-
A Comparative Study on Frequency-Constrained Unit Commitment Approaches in Island Power Systems
Authors:
Miad Sarvarizadeh,
Mohammad Rajabdorri,
Enrique Lobato,
Lukas Sigrist
Abstract:
The increasing penetration of renewable energy sources reduces rotating inertia and even frequency control capacity, affecting frequency stability. This challenge is significant in \gls{ips} that already suffer from low inertia and frequency control capacity. This paper presents a comparative study on different \gls{fcuc} formulations applied to \gls{ips}. Then, by considering under-frequency load…
▽ More
The increasing penetration of renewable energy sources reduces rotating inertia and even frequency control capacity, affecting frequency stability. This challenge is significant in \gls{ips} that already suffer from low inertia and frequency control capacity. This paper presents a comparative study on different \gls{fcuc} formulations applied to \gls{ips}. Then, by considering under-frequency load shedding as a significant measure of frequency stability in \gls{ips}, two indices are presented to fully compare the formulations from system benefits and computational burden perspectives. Simulations conducted on a real Spanish island show that the data-driven corrective \gls{fcuc} formulation has the most advantages among other formulations.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2025;
originally announced July 2025.
-
A Corrective Frequency-Constrained Unit Commitment with Data-driven Estimation of Optimal UFLS in Island Power Systems
Authors:
Miad Sarvarizadeh,
Lukas Sigrist,
Almudena Rouco,
Mohammad Rajabdorri,
Enrique Lobato
Abstract:
This paper presents a novel corrective \gls{fcuc} formulation for island power systems by implementing data-driven constraint learning to estimate the optimal \gls{ufls}. The Tobit model is presented to estimate the optimal amount of \gls{ufls} using the initial rate of change of frequency. The proposed formulation enables co-optimizing operation costs and \gls{ufls}. The aim is to account for opt…
▽ More
This paper presents a novel corrective \gls{fcuc} formulation for island power systems by implementing data-driven constraint learning to estimate the optimal \gls{ufls}. The Tobit model is presented to estimate the optimal amount of \gls{ufls} using the initial rate of change of frequency. The proposed formulation enables co-optimizing operation costs and \gls{ufls}. The aim is to account for optimal \gls{ufls} occurrences during operation planning, without increasing them. This would potentially reduce system operation costs by relaxing the reserve requirement constraint. The performance of the proposed formulation has been analyzed for a Spanish island power system through various simulations. Different daily demand profiles are analyzed to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed formulation. Additionally, a sensitivity analysis is conducted to demonstrate the effects of changing the cost associated with \gls{ufls}. The corrective \gls{fcuc} is shown to be capable of reducing system operation costs without jeopardizing the quality of the frequency response in terms of \gls{ufls} occurrence.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2025;
originally announced July 2025.
-
Flexible Robust Optimal Bidding of Renewable Virtual Power Plants in Sequential Markets
Authors:
Hadi Nemati,
Pedro Sánchez-Martín,
Álvaro Ortega,
Lukas Sigrist,
Enrique Lobato,
Luis Rouco
Abstract:
In this paper, a novel approach to define the optimal bidding of renewable-only virtual power plants (RVPPs) in the day-ahead, secondary reserve, and intra-day markets is proposed. To this aim, a robust optimization algorithm is developed to account for the asymmetric nature of the uncertainties that characterize the market prices, as well as the energy production of the RVPP stochastic sources an…
▽ More
In this paper, a novel approach to define the optimal bidding of renewable-only virtual power plants (RVPPs) in the day-ahead, secondary reserve, and intra-day markets is proposed. To this aim, a robust optimization algorithm is developed to account for the asymmetric nature of the uncertainties that characterize the market prices, as well as the energy production of the RVPP stochastic sources and flexible demand consumption. Simulation results show increased RVPP benefits compared to other existing solutions and demonstrate the potential of renewable sources to further increase their economic competitiveness. The simplicity of the implementation, the computational efficiency, and the flexible robustness are also verified.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Data-driven Estimation of Under Frequency Load Shedding after Outages in Small Power Systems
Authors:
Mohammad Rajabdorri,
Lukas Sigrist,
Enrique Lobato,
Matthias C. M. Troffaes,
Behzad Kazemtabrizi
Abstract:
This paper presents a data-driven methodology for estimating Under Frequency Load Shedding (UFLS) in small power systems. UFLS plays a vital role in maintaining system stability by shedding load when the frequency drops below a specified threshold following loss of generation. Using a dynamic System Frequency Response (SFR) model we generate different values of UFLS (i.e., labels) predicated on a…
▽ More
This paper presents a data-driven methodology for estimating Under Frequency Load Shedding (UFLS) in small power systems. UFLS plays a vital role in maintaining system stability by shedding load when the frequency drops below a specified threshold following loss of generation. Using a dynamic System Frequency Response (SFR) model we generate different values of UFLS (i.e., labels) predicated on a set of carefully selected operating conditions (i.e., features). Machine Learning (ML) algorithms are then applied to learn the relationship between chosen features and the UFLS labels. A novel regression tree and the Tobit model are suggested for this purpose and we show how the resulting non-linear model can be directly incorporated into a Mixed Integer Linear Programming (MILP) problem. The trained model can be used to estimate UFLS in security-constrained operational planning problems, improving frequency response, optimizing reserve allocation, and reducing costs. The methodology is applied to the La Palma island power system, demonstrating its accuracy and effectiveness. The results confirm that the amount of UFLS can be estimated with the Mean Absolute Error (MAE) as small as 0.213 MW for the whole process, with a model that is representable as a MILP for use in scheduling problems such as unit commitment among others.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2024; v1 submitted 18 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Data-Driven Continuous-Time Framework for Frequency-Constrained Unit Commitment
Authors:
Mohammad Rajabdorri,
Enrique Lobato,
Lukas Sigrist,
Jamshid Aghaei
Abstract:
The conventional approach to solving the unit commitment problem involves discrete intervals at an hourly scale, particularly when integrating frequency dynamics to formulate a frequency-constrained unit commitment. To overcome this limitation, a novel continuous-time frequency-constrained unit commitment framework is proposed in this paper. In this approach, Bernstein polynomials represent contin…
▽ More
The conventional approach to solving the unit commitment problem involves discrete intervals at an hourly scale, particularly when integrating frequency dynamics to formulate a frequency-constrained unit commitment. To overcome this limitation, a novel continuous-time frequency-constrained unit commitment framework is proposed in this paper. In this approach, Bernstein polynomials represent continuous variables in the unit commitment problem and enable the calculation of frequency response-related metrics such as the rate of change of frequency, quasi-steady-state frequency, and frequency nadir. Notably, startup and shut-down trajectories are meticulously considered, transforming the formulation into a fully continuous-time model and simplifying constraints related to variable continuity. To address the complexities associated with integrating the obtained non-linear frequency nadir constraint into a mixed-integer linear problem, an alternative data-driven frequency nadir constraint is proposed, which accurately constrains frequency nadir deviations throughout the time interval. To validate the proposed model, it is applied to the real-life network of the Spanish Island of La Palma. The results demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed formulation, indicating that the model is solved timely while mitigating the impact of intra-hour real-time power fluctuations on system frequency.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2024; v1 submitted 18 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Unit commitment with analytical underfrequency load-shedding constraints for island power systems
Authors:
Almudena Rouco,
Mohammad Rajabdorri,
Lukas Sigrist,
Enrique Lobato,
Ignacio Egido
Abstract:
This letter presents a corrective frequency-constrained UC (C-FCUC) for island power systems implementing analytical constraints on underfrequency load shedding (UFLS). Since UFLS is inevitable for sufficiently large disturbances, one can argue that less spinning reserve could be held back since UFLS takes place anyway. Congruently, the reserve criterion should consider UFLS likely to occur under…
▽ More
This letter presents a corrective frequency-constrained UC (C-FCUC) for island power systems implementing analytical constraints on underfrequency load shedding (UFLS). Since UFLS is inevitable for sufficiently large disturbances, one can argue that less spinning reserve could be held back since UFLS takes place anyway. Congruently, the reserve criterion should consider UFLS likely to occur under disturbances. The C-FCUC can be converted into a preventive frequency-constrained UC (P-FCUC) or the standard unit commitment (UC) and the C-FCUC is thus a generalization. The proposed formulation is successfully applied to a Spanish island power system.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Inclusion of Frequency Nadir constraint in the Unit Commitment Problem of Small Power Systems Using Machine Learning
Authors:
Mohammad Rajabdorri,
Behzad Kazemtabrizi,
Matthias Troffaes,
Lukas Sigrist,
Enrique Lobato
Abstract:
As the intention is to reduce the amount of thermal generation and to increase the share of clean energy, power systems are increasingly becoming susceptible to frequency instability after outages due to reduced levels of inertia. To address this issue frequency constraints are being included in the scheduling process, which ensure a tolerable frequency deviation in case of any contingencies. In t…
▽ More
As the intention is to reduce the amount of thermal generation and to increase the share of clean energy, power systems are increasingly becoming susceptible to frequency instability after outages due to reduced levels of inertia. To address this issue frequency constraints are being included in the scheduling process, which ensure a tolerable frequency deviation in case of any contingencies. In this paper, a method is proposed to integrate the non-linear frequency nadir constraint into the unit commitment problem, using machine learning. First a synthetic training dataset is generated. Then two of the available classic machine learning methods, namely logistic regression and support vector machine, are proposed to predict the frequency nadir. To be able to compare the machine learning methods to traditional frequency constrained unit commitment approaches, simulations on the power system of La Palma island are carried out for both proposed methods as well as an analytical linearized formulation of the frequency nadir. Our results show that the unit commitment problem with a machine learning based frequency nadir constraint is solved considerably faster than with the analytical formulation, while still achieving an acceptable frequency response quality after outages.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2024; v1 submitted 4 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Robust Frequency Constrained UC Using Data Driven Logistic Regression for Island Power Systems
Authors:
Mohammad Rajabdorri,
Enrique Lobato,
Lukas Sigrist
Abstract:
In the current practice of short-term power scheduling, online power reserves are used to address generation mismatches and contingencies. Neither online inertia nor the speed of the committed units is considered in the scheduling process. With the increasing injection of uncertain renewable energy sources, this practice is starting to fall short especially in island power systems, where the prima…
▽ More
In the current practice of short-term power scheduling, online power reserves are used to address generation mismatches and contingencies. Neither online inertia nor the speed of the committed units is considered in the scheduling process. With the increasing injection of uncertain renewable energy sources, this practice is starting to fall short especially in island power systems, where the primary frequency response is already scarce, and any contingency leads to potentially poor frequency response. This paper introduces a data driven linear constraint to improve the post-fault frequency quality in island power systems. A coherent initial data-set is obtained by simulating the system frequency response of single outages. Then logistic regression is employed as a predictive analytic procedure to differentiate the acceptable and unacceptable incidents. To compare the conventional methods with the proposed approach and also to handle the uncertain nature of renewable energy generation, an adaptive robust unit commitment formulation is utilized. Results for the island power system of La Palma show that depending on the chosen cut-point on the logistic regression estimation the proposed method can improve the frequency response quality of the system while reducing the operation costs.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2022; v1 submitted 17 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Modeling Demand Flexibility of RES-based Virtual Power Plants
Authors:
Oluwaseun Oladimeji,
Alvaro Ortega,
Lukas Sigrist,
Pedro Sanchez-Martin,
Enrique Lobato,
Luis Rouco
Abstract:
In this paper, an approach to evaluate the benefits of demand flexibility for Virtual Power Plants (VPPs) is presented. The flexible demands chosen in this study are part of a renewable energy source-based VPP that participates in Day-Ahead Market (DAM) and Intra-Day Market (IDM) and has dispatchable and non-dispatchable assets. A demand model with bi-level flexibility is proposed: the first level…
▽ More
In this paper, an approach to evaluate the benefits of demand flexibility for Virtual Power Plants (VPPs) is presented. The flexible demands chosen in this study are part of a renewable energy source-based VPP that participates in Day-Ahead Market (DAM) and Intra-Day Market (IDM) and has dispatchable and non-dispatchable assets. A demand model with bi-level flexibility is proposed: the first level is associated with DAM, whereas the second level is related to IDM sessions. Simulations are carried out considering a 12-node network to ascertain the eventual impacts of modeling demand flexibility on VPP operation. The market structure considered in the case study resembles the different trading floors in the Spanish electricity market. Results obtained show that the proposed demand flexibility scheme increases the overall profit of the VPP, as well as the revenues of the demand owners without disrupting consumers' comfort.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Optimal Participation of Heterogeneous, RES-based Virtual Power Plants in Energy Markets
Authors:
Oluwaseun Oladimeji,
Alvaro Ortega,
Lukas Sigrist,
Luis Rouco,
Pedro Sanchez-Martin,
Enrique Lobato
Abstract:
In this work, we present a detailed model of a Renewable Energy Source (RES)-based Virtual Power Plant (VPP) that participates in Day-Ahead Market (DAM) and Intra-Day Market (IDM) with dispatchable and non-dispatchable RESs and flexible demand assets. We propose a demand model with bi-level flexibility which are associated with the market sessions plus an improved solar thermal plant model with pi…
▽ More
In this work, we present a detailed model of a Renewable Energy Source (RES)-based Virtual Power Plant (VPP) that participates in Day-Ahead Market (DAM) and Intra-Day Market (IDM) with dispatchable and non-dispatchable RESs and flexible demand assets. We propose a demand model with bi-level flexibility which are associated with the market sessions plus an improved solar thermal plant model with piece-wise linear formulation of efficiency. A network-constrained unit commitment model is used by the VPP to submit DAM auctions and consequently participates in IDM to correct for deviations. Finally, we validate our model by assessing its operation on different weather conditions of uncertainty.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.