-
Gravitational physics in the context of Indian astronomy: A vision document
Authors:
P. Ajith,
K. G. Arun,
Sukanta Bose,
Sumanta Chakraborty,
Shantanu Desai,
A. Gopakumar,
Sanved Kolekar,
Rajesh Nayak,
Archana Pai,
Sudipta Sarkar,
Jasjeet Singh Bagla,
Patrick Das Gupta,
Rahul Kashyap,
Prashant Kocherlakota,
Prayush Kumar,
Banibrata Mukhopadhyay
Abstract:
Contributions from the Indian gravity community have played a significant role in shaping several branches of astronomy and astrophysics. This document reviews some of the most important contributions and presents a vision for gravity research in the context of astronomy \& astrophysics in India. This is an expanded version of one of the chapters in the recently released Vision Document of the Ast…
▽ More
Contributions from the Indian gravity community have played a significant role in shaping several branches of astronomy and astrophysics. This document reviews some of the most important contributions and presents a vision for gravity research in the context of astronomy \& astrophysics in India. This is an expanded version of one of the chapters in the recently released Vision Document of the Astronomical Society of India.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
The Life and Science of Thanu Padmanabhan
Authors:
Jasjeet Singh Bagla,
Krishnakanta Bhattacharya,
Sumanta Chakraborty,
Sunu Engineer,
Valerio Faraoni,
Sanved Kolekar,
Dawood Kothawala,
Kinjalk Lochan,
Sujoy Modak,
V. Parameswaran Nair,
Aseem Paranjape,
Krishnamohan Parattu,
Sarada G. Rajeev,
Bibhas Ranjan Majhi,
Tirthankar Roy Choudhury,
Mohammad Sami,
Sudipta Sarkar,
Sandipan Sengupta,
T. R. Seshadri,
S. Shankaranarayanan,
Suprit Singh,
Tejinder P. Singh,
L. Sriramkumar,
Urjit Yajnik
Abstract:
Thanu Padmanabhan was a renowned Indian theoretical physicist known for his research in general relativity, cosmology, and quantum gravity. In an extraordinary career spanning forty-two years, he published more than three hundred research articles, wrote ten highly successful technical and popular books, and mentored nearly thirty graduate students and post-doctoral fellows. He is best known for h…
▽ More
Thanu Padmanabhan was a renowned Indian theoretical physicist known for his research in general relativity, cosmology, and quantum gravity. In an extraordinary career spanning forty-two years, he published more than three hundred research articles, wrote ten highly successful technical and popular books, and mentored nearly thirty graduate students and post-doctoral fellows. He is best known for his deep work investigating gravitation as an emergent thermodynamic phenomenon. He was an outstanding teacher, and an indefatigable populariser of science, who travelled very widely to motivate and inspire young students. Paddy, as he was affectionately known, was also a close friend to his students and collaborators, treating them as part of his extended academic family. On September 17, 2021 Paddy passed away very unexpectedly, at the age of sixty-four and at the height of his research career, while serving as a Distinguished Professor at the Inter-University Centre for Astronomy and Astrophysics, Pune. His untimely demise has come as a shock to his family and friends and colleagues. In this article, several of them have come together to pay their tributes and share their fond memories of Paddy.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Wave Effects in Double-Plane Lensing
Authors:
Rahul Ramesh,
Ashish Kumar Meena,
J S Bagla
Abstract:
We discuss the wave optical effects in gravitational lens systems with two point mass lenses in two different lens planes. We identify and vary parameters (i.e., lens masses, related distances, and their alignments) related to the lens system to investigate their effects on the amplification factor. We find that due to a large number of parameters, it is not possible to make generalized statements…
▽ More
We discuss the wave optical effects in gravitational lens systems with two point mass lenses in two different lens planes. We identify and vary parameters (i.e., lens masses, related distances, and their alignments) related to the lens system to investigate their effects on the amplification factor. We find that due to a large number of parameters, it is not possible to make generalized statements regarding the amplification factor. We conclude by noting that the best approach to study two-plane and multi-plane lensing is to study various possible lens systems case by case in order to explore the possibilities in the parameter space instead of hoping to generalize the results of a few test cases. We present a preliminary analysis of the parameter space for a two-lens system here.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2021; v1 submitted 21 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Gravitational Lensing of Core Collapse Supernova Gravitational Wave Signals
Authors:
Rahul Ramesh,
Ashish Kumar Meena,
J. S. Bagla
Abstract:
We discuss the prospects of gravitational lensing of gravitational waves (GWs) coming from core-collapse supernovae (CCSN). As the CCSN GW signal can only be detected from within our own Galaxy and the local group by current and upcoming ground-based GW detectors, we focus on microlensing. We introduce a new technique based on analysis of the power spectrum and association of peaks of the power sp…
▽ More
We discuss the prospects of gravitational lensing of gravitational waves (GWs) coming from core-collapse supernovae (CCSN). As the CCSN GW signal can only be detected from within our own Galaxy and the local group by current and upcoming ground-based GW detectors, we focus on microlensing. We introduce a new technique based on analysis of the power spectrum and association of peaks of the power spectrum with the peaks of the amplification factor to identify lensed signals. We validate our method by applying it on the CCSN-like mock signals lensed by a point mass lens. We find that the lensed and unlensed signal can be differentiated using the association of peaks by more than one sigma for lens masses M$_{\rm L} {>} 150{\rm M}_{\odot}$. We also study the correlation integral between the power spectra and corresponding amplification factor. This statistical approach is able to differentiate between unlensed and lensed signals for lenses as small as M$_{\rm L} {\sim} 15{\rm M}_{\odot}$. Further, we demonstrate that this method can be used to estimate the mass of a lens in case the signal is lensed. The power spectrum based analysis is general and can be applied to any broad band signal and is especially useful for incoherent signals.
△ Less
Submitted 20 January, 2022; v1 submitted 6 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Tachyonic vs Quintessence dark energy: linear perturbations and CMB data
Authors:
Manvendra Pratap Rajvanshi,
Avinash Singh,
H. K. Jassal,
J. S. Bagla
Abstract:
We use linear perturbation theory to study perturbations in dynamical dark energy models. We compare quintessence and tachyonic dark energy models with identical background evolution. We write the corresponding equations for different models in a form that makes it easier to see that the two models are very hard to distinguish in the linear regime, especially for models with $(1 + w) \ll 1$. We us…
▽ More
We use linear perturbation theory to study perturbations in dynamical dark energy models. We compare quintessence and tachyonic dark energy models with identical background evolution. We write the corresponding equations for different models in a form that makes it easier to see that the two models are very hard to distinguish in the linear regime, especially for models with $(1 + w) \ll 1$. We use Cosmic Microwave Background data and parametric representations for the two models to illustrate that they cannot be distinguished for the same background evolution with existing observations. Further, we constrain tachyonic models with the Planck data. We do this analysis for exponential and inverse square potentials and find that the intrinsic parameters of the potentials remain very weakly constrained. In particular, this is true in the regime allowed by low redshift observations.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2021; v1 submitted 2 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Gravitational Lensing of Gravitational Waves: Effect of Microlens Population in Lensing Galaxies
Authors:
Anuj Mishra,
Ashish Kumar Meena,
Anupreeta More,
Sukanta Bose,
J S Bagla
Abstract:
With increasing sensitivities of the current ground-based gravitational-wave (GW) detectors, the prospects of detecting a strongly lensed GW signal are going to be high in the coming years. When such a signal passes through an intervening lensing galaxy or galaxy cluster, the embedded stellar-mass microlenses lead to interference patterns in the signal that may leave observable signatures. In this…
▽ More
With increasing sensitivities of the current ground-based gravitational-wave (GW) detectors, the prospects of detecting a strongly lensed GW signal are going to be high in the coming years. When such a signal passes through an intervening lensing galaxy or galaxy cluster, the embedded stellar-mass microlenses lead to interference patterns in the signal that may leave observable signatures. In this work, we present an extensive study of these wave effects in the LIGO/Virgo frequency band ($10$-$10^4$ Hz) due to the presence of the microlens population in galaxy-scale lenses for the first time. We consider a wide range of strong lensing (macro) magnifications and the corresponding surface microlens densities found in lensing galaxies and use them to generate realisations of the amplification factor. The methodologies for simulating amplification curves for both types of images (minima and saddle points) are also discussed. We then study how microlensing is broadly affected by the parameters like macro-magnifications, stellar densities, the initial mass function (IMF), types of images, and microlens distribution around the source. In general, with increasing macro-magnification values, the effects of microlensing become increasingly significant regardless of other parameters. Mismatch analysis between the lensed and the unlensed GW waveforms from chirping binaries suggests that, while inferring the source parameters, microlensing can not be neglected for macro-magnification $\gtrsim 15$. Furthermore, for extremely high macro-magnifications $\gtrsim 100$, the mismatch can even exceed $5\%$, which can result in both a missed detection and, consequently, a missed lensed signal.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2021; v1 submitted 7 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Non-linear spherical collapse in tachyon models, and a comparison of collapse in tachyon and quintessence models of dark energy
Authors:
Manvendra Pratap Rajvanshi,
J. S. Bagla
Abstract:
We study evolution of perturbations in dark matter and dark energy for spherical collapse. We study Tachyon models of dark energy using the approach outlined in Rajvanshi and Bagla (2018). We work with models that are allowed by current observations. We find that as with Quintessence models allowed by observations, dark energy perturbations do not affect evolution of perturbations in dark matter i…
▽ More
We study evolution of perturbations in dark matter and dark energy for spherical collapse. We study Tachyon models of dark energy using the approach outlined in Rajvanshi and Bagla (2018). We work with models that are allowed by current observations. We find that as with Quintessence models allowed by observations, dark energy perturbations do not affect evolution of perturbations in dark matter in a significant manner. Perturbations in dark energy remain small for such models. In order to compare different classes of dark energy models, we use reconstruction of potentials and study dark matter and dark energy perturbations for same expansion history in the two models. We find that dark matter perturbations carry no imprint of the class of dark energy models for the same expansion history: this is significant in that we can work with any convenient model to study clustering of dark matter. We find that the evolution of dark energy perturbations carries an imprint of the class of models in that these grow differently in Tachyon models and Quintessence models. However, the difference between these diminishes for (1+w)<<1 and hence prospects for differentiating between models using characteristics of perturbations are limited in our Universe.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2021; v1 submitted 17 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Gravitational Waves from merging binaries
Authors:
Jahanvi,
Ashish Kumar Meena,
J. S. Bagla
Abstract:
We discuss gravitational waves from merging binaries using a Newtonian approach with some inputs from the Post-Newtonian formalism. We show that it is possible to understand the key features of the signal using fundamental physics and also demonstrate that an approximate calculation gives us the correct order of magnitude estimate of the parameters describing the merging binary system. We build on…
▽ More
We discuss gravitational waves from merging binaries using a Newtonian approach with some inputs from the Post-Newtonian formalism. We show that it is possible to understand the key features of the signal using fundamental physics and also demonstrate that an approximate calculation gives us the correct order of magnitude estimate of the parameters describing the merging binary system. We build on this analysis to understand the range for different types of sources for given detector sensitivity. We also consider known binary pulsar systems and discuss the expected gravitational wave signal from these.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Finding Singularities in Gravitational Lensing
Authors:
Ashish Kumar Meena,
J. S. Bagla
Abstract:
The number of strong lens systems is expected to increase significantly in ongoing and upcoming surveys. With an increase in the total number of such systems we expect to discover many configurations that correspond to unstable caustics. In such cases, the instability can be used to our advantage for constraining the lens model. We have implemented algorithms for detection of different types of si…
▽ More
The number of strong lens systems is expected to increase significantly in ongoing and upcoming surveys. With an increase in the total number of such systems we expect to discover many configurations that correspond to unstable caustics. In such cases, the instability can be used to our advantage for constraining the lens model. We have implemented algorithms for detection of different types of singularities in gravitational lensing. We test our approach on a variety of lens models and then go on to apply it to the inferred mass distribution for Abell 697 as an example application. We propose to represent lenses using A3-lines and singular points (A4 and D4) in the image plane. We propose this as a compact representation of complex lens systems that can capture all the details in a single snapshot.
△ Less
Submitted 31 December, 2019; v1 submitted 3 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Gravitational collapse and structure formation in an expanding universe with dark energy
Authors:
Manvendra Pratap Rajvanshi,
Tuneer Chakraborty,
J. S. Bagla
Abstract:
Observations show that the expansion of the Universe is accelerating. This requires that the dominant constituent of matter in the Universe has some unusual properties like negative pressure. This exotic component has been given the name dark energy. We work with the simplest model of dark energy, the cosmological constant introduced by Einstein. We study the evolution of spherical over-densities…
▽ More
Observations show that the expansion of the Universe is accelerating. This requires that the dominant constituent of matter in the Universe has some unusual properties like negative pressure. This exotic component has been given the name dark energy. We work with the simplest model of dark energy, the cosmological constant introduced by Einstein. We study the evolution of spherical over-densities in such a model and show that there is a minimum over-density required for collapse: perturbations with a smaller amplitude do not collapse. This threshold is interesting as even perturbations with a positive over-density and negative energy do not collapse in finite time. Further, we show that perturbations with an amplitude larger than, but comparable to the threshold value, take a very long time to collapse. We compare the solutions with the case when dark energy is absent.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2019; v1 submitted 9 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Nonlinear spherical perturbations in Quintessence Models of Dark Energy
Authors:
Manvendra Pratap Rajvanshi,
Jasjeet Singh Bagla
Abstract:
Observations have confirmed the accelerated expansion of the universe. The accelerated expansion can be modelled by invoking a cosmological constant or a dynamical model of dark energy. A key difference between these models is that the equation of state parameter $w$ for dark energy differs from $-1$ in dynamical dark energy (DDE) models. Further, the equation of state parameter is not constant fo…
▽ More
Observations have confirmed the accelerated expansion of the universe. The accelerated expansion can be modelled by invoking a cosmological constant or a dynamical model of dark energy. A key difference between these models is that the equation of state parameter $w$ for dark energy differs from $-1$ in dynamical dark energy (DDE) models. Further, the equation of state parameter is not constant for a general DDE model. Such differences can be probed using the variation of scale factor with time by measuring distances. Another significant difference between the cosmological constant and DDE models is that the latter must cluster. Linear perturbation analysis indicates that perturbations in quintessence models of dark energy do not grow to have a significant amplitude at small length scales. In this paper we study the response of quintessence dark energy to non-linear perturbations in dark matter. We use a fully relativistic model for spherically symmetric perturbations. In this study we focus on thawing models. We find that in response to non-linear perturbations in dark matter, dark energy perturbations grow at a faster rate than expected in linear perturbation theory. We find that dark energy perturbation remains localised and does not diffuse out to larger scales. The dominant drivers of the evolution of dark energy perturbations are the local Hubble flow and a supression of gradients of the scalar field. We also find that the equation of state parameter $w$ changes in response to perturbations in dark matter such that it also becomes a function of position. The variation of $w$ in space is correlated with density contrast for matter. Variation of $w$ and perturbations in dark energy are more pronounced in response to large scale perturbations in matter while the dependence on the amplitude of matter perturbations is much weaker.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2018; v1 submitted 16 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Understanding the origin of CMB constraints on Dark Energy
Authors:
H. K. Jassal,
J. S. Bagla,
T. Padmanabhan
Abstract:
We study the observational constraints of CMB temperature and polarization anisotropies on models of dark energy, with special focus on models with variation in properties of dark energy with time. We demonstrate that the key constraint from CMB observations arises from the location of acoustic peaks. An additional constraint arises from the limits on Omega_nr from the relative amplitudes of aco…
▽ More
We study the observational constraints of CMB temperature and polarization anisotropies on models of dark energy, with special focus on models with variation in properties of dark energy with time. We demonstrate that the key constraint from CMB observations arises from the location of acoustic peaks. An additional constraint arises from the limits on Omega_nr from the relative amplitudes of acoustic peaks. Further, we show that the distance to the last scattering surface is not how the CMB observations constrain the combination of parameters for models of dark energy. We also use constraints from Supernova observations and show that unlike the Gold and Silver samples, the SNLS sample prefers a region of parameter space that has a significant overlap with the region preferred by the CMB observations. This is a verification of a conjecture made by us in an earlier work. We discuss combined constraints from WMAP5 and SNLS observations. We find that models with w ~ -1 are preferred for models with a constant equation of state parameters. In case of models with a time varying dark energy, we show that constraints on evolution of dark energy density are almost independent of the type of variation assumed for the equation of state parameter. This makes it easy to get approximate constraints from CMB observations on arbitrary models of dark energy. Constraints on models with a time varying dark energy are predominantly due to CMB observations, with Supernova constraints playing only a marginal role.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2010; v1 submitted 18 January, 2006;
originally announced January 2006.
-
Observational constraints on low redshift evolution of dark energy: How consistent are different observations?
Authors:
H. K. Jassal,
J. S. Bagla,
T. Padmanabhan
Abstract:
The dark energy component of the universe is often interpreted either in terms of a cosmological constant or as a scalar field. A generic feature of the scalar field models is that the equation of state parameter w= P/rho for the dark energy need not satisfy w=-1 and, in general, it can be a function of time. Using the Markov chain Monte Carlo method we perform a critical analysis of the cosmolo…
▽ More
The dark energy component of the universe is often interpreted either in terms of a cosmological constant or as a scalar field. A generic feature of the scalar field models is that the equation of state parameter w= P/rho for the dark energy need not satisfy w=-1 and, in general, it can be a function of time. Using the Markov chain Monte Carlo method we perform a critical analysis of the cosmological parameter space, allowing for a varying w. We use constraints on w(z) from the observations of high redshift supernovae (SN), the WMAP observations of CMB anisotropies and abundance of rich clusters of galaxies. For models with a constant w, the LCDM model is allowed with a probability of about 6% by the SN observations while it is allowed with a probability of 98.9% by WMAP observations. The LCDM model is allowed even within the context of models with variable w: WMAP observations allow it with a probability of 99.1% whereas SN data allows it with 23% probability. The SN data, on its own, favors phantom like equation of state (w<-1) and high values for Omega_NR. It does not distinguish between constant w (with w<-1) models and those with varying w(z) in a statistically significant manner. The SN data allows a very wide range for variation of dark energy density, e.g., a variation by factor ten in the dark energy density between z=0 and z=1 is allowed at 95% confidence level. WMAP observations provide a better constraint and the corresponding allowed variation is less than a factor of three. Allowing for variation in w has an impact on the values for other cosmological parameters in that the allowed range often becomes larger. (Abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2005; v1 submitted 30 June, 2005;
originally announced June 2005.
-
WMAP constraints on low redshift evolution of dark energy
Authors:
H. K. Jassal,
J. S. Bagla,
T. Padmanabhan
Abstract:
The conceptual difficulties associated with a cosmological constant have led to the investigation of alternative models in which the equation of state parameter, $w=p/ρ$, of the dark energy evolves with time. We show that combining the supernova type Ia observations {\it with the constraints from WMAP observations} restricts large variation of $ρ(z)$ at low redshifts. The combination of these tw…
▽ More
The conceptual difficulties associated with a cosmological constant have led to the investigation of alternative models in which the equation of state parameter, $w=p/ρ$, of the dark energy evolves with time. We show that combining the supernova type Ia observations {\it with the constraints from WMAP observations} restricts large variation of $ρ(z)$ at low redshifts. The combination of these two observational constraints is stronger than either one. The results are completely consistent with the cosmological constant as the source of dark energy.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2004; v1 submitted 20 April, 2004;
originally announced April 2004.
-
Cosmology with tachyon field as dark energy
Authors:
J. S. Bagla,
H. K. Jassal,
T. Padmanabhan
Abstract:
We present a detailed study of cosmological effects of homogeneous tachyon matter coexisting with non-relativistic matter and radiation, concentrating on the inverse square potential and the exponential potential for the tachyonic scalar field. A distinguishing feature of these models (compared to other cosmological models) is that the matter density parameter and the density parameter for tachy…
▽ More
We present a detailed study of cosmological effects of homogeneous tachyon matter coexisting with non-relativistic matter and radiation, concentrating on the inverse square potential and the exponential potential for the tachyonic scalar field. A distinguishing feature of these models (compared to other cosmological models) is that the matter density parameter and the density parameter for tachyons remain comparable even in the matter dominated phase. For the exponential potential, the solutions have an accelerating phase, followed by a phase with a(t) ~ t^{2/3} as t goes to infinity. This eliminates the future event horizon present in LCDM models and is an attractive feature from the string theory perspective. A comparison with supernova Ia data shows that for both the potentials there exists a range of models in which the universe undergoes an accelerated expansion at low redshifts and are also consistent with requirements of structure formation. They do require fine tuning of parameters but not any more than in the case of LCDM or quintessence models.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2003; v1 submitted 9 December, 2002;
originally announced December 2002.
-
Nonlinear Evolution of Density Perturbations
Authors:
J. S. Bagla,
T. Padmanabhan
Abstract:
: From the epoch of recombination $(z\approx 10^3)$ till today, the typical density contrasts have grown by a factor of about $10^6$ in a Friedmann universe with $Ω=1$. However, during the same epoch the typical gravitational potential has grown only by a factor of order unity. We present theoretical arguments explaining the origin of this approximate constancy of gravitational potential. This f…
▽ More
: From the epoch of recombination $(z\approx 10^3)$ till today, the typical density contrasts have grown by a factor of about $10^6$ in a Friedmann universe with $Ω=1$. However, during the same epoch the typical gravitational potential has grown only by a factor of order unity. We present theoretical arguments explaining the origin of this approximate constancy of gravitational potential. This fact can be exploited to provide a new, powerful, approximation scheme to study the formation of nonlinear structures in the universe. The essential idea of this method is to evolve the initial distribution of particles using a gravitational potential frozen in time (Frozen Potential Approximation). This approximation provides valuable insight into understanding various features of nonlinear evolution; for example, it provides a simple explanation as to why pancakes remain thin during the evolution even in the absence of any artificial, adhesion-like, damping terms. We compare the trajectories of particles in various approximations. We also discuss a few applications of the frozen potential approximation.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 1993;
originally announced September 1993.
-
Nonlinear evolution of density perturbations using approximate constancy of gravitational potential
Authors:
J. S. Bagla,
T. Padmanabhan
Abstract:
During the evolution of density inhomogeneties in an $Ω=1$, matter dominated universe, the typical density contrast changes from $δ\simeq 10^{-4}$ to $δ\simeq 10^2$. However, during the same time, the typical value of the gravitational potential generated by the perturbations changes only by a factor of order unity. This significant fact can be exploited to provide a new, powerful, approximation…
▽ More
During the evolution of density inhomogeneties in an $Ω=1$, matter dominated universe, the typical density contrast changes from $δ\simeq 10^{-4}$ to $δ\simeq 10^2$. However, during the same time, the typical value of the gravitational potential generated by the perturbations changes only by a factor of order unity. This significant fact can be exploited to provide a new, powerful, approximation scheme for studying the formation of nonlinear structures in the universe. This scheme, discussed in this paper, evolves the initial perturbation using a Newtonian gravitational potential frozen in time. We carry out this procedure for different intial spectra and compare the results with the Zeldovich approximation and the frozen flow approximation (proposed by Mattarrese et al. recently). Our results are in far better agreement with the N-body simulations than the Zeldovich approximation. It also provides a dynamical explanation for the fact that pancakes remain thin during the evolution. While there is some superficial similarity between the frozen flow results and ours, they differ considerably in the velocity information. Actual shell crossing does occur in our approximation; also there is motion of particles along the pancakes leading to further clumping. These features are quite different from those in frozen flow model. We also discuss the evolution of the two-point correlation function in various approximations.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 1993; v1 submitted 16 April, 1993;
originally announced April 1993.
