-
Benchmarking Neural Speech Codec Intelligibility with SITool
Authors:
Anna Leschanowsky,
Kishor Kayyar Lakshminarayana,
Anjana Rajasekhar,
Lyonel Behringer,
Ibrahim Kilinc,
Guillaume Fuchs,
Emanuël A. P. Habets
Abstract:
Speech intelligibility assessment is essential for evaluating neural speech codecs, yet most evaluation efforts focus on overall quality rather than intelligibility. Only a few publicly available tools exist for conducting standardized intelligibility tests, like the Diagnostic Rhyme Test (DRT) and Modified Rhyme Test (MRT). We introduce the Speech Intelligibility Toolkit for Subjective Evaluation…
▽ More
Speech intelligibility assessment is essential for evaluating neural speech codecs, yet most evaluation efforts focus on overall quality rather than intelligibility. Only a few publicly available tools exist for conducting standardized intelligibility tests, like the Diagnostic Rhyme Test (DRT) and Modified Rhyme Test (MRT). We introduce the Speech Intelligibility Toolkit for Subjective Evaluation (SITool), a Flask-based web application for conducting DRT and MRT in laboratory and crowdsourcing settings. We use SITool to benchmark 13 neural and traditional speech codecs, analyzing phoneme-level degradations and comparing subjective DRT results with objective intelligibility metrics. Our findings show that, while neural speech codecs can outperform traditional ones in subjective intelligibility, only STOI and ESTOI - not WER - significantly correlate with subjective results, although they struggle to capture gender and wordlist-specific variations observed in subjective evaluations.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
UBGAN: Enhancing Coded Speech with Blind and Guided Bandwidth Extension
Authors:
Kishan Gupta,
Srikanth Korse,
Andreas Brendel,
Nicola Pia,
Guillaume Fuchs
Abstract:
In practical application of speech codecs, a multitude of factors such as the quality of the radio connection, limiting hardware or required user experience necessitate trade-offs between achievable perceptual quality, engendered bitrate and computational complexity. Most conventional and neural speech codecs operate on wideband (WB) speech signals to achieve this compromise. To further enhance th…
▽ More
In practical application of speech codecs, a multitude of factors such as the quality of the radio connection, limiting hardware or required user experience necessitate trade-offs between achievable perceptual quality, engendered bitrate and computational complexity. Most conventional and neural speech codecs operate on wideband (WB) speech signals to achieve this compromise. To further enhance the perceptual quality of coded speech, bandwidth extension (BWE) of the transmitted speech is an attractive and popular technique in conventional speech coding. In contrast, neural speech codecs are typically trained end-to-end to a specific set of requirements and are often not easily adaptable. In particular, they are typically trained to operate at a single fixed sampling rate. With the Universal Bandwidth Extension Generative Adversarial Network (UBGAN), we propose a modular and lightweight GAN-based solution that increases the operational flexibility of a wide range of conventional and neural codecs. Our model operates in the subband domain and extends the bandwidth of WB signals from 8 kHz to 16 kHz, resulting in super-wideband (SWB) signals. We further introduce two variants, guided-UBGAN and blind-UBGAN, where the guided version transmits quantized learned representation as a side information at a very low bitrate additional to the bitrate of the codec, while blind-BWE operates without such side-information. Our subjective assessments demonstrate the advantage of UBGAN applied to WB codecs and highlight the generalization capacity of our proposed method across multiple codecs and bitrates.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
A first-order DirAC-based parametric Ambisonic coder for immersive communications
Authors:
Guillaume Fuchs,
Florin Ghido,
Dominik Weckbecker,
Oliver Thiergart
Abstract:
Directional Audio Coding (DirAC) is a proven method for parametrically representing a 3D audio scene in B-format and is capable of reproducing it on arbitrary loudspeaker layouts. Although such a method seems well suited for low bitrate Ambisonic transmission, little work has been done on the feasibility of building a real system upon it. In this paper, we present a DirAC-based coding for Higher-O…
▽ More
Directional Audio Coding (DirAC) is a proven method for parametrically representing a 3D audio scene in B-format and is capable of reproducing it on arbitrary loudspeaker layouts. Although such a method seems well suited for low bitrate Ambisonic transmission, little work has been done on the feasibility of building a real system upon it. In this paper, we present a DirAC-based coding for Higher-Order Ambisonics (HOA), developed as part of a standardisation effort to extend the 3GPP EVS codec to immersive communications. Starting from the first-order DirAC model, we show how to reduce algorithmic delay, the bitrate required for the parameters and complexity by bringing the full synthesis in the spherical harmonic domain. The evaluation of the proposed technique for coding 3\textsuperscript{rd} order Ambisonics at bitrates from 32 to 128 kbps shows the relevance of the parametric approach compared with existing solutions.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
On Improving Error Resilience of Neural End-to-End Speech Coders
Authors:
Kishan Gupta,
Nicola Pia,
Srikanth Korse,
Andreas Brendel,
Guillaume Fuchs,
Markus Multrus
Abstract:
Error resilient tools like Packet Loss Concealment (PLC) and Forward Error Correction (FEC) are essential to maintain a reliable speech communication for applications like Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP), where packets are frequently delayed and lost. In recent times, end-to-end neural speech codecs have seen a significant rise, due to their ability to transmit speech signal at low bitrates bu…
▽ More
Error resilient tools like Packet Loss Concealment (PLC) and Forward Error Correction (FEC) are essential to maintain a reliable speech communication for applications like Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP), where packets are frequently delayed and lost. In recent times, end-to-end neural speech codecs have seen a significant rise, due to their ability to transmit speech signal at low bitrates but few considerations were made about their error resilience in a real system. Recently introduced Neural End-to-End Speech Codec (NESC) can reproduce high quality natural speech at low bitrates. We extend its robustness to packet losses by adding a low complexity network to predict the codebook indices in latent space. Furthermore, we propose a method to add an in-band FEC at an additional bitrate of 0.8 kbps. Both subjective and objective assessment indicate the effectiveness of proposed methods, and demonstrate that coupling PLC and FEC provide significant robustness against packet losses.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Neural Speech Coding for Real-time Communications using Constant Bitrate Scalar Quantization
Authors:
Andreas Brendel,
Nicola Pia,
Kishan Gupta,
Lyonel Behringer,
Guillaume Fuchs,
Markus Multrus
Abstract:
Neural audio coding has emerged as a vivid research direction by promising good audio quality at very low bitrates unachievable by classical coding techniques. Here, end-to-end trainable autoencoder-like models represent the state of the art, where a discrete representation in the bottleneck of the autoencoder is learned. This allows for efficient transmission of the input audio signal. The learne…
▽ More
Neural audio coding has emerged as a vivid research direction by promising good audio quality at very low bitrates unachievable by classical coding techniques. Here, end-to-end trainable autoencoder-like models represent the state of the art, where a discrete representation in the bottleneck of the autoencoder is learned. This allows for efficient transmission of the input audio signal. The learned discrete representation of neural codecs is typically generated by applying a quantizer to the output of the neural encoder. In almost all state-of-the-art neural audio coding approaches, this quantizer is realized as a Vector Quantizer (VQ) and a lot of effort has been spent to alleviate drawbacks of this quantization technique when used together with a neural audio coder. In this paper, we propose and analyze simple alternatives to VQ, which are based on projected Scalar Quantization (SQ). These quantization techniques do not need any additional losses, scheduling parameters or codebook storage thereby simplifying the training of neural audio codecs. For real-time speech communication applications, these neural codecs are required to operate at low complexity, low latency and at low bitrates. We address those challenges by proposing a new causal network architecture that is based on SQ and a Short-Time Fourier Transform (STFT) representation. The proposed method performs particularly well in the very low complexity and low bitrate regime.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2024; v1 submitted 14 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
NESC: Robust Neural End-2-End Speech Coding with GANs
Authors:
Nicola Pia,
Kishan Gupta,
Srikanth Korse,
Markus Multrus,
Guillaume Fuchs
Abstract:
Neural networks have proven to be a formidable tool to tackle the problem of speech coding at very low bit rates. However, the design of a neural coder that can be operated robustly under real-world conditions remains a major challenge. Therefore, we present Neural End-2-End Speech Codec (NESC) a robust, scalable end-to-end neural speech codec for high-quality wideband speech coding at 3 kbps. The…
▽ More
Neural networks have proven to be a formidable tool to tackle the problem of speech coding at very low bit rates. However, the design of a neural coder that can be operated robustly under real-world conditions remains a major challenge. Therefore, we present Neural End-2-End Speech Codec (NESC) a robust, scalable end-to-end neural speech codec for high-quality wideband speech coding at 3 kbps. The encoder uses a new architecture configuration, which relies on our proposed Dual-PathConvRNN (DPCRNN) layer, while the decoder architecture is based on our previous work Streamwise-StyleMelGAN. Our subjective listening tests on clean and noisy speech show that NESC is particularly robust to unseen conditions and signal perturbations.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
PostGAN: A GAN-Based Post-Processor to Enhance the Quality of Coded Speech
Authors:
Srikanth Korse,
Nicola Pia,
Kishan Gupta,
Guillaume Fuchs
Abstract:
The quality of speech coded by transform coding is affected by various artefacts especially when bitrates to quantize the frequency components become too low. In order to mitigate these coding artefacts and enhance the quality of coded speech, a post-processor that relies on a-priori information transmitted from the encoder is traditionally employed at the decoder side. In recent years, several da…
▽ More
The quality of speech coded by transform coding is affected by various artefacts especially when bitrates to quantize the frequency components become too low. In order to mitigate these coding artefacts and enhance the quality of coded speech, a post-processor that relies on a-priori information transmitted from the encoder is traditionally employed at the decoder side. In recent years, several data-driven post-postprocessors have been proposed which were shown to outperform traditional approaches. In this paper, we propose PostGAN, a GAN-based neural post-processor that operates in the sub-band domain and relies on the U-Net architecture and a learned affine transform. It has been tested on the recently standardized low-complexity, low-delay bluetooth codec (LC3) for wideband speech at the lowest bitrate (16 kbit/s). Subjective evaluations and objective scores show that the newly introduced post-processor surpasses previously published methods and can improve the quality of coded speech by around 20 MUSHRA points.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
A DNN Based Post-Filter to Enhance the Quality of Coded Speech in MDCT Domain
Authors:
Kishan Gupta,
Srikanth Korse,
Bernd Edler,
Guillaume Fuchs
Abstract:
Frequency domain processing, and in particular the use of Modified Discrete Cosine Transform (MDCT), is the most widespread approach to audio coding. However, at low bitrates, audio quality, especially for speech, degrades drastically due to the lack of available bits to directly code the transform coefficients. Traditionally, post-filtering has been used to mitigate artefacts in the coded speech…
▽ More
Frequency domain processing, and in particular the use of Modified Discrete Cosine Transform (MDCT), is the most widespread approach to audio coding. However, at low bitrates, audio quality, especially for speech, degrades drastically due to the lack of available bits to directly code the transform coefficients. Traditionally, post-filtering has been used to mitigate artefacts in the coded speech by exploiting a-priori information of the source and extra transmitted parameters. Recently, data-driven post-filters have shown better results, but at the cost of significant additional complexity and delay. In this work, we propose a mask-based post-filter operating directly in MDCT domain of the codec, inducing no extra delay. The real-valued mask is applied to the quantized MDCT coefficients and is estimated from a relatively lightweight convolutional encoder-decoder network. Our solution is tested on the recently standardized low-delay, low-complexity codec (LC3) at lowest possible bitrate of 16 kbps. Objective and subjective assessments clearly show the advantage of this approach over the conventional post-filter, with an average improvement of 10 MUSHRA points over the LC3 coded speech.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
A Streamwise GAN Vocoder for Wideband Speech Coding at Very Low Bit Rate
Authors:
Ahmed Mustafa,
Jan Büthe,
Srikanth Korse,
Kishan Gupta,
Guillaume Fuchs,
Nicola Pia
Abstract:
Recently, GAN vocoders have seen rapid progress in speech synthesis, starting to outperform autoregressive models in perceptual quality with much higher generation speed. However, autoregressive vocoders are still the common choice for neural generation of speech signals coded at very low bit rates. In this paper, we present a GAN vocoder which is able to generate wideband speech waveforms from pa…
▽ More
Recently, GAN vocoders have seen rapid progress in speech synthesis, starting to outperform autoregressive models in perceptual quality with much higher generation speed. However, autoregressive vocoders are still the common choice for neural generation of speech signals coded at very low bit rates. In this paper, we present a GAN vocoder which is able to generate wideband speech waveforms from parameters coded at 1.6 kbit/s. The proposed model is a modified version of the StyleMelGAN vocoder that can run in frame-by-frame manner, making it suitable for streaming applications. The experimental results show that the proposed model significantly outperforms prior autoregressive vocoders like LPCNet for very low bit rate speech coding, with computational complexity of about 5 GMACs, providing a new state of the art in this domain. Moreover, this streamwise adversarial vocoder delivers quality competitive to advanced speech codecs such as EVS at 5.9 kbit/s on clean speech, which motivates further usage of feed-forward fully-convolutional models for low bit rate speech coding.
△ Less
Submitted 9 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
StyleMelGAN: An Efficient High-Fidelity Adversarial Vocoder with Temporal Adaptive Normalization
Authors:
Ahmed Mustafa,
Nicola Pia,
Guillaume Fuchs
Abstract:
In recent years, neural vocoders have surpassed classical speech generation approaches in naturalness and perceptual quality of the synthesized speech. Computationally heavy models like WaveNet and WaveGlow achieve best results, while lightweight GAN models, e.g. MelGAN and Parallel WaveGAN, remain inferior in terms of perceptual quality. We therefore propose StyleMelGAN, a lightweight neural voco…
▽ More
In recent years, neural vocoders have surpassed classical speech generation approaches in naturalness and perceptual quality of the synthesized speech. Computationally heavy models like WaveNet and WaveGlow achieve best results, while lightweight GAN models, e.g. MelGAN and Parallel WaveGAN, remain inferior in terms of perceptual quality. We therefore propose StyleMelGAN, a lightweight neural vocoder allowing synthesis of high-fidelity speech with low computational complexity. StyleMelGAN employs temporal adaptive normalization to style a low-dimensional noise vector with the acoustic features of the target speech. For efficient training, multiple random-window discriminators adversarially evaluate the speech signal analyzed by a filter bank, with regularization provided by a multi-scale spectral reconstruction loss. The highly parallelizable speech generation is several times faster than real-time on CPUs and GPUs. MUSHRA and P.800 listening tests show that StyleMelGAN outperforms prior neural vocoders in copy-synthesis and Text-to-Speech scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2021; v1 submitted 3 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Enhancement Of Coded Speech Using a Mask-Based Post-Filter
Authors:
Srikanth Korse,
Kishan Gupta,
Guillaume Fuchs
Abstract:
The quality of speech codecs deteriorates at low bitrates due to high quantization noise. A post-filter is generally employed to enhance the quality of the coded speech. In this paper, a data-driven post-filter relying on masking in the time-frequency domain is proposed. A fully connected neural network (FCNN), a convolutional encoder-decoder (CED) network and a long short-term memory (LSTM) netwo…
▽ More
The quality of speech codecs deteriorates at low bitrates due to high quantization noise. A post-filter is generally employed to enhance the quality of the coded speech. In this paper, a data-driven post-filter relying on masking in the time-frequency domain is proposed. A fully connected neural network (FCNN), a convolutional encoder-decoder (CED) network and a long short-term memory (LSTM) network are implemeted to estimate a real-valued mask per time-frequency bin. The proposed models were tested on the five lowest operating modes (6.65 kbps-15.85 kbps) of the Adaptive Multi-Rate Wideband codec (AMR-WB). Both objective and subjective evaluations confirm the enhancement of the coded speech and also show the superiority of the mask-based neural network system over a conventional heuristic post-filter used in the standard like ITU-T G.718.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
