-
Graph Neural Network Framework for Security Assessment Informed by Topological Measures
Authors:
Mojtaba Dezvarei,
Kevin Tomsovic,
Jinyuan Stella Sun,
Seddik M. Djouadi
Abstract:
In the power system, security assessment (SA) plays a pivotal role in determining the safe operation in a normal situation and some contingencies scenarios. Electrical variables as input variables of the model are mainly considered to indicate the power system operation as secure or insecure, according to the reliability criteria for contingency scenarios. In this approach, the features are in gri…
▽ More
In the power system, security assessment (SA) plays a pivotal role in determining the safe operation in a normal situation and some contingencies scenarios. Electrical variables as input variables of the model are mainly considered to indicate the power system operation as secure or insecure, according to the reliability criteria for contingency scenarios. In this approach, the features are in grid format data, where the relation between features and any knowledge of network topology is absent. Moreover, the traditional and common models, such as neural networks (NN), are not applicable if the input variables are in the graph format structure. Therefore, this paper examines the security analysis in the graph neural network (GNN) framework such that the GNN model incorporates the network connection and node's neighbors' influence for the assessment. Here the input features are separated graphs representing different network conditions in electrical and structural statuses. Topological characteristics defined by network centrality measures are added in the feature vector representing the structural properties of the network. The proposed model is simulated in the IEEE 118-Bus system for the voltage static security assessment (SSA). The performance indices validate the efficiency of the GNN-based model compared to the traditional NN model denoting that the information enclosed in graph data boosts the classifier performance since the GNN model benefits the neighbors' features. Moreover, outperforming of GNN-based model is determined when robustness and sensitivity analyzes are carried out. The proposed method is not limited to a specific task and can be extended for other security assessments with different critical variables, such as dynamic analysis and frequency criteria, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Exploring Physical-Based Constraints in Short-Term Load Forecasting: A Defense Mechanism Against Cyberattack
Authors:
Mojtaba Dezvarei,
Kevin Tomsovic,
Jinyuan Stella Sun,
Seddik M. Djouadi
Abstract:
Short-term load forecasting is an essential task that supports utilities to schedule generating sufficient power for balancing supply and demand, and can become an attractive target for cyber attacks. It has been shown that the power system state estimation is vulnerable to false data injection attacks. Similarly, false data injection on input variables can result in large forecast errors. The loa…
▽ More
Short-term load forecasting is an essential task that supports utilities to schedule generating sufficient power for balancing supply and demand, and can become an attractive target for cyber attacks. It has been shown that the power system state estimation is vulnerable to false data injection attacks. Similarly, false data injection on input variables can result in large forecast errors. The load forecasting system should have a protective mechanism to mitigate such attacks. One approach is to model physical system constraints that would identify anomalies. This study investigates possible constraints associated with a load forecasting application. Looking at regional forecasted loads, we analyze the relation between each zone through similarity measures used in time series in order to identify constraints. Comprehensive results for historical ERCOT load data indicate variation in the measures recognizing the existence of malicious action. Still, these static measures can not be considered an efficient index across different scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Hybrid Symbolic-Numeric Framework for Power System Modeling and Analysis
Authors:
Hantao Cui,
Fangxing Li,
Kevin Tomsovic
Abstract:
With the recent proliferation of open-source packages for computing, power system differential-algebraic equation (DAE) modeling and simulation are being revisited to reduce the programming efforts. Existing open-source tools require manual efforts to develop code for numerical equations, sparse Jacobians, and discontinuous components. This paper proposes a hybrid symbolic-numeric framework, exemp…
▽ More
With the recent proliferation of open-source packages for computing, power system differential-algebraic equation (DAE) modeling and simulation are being revisited to reduce the programming efforts. Existing open-source tools require manual efforts to develop code for numerical equations, sparse Jacobians, and discontinuous components. This paper proposes a hybrid symbolic-numeric framework, exemplified by an open-source Python-based library ANDES, which consists of a symbolic layer for descriptive modeling and a numeric layer for vector-based numerical computation. This method enables the implementation of DAE models by mixing and matching modeling components, through which models are described. In the framework, a rich set of discontinuous components and standard transfer function blocks are provided besides essential modeling elements for rapid modeling. ANDES can automatically generate robust and fast numerical simulation code, as well as and high-quality documentation. Case studies present a) two implementations of turbine governor model TGOV1, b) power flow computation time break down for MATPOWER systems, c) validation of time-domain simulation with commercial software using three test systems with a variety of models, and d) the full eigenvalue analysis for Kundur's system. Validation shows that ANDES closely matches the commercial tool DSATools for power flow, time-domain simulation, and eigenvalue analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 12 August, 2020; v1 submitted 21 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Review on Set-Theoretic Methods for Safety Verification and Control of Power System
Authors:
Yichen Zhang,
Yan Li,
Kevin Tomsovic,
Seddik Djouadi,
Meng Yue
Abstract:
Increasing penetration of renewable energy introduces significant uncertainty into power systems. Traditional simulation-based verification methods may not be applicable due to the unknown-but-bounded feature of the uncertainty sets. Emerging set-theoretic methods have been intensively investigated to tackle this challenge. The paper comprehensively reviews these methods categorized by underlying…
▽ More
Increasing penetration of renewable energy introduces significant uncertainty into power systems. Traditional simulation-based verification methods may not be applicable due to the unknown-but-bounded feature of the uncertainty sets. Emerging set-theoretic methods have been intensively investigated to tackle this challenge. The paper comprehensively reviews these methods categorized by underlying mathematical principles, that is, set operation-based methods and passivity-based methods. Set operation-based methods are more computationally efficient, while passivity-based methods provide semi-analytical expression of reachable sets, which can be readily employed for control. Other features between different methods are also discussed and illustrated by numerical examples. A benchmark example is presented and solved by different methods to verify consistency.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2020; v1 submitted 31 December, 2019;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Synthesizing Distributed Energy Resources in Microgrids with Temporal Logic Specifications
Authors:
Yichen Zhang,
Mohammed Olama,
Alexander Melin,
Yaosuo Xue,
Seddik Djouadi,
Kevin Tomsovic
Abstract:
Grid supportive (GS) modes integrated within distributed energy resources (DERs) can improve the frequency response. However, synthesis of GS modes for guaranteed performance is challenging. Moreover, a tool is needed to handle sophisticated specifications from grid codes and protection relays. This paper proposes a model predictive control (MPC)-based mode synthesis methodology, which can accommo…
▽ More
Grid supportive (GS) modes integrated within distributed energy resources (DERs) can improve the frequency response. However, synthesis of GS modes for guaranteed performance is challenging. Moreover, a tool is needed to handle sophisticated specifications from grid codes and protection relays. This paper proposes a model predictive control (MPC)-based mode synthesis methodology, which can accommodate the temporal logic specifications (TLSs). The TLSs allow richer descriptions of control specifications addressing both magnitude and time at the same time. The proposed controller will compute a series of Boolean control signals to synthesize the GS mode of DERs by solving the MPC problem under the normal condition, where the frequency response predicted by a reduced-order model satisfies the defined specifications. Once a sizable disturbance is detected, the pre-calculated signals are applied to the DERs. The proposed synthesis methodology is verified on the full nonlinear model in Simulink. A robust factor is imposed on the specifications to compensate the response mismatch between the reduce-order model and nonlinear model so that the nonlinear response satisfies the required TLS.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Provision for Guaranteed Inertial Response in Diesel-Wind Systems via Model Reference Control
Authors:
Yichen Zhang,
Alexander M. Melin,
Seddik M. Djouadi,
Mohammed M. Olama,
Kevin Tomsovic
Abstract:
Frequency performance has been a crucial issue for islanded microgrids. On the one hand, most distributed energy resources (DER) are converter-interfaced and do not inherently respond to frequency variations. On the other hand, current inertia emulation approach cannot provide guaranteed response. In this paper, a model reference control based inertia emulation strategy is proposed for diesel-wind…
▽ More
Frequency performance has been a crucial issue for islanded microgrids. On the one hand, most distributed energy resources (DER) are converter-interfaced and do not inherently respond to frequency variations. On the other hand, current inertia emulation approach cannot provide guaranteed response. In this paper, a model reference control based inertia emulation strategy is proposed for diesel-wind systems. Desired inertia can be precisely emulated through the proposed strategy. A typical frequency response model with parametric inertia is set to be the reference model. A measurement at a specific location delivers the information about the disturbance acting on the diesel-wind system to the reference model. The objective is for the speed of the diesel generator to track the reference so that the desired inertial response is realized. In addition, polytopic parameter uncertainty will be considered. The control strategy is configured in different ways according to different operating points. The parameters of the reference model are scheduled to ensure adequate frequency response under a pre-defined worst case. The controller is implemented in a nonlinear three-phase diesel-wind system fed microgrid using the Simulink software platform. The results show that exact synthetic inertia can be emulated and adequate frequency response is achieved.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2018; v1 submitted 12 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Set Theory-Based Safety Supervisory Control for Wind Turbines to Ensure Adequate Frequency Response
Authors:
Yichen Zhang,
M. Ehsan Raoufat,
Kevin Tomsovic,
Seddik M. Djouadi
Abstract:
Inadequate frequency response can arise due to a high penetration of wind turbine generators (WTGs) and requires a frequency support function to be integrated in the WTG. The appropriate design for these controllers to ensure adequate response has not been investigated thoroughly. In this paper, a safety supervisory control (SSC) is proposed to synthesize the supportive modes in WTGs to guarantee…
▽ More
Inadequate frequency response can arise due to a high penetration of wind turbine generators (WTGs) and requires a frequency support function to be integrated in the WTG. The appropriate design for these controllers to ensure adequate response has not been investigated thoroughly. In this paper, a safety supervisory control (SSC) is proposed to synthesize the supportive modes in WTGs to guarantee performance. The concept, region of safety (ROS), is stated for safe switching synthesis. An optimization formula is proposed to calculate the largest ROS. By assuming a polynomial structure, the problem can be solved by a sum of squares program. A feasible result will generate a polynomial, the zero sublevel set of which represents the ROS and is employed as the safety supervisor. A decentralized communication architecture is proposed for small-scale systems. Moreover, a scheduling loop is suggested so that the supervisor updates its boundary with respect to the renewable penetration level to be robust with respect to variations in system inertia. The proposed controller is first verified on a single-machine three-phase nonlinear microgrid, and then implemented on the IEEE 39-bus system. Both results indicate that the proposed framework and control configuration can guarantee adequate response without excessive conservativeness.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2018; v1 submitted 9 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Cyber-Physical Testbed for Power System Wide-Area Measurement-Based Control Using Open-Source Software
Authors:
Hantao Cui,
Fangxing Li,
Kevin Tomsovic,
Siqi Wang,
Riyasat Azim,
Yidan Lu,
Haoyu Yuan
Abstract:
The electric power system is a cyber-physical system with power flow in the physical system and information flow in the cyber. Simulation is crucial to understanding the dynamics and control of electric power systems yet the underlying communication system has historically been ignored in these studies. This paper aims at meeting the increasing needs to simulate the operations of a real power syst…
▽ More
The electric power system is a cyber-physical system with power flow in the physical system and information flow in the cyber. Simulation is crucial to understanding the dynamics and control of electric power systems yet the underlying communication system has historically been ignored in these studies. This paper aims at meeting the increasing needs to simulate the operations of a real power system including the physical system, the energy management system, the communication system, and the emerging wide-area measurement-based controls. This paper proposes a cyber-physical testbed design and implementation for verifying and demonstrating wide-area control methods based on streaming telemetry and phasor measurement unit data. The proposed decoupled architecture is composed of a differential algebraic equation based physical system simulator, a software-defined network, a scripting language environment for prototyping an EMS system and a control system, all of which are integrated over industry-standard communication protocols. The proposed testbed is implemented using open-source software packages managed by a Python dispatcher. Finally, demonstrations are presented to show two wide-area measurement-based controls - system separation control and hierarchical voltage control, in the implemented testbed.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Battery Energy Storage Scheduling for Optimal Load Variance Minimization
Authors:
Yichen Zhang,
Alexander Melin,
Mohammed Olama,
Seddik Djouadi,
Jin Dong,
Kevin Tomsovic
Abstract:
Generation portfolio can be significantly altered due to the deployment of distributed energy resources (DER) in distribution networks and the concept of microgrid. Generally, distribution networks can operate in a more resilient and economic fashion through proper coordination of DER. However, due to the partially uncontrollable and stochastic nature of some DER, the variance of net load of distr…
▽ More
Generation portfolio can be significantly altered due to the deployment of distributed energy resources (DER) in distribution networks and the concept of microgrid. Generally, distribution networks can operate in a more resilient and economic fashion through proper coordination of DER. However, due to the partially uncontrollable and stochastic nature of some DER, the variance of net load of distribution systems increases, which raises the operational cost and complicates operation for transmission companies. This motivates peak shaving and valley filling using energy storage units deployed in distribution systems. This paper aims at theoretical formulation of optimal load variance minimization, where the infinity norm of net load is minimized. Then, the problem is reformulated equivalently as a linear program. A case study is performed with capacity-limited battery energy storage model and the simplified power flow model of a radial distribution network. The influence of capacity limit and deployment location are studied.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2018; v1 submitted 9 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Hybrid Controller for Wind Turbine Generators to Ensure Adequate Frequency Response in Power Networks
Authors:
Yichen Zhang,
Kevin Tomsovic,
Seddik M. Djouadi,
Hector Pulgar-Painemal
Abstract:
Converter-interfaced power sources (CIPS) are hybrid control systems as they may switch between multiple operating modes. Due to increasing penetration, the hybrid behavior of CIPS, such as, wind turbine generators (WTG), may have significant impact on power system dynamics. In this paper, the frequency dynamics under inertia emulation and primary support from WTG is studied. A mode switching for…
▽ More
Converter-interfaced power sources (CIPS) are hybrid control systems as they may switch between multiple operating modes. Due to increasing penetration, the hybrid behavior of CIPS, such as, wind turbine generators (WTG), may have significant impact on power system dynamics. In this paper, the frequency dynamics under inertia emulation and primary support from WTG is studied. A mode switching for WTG to ensure adequate frequency response is proposed. The switching instants are determined by our proposed concept of a region of safety (ROS), which is the initial set of safe trajectories. The barrier certificate methodology is employed to derive a new algorithm to obtain and enlarge the ROS for the given desired safe limits and the worst-case disturbance scenarios. Then critical switching instants and a safe recovery procedure are found. In addition, the emulated inertia and load-damping effect is derived in the time frame of inertia and primary frequency response, respectively. The theoretical results under critical cases are consistent with simulations and can be used as guidance for practical control design.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Quantitative Control Approach for Wind Turbine Generators to Provide Fast Frequency Response with Guarantee of Rotor Security
Authors:
Siqi Wang,
Kevin Tomsovic
Abstract:
Wind generation is expected to reach substantially higher levels of penetration in the near future. With the converter interface, the rotor inertia of doubly-fed induction generator (DFIG) based wind turbine generator is effectively decoupled from the system, causing a reduction in inertial response. This can be compensated by enabling the DFIG to provide fast frequency response. This paper propos…
▽ More
Wind generation is expected to reach substantially higher levels of penetration in the near future. With the converter interface, the rotor inertia of doubly-fed induction generator (DFIG) based wind turbine generator is effectively decoupled from the system, causing a reduction in inertial response. This can be compensated by enabling the DFIG to provide fast frequency response. This paper proposes a quantitative control approach for DFIG to deliver fast frequency response in the inertial response time scale. A supplementary power surge function is added to the active power reference of DFIG. The exact amount of power surge that is available from DFIG-based wind turbine is quantified based on estimation of maximum extractable energy. Moreover, the operational constraints such as rotor limits and converter over-load limit are considered at the same time. Thus, the proposed approach not only provides adequate inertial response but also ensures the rotor speed is kept within a specified operating range. Rotor safety is guaranteed without the need for an additional rotor speed protection scheme.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Oscillation energy based sensitivity analysis and control for multi-mode oscillation systems
Authors:
Horacio Silva-Saravia,
Yajun Wang,
Hector Pulgar-Painemal,
Kevin Tomsovic
Abstract:
This paper describes a novel approach to analyze and control systems with multi-mode oscillation problems. Traditional single dominant mode analysis fails to provide effective control actions when several modes have similar low damping ratios. This work addresses this problem by considering all modes in the formulation of the system kinetic oscillation energy. The integral of energy over time defi…
▽ More
This paper describes a novel approach to analyze and control systems with multi-mode oscillation problems. Traditional single dominant mode analysis fails to provide effective control actions when several modes have similar low damping ratios. This work addresses this problem by considering all modes in the formulation of the system kinetic oscillation energy. The integral of energy over time defines the total action as a measure of dynamic performance, and its sensitivity allows comparing the performance of different actuators/locations in the system to select the most effective one to damp the oscillation energy. Time domain simulations in the IEEE 9-bus system and IEEE 39-bus system verify the findings obtained by the oscillation energy based analysis. Applications of the proposed method in control and system planning are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Event Analysis of Pulse-reclosers in Distribution Systems Through Sparse Representation
Authors:
M. E. Raoufat,
A. Taalimi,
K. Tomsovic,
R. Hay
Abstract:
The pulse-recloser uses pulse testing technology to verify that the line is clear of faults before initiating a reclose operation, which significantly reduces stress on the system components (e.g. substation transformers) and voltage sags on adjacent feeders. Online event analysis of pulse-reclosers are essential to increases the overall utility of the devices, especially when there are numerous d…
▽ More
The pulse-recloser uses pulse testing technology to verify that the line is clear of faults before initiating a reclose operation, which significantly reduces stress on the system components (e.g. substation transformers) and voltage sags on adjacent feeders. Online event analysis of pulse-reclosers are essential to increases the overall utility of the devices, especially when there are numerous devices installed throughout the distribution system. In this paper, field data recorded from several devices were analyzed to identify specific activity and fault locations. An algorithm is developed to screen the data to identify the status of each pole and to tag time windows with a possible pulse event. In the next step, selected time windows are further analyzed and classified using a sparse representation technique by solving an l1-regularized least-square problem. This classification is obtained by comparing the pulse signature with the reference dictionary to find a set that most closely matches the pulse features. This work also sheds additional light on the possibility of fault classification based on the pulse signature. Field data collected from a distribution system are used to verify the effectiveness and reliability of the proposed method.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Power System Supplementary Damping Controllers in the Presence of Saturation
Authors:
M. Ehsan Raoufat,
Kevin Tomsovic,
Seddik M. Djouadi
Abstract:
This paper presents the analysis and a method to design supplementary damping controllers (SDCs) for synchronous generators considering the effects of saturation limits. Usually such saturations of control signals are imposed in order to enforce practical limitations such as component ratings. However, to guarantee the stability in the presence of saturation limits, the state trajectories must rem…
▽ More
This paper presents the analysis and a method to design supplementary damping controllers (SDCs) for synchronous generators considering the effects of saturation limits. Usually such saturations of control signals are imposed in order to enforce practical limitations such as component ratings. However, to guarantee the stability in the presence of saturation limits, the state trajectories must remain inside the domain of attraction (DA). In this paper, the domain of attraction of a single-machine infinite-bus (SMIB) power system with saturation nonlinearity is estimated and compared with the exact description of the null controllable region. Then, state-feedback controllers are designed to enlarge the DA. Our analysis shows that nonlinear effects of saturation should be considered to guarantee stability and satisfactory performance. Simulation results on a detailed nonlinear model of a synchronous generator indicate that the DA enlarges with the proposed controller. The results also indicate that Critical Clearing Time (CCT) and damping of the system with saturation can be improved by the proposed method.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Control Allocation for Wide Area Coordinated Damping
Authors:
M. Ehsan Raoufat,
Kevin Tomsovic,
Seddik M. Djouadi
Abstract:
In this work, a modal-based sparse control allocation (CA) is proposed for coordinated and fault-tolerant wide-area damping controllers (WADCs). In our proposed method, the supervisory CA only communicates with necessary actuators to achieve the required damping performance and in case of actuator failures (e.g., due to loss of communication or scheduling), capabilities of the remaining actuators…
▽ More
In this work, a modal-based sparse control allocation (CA) is proposed for coordinated and fault-tolerant wide-area damping controllers (WADCs). In our proposed method, the supervisory CA only communicates with necessary actuators to achieve the required damping performance and in case of actuator failures (e.g., due to loss of communication or scheduling), capabilities of the remaining actuators are fully used before the nominal performance is degraded. This method offers the advantages of modular design where WADC is initially designed to achieve satisfactory damping without the detailed knowledge of actuators. In the next step, CA is designed to manage actuator failures and limitations without the need to redesign the nominal WADC. The proposed approach is applied to a modified $286$-bus Western Electricity Coordinating Council (WECC) system to verify the feasibility on a complex power system. Simulation results indicate the effectiveness of the proposed method in coordinating multiple actuators and building resiliency.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Emulated Inertia and Damping of Converter-Interfaced Power Source
Authors:
Bin Wang,
Yichen Zhang,
Kai Sun,
Kevin Tomsovic
Abstract:
Converter-interfaced power sources (CIPSs), like wind turbine and energy storage, can be switched to the inertia emulation mode when the detected frequency deviation exceeds a pre-designed threshold, i.e. dead band, to support the frequency response of a power grid. This letter proposes an approach to derive the emulated inertia and damping from a CIPS based on the linearized model of the CIPS and…
▽ More
Converter-interfaced power sources (CIPSs), like wind turbine and energy storage, can be switched to the inertia emulation mode when the detected frequency deviation exceeds a pre-designed threshold, i.e. dead band, to support the frequency response of a power grid. This letter proposes an approach to derive the emulated inertia and damping from a CIPS based on the linearized model of the CIPS and the power grid, where the grid is represented by an equivalent single machine. The emulated inertia and damping can be explicitly expressed in time and turn out to be time-dependent.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
