geometries, by extending a calculation pioneered by Halliwell and Louko. We confirm that the fluctuations are unstable, even in this restricted context which, arguably, is closer in spirit to the original proposal of Hartle and Hawking. Elucidating the reasons for the instability of the no-boundary proposal will hopefully show how to overcome these difficulties, or pave the way to new theories of initial conditions for the universe.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
