-
Aretakis Hair for Extreme Kerr Black Holes with Axisymmetric Scalar Perturbations
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
Gaurav Khanna,
Subir Sabharwal
Abstract:
We study the evolution of axially-symmetric scalar field perturbations on an extreme Kerr spacetime for initial data with multipole moments $\ell^{\prime}$ higher than the least radiative mode, and we measure modes $\ell$ -- and for the first time also horizon charges -- that are excited by mode coupling interactions. We then find the Ori-Sela prefactors, a certain quantity that can be evaluated a…
▽ More
We study the evolution of axially-symmetric scalar field perturbations on an extreme Kerr spacetime for initial data with multipole moments $\ell^{\prime}$ higher than the least radiative mode, and we measure modes $\ell$ -- and for the first time also horizon charges -- that are excited by mode coupling interactions. We then find the Ori-Sela prefactors, a certain quantity that can be evaluated at finite distances and the Aretakis constant along the event horizon of the extreme Kerr black hole for a sequence of initial data preparations that differ only by their distance from the event horizon. We find that for initial data in the near field there is a linear relationship of the Aretakis constant and the Ori-Sela prefactor. For initial data farther than these the linear relationship is not universal, and we propose that stronger numerical simulations would be needed to regain linearity. The linear relationship suggests that the Aretakis charge along the event horizon can be measured at a finite distance, thereby extending this type of violation of the no-hair theorems from the least radiative axisymmetric mode also to situations that involve mode coupling.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
New Horizons for Fundamental Physics with LISA
Authors:
K. G. Arun,
Enis Belgacem,
Robert Benkel,
Laura Bernard,
Emanuele Berti,
Gianfranco Bertone,
Marc Besancon,
Diego Blas,
Christian G. Böhmer,
Richard Brito,
Gianluca Calcagni,
Alejandro Cardenas-Avendaño,
Katy Clough,
Marco Crisostomi,
Valerio De Luca,
Daniela Doneva,
Stephanie Escoffier,
Jose Maria Ezquiaga,
Pedro G. Ferreira,
Pierre Fleury,
Stefano Foffa,
Gabriele Franciolini,
Noemi Frusciante,
Juan García-Bellido,
Carlos Herdeiro
, et al. (116 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA) has the potential to reveal wonders about the fundamental theory of nature at play in the extreme gravity regime, where the gravitational interaction is both strong and dynamical. In this white paper, the Fundamental Physics Working Group of the LISA Consortium summarizes the current topics in fundamental physics where LISA observations of GWs can be e…
▽ More
The Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA) has the potential to reveal wonders about the fundamental theory of nature at play in the extreme gravity regime, where the gravitational interaction is both strong and dynamical. In this white paper, the Fundamental Physics Working Group of the LISA Consortium summarizes the current topics in fundamental physics where LISA observations of GWs can be expected to provide key input. We provide the briefest of reviews to then delineate avenues for future research directions and to discuss connections between this working group, other working groups and the consortium work package teams. These connections must be developed for LISA to live up to its science potential in these areas.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Climbing up the memory staircase: Equatorial zoom-whirl orbits
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
Gaurav Khanna
Abstract:
The nonlinear, or null gravitational memory effect for zoom-whirl orbits around fast spinning Kerr black holes for extreme mass ratio systems has a staircase structure. The latter is characterized by a periodic fast increase in the memory during the whirl phases of the orbit, and near constant levels when the orbit is near apoapsis. We study the contribution of different spherical harmonic modes t…
▽ More
The nonlinear, or null gravitational memory effect for zoom-whirl orbits around fast spinning Kerr black holes for extreme mass ratio systems has a staircase structure. The latter is characterized by a periodic fast increase in the memory during the whirl phases of the orbit, and near constant levels when the orbit is near apoapsis. We study the contribution of different spherical harmonic modes to this effect, and discuss the relative importance thereof. Because the hereditary memory effect increases in magnitude linearly in the number of periapsis passages on a dynamical time scale, while the oscillatory parent gravitational waves are sourced by an orbit that evolves on a much longer radiation reaction time scale, the magnitude of the former relative to the latter increases with time. We also consider orphan memory and the memory effect for extreme mass ratio inspirals. We then discuss the prospect of detection with the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA).
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Scalar and gravitational hair for extreme Kerr black holes
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
Gaurav Khanna,
Subir Sabharwal
Abstract:
For scalar perturbations of an extreme Reissner-Nordstr{\" o}m black hole we show numerically that the Ori pre-factor equals the Aretakis conserved charge. We demonstrate a linear relation of a generalized Ori pre-factor -- a certain expression obtained from the late-time expansion or the perturbation field at finite distances -- and the Aretakis conserved charge for a family of scalar or gravitat…
▽ More
For scalar perturbations of an extreme Reissner-Nordstr{\" o}m black hole we show numerically that the Ori pre-factor equals the Aretakis conserved charge. We demonstrate a linear relation of a generalized Ori pre-factor -- a certain expression obtained from the late-time expansion or the perturbation field at finite distances -- and the Aretakis conserved charge for a family of scalar or gravitational perturbations of an extreme Kerr black hole, whose members vary only in the radial location of the center of the initial packet. We infer that it can be established that there is an Aretakis conserved charge for scalar or gravitational perturbations of extreme Kerr black holes. This conclusion, in addition to the calculation of the Aretakis charge, can be made from measurements at a finite distance: Extreme Kerr black holes have gravitational hair that can be measured at finite distances. This gravitational hair can in principle be detected by gravitational-wave detectors.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Prospects for Fundamental Physics with LISA
Authors:
Enrico Barausse,
Emanuele Berti,
Thomas Hertog,
Scott A. Hughes,
Philippe Jetzer,
Paolo Pani,
Thomas P. Sotiriou,
Nicola Tamanini,
Helvi Witek,
Kent Yagi,
Nicolas Yunes,
T. Abdelsalhin,
A. Achucarro,
K. V. Aelst,
N. Afshordi,
S. Akcay,
L. Annulli,
K. G. Arun,
I. Ayuso,
V. Baibhav,
T. Baker,
H. Bantilan,
T. Barreiro,
C. Barrera-Hinojosa,
N. Bartolo
, et al. (296 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
In this paper, which is of programmatic rather than quantitative nature, we aim to further delineate and sharpen the future potential of the LISA mission in the area of fundamental physics. Given the very broad range of topics that might be relevant to LISA, we present here a sample of what we view as particularly promising directions, based in part on the current research interests of the LISA sc…
▽ More
In this paper, which is of programmatic rather than quantitative nature, we aim to further delineate and sharpen the future potential of the LISA mission in the area of fundamental physics. Given the very broad range of topics that might be relevant to LISA, we present here a sample of what we view as particularly promising directions, based in part on the current research interests of the LISA scientific community in the area of fundamental physics. We organize these directions through a "science-first" approach that allows us to classify how LISA data can inform theoretical physics in a variety of areas. For each of these theoretical physics classes, we identify the sources that are currently expected to provide the principal contribution to our knowledge, and the areas that need further development. The classification presented here should not be thought of as cast in stone, but rather as a fluid framework that is amenable to change with the flow of new insights in theoretical physics.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2020; v1 submitted 27 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Repeated Ringing of the Black Hole's Bell: Quasi-Normal Bursts from Highly Eccentric, Extreme Mass-Ratio Binaries
Authors:
Nur E. M. Rifat,
Gaurav Khanna,
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
Recent studies of scalar and gravitational waveforms from high-eccentricity, extreme mass-ratio black hole binaries show the presence of quasi-normal bursts (QNB) -- lingering high frequency decaying oscillations (also known as ``wiggles'') -- soon after each periapsis passage. One puzzle associated with these QNB is that in the case of a nearly-extreme rotating central black hole the frequency of…
▽ More
Recent studies of scalar and gravitational waveforms from high-eccentricity, extreme mass-ratio black hole binaries show the presence of quasi-normal bursts (QNB) -- lingering high frequency decaying oscillations (also known as ``wiggles'') -- soon after each periapsis passage. One puzzle associated with these QNB is that in the case of a nearly-extreme rotating central black hole the frequency of the QNB has been found to be in a range which is lower than the corresponding range of relevant quasi-normal modes. We reproduce these results using a different approach and perform a detailed analysis to find evidence for the resolution of the puzzle and for the origin of the QNB. We find that the QNB frequency as measured at future null infinity evolves in (retarded) time and approaches the dominant quasi-normal frequency exponentially in time. We also show that the QNB amplitude decays inversely in (retarded) time. We discuss the time dependence of both the QNB waveform frequency and its amplitude and argue that this behavior arises as a result of the excitation of many quasi-normal overtones and the summation thereof.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
(Transient) Scalar Hair for (Nearly) Extreme Black Holes
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
Gaurav Khanna,
Subir Sabharwal
Abstract:
It has been shown recently that extreme Reissner-Nordström black holes perturbed by a minimally coupled, free, massless scalar field have permanent scalar hair. The hair - a conserved charge calculated at the black hole's event horizon - can be measured by a certain expression at future null infinity: the latter approaches the hair inversely in time. We generalize this newly discovered hair also f…
▽ More
It has been shown recently that extreme Reissner-Nordström black holes perturbed by a minimally coupled, free, massless scalar field have permanent scalar hair. The hair - a conserved charge calculated at the black hole's event horizon - can be measured by a certain expression at future null infinity: the latter approaches the hair inversely in time. We generalize this newly discovered hair also for extreme Kerr black holes. We study the behavior of nearly extreme black hole hair and its measurement at future null infinity as a transient phenomenon. For nearly extreme black holes the measurement at future null infinity of the length of the newly grown hair decreases quadratically in time at intermediate times until its length becomes short and the rate at which the length shortens further slows down. Eventually, the nearly extreme BH becomes bald again like non-extreme BHs.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2019; v1 submitted 7 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
The Marolf-Ori singularity inside fast spinning black holes
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
Gaurav Khanna
Abstract:
The effective shock wave singularity at the outgoing leg of the inner horizon of a linearly perturbed fast spinning black hole is studied numerically for either scalar field, or vacuum, gravitational perturbations. We demonstrate the occurrence of the Marolf-Ori singularity, including changes of order unity in the scalar field $φ$ for the scalar field model, and in the Weyl scalars $ψ_0$ and…
▽ More
The effective shock wave singularity at the outgoing leg of the inner horizon of a linearly perturbed fast spinning black hole is studied numerically for either scalar field, or vacuum, gravitational perturbations. We demonstrate the occurrence of the Marolf-Ori singularity, including changes of order unity in the scalar field $φ$ for the scalar field model, and in the Weyl scalars $ψ_0$ and $ψ_4$ (rescaled appropriately by the horizon function $Δ$) and the Kretschmann curvature scalar $K$ for the vacuum, gravitational perturbations model for both null and timelike geodesic observers. We quantify the shock sharpening effect and show that in all cases its rate agrees with expectations.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Physical objects approaching the Cauchy horizon of a rapidly rotating Kerr black hole
Authors:
Caroline Mallary,
Gaurav Khanna,
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
We solve the 2+1-dimensional Teukolsky equation numerically for the Weyl scalars $ψ_0$ and $ψ_4$ along a time-like geodesic approaching the Cauchy horizon of a rapidly rotating perturbed Kerr black hole. We find that both the amplitude and frequency of the Weyl scalars agree with the results of linear perturbation analysis. We then model a physical object by a simple damped harmonic oscillator, wh…
▽ More
We solve the 2+1-dimensional Teukolsky equation numerically for the Weyl scalars $ψ_0$ and $ψ_4$ along a time-like geodesic approaching the Cauchy horizon of a rapidly rotating perturbed Kerr black hole. We find that both the amplitude and frequency of the Weyl scalars agree with the results of linear perturbation analysis. We then model a physical object by a simple damped harmonic oscillator, which is driven by an external force that mimics the tidal force experienced by the infalling object. We use this model to find the total deformation of the object at the Cauchy horizon, and the resonant effect when the driving force's frequency matches the internal frequency of the oscillator that models the object.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2018; v1 submitted 17 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Linearized Stability of Extreme Black Holes
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
Gaurav Khanna
Abstract:
Extreme black holes have been argued to be unstable, in the sense that under linearized gravitational perturbations of the extreme Kerr spacetime the Weyl scalar $ψ_4$ blows up along their event horizons at very late advanced times. We show numerically, by solving the Teukolsky equation in 2+1D, that all algebraically-independent curvature scalar polynomials approach limits that exist when advance…
▽ More
Extreme black holes have been argued to be unstable, in the sense that under linearized gravitational perturbations of the extreme Kerr spacetime the Weyl scalar $ψ_4$ blows up along their event horizons at very late advanced times. We show numerically, by solving the Teukolsky equation in 2+1D, that all algebraically-independent curvature scalar polynomials approach limits that exist when advanced time along the event horizon approaches infinity. Therefore, the horizons of extreme black holes are stable against linearized gravitational perturbations. We argue that the divergence of $ψ_4$ is a consequence of the choice of a fixed tetrad, and that in a suitable dynamical tetrad all Weyl scalars, including $ψ_4$, approach their background extreme Kerr values. We make similar conclusions also for the case of scalar field perturbations of extreme Kerr.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Gravitational waves from a plunge into a nearly extremal Kerr black hole
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
Gaurav Khanna
Abstract:
We study numerically in the time domain the linearized gravitational waves emitted from a plunge into a nearly extremal Kerr black hole by solving the inhomogeneous Teukolsky equation. We consider spinning black holes for which the specific spin angular momentum $a/M=1-ε$, and we consider values of $ε\geq 10^{-6}$. We find an effective transient behavior for the quasi-normal ringdown: the early ph…
▽ More
We study numerically in the time domain the linearized gravitational waves emitted from a plunge into a nearly extremal Kerr black hole by solving the inhomogeneous Teukolsky equation. We consider spinning black holes for which the specific spin angular momentum $a/M=1-ε$, and we consider values of $ε\geq 10^{-6}$. We find an effective transient behavior for the quasi-normal ringdown: the early phase of the quasi-normal ringdown is governed by a decay according to inverse time, with frequency equaling twice the black hole's horizon frequency. The smaller $ε$ the later the transition from this transient inverse time decay to exponential decay. Such sources, if exist, may be interesting potential sources for terrestrial or space borne gravitational wave observatories.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
Gravitational Wave Detection in the Introductory Lab
Authors:
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
Great physics breakthroughs are rarely included in the introductory physics or astronomy course. General relativity and binary black hole coalescence are no different, and can be included in the introductory course only in a very limited sense. However, we can design activities that directly involve the detection of GW150914, the designation of the Gravitation Wave signal detected on September 14,…
▽ More
Great physics breakthroughs are rarely included in the introductory physics or astronomy course. General relativity and binary black hole coalescence are no different, and can be included in the introductory course only in a very limited sense. However, we can design activities that directly involve the detection of GW150914, the designation of the Gravitation Wave signal detected on September 14, 2015, thereby engage the students in this exciting discovery directly. The activities naturally do not include the construction of a detector or the detection of gravitational waves. Instead, we design it to include analysis of the data from GW150914, which includes some interesting analysis activities for students of the introductory course. The same activities can be assigned either as a laboratory exercise or as a computational project for the same population of students. The analysis tools used here are simple and available to the intended student population. It does not include the sophisticated analysis tools, which was used by LIGO to carefully analyze the detected signal. However, these simple tools are sufficient to allow the student to get important results.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2018; v1 submitted 15 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Cauchy-horizon singularity inside perturbed Kerr black holes
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
Gaurav Khanna,
Anıl Zenginoǧlu
Abstract:
The Cauchy horizon inside a perturbed Kerr black hole develops an instability that transforms it into a curvature singularity. We solve for the linearized Weyl scalars $ψ_0$ and $ψ_4$ and for the curvature scalar $R_{αβγδ}R^{αβγδ}$ along outgoing null rays approaching the Cauchy horizon in the interior of perturbed Kerr black holes using the Teukolsky equation, and compare our results with those f…
▽ More
The Cauchy horizon inside a perturbed Kerr black hole develops an instability that transforms it into a curvature singularity. We solve for the linearized Weyl scalars $ψ_0$ and $ψ_4$ and for the curvature scalar $R_{αβγδ}R^{αβγδ}$ along outgoing null rays approaching the Cauchy horizon in the interior of perturbed Kerr black holes using the Teukolsky equation, and compare our results with those found in perturbation analysis. Our results corroborate the previous perturbation analysis result that at its early parts the Cauchy horizon evolves into a deformationally-weak, null, scalar-curvature singularity. We find excellent agreement for $ψ_0(u={\rm const},v)$, where $u,v$ are advanced and retarded times, respectively. We do find, however, that the exponential growth rate of $R_{αβγδ}R^{αβγδ}(u={\rm const},v)$ approaching the singularity is dramatically slower than that found in perturbation analysis, and that the angular frequency is in excellent agreement.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2017; v1 submitted 19 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Self-force gravitational waveforms for extreme and intermediate mass ratio inspirals. III: Spin-orbit coupling revisited
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
Gaurav Khanna
Abstract:
The first- and second-order dissipative self force and the first order conservative self force are applied together with spin-orbit coupling to the quasi-circular motion of a test mass in the spacetime of a Schwarzschild black hole, for extreme or intermediate mass ratios. The partial dephasing of the gravitational waveform (at the order that is independent of the system's mass ratio) due to the s…
▽ More
The first- and second-order dissipative self force and the first order conservative self force are applied together with spin-orbit coupling to the quasi-circular motion of a test mass in the spacetime of a Schwarzschild black hole, for extreme or intermediate mass ratios. The partial dephasing of the gravitational waveform (at the order that is independent of the system's mass ratio) due to the self force is compared with that of spin-orbit coupling. We find that accurate waveforms for parameter estimation need to include both effects. Specifically, we find a particular value for the spin parameter such that the spin-orbit effect cancels out the self-force effect on the waveform. Exclusion of dephasing effects that are independent of the mass ratio therefore might lead to a non-perturbative error in the estimation of the system's parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2015; v1 submitted 17 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Mode coupling mechanism for late-time Kerr tails
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
Gaurav Khanna
Abstract:
We consider the decay rate for scalar fields in Kerr spacetime. We consider pure initial (azimuthal) multipoles $\ell'$ with respect to the class which includes Boyer-Lindquist coordinates, and focus attention on the decay rate of the multipole $\ell$. We use an iterative method proposed by Gleiser, Price, and Pullin, and identify the mode coupling mechanism through the iterations in powers of the…
▽ More
We consider the decay rate for scalar fields in Kerr spacetime. We consider pure initial (azimuthal) multipoles $\ell'$ with respect to the class which includes Boyer-Lindquist coordinates, and focus attention on the decay rate of the multipole $\ell$. We use an iterative method proposed by Gleiser, Price, and Pullin, and identify the mode coupling mechanism through the iterations in powers of the square of the Kerr black hole's specific angular momentum that gives rise to a decay rate formula recently proposed by Zenginoğlu, Khanna, and Burko. Modes $\ell$ may be excited through different channels, each leading to its own decay rate. The asymptotic decay rate of the mode $\ell$ is the slowest of the decay rate of the various channels. In some cases, more than one channel leads to the same decay rate, and then the amplitude of the mode is the sum of the amplitudes of the partial fields generated by the individual channels. We also show that one may identify the asymptotically-dominant channel of mode excitations, and obtain approximate results for the mode of interest by studying the dominant channel. The results of the dominant channel approximation approach the full-mode results at late times, and their difference approaches zero quadratically in inverse time.
△ Less
Submitted 18 December, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
-
Self-force gravitational waveforms for extreme and intermediate mass ratio inspirals. II: Importance of the second-order dissipative effect
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
Gaurav Khanna
Abstract:
We consider the importance of the second-order dissipative self force for gravitational wave dephasing for an extreme or intermediate mass ratio system moving along a quasi-circular Schwarzschild orbit. For the first-order self force we use the fully relativistic force in the Lorenz gauge for eternally circular geodesics. The second-order self force is modeled by its 3.5 post Newtonian counterpart…
▽ More
We consider the importance of the second-order dissipative self force for gravitational wave dephasing for an extreme or intermediate mass ratio system moving along a quasi-circular Schwarzschild orbit. For the first-order self force we use the fully relativistic force in the Lorenz gauge for eternally circular geodesics. The second-order self force is modeled by its 3.5 post Newtonian counterpart. We evolve the system using the osculating orbits method, and obtain the gravitational waveforms, whose phase includes all the terms - within our approximation (and using the self force along circular geodesics) - that are independent of the system's mass ratio. The partial dephasing due to the second-order dissipative self force is substantially smaller than that of the first-order conservative self force, although they are both at the same order in the mass ratio.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2013; v1 submitted 18 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Intermediate behavior of Kerr tails
Authors:
Anıl Zenginoğlu,
Gaurav Khanna,
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
The numerical investigation of wave propagation in the asymptotic domain of Kerr spacetime has only recently been possible thanks to the construction of suitable hyperboloidal coordinates. The asymptotics revealed an apparent puzzle in the decay rates of scalar fields: the late-time rates seemed to depend on whether finite distance observers are in the strong field domain or far away from the rota…
▽ More
The numerical investigation of wave propagation in the asymptotic domain of Kerr spacetime has only recently been possible thanks to the construction of suitable hyperboloidal coordinates. The asymptotics revealed an apparent puzzle in the decay rates of scalar fields: the late-time rates seemed to depend on whether finite distance observers are in the strong field domain or far away from the rotating black hole, an apparent phenomenon dubbed "splitting". We discuss far-field "splitting" in the full field and near-horizon "splitting" in certain projected modes using horizon-penetrating, hyperboloidal coordinates. For either case we propose an explanation to the cause of the "splitting" behavior, and we determine uniquely decay rates that previous studies found to be ambiguous or immeasurable. The far-field "splitting" is explained by competition between projected modes. The near-horizon "splitting" is due to excitation of lower multipole modes that back excite the multipole mode for which "splitting" is observed. In both cases "splitting" is an intermediate effect, such that asymptotically in time strong field rates are valid at all finite distances. At any finite time, however, there are three domains with different decay rates whose boundaries move outwards during evolution. We then propose a formula for the decay rate of tails that takes into account the inter--mode excitation effect that we study.
△ Less
Submitted 17 February, 2014; v1 submitted 29 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
Self Force Orbit-Integrated gravitational waveforms for E(I)MRIs
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
Kristen A. Lackeos
Abstract:
We present the first orbit-integrated self force effects for an IMRI or EMRI source, specifically the effects of its conservative piece on the orbit and on the waveform. We consider the quasi-circular motion of a particle in the spacetime of a Schwarzschild black hole, find the orbit and the corresponding gravitational waveform, and discuss the importance of the conservative piece of the self forc…
▽ More
We present the first orbit-integrated self force effects for an IMRI or EMRI source, specifically the effects of its conservative piece on the orbit and on the waveform. We consider the quasi-circular motion of a particle in the spacetime of a Schwarzschild black hole, find the orbit and the corresponding gravitational waveform, and discuss the importance of the conservative piece of the self force in detection and parameter estimation. We also show the effect of the conservative piece of the self force on gauge invariant quantities, specifically $u^t$ as a function of the angular frequency $Ω$. For long templates the inclusion of the conservative piece is crucial for gravitational-wave astronomy, yet may be ignored for short templates with little effect on detection rate.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2012;
originally announced July 2012.
-
Self-forced gravitational waveforms for Extreme and Intermediate mass ratio inspirals
Authors:
Kristen A. Lackeos,
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
We present the first orbit-integrated self force effects on the gravitational waveform for an I(E)MRI source. We consider the quasi-circular motion of a particle in the spacetime of a Schwarzschild black hole and study the dependence of the dephasing of the corresponding gravitational waveforms due to ignoring the conservative piece of the self force. We calculate the cumulative dephasing of the w…
▽ More
We present the first orbit-integrated self force effects on the gravitational waveform for an I(E)MRI source. We consider the quasi-circular motion of a particle in the spacetime of a Schwarzschild black hole and study the dependence of the dephasing of the corresponding gravitational waveforms due to ignoring the conservative piece of the self force. We calculate the cumulative dephasing of the waveforms and their overlap integral, and discuss the importance of the conservative piece of the self force in detection and parameter estimation. For long templates the inclusion of the conservative piece is crucial for gravitational-wave astronomy, yet may be ignored for short templates with little effect on detection rate. We then discuss the effect of the mass ratio and the start point of the motion on the dephasing.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2012; v1 submitted 7 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
On the falloff of radiated energy in black hole spacetimes
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
Scott A. Hughes
Abstract:
The goal of much research in relativity is to understand gravitational waves generated by a strong-field dynamical spacetime. Quantities of particular interest for many calculations are the Weyl scalar $ψ_4$, which is simply related to the flux of gravitational waves far from the source, and the flux of energy carried to distant observers, $\dot E$. Conservation laws guarantee that, in asympotical…
▽ More
The goal of much research in relativity is to understand gravitational waves generated by a strong-field dynamical spacetime. Quantities of particular interest for many calculations are the Weyl scalar $ψ_4$, which is simply related to the flux of gravitational waves far from the source, and the flux of energy carried to distant observers, $\dot E$. Conservation laws guarantee that, in asympotically flat spacetimes, $ψ_4 \propto 1/r$ and $\dot E \propto 1/r^2$ as $r \to \infty$. Most calculations extract these quantities at some finite extraction radius. An understanding of finite radius corrections to $ψ_4$ and $\dot E$ allows us to more accurately infer their asymptotic values from a computation. In this paper, we show that, if the final state of the system is a black hole, then the leading correction to $ψ_4$ is ${\cal O}(1/r^3)$, and that to the energy flux is ${\cal O}(1/r^4)$ --- not ${\cal O}(1/r^2)$ and ${\cal O}(1/r^3)$ as one might naively guess. Our argument only relies on the behavior of the curvature scalars for black hole spacetimes. Using black hole perturbation theory, we calculate the corrections to the leading falloff, showing that it is quite easy to correct for finite extraction radius effects.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2010; v1 submitted 26 July, 2010;
originally announced July 2010.
-
Late-time Kerr tails: generic and non-generic initial data sets, "up" modes, and superposition
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
Gaurav Khanna
Abstract:
Three interrelated questions concerning Kerr spacetime late-time scalar-field tails are considered numerically, specifically the evolutions of generic and non-generic initial data sets, the excitation of "up" modes, and the resolution of an apparent paradox related to the superposition principle. We propose to generalize the Barack-Ori formula for the decay rate of any tail multipole given a gener…
▽ More
Three interrelated questions concerning Kerr spacetime late-time scalar-field tails are considered numerically, specifically the evolutions of generic and non-generic initial data sets, the excitation of "up" modes, and the resolution of an apparent paradox related to the superposition principle. We propose to generalize the Barack-Ori formula for the decay rate of any tail multipole given a generic initial data set, to the contribution of any initial multipole mode. Our proposal leads to a much simpler expression for the late-time power law index. Specifically, we propose that the late-time decay rate of the $Y_{\ell m}$ spherical harmonic multipole moment because of an initial $Y_{\ell' m}$ multipole is independent of the azimuthal number $m$, and is given by $t^{-n}$, where $n=\ell'+\ell+1$ for $\ell<\ell'$ and $n=\ell'+\ell+3$ for $\ell\ge\ell'$. We also show explicitly that the angular symmetry group of a multipole does not determine its late-time decay rate.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2010; v1 submitted 4 January, 2010;
originally announced January 2010.
-
Black hole quasinormal mode spectroscopy with LISA
Authors:
Manish M. Jadhav,
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
The signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) for black hole quasinormal mode sources of low-frequency gravitational waves is estimated using a Monte Carlo approach that replaces the all-sky average approximation. We consider an eleven dimensional parameter space that includes both source and detector parameters. We find that in the black-hole mass range $M\sim 4$-$7\times 10^6M_{\odot}$ the SNR is significan…
▽ More
The signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) for black hole quasinormal mode sources of low-frequency gravitational waves is estimated using a Monte Carlo approach that replaces the all-sky average approximation. We consider an eleven dimensional parameter space that includes both source and detector parameters. We find that in the black-hole mass range $M\sim 4$-$7\times 10^6M_{\odot}$ the SNR is significantly higher than the SNR for the all-sky average case, as a result of the variation of the spin parameter of the sources. This increased SNR may translate to a higher event rate for the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA). We also study the directional dependence of the SNR, show at which directions in the sky LISA will have greater response, and identify the LISA blind spots.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2009; v1 submitted 19 November, 2008;
originally announced November 2008.
-
Computational Efficiency of Frequency-- and Time--Domain Calculations of Extreme Mass--Ratio Binaries: Equatorial Orbits
Authors:
Jonathan L. Barton,
David J. Lazar,
Daniel J. Kennefick,
Gaurav Khanna,
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
Gravitational waveforms and fluxes from extreme mass--ratio inspirals can be computed using time--domain methods with accuracy that is fast approaching that of frequency--domain methods. We study in detail the computational efficiency of these methods for equatorial orbits of fast spinning Kerr black holes, and find the number of modes needed in either method --as functions of the orbital parame…
▽ More
Gravitational waveforms and fluxes from extreme mass--ratio inspirals can be computed using time--domain methods with accuracy that is fast approaching that of frequency--domain methods. We study in detail the computational efficiency of these methods for equatorial orbits of fast spinning Kerr black holes, and find the number of modes needed in either method --as functions of the orbital parameters-- in order to achieve a desired accuracy level. We then estimate the total computation time and argue that for high eccentricity orbits the time--domain approach is more efficient computationally. We suggest that in practice low--$m$ modes are computed using the frequency--domain approach, and high--$m$ modes are computed using the time--domain approach, where $m$ is the azimuthal mode number.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2008;
originally announced April 2008.
-
Late-time Kerr tails revisited
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
Gaurav Khanna
Abstract:
The decay rate of late time tails in the Kerr spacetime have been the cause of numerous conflicting results, both analytical and numerical. In particular, there is much disagreement on whether the decay rate of an initially pure multipole moment ${\ell}$ is according to $t^{-(2{\bar\ell}+3)}$, where ${\bar\ell}$ is the least multipole moment whose excitation is not disallowed, or whether the dec…
▽ More
The decay rate of late time tails in the Kerr spacetime have been the cause of numerous conflicting results, both analytical and numerical. In particular, there is much disagreement on whether the decay rate of an initially pure multipole moment ${\ell}$ is according to $t^{-(2{\bar\ell}+3)}$, where ${\bar\ell}$ is the least multipole moment whose excitation is not disallowed, or whether the decay rate is according to $t^{-n}$, where $n=n({\ell})$. We do careful 2+1D numerical simulations, and explain the various results. In particular, we show that pure multipole outgoing initial data in either Boyer--Lindquist on ingoing Kerr coordinates on the corresponding slices lead to the same late time tail behavior. We also show that similar initial data specified in terms of the Poisson spherical coordinates lead to the simpler $t^{-(2{\bar\ell}+3)}$ late time tail. We generalize the rule $n=n({\ell})$ to subdominant modes, and also study the behavior of non--axisymmetric initial data. We discuss some of the causes for possible errors in 2+1D simulations, demonstrate that our simulations are free of those errors, and argue that some conflicting past results may be attributed to them.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2008; v1 submitted 6 November, 2007;
originally announced November 2007.
-
The late-time tails in the Reissner-Nordström spacetime revisited
Authors:
Carl J. Blaksley,
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
We propose that the late-time tail problem in the Reissner-Nordström (RN) spacetime is dual to a tail problem in the Schwarzschild spacetime with a different initial data set: at a fixed observation point the asymptotic decay rate of the fields are equal. This duality is used to find the decay rate for tails in RN. This decay rate is exactly as in Schwarzschild, including the case of the extreme…
▽ More
We propose that the late-time tail problem in the Reissner-Nordström (RN) spacetime is dual to a tail problem in the Schwarzschild spacetime with a different initial data set: at a fixed observation point the asymptotic decay rate of the fields are equal. This duality is used to find the decay rate for tails in RN. This decay rate is exactly as in Schwarzschild, including the case of the extremely-charged RN spacetime (ERN). The only case where any deviation from the Schwarzschild decay rate is found is the case of the tails along the event horizon of an ERN spacetime, where the decay rate is the same as at future null infinity. As observed at a fixed location, the decay rate in ERN is the same as in Schwarzschild. We verify these expectations with numerical simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2007;
originally announced October 2007.
-
Towards a wave-extraction method for numerical relativity. V. Extracting the Weyl scalars in the quasi-Kinnersley tetrad from spatial data
Authors:
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
We extract the Weyl scalars $Ψ_0$ and $Ψ_4$ in the quasi-Kinnersley tetrad by finding initially the (gauge--, tetrad--, and background--independent) transverse quasi-Kinnersley frame. This step still leaves two undetermined degrees of freedom: the ratio $|Ψ_0|/|Ψ_4|$, and one of the phases (the product $|Ψ_0|\cdot |Ψ_4|$ and the {\em sum} of the phases are determined by the so-called BB radiatio…
▽ More
We extract the Weyl scalars $Ψ_0$ and $Ψ_4$ in the quasi-Kinnersley tetrad by finding initially the (gauge--, tetrad--, and background--independent) transverse quasi-Kinnersley frame. This step still leaves two undetermined degrees of freedom: the ratio $|Ψ_0|/|Ψ_4|$, and one of the phases (the product $|Ψ_0|\cdot |Ψ_4|$ and the {\em sum} of the phases are determined by the so-called BB radiation scalar). The residual symmetry ("spin/boost") can be removed by gauge fixing of spin coefficients in two steps: First, we break the boost symmetry by requiring that $ρ$ corresponds to a global constant mass parameter that equals the ADM mass (or, equivalently in perturbation theory, that $ρ$ or $μ$ equal their values in the no-radiation limits), thus determining the two moduli of the Weyl scalars $|Ψ_0|, |Ψ_4|$, while leaving their phases as yet undetermined. Second, we break the spin symmetry by requiring that the ratio $π/τ$ gives the expected polarization state for the gravitational waves, thus determining the phases. Our method of gauge fixing--specifically its second step--is appropriate for cases for which the Weyl curvature is purely electric. Applying this method to Misner and Brill--Lindquist data, we explicitly find the Weyl scalars $Ψ_0$ and $Ψ_4$ perturbatively in the quasi-Kinnersley tetrad.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2007;
originally announced January 2007.
-
Orbital evolution for extreme mass-ratio binaries: conservative self forces
Authors:
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
The conservative dephasing effects of gravitational self forces for extreme mass-ratio inspirals are studied. Both secular and non-secular conservative effects may have a significant effect on LISA waveforms that is independent of the mass ratio of the system. Such effects need to be included in generated waveforms to allow for accurate gravitational wave astronomy that requires integration time…
▽ More
The conservative dephasing effects of gravitational self forces for extreme mass-ratio inspirals are studied. Both secular and non-secular conservative effects may have a significant effect on LISA waveforms that is independent of the mass ratio of the system. Such effects need to be included in generated waveforms to allow for accurate gravitational wave astronomy that requires integration times as long as a year.
△ Less
Submitted 2 January, 2007;
originally announced January 2007.
-
Accurate time-domain gravitational waveforms for extreme-mass-ratio binaries
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
Gaurav Khanna
Abstract:
The accuracy of time-domain solutions of the inhomogeneous Teukolsky equation is improved significantly. Comparing energy fluxes in gravitational waves with highly accurate frequency-domain results for circular equatorial orbits in Schwarzschild and Kerr, we find agreement to within 1% or better, which we believe can be even further improved. We apply our method to orbits for which frequency-dom…
▽ More
The accuracy of time-domain solutions of the inhomogeneous Teukolsky equation is improved significantly. Comparing energy fluxes in gravitational waves with highly accurate frequency-domain results for circular equatorial orbits in Schwarzschild and Kerr, we find agreement to within 1% or better, which we believe can be even further improved. We apply our method to orbits for which frequency-domain calculations have a relative disadvantage, specifically high-eccentricity (elliptical and parabolic) "zoom-whirl" orbits, and find the energy fluxes, waveforms, and characteristic strain in gravitational waves.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2007; v1 submitted 31 August, 2006;
originally announced September 2006.
-
Towards a novel wave-extraction method for numerical relativity
Authors:
Andrea Nerozzi,
Marco Bruni,
Lior M. Burko,
Virginia Re
Abstract:
We present the recent results of a research project aimed at constructing a robust wave extraction technique for numerical relativity. Our procedure makes use of Weyl scalars to achieve wave extraction. It is well known that, with a correct choice of null tetrad, Weyl scalars are directly associated to physical properties of the space-time under analysis in some well understood way. In particula…
▽ More
We present the recent results of a research project aimed at constructing a robust wave extraction technique for numerical relativity. Our procedure makes use of Weyl scalars to achieve wave extraction. It is well known that, with a correct choice of null tetrad, Weyl scalars are directly associated to physical properties of the space-time under analysis in some well understood way. In particular it is possible to associate $Ψ_4$ with the outgoing gravitational radiation degrees of freedom, thus making it a promising tool for numerical wave--extraction. The right choice of the tetrad is, however, the problem to be addressed. We have made progress towards identifying a general procedure for choosing this tetrad, by looking at transverse tetrads where $Ψ_1=Ψ_3=0$.
As a direct application of these concepts, we present a numerical study of the evolution of a non-linearly disturbed black hole described by the Bondi--Sachs metric. This particular scenario allows us to compare the results coming from Weyl scalars with the results coming from the news function which, in this particular case, is directly associated with the radiative degrees of freedom. We show that, if we did not take particular care in choosing the right tetrad, we would end up with incorrect results.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2006;
originally announced July 2006.
-
Orbital evolution of a test particle around a black hole: Indirect determination of the self force in the post Newtonian approximation
Authors:
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
Comparing the corrections to Kepler's law with orbital evolution under a self force, we extract the finite, already regularized part of the latter in a specific gauge. We apply this method to a quasi-circular orbit around a Schwarzschild black hole of an extreme mass ratio binary, and determine the first- and second-order conservative gravitational self force in a post Newtonian expansion. We us…
▽ More
Comparing the corrections to Kepler's law with orbital evolution under a self force, we extract the finite, already regularized part of the latter in a specific gauge. We apply this method to a quasi-circular orbit around a Schwarzschild black hole of an extreme mass ratio binary, and determine the first- and second-order conservative gravitational self force in a post Newtonian expansion. We use these results in the construction of the gravitational waveform, and revisit the question of the relative contribution of the self force and spin-orbit coupling.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 2006; v1 submitted 8 February, 2006;
originally announced February 2006.
-
Comment on "High-order contamination in the tail of gravitational collapse''
Authors:
Alexander Z. Smith,
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
We confront the predictions of S. Hod, Phys. Rev. D 60, 104053 (1999) for the late-time decay rate of black hole perturbations with numerical data. Specifically, we ask two questions: First, are corrections to the Price tail dominated by logarithmic terms, as predicted by Hod? Second, if there were logarithmic correction terms, do they take the specific form predicted in Hod's paper? The answer…
▽ More
We confront the predictions of S. Hod, Phys. Rev. D 60, 104053 (1999) for the late-time decay rate of black hole perturbations with numerical data. Specifically, we ask two questions: First, are corrections to the Price tail dominated by logarithmic terms, as predicted by Hod? Second, if there were logarithmic correction terms, do they take the specific form predicted in Hod's paper? The answer to both questions is ``no.''
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2006; v1 submitted 3 October, 2005;
originally announced October 2005.
-
Towards a wave-extraction method for numerical relativity: IV. Testing the quasi-Kinnersley method in the Bondi-Sachs framework
Authors:
Andrea Nerozzi,
Marco Bruni,
Virginia Re,
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
We present a numerical study of the evolution of a non-linearly disturbed black hole described by the Bondi--Sachs metric, for which the outgoing gravitational waves can readily be found using the news function. We compare the gravitational wave output obtained with the use of the news function in the Bondi--Sachs framework, with that obtained from the Weyl scalars, where the latter are evaluate…
▽ More
We present a numerical study of the evolution of a non-linearly disturbed black hole described by the Bondi--Sachs metric, for which the outgoing gravitational waves can readily be found using the news function. We compare the gravitational wave output obtained with the use of the news function in the Bondi--Sachs framework, with that obtained from the Weyl scalars, where the latter are evaluated in a quasi-Kinnersley tetrad. The latter method has the advantage of being applicable to any formulation of Einstein's equations---including the ADM formulation and its various descendants---in addition to being robust. Using the non-linearly disturbed Bondi--Sachs black hole as a test-bed, we show that the two approaches give wave-extraction results which are in very good agreement. When wave extraction through the Weyl scalars is done in a non quasi-Kinnersley tetrad, the results are markedly different from those obtained using the news function.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2006; v1 submitted 15 July, 2005;
originally announced July 2005.
-
Towards a wave--extraction method for numerical relativity: III. Analytical examples for the Beetle--Burko radiation scalar
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
Thomas W. Baumgarte,
Christopher Beetle
Abstract:
Beetle and Burko recently introduced a background--independent scalar curvature invariant for general relativity that carries information only about the gravitational radiation in generic spacetimes, in cases where such radiation is incontrovertibly defined. In this paper we adopt a formalism that only uses spatial data as they are used in numerical relativity and compute the Beetle--Burko radia…
▽ More
Beetle and Burko recently introduced a background--independent scalar curvature invariant for general relativity that carries information only about the gravitational radiation in generic spacetimes, in cases where such radiation is incontrovertibly defined. In this paper we adopt a formalism that only uses spatial data as they are used in numerical relativity and compute the Beetle--Burko radiation scalar for a number of analytical examples, specifically linearized Einstein--Rosen cylindrical waves, linearized quadrupole waves, the Kerr spacetime, Bowen--York initial data, and the Kasner spacetime. These examples illustrate how the Beetle--Burko radiation scalar can be used to examine the gravitational wave content of numerically generated spacetimes, and how it may provide a useful diagnostic for initial data sets.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2005; v1 submitted 6 May, 2005;
originally announced May 2005.
-
Late time tails from momentarily stationary, compact initial data in Schwarzschild spacetimes
Authors:
Richard H. Price,
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
An L-pole perturbation in Schwarzschild spacetime generally falls off at late times t as t^{-2L-3}. It has recently been pointed out by Karkowski, Swierczynski and Malec, that for initial data that is of compact support, and is initially momentarily static, the late-time behavior is different, going as t^{-2L-4}. By considering the Laplace transforms of the fields, we show here why the momentari…
▽ More
An L-pole perturbation in Schwarzschild spacetime generally falls off at late times t as t^{-2L-3}. It has recently been pointed out by Karkowski, Swierczynski and Malec, that for initial data that is of compact support, and is initially momentarily static, the late-time behavior is different, going as t^{-2L-4}. By considering the Laplace transforms of the fields, we show here why the momentarily stationary case is exceptional. We also explain, using a time-domain description, the special features of the time development in this exceptional case.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2004;
originally announced August 2004.
-
Towards wave extraction in numerical relativity: the quasi-Kinnersley frame
Authors:
Andrea Nerozzi,
Christopher Beetle,
Marco Bruni,
Lior M. Burko,
Denis Pollney
Abstract:
The Newman-Penrose formalism may be used in numerical relativity to extract coordinate-invariant information about gravitational radiation emitted in strong-field dynamical scenarios. The main challenge in doing so is to identify a null tetrad appropriately adapted to the simulated geometry such that Newman-Penrose quantities computed relative to it have an invariant physical meaning. In black h…
▽ More
The Newman-Penrose formalism may be used in numerical relativity to extract coordinate-invariant information about gravitational radiation emitted in strong-field dynamical scenarios. The main challenge in doing so is to identify a null tetrad appropriately adapted to the simulated geometry such that Newman-Penrose quantities computed relative to it have an invariant physical meaning. In black hole perturbation theory, the Teukolsky formalism uses such adapted tetrads, those which differ only perturbatively from the background Kinnersley tetrad. At late times, numerical simulations of astrophysical processes producing isolated black holes ought to admit descriptions in the Teukolsky formalism. However, adapted tetrads in this context must be identified using only the numerically computed metric, since no background Kerr geometry is known a priori. To do this, this paper introduces the notion of a quasi-Kinnersley frame. This frame, when space-time is perturbatively close to Kerr, approximates the background Kinnersley frame. However, it remains calculable much more generally, in space-times non-perturbatively different from Kerr. We give an explicit solution for the tetrad transformation which is required in order to find this frame in a general space-time.
△ Less
Submitted 15 July, 2005; v1 submitted 2 July, 2004;
originally announced July 2004.
-
Towards a novel wave-extraction method for numerical relativity. I. Foundations and initial-value formulation
Authors:
Christopher Beetle,
Marco Bruni,
Lior M. Burko,
Andrea Nerozzi
Abstract:
The Teukolsky formalism of black hole perturbation theory describes weak gravitational radiation generated by a mildly dynamical hole near equilibrium. A particular null tetrad of the background Kerr geometry, due to Kinnersley, plays a singularly important role within this formalism. In order to apply the rich physical intuition of Teukolsky's approach to the results of fully non-linear numeric…
▽ More
The Teukolsky formalism of black hole perturbation theory describes weak gravitational radiation generated by a mildly dynamical hole near equilibrium. A particular null tetrad of the background Kerr geometry, due to Kinnersley, plays a singularly important role within this formalism. In order to apply the rich physical intuition of Teukolsky's approach to the results of fully non-linear numerical simulations, one must approximate this Kinnersley tetrad using raw numerical data, with no a priori knowledge of a background. This paper addresses this issue by identifying the directions of the tetrad fields in a quasi-Kinnersley frame. This frame provides a unique, analytic extension of Kinnersley's definition for the Kerr geometry to a much broader class of space-times including not only arbitrary perturbations, but also many examples which differ non-perturbatively from Kerr. This paper establishes concrete limits delineating this class and outlines a scheme to calculate the quasi-Kinnersley frame in numerical codes based on the initial-value formulation of geometrodynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2005; v1 submitted 2 July, 2004;
originally announced July 2004.
-
Universality of massive scalar field late-time tails in black-hole spacetimes
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
G. Khanna
Abstract:
The late-time tails of a massive scalar field in the spacetime of black holes are studied numerically. Previous analytical results for a Schwarzschild black hole are confirmed: The late-time behavior of the field as recorded by a static observer is given by $ψ(t)\sim t^{-5/6}\sin [ω(t)\times t]$, where $ω(t)$ depends weakly on time. This result is carried over to the case of a Kerr black hole. I…
▽ More
The late-time tails of a massive scalar field in the spacetime of black holes are studied numerically. Previous analytical results for a Schwarzschild black hole are confirmed: The late-time behavior of the field as recorded by a static observer is given by $ψ(t)\sim t^{-5/6}\sin [ω(t)\times t]$, where $ω(t)$ depends weakly on time. This result is carried over to the case of a Kerr black hole. In particular, it is found that the power-law index of -5/6 depends on neither the multipole mode $\ell$ nor on the spin rate of the black hole $a/M$. In all black hole spacetimes, massive scalar fields have the same late-time behavior irrespective of their initial data (i.e., angular distribution). Their late-time behavior is universal.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2004; v1 submitted 3 March, 2004;
originally announced March 2004.
-
Radiation tails and boundary conditions for black hole evolutions
Authors:
Elspeth W. Allen,
Elizabeth Buckmiller,
Lior M. Burko,
Richard H. Price
Abstract:
In numerical computations of Einstein's equations for black hole spacetimes, it will be necessary to use approximate boundary conditions at a finite distance from the holes. We point out here that ``tails,'' the inverse power-law decrease of late-time fields, cannot be expected for such computations. We present computational demonstrations and discussions of features of late-time behavior in an…
▽ More
In numerical computations of Einstein's equations for black hole spacetimes, it will be necessary to use approximate boundary conditions at a finite distance from the holes. We point out here that ``tails,'' the inverse power-law decrease of late-time fields, cannot be expected for such computations. We present computational demonstrations and discussions of features of late-time behavior in an evolution with a boundary condition.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2004;
originally announced January 2004.
-
The Periodic Standing-Wave Approximation: Overview and Three Dimensional Scalar Models
Authors:
Zeferino Andrade,
Christopher Beetle,
Alexey Blinov,
Benjamin Bromley,
Lior M. Burko,
Maria Cranor,
Robert Owen,
Richard H. Price
Abstract:
The periodic standing-wave method for binary inspiral computes the exact numerical solution for periodic binary motion with standing gravitational waves, and uses it as an approximation to slow binary inspiral with outgoing waves. Important features of this method presented here are: (i) the mathematical nature of the ``mixed'' partial differential equations to be solved, (ii) the meaning of sta…
▽ More
The periodic standing-wave method for binary inspiral computes the exact numerical solution for periodic binary motion with standing gravitational waves, and uses it as an approximation to slow binary inspiral with outgoing waves. Important features of this method presented here are: (i) the mathematical nature of the ``mixed'' partial differential equations to be solved, (ii) the meaning of standing waves in the method, (iii) computational difficulties, and (iv) the ``effective linearity'' that ultimately justifies the approximation. The method is applied to three dimensional nonlinear scalar model problems, and the numerical results are used to demonstrate extraction of the outgoing solution from the standing-wave solution, and the role of effective linearity.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2004; v1 submitted 30 September, 2003;
originally announced October 2003.
-
Orbital evolution of a particle around a black hole: II. Comparison of contributions of spin-orbit coupling and the self force
Authors:
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
We consider the evolution of the orbit of a spinning compact object in a quasi-circular, planar orbit around a Schwarzschild black hole in the extreme mass ratio limit. We compare the contributions to the orbital evolution of both spin-orbit coupling and the local self force. Making assumptions on the behavior of the forces, we suggest that the decay of the orbit is dominated by radiation reacti…
▽ More
We consider the evolution of the orbit of a spinning compact object in a quasi-circular, planar orbit around a Schwarzschild black hole in the extreme mass ratio limit. We compare the contributions to the orbital evolution of both spin-orbit coupling and the local self force. Making assumptions on the behavior of the forces, we suggest that the decay of the orbit is dominated by radiation reaction, and that the conservative effect is typically dominated by the spin force. We propose that a reasonable approximation for the gravitational waveform can be obtained by ignoring the local self force, for adjusted values of the parameters of the system. We argue that this approximation will only introduce small errors in the astronomical determination of these parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2003;
originally announced August 2003.
-
3D simulations of linearized scalar fields in Kerr spacetime
Authors:
Mark A. Scheel,
Adrienne L. Erickcek,
Lior M. Burko,
Lawrence E. Kidder,
Harald P. Pfeiffer,
Saul A. Teukolsky
Abstract:
We investigate the behavior of a dynamical scalar field on a fixed Kerr background in Kerr-Schild coordinates using a 3+1 dimensional spectral evolution code, and we measure the power-law tail decay that occurs at late times. We compare evolutions of initial data proportional to f(r) Y_lm(theta,phi) where Y_lm is a spherical harmonic and (r,theta,phi) are Kerr-Schild coordinates, to that of init…
▽ More
We investigate the behavior of a dynamical scalar field on a fixed Kerr background in Kerr-Schild coordinates using a 3+1 dimensional spectral evolution code, and we measure the power-law tail decay that occurs at late times. We compare evolutions of initial data proportional to f(r) Y_lm(theta,phi) where Y_lm is a spherical harmonic and (r,theta,phi) are Kerr-Schild coordinates, to that of initial data proportional to f(r_BL) Y_lm(theta_BL,phi), where (r_BL,theta_BL) are Boyer-Lindquist coordinates. We find that although these two cases are initially almost identical, the evolution can be quite different at intermediate times; however, at late times the power-law decay rates are equal.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2004; v1 submitted 6 May, 2003;
originally announced May 2003.
-
A Radiation Scalar for Numerical Relativity
Authors:
Christopher Beetle,
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
This letter describes a scalar curvature invariant for general relativity with a certain, distinctive feature. While many such invariants exist, this one vanishes in regions of space-time which can be said unambiguously to contain no gravitational radiation. In more general regions which incontrovertibly support non-trivial radiation fields, it can be used to extract local, coordinate-independen…
▽ More
This letter describes a scalar curvature invariant for general relativity with a certain, distinctive feature. While many such invariants exist, this one vanishes in regions of space-time which can be said unambiguously to contain no gravitational radiation. In more general regions which incontrovertibly support non-trivial radiation fields, it can be used to extract local, coordinate-independent information partially characterizing that radiation. While a clear, physical interpretation is possible only in such radiation zones, a simple algorithm can be given to extend the definition smoothly to generic regions of space-time.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2002;
originally announced October 2002.
-
Radiative falloff in the background of rotating black hole
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
Gaurav Khanna
Abstract:
We study numerically the late-time tails of linearized fields with any spin $s$ in the background of a spinning black hole. Our code is based on the ingoing Kerr coordinates, which allow us to penetrate through the event horizon. The late time tails are dominated by the mode with the least multipole moment $\ell$ which is consistent with the equatorial symmetry of the initial data and is equal t…
▽ More
We study numerically the late-time tails of linearized fields with any spin $s$ in the background of a spinning black hole. Our code is based on the ingoing Kerr coordinates, which allow us to penetrate through the event horizon. The late time tails are dominated by the mode with the least multipole moment $\ell$ which is consistent with the equatorial symmetry of the initial data and is equal to or greater than the least radiative mode with $s$ and the azimuthal number $m$.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2003; v1 submitted 27 September, 2002;
originally announced September 2002.
-
Black hole singularities: a new critical phenomenon
Authors:
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
The singularitiy inside a spherical charged black hole, coupled to a spherical, massless scalar field is studied numerically. The profile of the characteristic scalar field was taken to be a power of advanced time with an exponent $α>0$. A critical exponent $α_{\rm crit}$ exists. For exponents below the critical one ($α<α_{\rm crit}$) the singularity is a union of spacelike and null sectors, as…
▽ More
The singularitiy inside a spherical charged black hole, coupled to a spherical, massless scalar field is studied numerically. The profile of the characteristic scalar field was taken to be a power of advanced time with an exponent $α>0$. A critical exponent $α_{\rm crit}$ exists. For exponents below the critical one ($α<α_{\rm crit}$) the singularity is a union of spacelike and null sectors, as is also the case for data with compact support. For exponents greater than the critical one ($α>α_{\rm crit}$) an all-encompassing, spacelike singularity evolves, which completely blocks the ``tunnel'' inside the black hole, preventing the use of the black hole as a portal for hyperspace travel.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2003; v1 submitted 23 September, 2002;
originally announced September 2002.
-
Orbital evolution of a test particle around a black hole: higher-order corrections
Authors:
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
We study the orbital evolution of a radiation-damped binary in the extreme mass ratio limit, and the resulting waveforms, to one order beyond what can be obtained using the conservation laws approach. The equations of motion are solved perturbatively in the mass ratio (or the corresponding parameter in the scalar field toy model), using the self force, for quasi-circular orbits around a Schwarzs…
▽ More
We study the orbital evolution of a radiation-damped binary in the extreme mass ratio limit, and the resulting waveforms, to one order beyond what can be obtained using the conservation laws approach. The equations of motion are solved perturbatively in the mass ratio (or the corresponding parameter in the scalar field toy model), using the self force, for quasi-circular orbits around a Schwarzschild black hole. This approach is applied for the scalar model. Higher-order corrections yield a phase shift which, if included, may make gravitational-wave astronomy potentially highly accurate.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2002;
originally announced August 2002.
-
Survival of the black hole's Cauchy horizon under non-compact perturbations
Authors:
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
We study numerically the evolution of spactime, and in particular of a spacetime singularity, inside a black hole under a class of perturbations of non-compact support. We use a very simplified toy model of a spherical charged black hole which is perturbed nonlinearly by a self-gravitating, spherical scalar field. The latter grows logarithmically with advanced time along an outgoing characterist…
▽ More
We study numerically the evolution of spactime, and in particular of a spacetime singularity, inside a black hole under a class of perturbations of non-compact support. We use a very simplified toy model of a spherical charged black hole which is perturbed nonlinearly by a self-gravitating, spherical scalar field. The latter grows logarithmically with advanced time along an outgoing characteristic hypersurface. We find that for that class of perturbations a portion of the Cauchy horizon survives as a non-central, null singularity.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2002;
originally announced June 2002.
-
Self interaction near dielectrics
Authors:
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
We compute the force acting on a free, static electric charge outside a uniform dielectric sphere. We view this force as a self-interaction force, and compute it by applying the Lorentz force directly to the charge's electric field at its location. We regularize the divergent bare force using two different methods: A direct application of the Quinn-Wald Comparison Axiom, and Mode-Sum Regularizat…
▽ More
We compute the force acting on a free, static electric charge outside a uniform dielectric sphere. We view this force as a self-interaction force, and compute it by applying the Lorentz force directly to the charge's electric field at its location. We regularize the divergent bare force using two different methods: A direct application of the Quinn-Wald Comparison Axiom, and Mode-Sum Regularization.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2002;
originally announced January 2002.
-
Instability of scalar charges in 1+1D and 2+1D
Authors:
Lior M. Burko
Abstract:
We study the phenomenon of mass loss by a scalar charge -- a point particle which acts as a source for a (non-interacting) scalar field -- in (1+1)-dimensional and (2+1)-dimensional flat spacetime. We find that such particles are unstable against self interaction: they lose their mass through the emission of monopole radiation. This is in sharp contrast with scalar charges in (3+1)-dimensional f…
▽ More
We study the phenomenon of mass loss by a scalar charge -- a point particle which acts as a source for a (non-interacting) scalar field -- in (1+1)-dimensional and (2+1)-dimensional flat spacetime. We find that such particles are unstable against self interaction: they lose their mass through the emission of monopole radiation. This is in sharp contrast with scalar charges in (3+1)-dimensional flat spacetime, where no such phenomenon occurs.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2002;
originally announced January 2002.
-
Mass loss by a scalar charge in an expanding universe
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
Abraham I. Harte,
Eric Poisson
Abstract:
We study the phenomenon of mass loss by a scalar charge -- a point particle that acts a source for a noninteracting scalar field -- in an expanding universe. The charge is placed on comoving world lines of two cosmological spacetimes: a de Sitter universe, and a spatially-flat, matter-dominated universe. In both cases, we find that the particle's rest mass is not a constant, but that it changes…
▽ More
We study the phenomenon of mass loss by a scalar charge -- a point particle that acts a source for a noninteracting scalar field -- in an expanding universe. The charge is placed on comoving world lines of two cosmological spacetimes: a de Sitter universe, and a spatially-flat, matter-dominated universe. In both cases, we find that the particle's rest mass is not a constant, but that it changes in response to the emission of monopole scalar radiation by the particle. In de Sitter spacetime, the particle radiates all of its mass within a finite proper time. In the matter-dominated cosmology, this happens only if the charge of the particle is sufficiently large; for smaller charges the particle first loses some of its mass, but then regains it all eventually.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2002; v1 submitted 7 January, 2002;
originally announced January 2002.
-
Self force on a scalar charge in the spacetime of a stationary, axisymmetric black hole
Authors:
Lior M. Burko,
Yuk Tung Liu
Abstract:
We study the self force acting on a particle endowed with scalar charge, which is held static (with respect to an undragged, static observer at infinity) outside a stationary, axially-symmetric black hole. We find that the acceleration due to the self force is in the same direction as the black hole's spin, and diverges when the particle approaches the outer boundary of the black hole's ergosphe…
▽ More
We study the self force acting on a particle endowed with scalar charge, which is held static (with respect to an undragged, static observer at infinity) outside a stationary, axially-symmetric black hole. We find that the acceleration due to the self force is in the same direction as the black hole's spin, and diverges when the particle approaches the outer boundary of the black hole's ergosphere. This acceleration diverges more rapidly approaching the ergosphere's boundary than the particle's acceleration in the absence of the self force. At the leading order this self force is a (post)$^2$-Newtonian effect. For scalar charges with high charge-to-mass ratio, the acceleration due to the self force starts dominating over the regular acceleration already far from the black hole. The self force is proportional to the rate at which the black hole's rotational energy is dissipated. This self force is local (i.e., only the Abraham-Lorentz-Dirac force and the local coupling to Ricci curvature contribute to it). The non-local, tail part of the self force is zero.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2001;
originally announced March 2001.
