-
Sensitivity of DC Network Representation for GIC Analysis
Authors:
Aniruddh Mishra,
Arthur K. Barnes,
Jose E. Tabarez,
Adam Mate
Abstract:
Geomagnetic disturbances are a threat to the reliability and security of our national critical energy infrastructures. These events specifically result in geomagnetically induced currents, which can cause damage to transformers due to magnetic saturation. In order to mitigate these effects, blocker devices must be placed in optimal locations. Finding this placement requires a dc representation of…
▽ More
Geomagnetic disturbances are a threat to the reliability and security of our national critical energy infrastructures. These events specifically result in geomagnetically induced currents, which can cause damage to transformers due to magnetic saturation. In order to mitigate these effects, blocker devices must be placed in optimal locations. Finding this placement requires a dc representation of the ac transmission lines, which this paper discusses. Different decisions in this process, including the method of representing the blocking devices, result in significant variations to the power loss calculations. To analyze these effects, we conclude the paper by comparing the losses on a sample network with different modeling implementations.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
A Review of the GIC Blocker Placement Problem
Authors:
Arthur K. Barnes,
Adam Mate,
Russell Bent
Abstract:
Space weather poses a tremendous threat to power systems: geomagnetic disturbances could result in widespread disruptions and long-duration blackouts, including severe damage to system components. To mitigate their impacts, a handful of strategies exist, with the most promising being the deployment of transformer neutral blocking devices. The high cost of these devices, however, precludes their in…
▽ More
Space weather poses a tremendous threat to power systems: geomagnetic disturbances could result in widespread disruptions and long-duration blackouts, including severe damage to system components. To mitigate their impacts, a handful of strategies exist, with the most promising being the deployment of transformer neutral blocking devices. The high cost of these devices, however, precludes their installation at all substations; this motivates the development of effective solutions for the cost-effective placement of such devices. While the current state-of-the-art in blocker placement methods is insufficient to be applied to real-sized power grids, ongoing research continues to increase the size of networks for which the placement problem remains tractable. Along these lines, the contributions of this paper are two fold: first, a comprehensive overview of the current state-of-the-art in blocker placement methods is provided; and second, a complete optimization formulation - implemented and benchmarked in an open-source software - for the blocker placement problem is presented.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2024; v1 submitted 11 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Developing Optimization-Based Inverter Models for Short Circuit Studies
Authors:
Thabiso R. Mabote,
Jose E. Tabarez,
Arthur K. Barnes,
Adam Mate,
Russell W. Bent,
Eduardo Cotilla-Sanchez
Abstract:
As inverter-based generation becomes more common in distribution networks, it is important to create models for use in optimization-based problems that accurately represent their non-linear behavior when saturated. This work presents models for grid-following and grid-forming inverters, and demonstrates their use in optimization-based fault studies. The developed models are shown to provide result…
▽ More
As inverter-based generation becomes more common in distribution networks, it is important to create models for use in optimization-based problems that accurately represent their non-linear behavior when saturated. This work presents models for grid-following and grid-forming inverters, and demonstrates their use in optimization-based fault studies. The developed models are shown to provide results in line with experimental tests from literature; however, grid-forming inverter models fail to provide feasible solutions for certain fault types even when currents, voltages, and powers from the models seem reasonable. This work lays down the foundation for the development of relaxed models for both grid-following and grid-forming inverter models for use in optimization problems.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2023; v1 submitted 1 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Real-Time Implementation of Dynamic State Estimation for Microgrid Load Bus Protection
Authors:
Sarbajit Basu,
Arthur K. Barnes,
Adam Mate,
Olga Lavrova
Abstract:
Inverter-interfaced microgrids, owing to the lack of fault current, cannot be protected using traditional over-current protections, while admittance or differential relaying protection schemes are not practical to be implemented. Dynamic state estimation can track and predict power system transients and has been extensively investigated for setting-less protection. A novel real-time application of…
▽ More
Inverter-interfaced microgrids, owing to the lack of fault current, cannot be protected using traditional over-current protections, while admittance or differential relaying protection schemes are not practical to be implemented. Dynamic state estimation can track and predict power system transients and has been extensively investigated for setting-less protection. A novel real-time application of dynamic state estimation for protection is proposed in this paper, wherein parameter estimation and parallel processing is used to identify the state of the system. The implementation scheme has low process complexity and employs a data acquisition device and estimator that run on a general-purpose computer. This proposed implementation extends the state-of-the-art, under short-circuit conditions, to a real-time implementation with a lumped-load radial microgrid and a grid-forming inverter with current-limiting behavior.
△ Less
Submitted 29 July, 2024; v1 submitted 21 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Measuring and Analyzing Effects of HEMP Simulation on Synthetic Power Grids
Authors:
Carson L. May,
Arthur K. Barnes,
Jose E. Tabarez,
Adam Mate,
Eric M. Nelson,
Ross Guttromson
Abstract:
There is significant uncertainty about the potential effects of a high-altitude electromagnetic pulse (HEMP) detonation on the bulk electric system. This study attempts to account for such uncertainty, in using Monte-Carlo methods to account for speculated range of effect of HEMP contingency. Through task parallelism and asynchronous processing techniques implemented throughout simulation, this st…
▽ More
There is significant uncertainty about the potential effects of a high-altitude electromagnetic pulse (HEMP) detonation on the bulk electric system. This study attempts to account for such uncertainty, in using Monte-Carlo methods to account for speculated range of effect of HEMP contingency. Through task parallelism and asynchronous processing techniques implemented throughout simulation, this study measure the effects of 700 large-scale HEMP simulations on a 7173 bus synthetic power grid. Analysis explores how contingency severity varies, depending on initial contingency parameters. Severity indices were captured throughout simulation to measure and quantify the cascading nature of an HEMP event. Further development of HEMP simulation modeling is explored as well, which could augment forecasts of potential contingency events as well.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2023; v1 submitted 30 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Fault Current-Constrained Optimal Power Flow on Unbalanced Distribution Networks
Authors:
Jose E. Tabarez,
Arthur K. Barnes,
Adam Mate,
Russell W. Bent
Abstract:
With the proliferation of distributed generation into distribution networks, the need to consider fault currents in the dispatch problem becomes increasingly relevant. This paper introduces a method for adding fault current constraints into optimal power flow in order to reduce fault currents while minimizing generation cost. The optimal power flow problem is formulated as a single optimization pr…
▽ More
With the proliferation of distributed generation into distribution networks, the need to consider fault currents in the dispatch problem becomes increasingly relevant. This paper introduces a method for adding fault current constraints into optimal power flow in order to reduce fault currents while minimizing generation cost. The optimal power flow problem is formulated as a single optimization problem with sub-networks representing the faults of interest. Having a single optimization problem allows the decision variables to be coupled across the optimal power flow and the fault current studies without having to iterate over possible solutions. The proposed method is applicable to unbalanced distribution networks, including those with transformers that introduce phase-shifts.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2023; v1 submitted 22 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Dynamic State Estimation-Based Protection for Induction Motor Loads
Authors:
Arthur K. Barnes,
Sarbajit Basu,
Adam Mate
Abstract:
Ensuring protective device coordination is critical to maintain the resilience and improve the reliability of large microgrids. Inverter-interfaced generation, however, poses significant challenges when designing protection systems. Traditional time-overcurrent protective devices are unsuitable on account of the lack of fault current. Present industry practice is to force all inverters to shut dow…
▽ More
Ensuring protective device coordination is critical to maintain the resilience and improve the reliability of large microgrids. Inverter-interfaced generation, however, poses significant challenges when designing protection systems. Traditional time-overcurrent protective devices are unsuitable on account of the lack of fault current. Present industry practice is to force all inverters to shut down during faults, which prevents large microgrids from operating in a resilient and reliable manner. Dynamic state estimation (DSE) has been proposed for line protection, and more recently for the protection of load buses or downstream radial portions of microgrids. However, only passive loads with series resistive-inductive loads have been tested with DSE, even though the behavior of dynamic loads -- such as induction motors or power electronics -- may differ significantly during faults. This paper considers the case of applying DSE to protecting a load bus serving a three-phase induction motor.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2023; v1 submitted 18 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Dynamic State Estimation for Load Bus Protection on Inverter-Interfaced Microgrids
Authors:
Arthur K. Barnes,
Adam Mate,
Jean Marie V. Bikorimana,
Ricardo J. Castillo
Abstract:
Inverter-interfaced microgrids results in challenges when designing protection systems. Traditional time-overcurrent, admittance, and differential protection methods are unsuitable on account of lack of fault current, excessively short lines, or a prohibitive number of protective devices needing to be installed. Current practice is to force all inverters to shut down during fault conditions, weake…
▽ More
Inverter-interfaced microgrids results in challenges when designing protection systems. Traditional time-overcurrent, admittance, and differential protection methods are unsuitable on account of lack of fault current, excessively short lines, or a prohibitive number of protective devices needing to be installed. Current practice is to force all inverters to shut down during fault conditions, weakening resilience and reducing reliability. Dynamic state estimation (DSE), which has been explored for both line protection and load bus protection before, is a potential solution to these challenges to create widely utilizable, highly reliable protection systems. However, it has only been tested for load protection with ideal voltage sources, which do not capture the short-circuit behavior of inverter-interfaced generation, notably low fault current and unbalanced output voltage. This paper aims to extend the state-of-the-art on DSE load protection: the performance of DSE during short-circuit conditions with a grid-forming inverter with current-limiting behavior during fault conditions is investigated.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2022; v1 submitted 13 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Relaxation Based Modeling of GMD Induced Cascading Failures in PowerModelsGMD.jl
Authors:
Adam Mate,
Arthur K. Barnes,
Steven K. Morley,
Jacob A. Friz-Trillo,
Eduardo Cotilla-Sanchez,
Sean P. Blake
Abstract:
A major risk of geomagnetic disturbances (GMDs) is cascading failure of electrical grids. The modeling of GMD events and cascading outages in power systems is difficult, both independently and jointly, because of the many different mechanisms and physics involved. This paper introduces a relaxation based modeling of GMD-induced cascading failures:~the dc approximation-based DCSIMSEP solver was ada…
▽ More
A major risk of geomagnetic disturbances (GMDs) is cascading failure of electrical grids. The modeling of GMD events and cascading outages in power systems is difficult, both independently and jointly, because of the many different mechanisms and physics involved. This paper introduces a relaxation based modeling of GMD-induced cascading failures:~the dc approximation-based DCSIMSEP solver was adapted to simulate cascading as a result of GMDs, the full set of ac power flow equations were relaxed to guarantee optimality, and the reactive power losses were modeled while keeping the problem convex. The developed algorithm was implemented in PowerModelsGMD.jl - an open-source software specifically designed to model and analyze geomagnetic hazards - and demonstrated to work on the RTS-GMLC-GIC-EAST synthetic test network.
△ Less
Submitted 30 December, 2021; v1 submitted 14 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
The Risk of Hidden Failures to the United States Electrical Grid and Potential for Mitigation
Authors:
Arthur K. Barnes,
Adam Mate,
Jose E. Tabarez
Abstract:
Hidden failures present a noticeable impact to the reliability of the United States electrical grid. These hazards are responsible for protective device misoperations and can cause multiple-element contingencies across nearby components, greatly increasing the likelihood of cascading events. This paper provides an in-depth overview of the causes and risks of hidden failures and discusses methods f…
▽ More
Hidden failures present a noticeable impact to the reliability of the United States electrical grid. These hazards are responsible for protective device misoperations and can cause multiple-element contingencies across nearby components, greatly increasing the likelihood of cascading events. This paper provides an in-depth overview of the causes and risks of hidden failures and discusses methods for identifying critical locations where hidden failures could pose a risk of cascading failure, with the ultimate goal being to identify efficient mitigation methods that can prevent their occurrence in protective relays.
△ Less
Submitted 30 December, 2021; v1 submitted 7 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Implementing Admittance Relaying for Microgrid Protection
Authors:
Arthur K. Barnes,
Adam Mate
Abstract:
The rapid increase of distributed energy resources has led to the widespread deployment of microgrids. These flexible and efficient local energy grids are able to operate in both grid-connected mode and islanded mode; they are interfaced to the main power system by a fast semiconductor switch and commonly make use of inverter-interfaced generation. This paper focuses on inverter interfaced microgr…
▽ More
The rapid increase of distributed energy resources has led to the widespread deployment of microgrids. These flexible and efficient local energy grids are able to operate in both grid-connected mode and islanded mode; they are interfaced to the main power system by a fast semiconductor switch and commonly make use of inverter-interfaced generation. This paper focuses on inverter interfaced microgrids, which present a challenge for protection as they do not provide the high short-circuit current necessary for conventional time-overcurrent protection. The application of admittance relaying for the protection of inverter-interfaced microgrids is investigated as a potential solution. The comparison of analytical and simulated results of performed four experiments prove the suitability of admittance relaying for microgrids protection.
△ Less
Submitted 27 December, 2022; v1 submitted 19 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Dynamic State Estimation for Radial Microgrid Protection
Authors:
Arthur K. Barnes,
Adam Mate
Abstract:
Microgrids are localized electrical grids with control capability that are able to disconnect from the traditional grid to operate autonomously. They strengthen grid resilience, help mitigate grid disturbances, and support a flexible grid by enabling the integration of distributed energy resources. Given the likely presence of critical loads, the proper protection of microgrids is of vital importa…
▽ More
Microgrids are localized electrical grids with control capability that are able to disconnect from the traditional grid to operate autonomously. They strengthen grid resilience, help mitigate grid disturbances, and support a flexible grid by enabling the integration of distributed energy resources. Given the likely presence of critical loads, the proper protection of microgrids is of vital importance; however, this is complicated in the case of inverter-interfaced microgrids where low fault currents preclude the use of conventional time-overcurrent protection. This paper introduces and investigates the application of dynamic state estimation, a generalization of differential protection, for the protection of radial portions of microgrids (or distribution networks); both phasor-based and dynamic approaches are investigated for protection. It is demonstrated through experiments on three case-study systems that dynamic state estimation is capable of correctly identifying model parameters for both normal and faulted operation.
△ Less
Submitted 30 December, 2022; v1 submitted 19 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Analyzing and Mitigating the Impacts of GMD and EMP Events on the Electrical Grid with PowerModelsGMD.jl
Authors:
Adam Mate,
Arthur K. Barnes,
Russell W. Bent,
Eduardo Cotilla-Sanchez
Abstract:
Geomagnetic disturbances and E3 high-altitude electromagnetic pulse events pose a substantial threat to the electrical grid by adversely impacting and damaging high-voltage transmission networks and equipment. To evaluate the risks and mitigate the potential effects of these hazards, this work proposes PowerModelsGMD.jl (abbr. PMsGMD). PMsGMD is an open-source Julia package that solves for quasi-d…
▽ More
Geomagnetic disturbances and E3 high-altitude electromagnetic pulse events pose a substantial threat to the electrical grid by adversely impacting and damaging high-voltage transmission networks and equipment. To evaluate the risks and mitigate the potential effects of these hazards, this work proposes PowerModelsGMD.jl (abbr. PMsGMD). PMsGMD is an open-source Julia package that solves for quasi-dc line flow and ac power flow problems in a system subjected to geomagnetically induced currents. Unlike commercially available software solutions, it is extensible and applicable to a variety of problems. The flexibility of this framework is demonstrated by applying it to the problem of identifying mitigation strategies via line switching for a time-extended transformer heating problem. An overview of PMsGMD is presented in this paper: introduction to its design, validation of its implementation, demonstration of its performance and effectiveness, and a description of how it may be applied to aid system-operation decisions.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2021; v1 submitted 13 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
