-
Determining the difference between local acceleration and local gravity: applications of the equivalence principle to relativistic trajectories
Authors:
Steven A. Balbus
Abstract:
We show by direct calculation that the common Equivalence Principle explanation for why gravity must deflect light is quantitatively incorrect by a factor of three in Schwarzschild geometry. It is therefore possible, at least as a matter of principle, to tell the difference between local acceleration and a true gravitational field by measuring the local deflection of light. We calculate as well th…
▽ More
We show by direct calculation that the common Equivalence Principle explanation for why gravity must deflect light is quantitatively incorrect by a factor of three in Schwarzschild geometry. It is therefore possible, at least as a matter of principle, to tell the difference between local acceleration and a true gravitational field by measuring the local deflection of light. We calculate as well the deflection of test particles of arbitrary energy, and construct a leading-order coordinate transformation from Schwarzschild to local inertial coordinates, which shows explicitly how the effects of spatial curvature manifest locally for relativistic trajectories of both finite and vanishing rest mass particles.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Testing theories of accretion and gravity with super-extremal Kerr discs
Authors:
Andrew Mummery,
Steven Balbus,
Adam Ingram
Abstract:
Fitting the thermal continuum emission of accreting black holes observed across X-ray bands represents one of the principle means of constraining the properties (mass and spin) of astrophysical black holes. Recent ''continuum fitting'' studies of Galactic X-ray binaries in the soft state have found best fitting dimensionless spin values which run into the prior bounds placed on traditional models…
▽ More
Fitting the thermal continuum emission of accreting black holes observed across X-ray bands represents one of the principle means of constraining the properties (mass and spin) of astrophysical black holes. Recent ''continuum fitting'' studies of Galactic X-ray binaries in the soft state have found best fitting dimensionless spin values which run into the prior bounds placed on traditional models ($a_\star = 0.9999$). It is of critical importance that these results are robust, and not a result solely of the presence of these prior bounds and deficiencies in conventional models of accretion. Motivated by these results we derive and present superkerr, an XSPEC model comprising of a thin accretion disc solution valid in the Kerr geometry for arbitrary spin parameter $a_\star$, extending previous models valid only for black holes ($|a_\star| < 1$). This extension into ''superextremal'' spacetimes with $|a_\star| > 1$ includes solutions which describe discs evolving around naked singularities, not black holes. While being valid solutions of Einstein's field equations these naked singularities are not expected to be present in nature. We discuss how the ''measurement'' of a Kerr spin parameter $1 < a_\star < 5/3$ would present compelling evidence for the requirement of a rethink in either standard accretion theory, or our theories of gravity.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Accretion within the innermost stable circular orbit: analytical thermodynamic solutions in the adiabatic limit
Authors:
Andrew Mummery,
Steven Balbus
Abstract:
We present analytical solutions for the thermodynamic (temperature, pressure, density, etc.) properties of thin accretion flows in the region within the innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO) of a Kerr black hole, the first analytical solutions of their kind. These solutions are constructed in the adiabatic limit and neglect radiative losses, an idealisation valid for a restricted region of parame…
▽ More
We present analytical solutions for the thermodynamic (temperature, pressure, density, etc.) properties of thin accretion flows in the region within the innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO) of a Kerr black hole, the first analytical solutions of their kind. These solutions are constructed in the adiabatic limit and neglect radiative losses, an idealisation valid for a restricted region of parameter space. We highlight a number of remarkable properties of these solutions, including that these solutions cool for radii $r_I/2 < r < r_I$, before increasing in temperature for $0 < r < r_I/2$, independent of black hole spin and assumptions regarding the equation of state of the accretion flow. The radiative temperature of these solutions can, for some values of the free parameters of the theory, peak within the ISCO and not in the main body of the disc. These solutions represent a fundamentally new class of analytical accretion solutions, which are both non-circular and non-radial in character.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
A complete characterisation of the orbital shapes of the non-circular Kerr geodesic solutions with circular orbit constants of motion
Authors:
Andrew Mummery,
Steven Balbus
Abstract:
We present analytical solutions describing a family of both inwardly and outwardly spiralling orbits in the Kerr spacetime. The solutions are exact, and remarkable for their simplicity. These orbits all have the angular momentum and energy of a circular orbit at some radius $r_c$, but are not restricted to remaining on that circular orbit, a property not possible in Newtonian gravity. We demonstra…
▽ More
We present analytical solutions describing a family of both inwardly and outwardly spiralling orbits in the Kerr spacetime. The solutions are exact, and remarkable for their simplicity. These orbits all have the angular momentum and energy of a circular orbit at some radius $r_c$, but are not restricted to remaining on that circular orbit, a property not possible in Newtonian gravity. We demonstrate that there are five distinct orbital solutions which terminate at the black hole singularity, and three solutions which either escape to infinity or remain bound. The different orbital solutions are characterised entirely by the black hole spin $a$ and the location of $r_c$. Photon orbits spiralling into or out of their (unstable) circular orbit radii are also analysed. These have properties similar to the hyperbolic class of massive particle orbits discussed herein.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Inspirals from the innermost stable circular orbit of Kerr black holes: Exact solutions and universal radial flow
Authors:
Andrew Mummery,
Steven Balbus
Abstract:
We present exact solutions of test particle orbits spiralling inward from the innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO) of a Kerr black hole. Our results are valid for any allowed value of the angular momentum $a$-parameter of the Kerr metric. These solutions are of considerable physical interest. In particular, the radial 4-velocity of these orbits is both remarkably simple and, with the radial coor…
▽ More
We present exact solutions of test particle orbits spiralling inward from the innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO) of a Kerr black hole. Our results are valid for any allowed value of the angular momentum $a$-parameter of the Kerr metric. These solutions are of considerable physical interest. In particular, the radial 4-velocity of these orbits is both remarkably simple and, with the radial coordinate scaled by its ISCO value, universal in form, otherwise completely independent of the black hole spin.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
A Poynting theorem formulation for the gravitational wave stress pseudo tensor
Authors:
Steven A. Balbus
Abstract:
A very simple and physical derivation of the conservation equation for the propagation of gravitational radiation is presented. The formulation is exact. The result takes the readily recognisable and intuitive form of a Poynting-style equation, in which the outward propagation of stress-energy is directly related to the volumetric equivalent of a radiation reaction force acting back upon the sourc…
▽ More
A very simple and physical derivation of the conservation equation for the propagation of gravitational radiation is presented. The formulation is exact. The result takes the readily recognisable and intuitive form of a Poynting-style equation, in which the outward propagation of stress-energy is directly related to the volumetric equivalent of a radiation reaction force acting back upon the sources, including the purely gravitational contribution to the sources. Upon averaging, the emergent pseudo tensor for the gravitational radiation is in exact agreement with that found by much more labour-intensive methods.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Simplified derivation of the gravitational wave stress tensor from the linearized Einstein field equations
Authors:
Steven A Balbus
Abstract:
A conserved stress energy tensor for weak field gravitational waves propagating in vacuum is derived directly from the linearized wave equation alone, for an arbitrary gauge using standard general relativity. In any harmonic gauge, the form of the tensor leads directly to the classical expression for the outgoing wave energy. The method described here, however, is a much simpler, shorter, and more…
▽ More
A conserved stress energy tensor for weak field gravitational waves propagating in vacuum is derived directly from the linearized wave equation alone, for an arbitrary gauge using standard general relativity. In any harmonic gauge, the form of the tensor leads directly to the classical expression for the outgoing wave energy. The method described here, however, is a much simpler, shorter, and more physically motivated approach than is the customary procedure, which involves a lengthy and cumbersome second-order (in wave-amplitude) calculation starting with the Einstein tensor. Our method has the added advantage of exhibiting the direct coupling between the outgoing energy flux in gravitational waves and the work done by the gravitational field on the sources. For nonharmonic gauges, the directly derived wave stress tensor has an apparent index asymmetry. This coordinate artefact may be removed, and the symmetrized (still gauge-invariant) tensor then takes on its widely-used form. Angular momentum conservation follows immediately. For any harmonic gauge, however, the stress tensor is manifestly symmetric from the start and its derivation depends, in its entirety, on the structure of the linearized wave equation.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2016; v1 submitted 20 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
