Showing 1–22 of 22 results for author: Chambers, C P

Ordered Probabilistic Choice

Authors: Christopher P. Chambers, Yusufcan Masatlioglu, Kemal Yildiz

Abstract: We introduce a novel perspective by linking ordered probabilistic choice to copula theory, a mathematical framework for modeling dependencies in multivariate distributions. Each representation of ordered probabilistic choice behavior can be associated with a copula, enabling the analysis of representations through established results from copula theory. We provide functional forms to describe the… ▽ More We introduce a novel perspective by linking ordered probabilistic choice to copula theory, a mathematical framework for modeling dependencies in multivariate distributions. Each representation of ordered probabilistic choice behavior can be associated with a copula, enabling the analysis of representations through established results from copula theory. We provide functional forms to describe the "extremal" representations of an ordered probabilistic choice behavior and their distinctive structural properties. The resulting functional forms act as an "identification method" that uniquely generates heterogeneous choice types and their weights. These results provide valuable tools for analysts to identify micro-level behavioral heterogeneity from macro-level observable data. △ Less

Submitted 8 July, 2025; v1 submitted 1 April, 2025; originally announced April 2025.

Decision theory and the "almost implies near" phenomenon

Authors: Christopher P Chambers, Federico Echenique

Abstract: This paper explores relaxing behavioral axioms in decision theory. We demonstrate that when a preference approximately satisfies a key axiom (like independence or stationarity) its utility representation is close to a standard model. The degree of the axiom's violation quantitatively determines this proximity. Interestingly, we show that in some cases, a relaxed axiom, when combined with another p… ▽ More This paper explores relaxing behavioral axioms in decision theory. We demonstrate that when a preference approximately satisfies a key axiom (like independence or stationarity) its utility representation is close to a standard model. The degree of the axiom's violation quantitatively determines this proximity. Interestingly, we show that in some cases, a relaxed axiom, when combined with another property like homotheticity, still implies an exact representation. We establish these ``almost implies near'' results for choice under risk, uncertainty, and intertemporal choice, connecting axiomatic deviations to the notion of approximate optimization. △ Less

Submitted 10 July, 2025; v1 submitted 10 February, 2025; originally announced February 2025.

Revealed Social Networks

Authors: Christopher P. Chambers, Yusufcan Masatlioglu, Christopher Turansick

Abstract: The linear-in-means model is the standard empirical model of peer effects. Using choice data and exogenous group variation, we first develop a revealed preference style test for the linear-in-means model. This test is formulated as a linear program and can be interpreted as a no money pump condition with an additional incentive compatibility constraint. We then study the identification properties… ▽ More The linear-in-means model is the standard empirical model of peer effects. Using choice data and exogenous group variation, we first develop a revealed preference style test for the linear-in-means model. This test is formulated as a linear program and can be interpreted as a no money pump condition with an additional incentive compatibility constraint. We then study the identification properties of the linear-in-means model. A key takeaway from our analysis is that there is a close relationship between the dimension of the outcome variable and the identifiability of the model. Importantly, when the outcome variable is one-dimensional, failures of identification are generic. On the other hand, when the outcome variable is multi-dimensional, we provide natural conditions under which identification is generic. △ Less

Submitted 13 June, 2025; v1 submitted 5 January, 2025; originally announced January 2025.

Revealed Invariant Preference

Authors: Peter Caradonna, Christopher P. Chambers

Abstract: We consider the problem of rationalizing choice data by a preference satisfying an arbitrary collection of invariance axioms. Examples of such axioms include quasilinearity, homotheticity, independence-type axioms for mixture spaces, constant relative/absolute risk and ambiguity aversion axioms, stationarity for dated rewards or consumption streams, separability, and many others. We provide necess… ▽ More We consider the problem of rationalizing choice data by a preference satisfying an arbitrary collection of invariance axioms. Examples of such axioms include quasilinearity, homotheticity, independence-type axioms for mixture spaces, constant relative/absolute risk and ambiguity aversion axioms, stationarity for dated rewards or consumption streams, separability, and many others. We provide necessary and sufficient conditions for invariant rationalizability via a novel approach which relies on tools from the theoretical computer science literature on automated theorem proving. We also establish a generalization of the Dushnik-Miller theorem, which we use to give a complete description of the out-of-sample predictions generated by the data under any such collection of axioms. △ Less

Submitted 8 August, 2024; originally announced August 2024.

Manipulation of Belief Aggregation Rules

Authors: Christopher P. Chambers, Federico Echenique, Takashi Hayashi

Abstract: This paper studies manipulation of belief aggregation rules in the setting where the society first collects individual's probabilistic opinions and then solves a public portfolio choice problem with common utility based on the aggregate belief. First, we show that belief reporting in Nash equilibrium under the linear opinion pool and log utility is identified as the profile of state-contingent w… ▽ More This paper studies manipulation of belief aggregation rules in the setting where the society first collects individual's probabilistic opinions and then solves a public portfolio choice problem with common utility based on the aggregate belief. First, we show that belief reporting in Nash equilibrium under the linear opinion pool and log utility is identified as the profile of state-contingent wealth shares in parimutuel equilibrium with risk-neutral preference. Then we characterize belief aggregation rules which are Nash-implementable. We provide a necessary and essentially sufficient condition for implementability, which is independent of the common risk attitude. △ Less

Submitted 2 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

The Limits of Identification in Discrete Choice

Authors: Christopher P. Chambers, Christopher Turansick

Abstract: This paper uncovers tight bounds on the number of preferences permissible in identified random utility models. We show that as the number of alternatives in a discrete choice model becomes large, the fraction of preferences admissible in an identified model rapidly tends to zero. We propose a novel sufficient condition ensuring identification, which is strictly weaker than some of those existing i… ▽ More This paper uncovers tight bounds on the number of preferences permissible in identified random utility models. We show that as the number of alternatives in a discrete choice model becomes large, the fraction of preferences admissible in an identified model rapidly tends to zero. We propose a novel sufficient condition ensuring identification, which is strictly weaker than some of those existing in the literature. While this sufficient condition reaches our upper bound, an example demonstrates that this condition is not necessary for identification. Using our new condition, we show that the classic ``Latin Square" example from social choice theory is identified from stochastic choice data. △ Less

Submitted 2 December, 2024; v1 submitted 20 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Success functions in large contests

Authors: Yaron Azrieli, Christopher P. Chambers

Abstract: We consider contests with a large set (continuum) of participants and axiomatize contest success functions that arise when performance is composed of both effort and a random element, and when winners are those whose performance exceeds a cutoff determined by a market clearing condition. A co-monotonicity property is essentially all that is needed for a representation in the general case, but sign… ▽ More We consider contests with a large set (continuum) of participants and axiomatize contest success functions that arise when performance is composed of both effort and a random element, and when winners are those whose performance exceeds a cutoff determined by a market clearing condition. A co-monotonicity property is essentially all that is needed for a representation in the general case, but significantly stronger conditions must hold to obtain an additive structure. We illustrate the usefulness of this framework by revisiting some of the classic questions in the contests literature. △ Less

Submitted 7 May, 2024; v1 submitted 11 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Coherent Distorted Beliefs

Authors: Christopher P. Chambers, Yusufcan Masatlioglu, Collin Raymond

Abstract: Many models of economics assume that individuals distort objective probabilities. We propose a simple consistency condition on distortion functions, which we term distortion coherence, that ensures that the function commutes with conditioning on an event. We show that distortion coherence restricts belief distortions to have a particular function form: power-weighted distortions, where distorted b… ▽ More Many models of economics assume that individuals distort objective probabilities. We propose a simple consistency condition on distortion functions, which we term distortion coherence, that ensures that the function commutes with conditioning on an event. We show that distortion coherence restricts belief distortions to have a particular function form: power-weighted distortions, where distorted beliefs are proportional to the original beliefs raised to a power and weighted by a state-specific value. We generalize our findings to allow for distortions of the probabilities assigned to both states and signals, which nests the functional forms widely used in studying probabilistic biases (e.g., Grether, 1980 and Benjamin, 2019). We show how coherent distorted beliefs are tightly related to several extant models of motivated beliefs: they are the outcome of maximizing anticipated expected utility subject to a generalized Kullback-Liebler cost of distortion. Moreover, in the domain of lottery choice, we link coherent distortions to explanations of non-expected utility like the Allais paradox: individuals who maximize subjective expected utility maximizers conditional on coherent distorted beliefs are equivalent to the weighted utility maximizers studied by Chew [1983]. △ Less

Submitted 6 June, 2024; v1 submitted 15 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Linearity of Aggregate Production Functions

Authors: Christopher P. Chambers, Alexis Akira Toda

Abstract: We prove that when individual firms employ constant-returns-to-scale production functions, the aggregate production function defined by the maximum achievable total output given total inputs is always linear on some part of the domain. Our result provides a microfoundation for the linear production function. We prove that when individual firms employ constant-returns-to-scale production functions, the aggregate production function defined by the maximum achievable total output given total inputs is always linear on some part of the domain. Our result provides a microfoundation for the linear production function. △ Less

Submitted 27 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

A duality between utility transforms and probability distortions

Authors: Christopher P. Chambers, Peng Liu, Ruodu Wang

Abstract: In this paper, we establish a mathematical duality between utility transforms and probability distortions. These transforms play a central role in decision under risk by forming the foundation for the classic theories of expected utility, dual utility, and rank-dependent utility. Our main results establish that probability distortions are characterized by commutation with utility transforms, and u… ▽ More In this paper, we establish a mathematical duality between utility transforms and probability distortions. These transforms play a central role in decision under risk by forming the foundation for the classic theories of expected utility, dual utility, and rank-dependent utility. Our main results establish that probability distortions are characterized by commutation with utility transforms, and utility transforms are characterized by commutation with probability distortions. These results require no additional conditions, and hence each class can be axiomatized with only one property. Moreover, under monotonicity, rank-dependent utility transforms can be characterized by set commutation with either utility transforms or probability distortions. △ Less

Submitted 19 March, 2024; v1 submitted 25 August, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

Comments: 24 pages

MSC Class: 91B70

Multiple Adjusted Quantiles

Authors: Christopher P. Chambers, Alan D. Miller

Abstract: We cardinally and ordinally rank distribution functions (CDFs). We present a new class of statistics, maximal adjusted quantiles, and show that a statistic is invariant with respect to cardinal shifts, preserves least upper bounds with respect to the first order stochastic dominance relation, and is lower semicontinuous if and only if it is a maximal adjusted quantile. A dual result is provided, a… ▽ More We cardinally and ordinally rank distribution functions (CDFs). We present a new class of statistics, maximal adjusted quantiles, and show that a statistic is invariant with respect to cardinal shifts, preserves least upper bounds with respect to the first order stochastic dominance relation, and is lower semicontinuous if and only if it is a maximal adjusted quantile. A dual result is provided, as are ordinal results. Preservation of least upper bounds is given several interpretations, including one that relates to changes in tax brackets, and one that relates to valuing options composed of two assets. △ Less

Submitted 10 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Non-diversified portfolios with subjective expected utility

Authors: Christopher P. Chambers, Georgios Gerasimou

Abstract: Diversification is the typical investment strategy of risk-averse agents. However, non-diversified positions that allocate all resources to a single asset, state of the world or revenue stream are common too. We show that whenever finitely many non-diversified demands under uncertainty are compatible with risk-averse subjective expected utility maximization under strictly positive beliefs, they ar… ▽ More Diversification is the typical investment strategy of risk-averse agents. However, non-diversified positions that allocate all resources to a single asset, state of the world or revenue stream are common too. We show that whenever finitely many non-diversified demands under uncertainty are compatible with risk-averse subjective expected utility maximization under strictly positive beliefs, they are also rationalizable under the same beliefs by many qualitatively distinct risk-averse as well as risk-neutral and risk-seeking preferences. △ Less

Submitted 17 October, 2024; v1 submitted 17 April, 2023; originally announced April 2023.

A Note on Invariant Extensions of Preorders

Authors: Peter Caradonna, Christopher P. Chambers

Abstract: We consider the problem of extending an acyclic binary relation that is invariant under a given family of transformations into an invariant preference. We show that when a family of transformations is commutative, every acyclic invariant binary relation extends. We find that, in general, the set of extensions agree on the ranking of many pairs that (i) are unranked by the original relation, and (i… ▽ More We consider the problem of extending an acyclic binary relation that is invariant under a given family of transformations into an invariant preference. We show that when a family of transformations is commutative, every acyclic invariant binary relation extends. We find that, in general, the set of extensions agree on the ranking of many pairs that (i) are unranked by the original relation, and (ii) cannot be ranked by invariance or transitivity considerations alone. We interpret these additional implications as the out-of-sample predictions generated by invariance, and study their structure. △ Less

Submitted 8 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Recovering utility

Authors: Christopher P. Chambers, Federico Echenique, Nicolas S. Lambert

Abstract: We provide sufficient conditions under which a utility function may be recovered from a finite choice experiment. Identification, as is commonly understood in decision theory, is not enough. We provide a general recoverability result that is widely applicable to modern theories of choice under uncertainty. Key is to allow for a monetary environment, in which an objective notion of monotonicity is… ▽ More We provide sufficient conditions under which a utility function may be recovered from a finite choice experiment. Identification, as is commonly understood in decision theory, is not enough. We provide a general recoverability result that is widely applicable to modern theories of choice under uncertainty. Key is to allow for a monetary environment, in which an objective notion of monotonicity is meaningful. In such environments, we show that subjective expected utility, as well as variational preferences, and other parametrizations of utilities over uncertain acts are recoverable. We also consider utility recovery in a statistical model with noise and random deviations from utility maximization. △ Less

Submitted 26 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Haves and Have-Nots: A Theory of Economic Sufficientarianism

Authors: Christopher P. Chambers, Siming Ye

Abstract: We introduce a generalization of the concept of sufficientarianism, intended to rank allocations involving multiple consumption goods. In ranking allocations of goods for a fixed society of agents, sufficientarianism posits that allocations are compared according to the number of individuals whose consumption is deemed sufficient. We base our analysis on a novel ethical concept, which we term suff… ▽ More We introduce a generalization of the concept of sufficientarianism, intended to rank allocations involving multiple consumption goods. In ranking allocations of goods for a fixed society of agents, sufficientarianism posits that allocations are compared according to the number of individuals whose consumption is deemed sufficient. We base our analysis on a novel ethical concept, which we term sufficientarian judgment. Sufficientarian judgment asserts that if in starting from an allocation in which all agents have identical consumption, a change in one agent's consumption hurts society, then there is no change in any other agent's consumption which could subsequently benefit society. Sufficientarianism is shown to be equivalent to sufficientarian judgment, symmetry, and separability. We investigate our axioms in an abstract environment, and in specific economic environments. Finally, we argue formally that sufficientarian judgment is closely related to the leximin principle. △ Less

Submitted 18 September, 2023; v1 submitted 20 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Empirical Welfare Economics

Authors: Christopher P Chambers, Federico Echenique

Abstract: Welfare economics relies on access to agents' utility functions: we revisit classical questions in welfare economics, assuming access to data on agents' past choices instead of their utilities. Our main result considers the existence of utilities that render a given allocation Pareto optimal. We show that a candidate allocation is efficient for some utilities consistent with the choice data if and… ▽ More Welfare economics relies on access to agents' utility functions: we revisit classical questions in welfare economics, assuming access to data on agents' past choices instead of their utilities. Our main result considers the existence of utilities that render a given allocation Pareto optimal. We show that a candidate allocation is efficient for some utilities consistent with the choice data if and only if it is efficient for an incomplete relation derived from the revealed preference relations and convexity. Similar ideas are used to make counterfactual choices for a single consumer, policy comparisons by the Kaldor criterion, and offer bounds on the degree of inefficiency in a Pareto suboptimal allocation. △ Less

Submitted 24 June, 2024; v1 submitted 6 August, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

Correlated Choice

Authors: Christopher P. Chambers, Yusufcan Masatlioglu, Christopher Turansick

Abstract: We study random joint choice rules, allowing for interdependence of choice across budgets. These capture random choice by multiple agents, or a single agent across goods or time periods. Our interest is in separable choice rules, where each agent can be thought of as acting independently of the other. A random joint choice rule satisfies marginality if it induces well defined marginal random choic… ▽ More We study random joint choice rules, allowing for interdependence of choice across budgets. These capture random choice by multiple agents, or a single agent across goods or time periods. Our interest is in separable choice rules, where each agent can be thought of as acting independently of the other. A random joint choice rule satisfies marginality if it induces well defined marginal random choice rules. We offer two characterizations of random joint choice rules satisfying marginality in terms of separable choice rules. While marginality is a necessary condition for separability, we show that it fails to be sufficient. We provide an additional condition on the marginal choice rules which, along with marginality, is sufficient for separability. △ Less

Submitted 11 October, 2022; v1 submitted 8 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Comments: 31 pages

Decreasing Impatience

Authors: Christopher P. Chambers, Federico Echenique, Alan D. Miller

Abstract: We characterize decreasing impatience, a common behavioral phenomenon in intertemporal choice. Discount factors that display decreasing impatience are characterized through a convexit y axiom for investments at fixed interest rates. Then we show that they are equivalent to a geometric average of generalized quasi-hype rbolic discount rates. Finally, they emerge through parimutuel preference aggreg… ▽ More We characterize decreasing impatience, a common behavioral phenomenon in intertemporal choice. Discount factors that display decreasing impatience are characterized through a convexit y axiom for investments at fixed interest rates. Then we show that they are equivalent to a geometric average of generalized quasi-hype rbolic discount rates. Finally, they emerge through parimutuel preference aggregation of exponential discount factors. △ Less

Submitted 4 August, 2022; v1 submitted 4 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Recovering Preferences from Finite Data

Authors: Christopher P. Chambers, Federico Echenique, Nicolas Lambert

Abstract: We study preferences estimated from finite choice experiments and provide sufficient conditions for convergence to a unique underlying "true" preference. Our conditions are weak, and therefore valid in a wide range of economic environments. We develop applications to expected utility theory, choice over consumption bundles, menu choice and intertemporal consumption. Our framework unifies the revea… ▽ More We study preferences estimated from finite choice experiments and provide sufficient conditions for convergence to a unique underlying "true" preference. Our conditions are weak, and therefore valid in a wide range of economic environments. We develop applications to expected utility theory, choice over consumption bundles, menu choice and intertemporal consumption. Our framework unifies the revealed preference tradition with models that allow for errors. △ Less

Submitted 30 October, 2020; v1 submitted 12 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Spherical Preferences

Authors: Christopher P. Chambers, Federico Echenique

Abstract: We introduce and study the property of orthogonal independence, a restricted additivity axiom applying when alternatives are orthogonal. The axiom requires that the preference for one marginal change over another should be maintained after each marginal change has been shifted in a direction that is orthogonal to both. We show that continuous preferences satisfy orthogonal independence if and on… ▽ More We introduce and study the property of orthogonal independence, a restricted additivity axiom applying when alternatives are orthogonal. The axiom requires that the preference for one marginal change over another should be maintained after each marginal change has been shifted in a direction that is orthogonal to both. We show that continuous preferences satisfy orthogonal independence if and only if they are spherical: their indifference curves are spheres with the same center, with preference being "monotone" either away or towards the center. Spherical preferences include linear preferences as a special (limiting) case. We discuss different applications to economic and political environments. Our result delivers Euclidean preferences in models of spatial voting, quadratic welfare aggregation in social choice, and expected utility in models of choice under uncertainty. △ Less

Submitted 12 February, 2020; v1 submitted 8 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

MSC Class: 91B02; 62P20

A characterization of "Phelpsian" statistical discrimination

Authors: Christopher P. Chambers, Federico Echenique

Abstract: We establish that statistical discrimination is possible if and only if it is impossible to uniquely identify the signal structure observed by an employer from a realized empirical distribution of skills. The impossibility of statistical discrimination is shown to be equivalent to the existence of a fair, skill-dependent, remuneration for workers. Finally, we connect the statistical discrimination… ▽ More We establish that statistical discrimination is possible if and only if it is impossible to uniquely identify the signal structure observed by an employer from a realized empirical distribution of skills. The impossibility of statistical discrimination is shown to be equivalent to the existence of a fair, skill-dependent, remuneration for workers. Finally, we connect the statistical discrimination literature to Bayesian persuasion, establishing that if discrimination is absent, then the optimal signaling problem results in a linear payoff function (as well as a kind of converse). △ Less

Submitted 3 August, 2018; originally announced August 2018.

MSC Class: 91B15

Preference Identification

Authors: Christopher P. Chambers, Federico Echenique, Nicolas S. Lambert

Abstract: An experimenter seeks to learn a subject's preference relation. The experimenter produces pairs of alternatives. For each pair, the subject is asked to choose. We argue that, in general, large but finite data do not give close approximations of the subject's preference, even when the limiting (countably infinite) data are enough to infer the preference perfectly. We provide sufficient conditions o… ▽ More An experimenter seeks to learn a subject's preference relation. The experimenter produces pairs of alternatives. For each pair, the subject is asked to choose. We argue that, in general, large but finite data do not give close approximations of the subject's preference, even when the limiting (countably infinite) data are enough to infer the preference perfectly. We provide sufficient conditions on the set of alternatives, preferences, and sequences of pairs so that the observation of finitely many choices allows the experimenter to learn the subject's preference with arbitrary precision. While preferences can be identified under our sufficient conditions, we show that it is harder to identify utility functions. We illustrate our results with several examples, including consumer choice, expected utility, and preferences in the Anscombe-Aumann model. △ Less

Submitted 30 July, 2018; originally announced July 2018.

MSC Class: 91B08