-
Discovery and Characterization of Cross-Area and Intra-Area SSOs Sensitive to Delay in Droop Control of Grid-Forming Converters
Authors:
Lilan Karunaratne,
Nilanjan Ray Chaudhuri,
Amirthagunaraj Yogarathnam,
Meng Yue
Abstract:
Subsynchronous oscillations (SSOs) involving grid-forming converters (GFCs) are in a less familiar territory of power system dynamics. This letter reports a new phenomenon namely cross-area SSOs in grids with 100% droop-controlled GFC-based renewable penetration, which was discovered during our study on evaluating the adequacy of quasistationary phasor calculus (QPC) and space phasor calculus (SPC…
▽ More
Subsynchronous oscillations (SSOs) involving grid-forming converters (GFCs) are in a less familiar territory of power system dynamics. This letter reports a new phenomenon namely cross-area SSOs in grids with 100% droop-controlled GFC-based renewable penetration, which was discovered during our study on evaluating the adequacy of quasistationary phasor calculus (QPC) and space phasor calculus (SPC)-based models in capturing SSOs. We present frequency-domain characterization of such oscillatory modes in addition to intra-area SSOs in grids involving GFCs and study the impact of a delay in power-frequency droop feedback loop in regards to their stability. Electromagnetic transient (EMT) simulations validate our findings.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
A Case Study on Modeling Adequacy of a Grid with Subsynchronous Oscillations Involving IBRs
Authors:
Lilan Karunaratne,
Nilanjan Ray Chaudhuri,
Amirthagunaraj Yogarathnam,
Meng Yue
Abstract:
A case study on modeling adequacy of a grid in presence of renewable resources based on grid-forming converters (GFCs) is the subject matter of this paper. For this purpose, a 4-machine 11-bus IEEE benchmark model is modified by considering GFCs replacing synchronous generators that led to unstable subsynchronous oscillations (SSOs). We aim to: (a) understand if transmission network dynamics shoul…
▽ More
A case study on modeling adequacy of a grid in presence of renewable resources based on grid-forming converters (GFCs) is the subject matter of this paper. For this purpose, a 4-machine 11-bus IEEE benchmark model is modified by considering GFCs replacing synchronous generators that led to unstable subsynchronous oscillations (SSOs). We aim to: (a) understand if transmission network dynamics should be considered in such cases, (b) revisit the space-phasor-calculus (SPC) in d-q frame under balanced condition that captures such phenomena and lends itself to eigenvalue analysis, and (c) emphasize limitations of such models while underscoring their importance for large-scale power system simulations. Time-domain and frequency-domain results from SPC and quasistationary phasor calculus (QPC) models are compared with electromagnetic transient (EMT)-based simulations. It is shown that models with transmission line dynamics in SPC framework can capture the SSO mode while QPC models that neglect these dynamics fail to do so.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
An Approach to Evaluate Modeling Adequacy for Small-Signal Stability Analysis of IBR-related SSOs in Multimachine Systems
Authors:
Lilan Karunaratne,
Nilanjan Ray Chaudhuri,
Amirthagunaraj Yogarathnam,
Meng Yue
Abstract:
Time-varying phasor-based analysis of subsynchronous oscillations (SSOs) involving grid-following converters (GFLCs) and its benchmarking with electromagnetic transient (EMT) models have so far been restricted to highly simplified grid models with constant voltage sources behind series R-L circuits. In this paper, modeling adequacy of bulk power systems with synchronous generators (SGs), transmiss…
▽ More
Time-varying phasor-based analysis of subsynchronous oscillations (SSOs) involving grid-following converters (GFLCs) and its benchmarking with electromagnetic transient (EMT) models have so far been restricted to highly simplified grid models with constant voltage sources behind series R-L circuits. In this paper, modeling adequacy of bulk power systems with synchronous generators (SGs), transmission systems, loads, and GFLCs are considered. To this end, we revisit the notions of time-varying phasor calculus, highlighting the distinction between space-phasor-calculus (SPC) and two often interchangeably used frameworks namely baseband-abc and generalized averaging. We present the models of grids in SPC framework that include transmission line dynamics, load dynamics, and SG stator transients. Next, we propose a generic approach to study modeling adequacy in small-signal sense by (a) identifying critical modes through eigenvalue and singular value analysis followed by (b) using weighted maximum singular value error magnitudes as metrics, and (c) further cross-validation. Using a modified 4-machine IEEE benchmark model with up to 3 GFLCs we show that SPC framework can be used for analysis of SSOs. Further, we consider the quasistationary phasor calculus (QPC) framework that neglects transmission line, load, and SG stator dynamics to show its adequacy in SSO modeling and analysis. Time-domain and frequency-domain results with EMT models are also presented.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2024; v1 submitted 12 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
