-
A nested nonparametric logit model for microtransit revenue management supplemented with citywide synthetic data
Authors:
Xiyuan Ren,
Joseph Y. J. Chow,
Venktesh Pandey,
Linfei Yuan
Abstract:
As an IT-enabled multi-passenger mobility service, microtransit can improve accessibility, reduce congestion, and enhance flexibility. However, its heterogeneous impacts across travelers necessitate better tools for microtransit forecasting and revenue management, especially when actual usage data are limited. We propose a nested nonparametric model for joint travel mode and ride pass subscription…
▽ More
As an IT-enabled multi-passenger mobility service, microtransit can improve accessibility, reduce congestion, and enhance flexibility. However, its heterogeneous impacts across travelers necessitate better tools for microtransit forecasting and revenue management, especially when actual usage data are limited. We propose a nested nonparametric model for joint travel mode and ride pass subscription choice, estimated using marginal subscription data and synthetic populations. The model improves microtransit choice modeling by (1) leveraging citywide synthetic data for greater spatiotemporal granularity, (2) employing an agent-based estimation approach to capture heterogeneous user preferences, and (3) integrating mode choice parameters into subscription choice modeling. We apply our methodology to a case study in Arlington, TX, using synthetic data from Replica Inc. and microtransit data from Via. Our model accurately predicts the number of subscribers in the upper branch and achieves a high McFadden R2 in the lower branch (0.603 for weekday trips and 0.576 for weekend trips), while also retrieving interpretable elasticities and consumer surplus. We further integrate the model into a simulation-based framework for microtransit revenue management. For the ride pass pricing policy, our simulation results show that reducing the price of the weekly pass ($25 -> $18.9) and monthly pass ($80 -> $71.5) would surprisingly increase total revenue by $127 per day. For the subsidy policy, our simulation results show that a 100% fare discount would reduce 61 car trips to AT&T Stadium for a game event, and increase 82 microtransit trips to Medical City Arlington, but require subsidies of $533 per event and $483 per day, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2025; v1 submitted 22 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Nonparametric mixed logit model with market-level parameters estimated from market share data
Authors:
Xiyuan Ren,
Joseph Y. J. Chow,
Prateek Bansal
Abstract:
We propose a nonparametric mixed logit model that is estimated using market-level choice share data. The model treats each market as an agent and represents taste heterogeneity through market-specific parameters by solving a multiagent inverse utility maximization problem, addressing the limitations of existing market-level choice models with parametric estimation. A simulation study is conducted…
▽ More
We propose a nonparametric mixed logit model that is estimated using market-level choice share data. The model treats each market as an agent and represents taste heterogeneity through market-specific parameters by solving a multiagent inverse utility maximization problem, addressing the limitations of existing market-level choice models with parametric estimation. A simulation study is conducted to evaluate the performance of our model in terms of estimation time, estimation accuracy, and out-of-sample predictive accuracy. In a real data application, we estimate the travel mode choice of 53.55 million trips made by 19.53 million residents in New York State. These trips are aggregated based on population segments and census block group-level origin-destination (OD) pairs, resulting in 120,740 markets. We benchmark our model against multinomial logit (MNL), nested logit (NL), inverse product differentiation logit (IPDL), and the BLP models. The results show that the proposed model improves the out-of-sample accuracy from 65.30% to 81.78%, with a computation time less than one-tenth of that taken to estimate the BLP model. The price elasticities and diversion ratios retrieved from our model and benchmark models exhibit similar substitution patterns. Moreover, the market-level parameters estimated by our model provide additional insights and facilitate their seamless integration into supply-side optimization models for transportation design. By measuring the compensating variation for the driving mode, we found that a $9 congestion toll would impact roughly 60 % of the total travelers. As an application of supply-demand integration, we showed that a 50% discount of transit fare could bring a maximum ridership increase of 9402 trips per day under a budget of $50,000 per day.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2025; v1 submitted 22 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Impact of COVID-19 behavioral inertia on reopening strategies for New York City Transit
Authors:
Ding Wang,
Brian Yueshuai He,
Jingqin Gao,
Joseph Y. J. Chow,
Kaan Ozbay,
Shri Iyer
Abstract:
The COVID-19 pandemic has affected travel behaviors and transportation system operations, and cities are grappling with what policies can be effective for a phased reopening shaped by social distancing. A baseline model was previously developed and calibrated for pre-COVID conditions as MATSim-NYC. A new COVID model is calibrated that represents travel behavior during the COVID-19 pandemic by reca…
▽ More
The COVID-19 pandemic has affected travel behaviors and transportation system operations, and cities are grappling with what policies can be effective for a phased reopening shaped by social distancing. A baseline model was previously developed and calibrated for pre-COVID conditions as MATSim-NYC. A new COVID model is calibrated that represents travel behavior during the COVID-19 pandemic by recalibrating the population agendas to include work-from-home and re-estimating the mode choice model for MATSim-NYC to fit observed traffic and transit ridership data. Assuming the change in behavior exhibits inertia during reopening, we analyze the increase in car traffic due to the phased reopen plan guided by the state government of New York. Four reopening phases and two reopening scenarios (with and without transit capacity restrictions) are analyzed. A Phase 4 reopening with 100% transit capacity may only see as much as 73% of pre-COVID ridership and an increase in the number of car trips by as much as 142% of pre-pandemic levels. Limiting transit capacity to 50% would decrease transit ridership further from 73% to 64% while increasing car trips to as much as 143% of pre-pandemic levels. While the increase appears small, the impact on consumer surplus is disproportionately large due to already increased traffic congestion. Many of the trips also get shifted to other modes like micromobility. The findings imply that a transit capacity restriction policy during reopening needs to be accompanied by (1) support for micromobility modes, particularly in non-Manhattan boroughs, and (2) congestion alleviation policies that focus on reducing traffic in Manhattan, such as cordon-based pricing.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2021; v1 submitted 23 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
A many-to-many assignment game and stable outcome algorithm to evaluate collaborative Mobility-as-a-Service platforms
Authors:
Theodoros P. Pantelidis,
Joseph Y. J. Chow,
Saeid Rasulkhani
Abstract:
As Mobility as a Service (MaaS) systems become increasingly popular, travel is changing from unimodal trips to personalized services offered by a platform of mobility operators. Evaluation of MaaS platforms depends on modeling both user route decisions as well as operator service and pricing decisions. We adopt a new paradigm for traffic assignment in a MaaS network of multiple operators using the…
▽ More
As Mobility as a Service (MaaS) systems become increasingly popular, travel is changing from unimodal trips to personalized services offered by a platform of mobility operators. Evaluation of MaaS platforms depends on modeling both user route decisions as well as operator service and pricing decisions. We adopt a new paradigm for traffic assignment in a MaaS network of multiple operators using the concept of stable matching to allocate costs and determine prices offered by operators corresponding to user route choices and operator service choices without resorting to nonconvex bilevel programming formulations. Unlike our prior work, the proposed model allows travelers to make multimodal, multi-operator trips, resulting in stable cost allocations between competing network operators to provide MaaS for users. An algorithm is proposed to efficiently generate stability conditions for the stable outcome model. Extensive computational experiments demonstrate the use of the model to handling pricing responses of MaaS operators in technological and capacity changes, government acquisition, consolidation, and firm entry, using the classic Sioux Falls network. The proposed algorithm replicates the same stability conditions as explicit path enumeration while taking only 17 seconds compared to explicit path enumeration timing out over 2 hours.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2020; v1 submitted 11 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Forecasting e-scooter substitution of direct and access trips by mode and distance
Authors:
Mina Lee,
Joseph Y. J. Chow,
Gyugeun Yoon,
Brian Yueshuai He
Abstract:
An e-scooter trip model is estimated from four U.S. cities: Portland, Austin, Chicago and New York City. A log-log regression model is estimated for e-scooter trips based on user age, population, land area, and the number of scooters. The model predicts 75K daily e-scooter trips in Manhattan for a deployment of 2000 scooters, which translates to 77 million USD in annual revenue. We propose a novel…
▽ More
An e-scooter trip model is estimated from four U.S. cities: Portland, Austin, Chicago and New York City. A log-log regression model is estimated for e-scooter trips based on user age, population, land area, and the number of scooters. The model predicts 75K daily e-scooter trips in Manhattan for a deployment of 2000 scooters, which translates to 77 million USD in annual revenue. We propose a novel nonlinear, multifactor model to break down the number of daily trips by the alternative modes of transportation that they would likely substitute based on statistical similarity. The model parameters reveal a relationship with direct trips of bike, walk, carpool, automobile and taxi as well as access/egress trips with public transit in Manhattan. Our model estimates that e-scooters could replace 32% of carpool; 13% of bike; and 7.2% of taxi trips. The distance structure of revenue from access/egress trips is found to differ from that of other substituted trips.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2021; v1 submitted 21 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
