-
The green hydrogen ambition and implementation gap
Authors:
Adrian Odenweller,
Falko Ueckerdt
Abstract:
Green hydrogen is critical for decarbonising hard-to-electrify sectors, but faces high costs and investment risks. Here we define and quantify the green hydrogen ambition and implementation gap, showing that meeting hydrogen expectations will remain challenging despite surging announcements of projects and subsidies. Tracking 137 projects over three years, we identify a wide 2022 implementation ga…
▽ More
Green hydrogen is critical for decarbonising hard-to-electrify sectors, but faces high costs and investment risks. Here we define and quantify the green hydrogen ambition and implementation gap, showing that meeting hydrogen expectations will remain challenging despite surging announcements of projects and subsidies. Tracking 137 projects over three years, we identify a wide 2022 implementation gap with only 2% of global capacity announcements finished on schedule. In contrast, the 2030 ambition gap towards 1.5°C scenarios is gradually closing as the announced project pipeline has nearly tripled to 441 GW within three years. However, we estimate that, without carbon pricing, realising all these projects would require global subsidies of \$1.6 trillion (\$1.2 - 2.6 trillion range), far exceeding announced subsidies. Given past and future implementation gaps, policymakers must prepare for prolonged green hydrogen scarcity. Policy support needs to secure hydrogen investments, but should focus on applications where hydrogen is indispensable.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Multi-level emission impacts of electrification and coal pathways in China's netzero transition
Authors:
Chen Chris Gong,
Falko Ueckerdt,
Christoph Bertram,
Yuxin Yin,
David Bantje,
Robert Pietzcker,
Johanna Hoppe,
Robin Hasse,
Michaja Pehl,
Simón Moreno-Leiva,
Jakob Duerrwaechter,
Jarusch Muessel,
Gunnar Luderer
Abstract:
Decarbonizing China's energy system requires both greening the power supply and electrifying end-use sectors. However, concerns exist that electrification may increase emissions while coal power dominates. Using a global climate model, we explore electrification scenarios with varying coal phase-out timelines and assess their climate impact on China's sectors. A ten-year delay in coal phase-out co…
▽ More
Decarbonizing China's energy system requires both greening the power supply and electrifying end-use sectors. However, concerns exist that electrification may increase emissions while coal power dominates. Using a global climate model, we explore electrification scenarios with varying coal phase-out timelines and assess their climate impact on China's sectors. A ten-year delay in coal phase-out could increase global peak temperature by about 0.02°C. However, on a sectoral level, there is no evidence of significant additional emissions from electrification, even with a slower coal phase-out. This challenges the sequential ``order of abatement'' view, showing electrification can start before the power sector is fully decarbonized. As long as power emission intensity drops below 150 gCO2/kWh by 2040, electrification can substantially reduce the carbon footprint of buildings, steel, and transport services, and along with energy efficiency measures, it can avoid approximately 0.035°C of additional global warming by 2060.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2025; v1 submitted 7 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Bidirectional coupling of a long-term integrated assessment model REMIND v3.0.0 with an hourly power sector model DIETER v1.0.2
Authors:
Chen Chris Gong,
Falko Ueckerdt,
Robert Pietzcker,
Adrian Odenweller,
Wolf-Peter Schill,
Martin Kittel,
Gunnar Luderer
Abstract:
Integrated assessment models (IAMs) are a central tool for the quantitative analysis of climate change mitigation strategies. However, due to their global, cross-sectoral and centennial scope, IAMs cannot explicitly represent the spatio-temporal detail required to properly analyze the key role of variable renewable electricity (VRE) for decarbonizing the power sector and end-use electrification. I…
▽ More
Integrated assessment models (IAMs) are a central tool for the quantitative analysis of climate change mitigation strategies. However, due to their global, cross-sectoral and centennial scope, IAMs cannot explicitly represent the spatio-temporal detail required to properly analyze the key role of variable renewable electricity (VRE) for decarbonizing the power sector and end-use electrification. In contrast, power sector models (PSMs) incorporate high spatio-temporal resolutions, but tend to have narrower scopes and shorter time horizons. To overcome these limitations, we present a novel methodology: an iterative and fully automated soft-coupling framework that combines the strengths of a IAM and a PSM. This framework uses the market values of power generation as well as the capture prices of demand in the PSM as price signals that change the capacity and power mix of the IAM. Hence, both models make endogenous investment decisions, leading to a joint solution. We apply the method to Germany in a proof-of-concept study using the IAM REMIND and the PSM DIETER, and confirm the theoretical prediction of almost-full convergence both in terms of decision variables and (shadow) prices. At the end of the iterative process, the absolute model difference between the generation shares of any generator type for any year is <5% for a simple configuration (no storage, no flexible demand), and 6-7% for a more realistic and detailed configuration (with storage and flexible demand). For the simple configuration, we mathematically show that this coupling scheme corresponds uniquely to an iterative mapping of the Lagrangians of two power sector optimization problems of different time resolutions, which can lead to a comprehensive model convergence of both decision variables and (shadow) prices. Since our approach is based on fundamental economic principles, it is applicable also to other IAM-PSM pairs.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2022; v1 submitted 6 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
