-
Sticky information and price controls: Evidence from a natural experiment
Authors:
Doron Sayag,
Avichai Snir,
Daniel Levy
Abstract:
We test the predictions of the sticky information model using a survey dataset by comparing shoppers accuracy in recalling the prices of regulated and comparable unregulated products. Because regulated product prices are capped, they are sold more than comparable unregulated products, while their prices change less frequently and vary less across stores and between brands, than the prices of compa…
▽ More
We test the predictions of the sticky information model using a survey dataset by comparing shoppers accuracy in recalling the prices of regulated and comparable unregulated products. Because regulated product prices are capped, they are sold more than comparable unregulated products, while their prices change less frequently and vary less across stores and between brands, than the prices of comparable unregulated products. Therefore, shoppers would be expected to recall the regulated product prices more accurately. However, we find that shoppers are better at recalling the prices of unregulated products, in line with the sticky information model which predicts that shoppers will be more attentive to prices that change more frequently.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Price Setting Rules, Rounding Tax, and Inattention Penalty
Authors:
Doron Sayag,
Avichai Snir,
Daniel Levy
Abstract:
We study the price rounding regulation in Israel, which outlawed non-0-ending prices, forcing retailers to round 9 ending prices, which in many stores, comprised more than 60 percent of all prices. The goal of the regulation was to eliminate the rounding tax, the extra amount consumers paid because of price rounding, which was necessitated by the abolition of low denomination coins, and the inatte…
▽ More
We study the price rounding regulation in Israel, which outlawed non-0-ending prices, forcing retailers to round 9 ending prices, which in many stores, comprised more than 60 percent of all prices. The goal of the regulation was to eliminate the rounding tax, the extra amount consumers paid because of price rounding, which was necessitated by the abolition of low denomination coins, and the inattention tax, the extra amount consumers paid the retailers because of their inattention to the prices rightmost digits. Using 4 different datasets, we assess the success of the government in achieving these goals, focusing on fast moving consumer goods, a category of products strongly affected by the price rounding regulation. We focus on the response of the retailers to the price rounding regulation and find that although the government succeeded in eliminating the rounding tax, the bottom line is that shoppers end up paying more, not less, because of the regulation, underscoring, once again, the warning of Milton Friedman that policies should be judged by their results, not by their intentions.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
Large Effects of Small Cues: Priming Selfish Economic Decisions
Authors:
Avichai Snir,
Dudi Levy,
Dian Wang,
Haipeng Allan Chen,
Daniel Levy
Abstract:
Many experimental studies report that economics students tend to act more selfishly than students of other disciplines, a finding that received widespread public and professional attention. Two main explanations that the existing literature offers for the differences found in the behavior between economists and noneconomists are the selection effect, and the indoctrination effect. We offer an alte…
▽ More
Many experimental studies report that economics students tend to act more selfishly than students of other disciplines, a finding that received widespread public and professional attention. Two main explanations that the existing literature offers for the differences found in the behavior between economists and noneconomists are the selection effect, and the indoctrination effect. We offer an alternative, novel explanation. We argue that these differences can be explained by differences in the interpretation of the context. We test this hypothesis by conducting two social dilemma experiments in the US and Israel with participants from both economics and non-economics majors. In the experiments, participants face a tradeoff between profit maximization, that is the market norm and workers welfare, that is the social norm. We use priming to manipulate the cues that the participants receive before they make their decision. We find that when participants receive cues signaling that the decision has an economic context, both economics and non-economics students tend to maximize profits. When the participants receive cues emphasizing social norms, on the other hand, both economics and non-economics students are less likely to maximize profits. We conclude that some of the differences found between the decisions of economics and non-economics students can be explained by contextual cues.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Price Gouging or Market Forces? Fairness Perceptions of Price Hikes in the Pandemic
Authors:
Avichai Snir,
Daniel Levy,
Dudi Levy,
Haipeng Allan Chen
Abstract:
We report the results of surveys we conducted in the US and Israel in 2020, a time when many prices increased following the spread of the pandemic. To assess respondents perceptions of price increases, we focus on goods whose prices have increased during the pandemic, including some essential goods. Consistent with the principle of dual entitlement, we find that respondents perceive price increase…
▽ More
We report the results of surveys we conducted in the US and Israel in 2020, a time when many prices increased following the spread of the pandemic. To assess respondents perceptions of price increases, we focus on goods whose prices have increased during the pandemic, including some essential goods. Consistent with the principle of dual entitlement, we find that respondents perceive price increases as more acceptable if they are due to cost shocks than if they are due to demand shocks. However, we also find large differences across the two populations, as well as across goods.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Small Price Changes, Sales Volume, and Menu Cost
Authors:
Doron Sayag,
Avichai Snir,
Daniel Levy
Abstract:
The finding of small price changes in many retail price datasets is often viewed as a puzzle. We show that a possible explanation for the presence of small price changes is related to sales volume, an observation that has been overlooked in the existing literature. Analyzing a large retail scanner price dataset that contains information on both prices and sales volume, we find that small price cha…
▽ More
The finding of small price changes in many retail price datasets is often viewed as a puzzle. We show that a possible explanation for the presence of small price changes is related to sales volume, an observation that has been overlooked in the existing literature. Analyzing a large retail scanner price dataset that contains information on both prices and sales volume, we find that small price changes are more frequent when products sales volume is high. This finding holds across product categories, within product categories, and for individual products. It is also robust to various sensitivity analyses such as measurement errors, the definition of small price changes, the inclusion of measures of price synchronization, the size of producers, the time horizon used to compute the average sales volume, the revenues, the competition, shoppers characteristics, etc.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Retail Pricing Format and Rigidity of Regular Prices
Authors:
Sourav Ray,
Avichai Snir,
Daniel Levy
Abstract:
We study the price rigidity of regular and sale prices, and how it is affected by pricing formats (pricing strategies). We use data from three large Canadian stores with different pricing formats (Every-Day-Low-Price, Hi-Lo, and Hybrid) that are located within a 1 km radius of each other. Our data contains both the actual transaction prices and actual regular prices as displayed on the store shelv…
▽ More
We study the price rigidity of regular and sale prices, and how it is affected by pricing formats (pricing strategies). We use data from three large Canadian stores with different pricing formats (Every-Day-Low-Price, Hi-Lo, and Hybrid) that are located within a 1 km radius of each other. Our data contains both the actual transaction prices and actual regular prices as displayed on the store shelves. We combine these data with two generated regular price series (filtered prices and reference prices) and study their rigidity. Regular price rigidity varies with store formats because different format stores treat sale prices differently, and consequently define regular prices differently. Correspondingly, the meanings of price cuts and sale prices vary across store formats. To interpret the findings, we consider the store pricing format distribution across the US.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
3 Lessons from Hyperinflationary Periods
Authors:
Mark Bergen,
Thomas Bergen,
Daniel Levy,
Rose Semenov
Abstract:
Inflation is painful, for firms, customers, employees, and society. But careful study of periods of hyperinflation point to ways that firms can adapt. In particular, companies need to think about how to change prices regularly and cheaply, because constant price changes can ultimately be very, very expensive. And they should consider how to communicate those price changes to customers. Providing c…
▽ More
Inflation is painful, for firms, customers, employees, and society. But careful study of periods of hyperinflation point to ways that firms can adapt. In particular, companies need to think about how to change prices regularly and cheaply, because constant price changes can ultimately be very, very expensive. And they should consider how to communicate those price changes to customers. Providing clarity and predictability can increase consumer trust and help firms in the long run.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Zero-Ending Prices, Cognitive Convenience, and Price Rigidity
Authors:
Avichai Snir,
Haipeng,
Chen,
Daniel Levy
Abstract:
We assess the role of cognitive convenience in the popularity and rigidity of 0 ending prices in convenience settings. Studies show that 0 ending prices are common at convenience stores because of the transaction convenience that 0 ending prices offer. Using a large store level retail CPI data, we find that 0 ending prices are popular and rigid at convenience stores even when they offer little tra…
▽ More
We assess the role of cognitive convenience in the popularity and rigidity of 0 ending prices in convenience settings. Studies show that 0 ending prices are common at convenience stores because of the transaction convenience that 0 ending prices offer. Using a large store level retail CPI data, we find that 0 ending prices are popular and rigid at convenience stores even when they offer little transaction convenience. We corroborate these findings with two large retail scanner price datasets from Dominicks and Nielsen. In the Dominicks data, we find that there are more 0 endings in the prices of the items in the front end candies category than in any other category, even though these prices have no effect on the convenience of the consumers check out transaction. In addition, in both Dominicks and Nielsens datasets, we find that 0 ending prices have a positive effect on demand. Ruling out consumer antagonism and retailers use of heuristics in pricing, we conclude that 0 ending prices are popular and rigid, and that they increase demand at convenience settings, not only for their transaction convenience, but also for the cognitive convenience they offer.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Potterian Economics
Authors:
Daniel Levy,
Avichai Snir
Abstract:
Recent studies in psychology and neuroscience offer systematic evidence that fictional works exert a surprisingly strong influence on readers and have the power to shape their opinions and worldviews. Building on these findings, we study what we term Potterian economics, the economic ideas, insights, and structure, found in Harry Potter books, to assess how the books might affect economic literacy…
▽ More
Recent studies in psychology and neuroscience offer systematic evidence that fictional works exert a surprisingly strong influence on readers and have the power to shape their opinions and worldviews. Building on these findings, we study what we term Potterian economics, the economic ideas, insights, and structure, found in Harry Potter books, to assess how the books might affect economic literacy. A conservative estimate suggests that more than 7.3 percent of the world population has read the Harry Potter books, and millions more have seen their movie adaptations. These extraordinary figures underscore the importance of the messages the books convey. We explore the Potterian economic model and compare it to professional economic models to assess the consistency of the Potterian economic principles with the existing economic models. We find that some of the principles of Potterian economics are consistent with economists models. Many other principles, however, are distorted and contain numerous inaccuracies, contradicting professional economists views and insights. We conclude that Potterian economics can teach us about the formation and dissemination of folk economics, the intuitive notions of naive individuals who see market transactions as a zero-sum game, who care about distribution but fail to understand incentives and efficiency, and who think of prices as allocating wealth but not resources or their efficient use.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
