Towards a Network Control Theory of Electroconvulsive Therapy Response
Authors:
Tim Hahn,
Hamidreza Jamalabadi,
Erfan Nozari,
Nils R. Winter,
Jan Ernsting,
Marius Gruber,
Marco J. Mauritz,
Pascal Grumbach,
Lukas Fisch,
Ramona Leenings,
Kelvin Sarink,
Julian Blanke,
Leon Kleine Vennekate,
Daniel Emden,
Nils Opel,
Dominik Grotegerd,
Verena Enneking,
Susanne Meinert,
Tiana Borgers,
Melissa Klug,
Elisabeth J. Leehr,
Katharina Dohm,
Walter Heindel,
Joachim Gross,
Udo Dannlowski
, et al. (2 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT) is arguably the most effective intervention for treatment-resistant depression. While large interindividual variability exists, a theory capable of predicting individual response to ECT remains elusive. To address this, we posit a quantitative, mechanistic framework of ECT response based on Network Control Theory (NCT). Then, we empirically test our approach and emp…
▽ More
Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT) is arguably the most effective intervention for treatment-resistant depression. While large interindividual variability exists, a theory capable of predicting individual response to ECT remains elusive. To address this, we posit a quantitative, mechanistic framework of ECT response based on Network Control Theory (NCT). Then, we empirically test our approach and employ it to predict ECT treatment response. To this end, we derive a formal association between Postictal Suppression Index (PSI) - an ECT seizure quality index - and whole-brain modal and average controllability, NCT metrics based on white matter brain network architecture, respectively. Exploiting the known association of ECT response and PSI, we then hypothesized an association between our controllability metrics and ECT response mediated by PSI. We formally tested this conjecture in N=50 depressive patients undergoing ECT. We show that whole-brain controllability metrics based on pre-ECT structural connectome data predict ECT response in accordance with our hypotheses. In addition, we show the expected mediation effects via PSI. Importantly, our theoretically motivated metrics are at least on par with extensive machine learning models based on pre-ECT connectome data. In summary, we derived and tested a control-theoretic framework capable of predicting ECT response based on individual brain network architecture. It makes testable, quantitative predictions regarding individual therapeutic response, which are corroborated by strong empirical evidence. Our work might constitute a starting point for a comprehensive, quantitative theory of personalized ECT interventions rooted in control theory.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
A Network Control Theory Approach to Longitudinal Symptom Dynamics in Major Depressive Disorder
Authors:
Tim Hahn,
Hamidreza Jamalabadi,
Daniel Emden,
Janik Goltermann,
Jan Ernsting,
Nils R. Winter,
Lukas Fisch,
Ramona Leenings,
Kelvin Sarink,
Vincent Holstein,
Marius Gruber,
Dominik Grotegerd,
Susanne Meinert,
Katharina Dohm,
Elisabeth J. Leehr,
Maike Richter,
Lisa Sindermann,
Verena Enneking,
Hannah Lemke,
Stephanie Witt,
Marcella Rietschel,
Katharina Brosch,
Julia-Katharina Pfarr,
Tina Meller,
Kai Gustav Ringwald
, et al. (9 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Background: The evolution of symptoms over time is at the heart of understanding and treating mental disorders. However, a principled, quantitative framework explaining symptom dynamics remains elusive. Here, we propose a Network Control Theory of Psychopathology allowing us to formally derive a theoretical control energy which we hypothesize quantifies resistance to future symptom improvement in…
▽ More
Background: The evolution of symptoms over time is at the heart of understanding and treating mental disorders. However, a principled, quantitative framework explaining symptom dynamics remains elusive. Here, we propose a Network Control Theory of Psychopathology allowing us to formally derive a theoretical control energy which we hypothesize quantifies resistance to future symptom improvement in Major Depressive Disorder (MDD). We test this hypothesis and investigate the relation to genetic and environmental risk as well as resilience.
Methods: We modelled longitudinal symptom-network dynamics derived from N=2,059 Beck Depression Inventory measurements acquired over a median of 134 days in a sample of N=109 patients suffering from MDD. We quantified the theoretical energy required for each patient and time-point to reach a symptom-free state given individual symptom-network topology (E 0 ) and 1) tested if E 0 predicts future symptom improvement and 2) whether this relationship is moderated by Polygenic Risk Scores (PRS) of mental disorders, childhood maltreatment experience, and self-reported resilience.
Outcomes: We show that E 0 indeed predicts symptom reduction at the next measurement and reveal that this coupling between E 0 and future symptom change increases with higher genetic risk and childhood maltreatment while it decreases with resilience.
Interpretation: Our study provides a mechanistic framework capable of predicting future symptom improvement based on individual symptom-network topology and clarifies the role of genetic and environmental risk as well as resilience. Our control-theoretic framework makes testable, quantitative predictions for individual therapeutic response and provides a starting-point for the theory-driven design of personalized interventions.
Funding: German Research Foundation and Interdisciplinary Centre for Clinical Research, Münster
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
