Optimal Intermittent Particle Filter
Authors:
Antoine Aspeel,
Amaury Gouverneur,
Raphaël M. Jungers,
Benoit Macq
Abstract:
The problem of the optimal allocation (in the expected mean square error sense) of a measurement budget for particle filtering is addressed. We propose three different optimal intermittent filters, whose optimality criteria depend on the information available at the time of decision making. For the first, the stochastic program filter, the measurement times are given by a policy that determines wh…
▽ More
The problem of the optimal allocation (in the expected mean square error sense) of a measurement budget for particle filtering is addressed. We propose three different optimal intermittent filters, whose optimality criteria depend on the information available at the time of decision making. For the first, the stochastic program filter, the measurement times are given by a policy that determines whether a measurement should be taken based on the measurements already acquired. The second, called the offline filter, determines all measurement times at once by solving a combinatorial optimization program before any measurement acquisition. For the third one, which we call online filter, each time a new measurement is received, the next measurement time is recomputed to take all the information that is then available into account. We prove that in terms of expected mean square error, the stochastic program filter outperforms the online filter, which itself outperforms the offline filter. However, these filters are generally intractable. For this reason, the filter estimate is approximated by a particle filter. Moreover, the mean square error is approximated using a Monte-Carlo approach, and different optimization algorithms are compared to approximately solve the combinatorial programs (a random trial algorithm, greedy forward and backward algorithms, a simulated annealing algorithm, and a genetic algorithm). Finally, the performance of the proposed methods is illustrated on two examples: a tumor motion model and a common benchmark for particle filtering.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
Optimal measurement budget allocation for particle filtering
Authors:
Antoine Aspeel,
Amaury Gouverneur,
Raphaël M. Jungers,
Benoît Macq
Abstract:
Particle filtering is a powerful tool for target tracking. When the budget for observations is restricted, it is necessary to reduce the measurements to a limited amount of samples carefully selected. A discrete stochastic nonlinear dynamical system is studied over a finite time horizon. The problem of selecting the optimal measurement times for particle filtering is formalized as a combinatorial…
▽ More
Particle filtering is a powerful tool for target tracking. When the budget for observations is restricted, it is necessary to reduce the measurements to a limited amount of samples carefully selected. A discrete stochastic nonlinear dynamical system is studied over a finite time horizon. The problem of selecting the optimal measurement times for particle filtering is formalized as a combinatorial optimization problem. We propose an approximated solution based on the nesting of a genetic algorithm, a Monte Carlo algorithm and a particle filter. Firstly, an example demonstrates that the genetic algorithm outperforms a random trial optimization. Then, the interest of non-regular measurements versus measurements performed at regular time intervals is illustrated and the efficiency of our proposed solution is quantified: better filtering performances are obtained in 87.5% of the cases and on average, the relative improvement is 27.7%.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
