-
Closed-Loop Sensitivity Identification for Cross-Directional Systems
Authors:
Callum Umana Stuart,
Idris Kempf
Abstract:
At Diamond Light Source, the UK's national synchrotron facility, electron beam disturbances are attenuated by the fast orbit feedback (FOFB), which controls a cross-directional (CD) system with hundreds of inputs and outputs. Due to the inability to measure the disturbances in real-time, the closed-loop sensitivity of the FOFB can only be evaluated indirectly, making it difficult to compare FOFB a…
▽ More
At Diamond Light Source, the UK's national synchrotron facility, electron beam disturbances are attenuated by the fast orbit feedback (FOFB), which controls a cross-directional (CD) system with hundreds of inputs and outputs. Due to the inability to measure the disturbances in real-time, the closed-loop sensitivity of the FOFB can only be evaluated indirectly, making it difficult to compare FOFB algorithms and detect faults. Existing methods rely on comparing open-loop with closed-loop measurements, but they are prone to instabilities and actuator saturation because of the system's strong directionality. Here, we introduce a reference signal to estimate the complementary sensitivity in closed loop. By decoupling the system into sets of single-input, single-output (SISO) systems, the reference signal is designed mode-by-mode, accommodating the system's strong directionality. Additionally, a lower bound on the reference amplitude is derived to limit the estimation error in the presence of disturbances and measurement noise. This method enables the use of SISO system identification techniques, making it suitable for large-scale systems. It not only facilitates performance estimation of ill-conditioned CD systems in closed-loop but also provides a signal for fault detection. The potential applications of this approach extend to other CD systems, such as papermaking, steel rolling, or battery manufacturing processes.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2024; v1 submitted 2 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Control of Cross-Directional Systems using the Generalised Singular Value Decomposition
Authors:
Idris Kempf,
Paul J. Goulart,
Stephen Duncan
Abstract:
Diamond Light Source produces synchrotron radiation by accelerating electrons to relativistic speeds. In order to maximise the intensity of the radiation, vibrations of the electron beam are attenuated by a multi-input multi-output (MIMO) control system actuating hundreds of magnets at kilohertz rates. For future accelerator configurations, in which two separate arrays of magnets with different ba…
▽ More
Diamond Light Source produces synchrotron radiation by accelerating electrons to relativistic speeds. In order to maximise the intensity of the radiation, vibrations of the electron beam are attenuated by a multi-input multi-output (MIMO) control system actuating hundreds of magnets at kilohertz rates. For future accelerator configurations, in which two separate arrays of magnets with different bandwidths are used in combination, standard accelerator control design methods based on the singular value decomposition (SVD) of the system gain matrix are not suitable. We therefore propose to use the generalised singular value decomposition (GSVD) to decouple a two-array cross-directional (CD) system into sets of two-input single-output (TISO) and single-input single-output (SISO) systems. We demonstrate that the two-array decomposition is linked to a single-array system, which is used to accommodate ill-conditioned systems and compensate for the non-orthogonality of the GSVD. The GSVD-based design is implemented and validated through real-world experiments at Diamond. Our approach provides a natural extension of single-array methods and has potential application in other CD systems, including paper making, steel rolling or battery manufacturing processes.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Control of Cross-Directional Systems with Approximate Symmetries
Authors:
Idris Kempf,
Paul Goulart,
Stephen Duncan
Abstract:
Structural symmetries of linear dynamical systems can be exploited for decoupling the dynamics and reducing the computational complexity of the controller implementation. However, in practical applications, inexact structural symmetries undermine the ability to decouple the system, resulting in the loss of any potential complexity reduction. To address this, we propose substituting an approximatio…
▽ More
Structural symmetries of linear dynamical systems can be exploited for decoupling the dynamics and reducing the computational complexity of the controller implementation. However, in practical applications, inexact structural symmetries undermine the ability to decouple the system, resulting in the loss of any potential complexity reduction. To address this, we propose substituting an approximation with exact structural symmetries for the original system model, thereby introducing an approximation error. We focus on internal model controllers for cross-directional systems encountered in large-scale and high-speed control problems of synchrotrons or the process industry and characterise the stability, performance, and robustness properties of the resulting closed loop. While existing approaches replace the original system model with one that minimises the Frobenius norm of the approximation error, we show that this can lead to instability or poor performance. Instead, we propose approximations that are obtained from semidefinite programming problems. We show that our proposed approximations can yield stable systems even when the Frobenius norm approximation does not. The paper concludes with numerical examples and a case study of a synchrotron light source with inexact structural symmetries. Exploiting structural symmetries in large-scale and high-speed systems enables faster sampling times and the use of more advanced control techniques, even when the symmetries are approximate.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Model Predictive Control for Electron Beam Stabilization in a Synchrotron
Authors:
Idris Kempf,
Paul J. Goulart,
Stephen R. Duncan
Abstract:
Electron beam stabilization in a synchrotron is a disturbance rejection problem, with hundreds of inputs and outputs, that is sampled at frequencies higher than $10$ kHz. In this feasibility study, we focus on the practical issues of an efficient implementation of model predictive control (MPC) for the heavily ill-conditioned plant of the electron beam stabilization problem. To obtain a tractable…
▽ More
Electron beam stabilization in a synchrotron is a disturbance rejection problem, with hundreds of inputs and outputs, that is sampled at frequencies higher than $10$ kHz. In this feasibility study, we focus on the practical issues of an efficient implementation of model predictive control (MPC) for the heavily ill-conditioned plant of the electron beam stabilization problem. To obtain a tractable control problem that can be solved using only a few iterations of the fast gradient method, we investigate different methods for preconditioning the resulting optimization problem and relate our findings to standard regularization techniques from cross-directional control. We summarize the single- and multi-core implementations of our control algorithm on a digital signal processor (DSP), and show that MPC can be executed at the rate required for synchrotron control. MPC overcomes various problems of standard electron beam stabilization techniques, and the successful implementation can increase the stability of photon beams in synchrotron light sources.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Multi-Array Electron Beam Stabilization using Block-Circulant Transformation and Generalized Singular Value Decomposition
Authors:
Idris Kempf,
Stephen R. Duncan,
Paul J. Goulart,
Guenther Rehm
Abstract:
We introduce a novel structured controller design for the electron beam stabilization problem of the UK's national synchrotron light source. Because changes to the synchrotron will not allow the application of existing control approaches, we develop a novel method to diagonalize the multi-input multi-output (MIMO) system. A generalized singular value decomposition (GSVD) is used to simultaneously…
▽ More
We introduce a novel structured controller design for the electron beam stabilization problem of the UK's national synchrotron light source. Because changes to the synchrotron will not allow the application of existing control approaches, we develop a novel method to diagonalize the multi-input multi-output (MIMO) system. A generalized singular value decomposition (GSVD) is used to simultaneously diagonalize the actuator response matrices, which is applicable to an arbitrary number of actuator dynamics in a cross-directional setting. The resulting decoupled systems are regulated using mid-ranged control and the controller gains derived as a function of the generalized singular values. In addition, we exploit the inherent block-circulant symmetry of the system. The performance of our controller is demonstrated using simulations that involve machine data.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Symmetry Exploitation in Orbit Feedback Systems of Synchrotron Storage Rings
Authors:
Idris Kempf,
Paul J. Goulart,
Stephen R. Duncan,
Guenther Rehm
Abstract:
Structural symmetries in the storage ring of synchrotrons are intentionally created during the design phase of the magnetic lattices, but they are not considered in the design of control algorithms that stabilize the beam of accelerated particles. The choice of control algorithm, however, is limited by the speed requirements of the synchrotron. Standard control algorithms for synchrotrons are base…
▽ More
Structural symmetries in the storage ring of synchrotrons are intentionally created during the design phase of the magnetic lattices, but they are not considered in the design of control algorithms that stabilize the beam of accelerated particles. The choice of control algorithm, however, is limited by the speed requirements of the synchrotron. Standard control algorithms for synchrotrons are based on a singular value decomposition (SVD) of the orbit response matrix. SVD controllers neither exploit the structural symmetries nor exhibit any speed advantages. Based on the periodicity and the reflection properties of the betatron function, we show that these structural symmetries are inherited by the orbit response matrix. We show that the resulting block-circulant and centrosymmetric properties of the matrix can be used for different computationally efficient decompositions of the controller. We also address the case of broken symmetry due to odd placements of magnets and monitors. Our efficient decomposition could enable the use of more advanced control techniques for synchrotrons, such as control algorithms that require real-time optimization. These advanced control techniques could in turn increase the quality of research in synchrotron light sources.
△ Less
Submitted 31 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Fast Gradient Method for Model Predictive Control with Input Rate and Amplitude Constraints
Authors:
Idris Kempf,
Paul Goulart,
Stephen Duncan
Abstract:
This paper is concerned with the computing efficiency of model predictive control (MPC) problems for dynamical systems with both rate and amplitude constraints on the inputs. Instead of augmenting the decision variables of the underlying finite-horizon optimal control problem to accommodate the input rate constraints, we propose to solve this problem using the fast gradient method (FGM), where the…
▽ More
This paper is concerned with the computing efficiency of model predictive control (MPC) problems for dynamical systems with both rate and amplitude constraints on the inputs. Instead of augmenting the decision variables of the underlying finite-horizon optimal control problem to accommodate the input rate constraints, we propose to solve this problem using the fast gradient method (FGM), where the projection step is solved using Dykstra's algorithm. We show that, relative to the Alternating Direction of Method Multipliers (ADMM), this approach greatly reduces the computation time while halving the memory usage. Our algorithm is implemented in C and its performance demonstrated using several examples.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
ADMM for Block Circulant Model Predictive Control
Authors:
Idris Kempf,
Paul J. Goulart,
Stephen Duncan
Abstract:
This paper deals with model predictive control problems for large scale dynamical systems with cyclic symmetry. Based on the properties of block circulant matrices, we introduce a complex-valued coordinate transformation that block diagonalizes and truncates the original finite-horizon optimal control problem. Using this coordinate transformation, we develop a modified alternating direction method…
▽ More
This paper deals with model predictive control problems for large scale dynamical systems with cyclic symmetry. Based on the properties of block circulant matrices, we introduce a complex-valued coordinate transformation that block diagonalizes and truncates the original finite-horizon optimal control problem. Using this coordinate transformation, we develop a modified alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM) algorithm for general constrained quadratic programs with block circulant blocks. We test our modified algorithm in two different simulated examples and show that our coordinate transformation significantly increases the computation speed.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
