A Network Control Theory Approach to Longitudinal Symptom Dynamics in Major Depressive Disorder
Authors:
Tim Hahn,
Hamidreza Jamalabadi,
Daniel Emden,
Janik Goltermann,
Jan Ernsting,
Nils R. Winter,
Lukas Fisch,
Ramona Leenings,
Kelvin Sarink,
Vincent Holstein,
Marius Gruber,
Dominik Grotegerd,
Susanne Meinert,
Katharina Dohm,
Elisabeth J. Leehr,
Maike Richter,
Lisa Sindermann,
Verena Enneking,
Hannah Lemke,
Stephanie Witt,
Marcella Rietschel,
Katharina Brosch,
Julia-Katharina Pfarr,
Tina Meller,
Kai Gustav Ringwald
, et al. (9 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Background: The evolution of symptoms over time is at the heart of understanding and treating mental disorders. However, a principled, quantitative framework explaining symptom dynamics remains elusive. Here, we propose a Network Control Theory of Psychopathology allowing us to formally derive a theoretical control energy which we hypothesize quantifies resistance to future symptom improvement in…
▽ More
Background: The evolution of symptoms over time is at the heart of understanding and treating mental disorders. However, a principled, quantitative framework explaining symptom dynamics remains elusive. Here, we propose a Network Control Theory of Psychopathology allowing us to formally derive a theoretical control energy which we hypothesize quantifies resistance to future symptom improvement in Major Depressive Disorder (MDD). We test this hypothesis and investigate the relation to genetic and environmental risk as well as resilience.
Methods: We modelled longitudinal symptom-network dynamics derived from N=2,059 Beck Depression Inventory measurements acquired over a median of 134 days in a sample of N=109 patients suffering from MDD. We quantified the theoretical energy required for each patient and time-point to reach a symptom-free state given individual symptom-network topology (E 0 ) and 1) tested if E 0 predicts future symptom improvement and 2) whether this relationship is moderated by Polygenic Risk Scores (PRS) of mental disorders, childhood maltreatment experience, and self-reported resilience.
Outcomes: We show that E 0 indeed predicts symptom reduction at the next measurement and reveal that this coupling between E 0 and future symptom change increases with higher genetic risk and childhood maltreatment while it decreases with resilience.
Interpretation: Our study provides a mechanistic framework capable of predicting future symptom improvement based on individual symptom-network topology and clarifies the role of genetic and environmental risk as well as resilience. Our control-theoretic framework makes testable, quantitative predictions for individual therapeutic response and provides a starting-point for the theory-driven design of personalized interventions.
Funding: German Research Foundation and Interdisciplinary Centre for Clinical Research, Münster
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
Genetic, Individual, and Familial Risk Correlates of Brain Network Controllability in Major Depressive Disorder
Authors:
Tim Hahn,
Nils R. Winter,
Jan Ernsting,
Marius Gruber,
Marco J. Mauritz,
Lukas Fisch,
Ramona Leenings,
Kelvin Sarink,
Julian Blanke,
Vincent Holstein,
Daniel Emden,
Marie Beisemann,
Nils Opel,
Dominik Grotegerd,
Susanne Meinert,
Walter Heindel,
Stephanie Witt,
Marcella Rietschel,
Markus M. Nöthen,
Andreas J. Forstner,
Tilo Kircher,
Igor Nenadic,
Andreas Jansen,
Bertram Müller-Myhsok,
Till F. M. Andlauer
, et al. (5 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Background: A therapeutic intervention in psychiatry can be viewed as an attempt to influence the brain's large-scale, dynamic network state transitions underlying cognition and behavior. Building on connectome-based graph analysis and control theory, Network Control Theory is emerging as a powerful tool to quantify network controllability - i.e., the influence of one brain region over others rega…
▽ More
Background: A therapeutic intervention in psychiatry can be viewed as an attempt to influence the brain's large-scale, dynamic network state transitions underlying cognition and behavior. Building on connectome-based graph analysis and control theory, Network Control Theory is emerging as a powerful tool to quantify network controllability - i.e., the influence of one brain region over others regarding dynamic network state transitions. If and how network controllability is related to mental health remains elusive.
Methods: From Diffusion Tensor Imaging data, we inferred structural connectivity and inferred calculated network controllability parameters to investigate their association with genetic and familial risk in patients diagnosed with major depressive disorder (MDD, n=692) and healthy controls (n=820).
Results: First, we establish that controllability measures differ between healthy controls and MDD patients while not varying with current symptom severity or remission status. Second, we show that controllability in MDD patients is associated with polygenic scores for MDD and psychiatric cross-disorder risk. Finally, we provide evidence that controllability varies with familial risk of MDD and bipolar disorder as well as with body mass index.
Conclusions: We show that network controllability is related to genetic, individual, and familial risk in MDD patients. We discuss how these insights into individual variation of network controllability may inform mechanistic models of treatment response prediction and personalized intervention-design in mental health.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
