-
Fate of Mixmaster Chaos in a Deformed Algebra framework
Authors:
G. Barca,
E. Giovannetti
Abstract:
We analyze the anisotropic Bianchi models, and in particular the Bianchi Type IX known as the Mixmaster universe, where the Misner anisotropic variables obey Deformed Commutation Relations inspired by Quantum Gravity theories. We consider three different deformations, two of which have been able to remove the initial singularity similarly to Loop Quantum Cosmology when implemented to the single vo…
▽ More
We analyze the anisotropic Bianchi models, and in particular the Bianchi Type IX known as the Mixmaster universe, where the Misner anisotropic variables obey Deformed Commutation Relations inspired by Quantum Gravity theories. We consider three different deformations, two of which have been able to remove the initial singularity similarly to Loop Quantum Cosmology when implemented to the single volume variable. Here, the two-dimensional Algebras naturally implement a form of Non-Commutativity between the space variables that affects the dynamics of the anisotropies. In particular, we implement the modifications in their classical limit, where the Deformed Commutators become Deformed Poisson Brackets. We derive the modified Belinskii-Khalatnikov-Lifshitz map in all the three cases, and we study the fate of the chaotic behavior that the model classically presents. Depending on the sign of the deformation, the dynamics will either settle into oscillations between two almost-constant angles, or stop reflecting after a finite number of iterations and reach the singularity as one last simple Kasner solution. In either case, chaos is removed.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2025; v1 submitted 30 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
Quantum Isotropic Universe in RQM Analogy: the Cosmological Horizon
Authors:
Gabriele Barca,
Luisa Boglioni,
Giovanni Montani
Abstract:
We investigate the quantum dynamics of the isotropic Universe in the presence of a free massless scalar field, playing the role of a physical clock. The Hilbert space is constructed via a direct analogy between the Wheeler-DeWitt equation in the minisuperspace and a relativistic scalar one in physical space. In particular, we show how the introduction of a "turning point" in the Universe evolution…
▽ More
We investigate the quantum dynamics of the isotropic Universe in the presence of a free massless scalar field, playing the role of a physical clock. The Hilbert space is constructed via a direct analogy between the Wheeler-DeWitt equation in the minisuperspace and a relativistic scalar one in physical space. In particular, we show how the introduction of a "turning point" in the Universe evolution allows to overcome an intrinsic ambiguity in representing the expanding and collapsing Universe. In this way, the positive and negative frequencies are simply identified with time reversed states. The main subject of the present analysis is the construction of a horizon operator, whose quantum behavior is investigated when Polymer Quantum Mechanics is implemented to describe the asymptotic evolution near the initial singularity. The reason of this choice is motivated by the intrinsic spreading of localized wavepackets when the polymer dispersion relation governs the quantum dynamics. The evidence that the mean value of the quantum horizon operator follows its semiclassical behavior (corrected for polymerization) is a clear indication that a concept of causality can be restored also in the quantum cosmological picture.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2024; v1 submitted 10 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Non-Singular Gravitational Collapse through Modified Heisenberg Algebra
Authors:
Gabriele Barca,
Giovanni Montani
Abstract:
We study the effects of cut-off physics, in the form of a modified algebra inspired by Polymer Quantum Mechanics and by the Generalized Uncertainty Principle representation, on the collapse of a spherical dust cloud. We analyze both the Newtonian formulation, originally developed by Hunter, and the general relativistic formulation, that is the Oppenheimer-Snyder model; in both frameworks we find t…
▽ More
We study the effects of cut-off physics, in the form of a modified algebra inspired by Polymer Quantum Mechanics and by the Generalized Uncertainty Principle representation, on the collapse of a spherical dust cloud. We analyze both the Newtonian formulation, originally developed by Hunter, and the general relativistic formulation, that is the Oppenheimer-Snyder model; in both frameworks we find that the collapse is stabilized to an asymptotically static state above the horizon, and the singularity is removed. In the Newtonian case, by requiring the Newtonian approximation to be valid, we find lower bounds of the order of unity (in Planck units) for the deformation parameter of the modified algebra. We then study the behaviour of small perturbations on the non-singular collapsing backgrounds, and find that for certain range of the parameters (the polytropic index for the Newtonian case and the sound velocity in the relativistic setting) the collapse is stable to perturbations of all scales, and the non-singular super-Schwarzschild configurations have physical meaning.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2024; v1 submitted 18 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Emergent Universe Model from Modified Heisenberg Algebra
Authors:
Gabriele Barca,
Giovanni Montani,
Alessandro Melchiorri
Abstract:
We provide an Emergent Universe picture in which the fine-tuning on the initial conditions is replaced by cut-off physics, implemented on a semiclassical level when referred to the Universe dynamics and on a purely quantum level for the quantum fluctuations of the inflaton field. The adopted cut-off physics is inspired by Polymer Quantum Mechanics but expanded in the limit of a small lattice step.…
▽ More
We provide an Emergent Universe picture in which the fine-tuning on the initial conditions is replaced by cut-off physics, implemented on a semiclassical level when referred to the Universe dynamics and on a purely quantum level for the quantum fluctuations of the inflaton field. The adopted cut-off physics is inspired by Polymer Quantum Mechanics but expanded in the limit of a small lattice step. On a quasi-classical level, this results in modified Poisson Brackets for the Hamiltonian Universe dynamics similar to a Generalized Uncertainty Principle algebra. The resulting Universe is indeed asymptotically Einstein-static, emerging from a finite volume configuration in the distant past and then properly reconnecting with the most relevant Universe phases. The calculation of the modifications of the primordial inflaton spectrum is then performed by treating new physics as a small correction on the standard Hamiltonian of each Fourier mode of the field. The merit of this study is to provide a new paradigm for a non-singular Emergent Universe, which is associated with a precise fingerprint on the temperature distribution of the microwave background, in principle observable by future experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2023; v1 submitted 2 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
PQM and the GUP: Implications of Lattice Dynamics and Minimal Uncertainties in Quantum Mechanics and Cosmology
Authors:
Gabriele Barca,
Eleonora Giovannetti,
Giovanni Montani
Abstract:
We compare two alternative representations of quantum mechanics: Polymer Quantum Mechanics (PQM), which presents features similar to Loop Quantum Gravity and Loop Quantum Cosmology, and the Generalized Uncertainty Principle (GUP) representation, that through a modified Algebra yields an alternative uncertainty principle similar to those derived in String Theories and Brane Cosmology. These formali…
▽ More
We compare two alternative representations of quantum mechanics: Polymer Quantum Mechanics (PQM), which presents features similar to Loop Quantum Gravity and Loop Quantum Cosmology, and the Generalized Uncertainty Principle (GUP) representation, that through a modified Algebra yields an alternative uncertainty principle similar to those derived in String Theories and Brane Cosmology. These formalisms can be recast to apparently look similar, but while the GUP yields an absolute minimal uncertainty on position, PQM implements some kind of ultraviolet cut-off through a lattice and does not have a minimal uncertainty. Then we implement them on the anisotropic Bianchi I model in Misner-like variables on a semiclassical level: PQM always implies a removal of the singularities, while the GUP fails to do so, highlighting once again how the two representations are fundamentally incompatible.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Comparison of the Semiclassical and Quantum Dynamics of the Bianchi I Cosmology in the Polymer and GUP Extended Paradigms
Authors:
Gabriele Barca,
Eleonora Giovannetti,
Giovanni Montani
Abstract:
We compare in some detail Polymer Quantum Mechanics and the Generalized Uncertainty Principle approach to clarify to what extent we can treat them on the same footing. We show that, while on a semiclassical level they may be formulated as similar modifications of the Poisson algebra, on a quantum level they intrinsically differ because PQM implies no absolute minimal uncertainty on position. Then…
▽ More
We compare in some detail Polymer Quantum Mechanics and the Generalized Uncertainty Principle approach to clarify to what extent we can treat them on the same footing. We show that, while on a semiclassical level they may be formulated as similar modifications of the Poisson algebra, on a quantum level they intrinsically differ because PQM implies no absolute minimal uncertainty on position. Then we implement these schemes to Bianchi I cosmology on a semiclassical level deforming only the algebra of the Universe volume, searching for alternative formulations able to account for the modified Friedmann equations emerging in Brane Cosmology and Loop Quantum Cosmology. On a pure quantum level, we implement the two approaches through their original setups and reduce the two resulting Wheeler-DeWitt equations to the same morphological structure, showing how the polymer formalism is associated with a bouncing dynamics while in the Generalized Uncertainty Principle case the singularity is still present. The implications of the wavepacket spreading are also discussed in both approaches, outlining that, when the singularity survives, the Planckian era must necessarily be approached by a fully quantum (non-peaked) state of the Universe.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2022; v1 submitted 16 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Polymer Quantization of the Isotropic Universe: comparison with the Bounce of Loop Quantum Cosmology
Authors:
Gabriele Barca,
Eleonora Giovannetti,
Federico Mandini,
Giovanni Montani
Abstract:
We implement Polymer Quantum Mechanics on the Hamiltonian formulation of the isotropic Universe in both the representations of the standard Ashtekar-Barbero-Immirzi connection and of a new generalized coordinate conjugate to the Universe volume. The resulting dynamics is a bouncing cosmology; when quantizing the volume-like variable the Big Bounce is an intrinsic cut-off on the cosmological dynami…
▽ More
We implement Polymer Quantum Mechanics on the Hamiltonian formulation of the isotropic Universe in both the representations of the standard Ashtekar-Barbero-Immirzi connection and of a new generalized coordinate conjugate to the Universe volume. The resulting dynamics is a bouncing cosmology; when quantizing the volume-like variable the Big Bounce is an intrinsic cut-off on the cosmological dynamics, while when using the standard connection the Bounce density results to be dependent on the initial conditions of the prepared wave packet. Then we compare the nature of the resulting Bounce with what emerges in Loop Quantum Cosmology, where the dependence of the critical density on the initial conditions is present when the minimum area eigenvalue is implemented in a comoving representation instead of the physical one. We conclude that, if one hand the preferable scenario should be a Big Bounce whose density depends on initial conditions in view of the privileged SU(2) character that the Ashtekar-Barbero-Immirzi connection possesses in the full Loop Quantum Gravity, on the other hand the equivalence demonstrated in the context of polymer cosmology can be a hint in favour of the viability of the improved scheme of Loop Quantum Cosmology even though it is not expressed through the privileged set of variables.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
An Overview on the Nature of the Bounce in LQC and PQM
Authors:
Gabriele Barca,
Eleonora Giovannetti,
Giovanni Montani
Abstract:
We present a review on basic aspects of quantum cosmology in the presence of cut-off physics. We first analyze how the Wheeler-DeWitt equation in a pure metric approach describes the quantum Universe, showing how the singularity is not removed. We then discuss basic features of loop quantum cosmology. For the isotropic Universe, we compare the original $μ_0$ scheme and the most commonly accepted f…
▽ More
We present a review on basic aspects of quantum cosmology in the presence of cut-off physics. We first analyze how the Wheeler-DeWitt equation in a pure metric approach describes the quantum Universe, showing how the singularity is not removed. We then discuss basic features of loop quantum cosmology. For the isotropic Universe, we compare the original $μ_0$ scheme and the most commonly accepted formulation, the $\barμ$ scheme. Some results concerning the Bianchi Universes are also discussed. Finally, we consider some relevant criticisms on the real link between full loop quantum gravity and its minisuperspace implementation. In the second part of the review we consider the isotropic Universe and the Bianchi models in the framework of polymer quantum mechanics. We first address the polymerization in terms of the Ashtekar-Barbero-Immirzi connection and show how the resulting dynamics is isomorphic to the $μ_0$. Then we analyze the polymerization of volume-like variables, and we see the resulting dynamics is isomorphic to the $\barμ$ scheme with a fixed critical energy density. Finally, we consider the polymer quantum dynamics of the homogeneous and inhomogeneous Mixmaster model through a metric approach. We compare the results obtained by using the volume variable to the standard Misner variable. In the latter case we find a cosmology that is still singular, and its chaotic properties depend on the ratio between the lattice steps for the isotropic and anisotropic variables. We conclude the review with some considerations on changing variables in the polymer representation. In particular we consider how the dynamics can be mapped in two different sets of variables (at the price of using a coordinate-dependent lattice step), and we infer some possible implications on the equivalence of the $μ_0$ and $\barμ$ scheme of loop quantum cosmology.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Polymer dynamics of isotropic universe in Ashtekar and in volume variables
Authors:
Eleonora Giovannetti,
Gabriele Barca,
Federico Mandini,
Giovanni Montani
Abstract:
We analyze the semiclassical and quantum polymer dynamics of the isotropic Universe in terms of both the standard Ashtekar-Barbero-Immirzi connection and its conjugate momentum and also of the new generalized coordinate conjugate to the Universe volume. We study the properties of the resulting bouncing cosmology that emerges in both the representations and we show that the Big Bounce is an intrins…
▽ More
We analyze the semiclassical and quantum polymer dynamics of the isotropic Universe in terms of both the standard Ashtekar-Barbero-Immirzi connection and its conjugate momentum and also of the new generalized coordinate conjugate to the Universe volume. We study the properties of the resulting bouncing cosmology that emerges in both the representations and we show that the Big Bounce is an intrinsic cut-off on the cosmological dynamics only when the volume variable is implemented, while in terms of the standard connection the Universe Bounce energy density is fixed by the initial conditions on the prepared wavepacket. As a phenomenological implication, we introduce particle creation as a dissipative term and study the production of entropy in the two formulations. Then, we compare the obtained dynamics with what emerges in Loop Quantum Cosmology, where the same difference in the nature of the Big Bounce is associated to fixing a minimum area eigenvalue in a comoving or in a physical representation. We conclude that the privileged character of the Ashtekar-Barbero-Immirzi connection suggests that the natural scenario in the polymer framework is a Big Bounce that is not a Universal cut-off. However, by a parallelism between the polymer and Loop Quantum Cosmology properties of the basic operators, we also develop some considerations in favour of the viability of the $\barμ$ scheme of Loop Quantum Cosmology on a semiclassical level.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2022; v1 submitted 18 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Semiclassical and Quantum Polymer Effects in the Flat Isotropic Universe
Authors:
Gabriele Barca,
Paolo Di Antonio,
Giovanni Montani,
Alberto Patti
Abstract:
We analyze some relevant semiclassical and quantum features of the implementation of Polymer Quantum Mechanics to the phenomenology of the flat isotropic Universe.
We firstly investigate a parallelism between the semiclassical polymer dynamics of the flat isotropic Universe, as reduced to the effect of a modified simplectic structure, and the so-called Generalized Uncertainty Principle. We show…
▽ More
We analyze some relevant semiclassical and quantum features of the implementation of Polymer Quantum Mechanics to the phenomenology of the flat isotropic Universe.
We firstly investigate a parallelism between the semiclassical polymer dynamics of the flat isotropic Universe, as reduced to the effect of a modified simplectic structure, and the so-called Generalized Uncertainty Principle. We show how the difference in the sign of the fundamental Poisson bracket is reflected in a sign of the modified source term in the Friedmann equation, responsible for the removal of the initial singularity in the polymer case and for the survival of a singular point in the Universe past, when the Generalized Uncertainty Principle is concerned.
Then, we study the regularization of the vacuum energy of a free massless scalar field, by implementing a second quantization formalism in the context of Polymer Quantum Mechanics. We show that, from this reformulation, naturally emerges a Cosmological Constant term for the isotropic Universe, whose value depends directly on the polymer parameter of the regularization.
Finally, we investigate the behaviour of gravitational waves on the background of a modified dynamics, according to the semiclassical Friedmann equation. We demonstrate that the presence of a Bounce in the Universe past, naturally removes the divergence of the gravitational wave amplitude and they can, in principle, propagate across the minimum volume turning point. This result offers the intriguing perspective for the detection of gravitational signals coming from the pre-Big Bounce collapsing Universe.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2020; v1 submitted 6 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Semi-classical and quantum analysis of the isotropic Universe in the polymer paradigm
Authors:
Giovanni Montani,
Claudia Mantero,
Flavio Bombacigno,
Francesco Cianfrani,
Gabriele Barca
Abstract:
We analyse the semi-classical and quantum dynamics of the isotropic Universe in the framework of the Polymer Quantum mechanics, in order to implement a cut-off physics on the initial singularity. We first identify in the Universe cubed scale factor (i.e. the spatial volume) the suitable configuration variable, providing a constant critical energy density, such that the Bounce arises as intrinsic g…
▽ More
We analyse the semi-classical and quantum dynamics of the isotropic Universe in the framework of the Polymer Quantum mechanics, in order to implement a cut-off physics on the initial singularity. We first identify in the Universe cubed scale factor (i.e. the spatial volume) the suitable configuration variable, providing a constant critical energy density, such that the Bounce arises as intrinsic geometric feature. We then investigate the obtained semi-classical Bounce dynamics for the primordial Universe, and we outline its impact on the resolution of cosmological paradoxes, as soon as the semi-classical evolution is extended (in the spirit of the Ehrenfest theorem) to the collapsing pre-Bounce Universe. Finally, we validate the use of the semi-classical effective dynamics by investigating the behaviour of the expectation values of a proper semiclassical states. The present analysis has the merit to enforce the equivalence between the Polymer quantization paradigm in the Minisuperspace and the Loop Quantum Cosmology approach. In fact, our study allows to define a precise correspondence between the Polymer cut-off scale and the discrete geometric structure of LQG.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2019; v1 submitted 27 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
