-
Verification of Quantum Circuits through Barrier Certificates using a Scenario Approach
Authors:
Siwei Hu,
Victor Lopata,
Sadegh Soudjani,
Paolo Zuliani
Abstract:
In recent years, various techniques have been explored for the verification of quantum circuits, including the use of barrier certificates, mathematical tools capable of demonstrating the correctness of such systems. These certificates ensure that, starting from initial states and applying the system's dynamics, the system will never reach undesired states. In this paper, we propose a methodology…
▽ More
In recent years, various techniques have been explored for the verification of quantum circuits, including the use of barrier certificates, mathematical tools capable of demonstrating the correctness of such systems. These certificates ensure that, starting from initial states and applying the system's dynamics, the system will never reach undesired states. In this paper, we propose a methodology for synthesizing such certificates for quantum circuits using a scenario-based approach, for both finite and infinite time horizons. In addition, our approach can handle uncertainty in the initial states and in the system's dynamics. We present several case studies on quantum circuits, comparing the performance of different types of barrier certificate and analyzing which one is most suitable for each case.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2025; v1 submitted 9 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
High-level quantum algorithm programming using Silq
Authors:
Viktorija Bezganovic,
Marco Lewis,
Sadegh Soudjani,
Paolo Zuliani
Abstract:
Quantum computing, with its vast potential, is fundamentally shaped by the intricacies of quantum mechanics, which both empower and constrain its capabilities. The development of a universal, robust quantum programming language has emerged as a key research focus in this rapidly evolving field. This paper explores Silq, a recent high-level quantum programming language, highlighting its strengths a…
▽ More
Quantum computing, with its vast potential, is fundamentally shaped by the intricacies of quantum mechanics, which both empower and constrain its capabilities. The development of a universal, robust quantum programming language has emerged as a key research focus in this rapidly evolving field. This paper explores Silq, a recent high-level quantum programming language, highlighting its strengths and unique features. We aim to share our insights on designing and implementing high-level quantum algorithms using Silq, demonstrating its practical applications and advantages for quantum programming.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2025; v1 submitted 16 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Verification of Quantum Circuits through Discrete-Time Barrier Certificates
Authors:
Marco Lewis,
Sadegh Soudjani,
Paolo Zuliani
Abstract:
Current methods for verifying quantum computers are predominately based on interactive or automatic theorem provers. Considering that quantum computers are dynamical in nature, this paper employs and extends the concepts from the verification of dynamical systems to verify properties of quantum circuits. Our main contribution is to propose k-inductive barrier certificates over complex variables an…
▽ More
Current methods for verifying quantum computers are predominately based on interactive or automatic theorem provers. Considering that quantum computers are dynamical in nature, this paper employs and extends the concepts from the verification of dynamical systems to verify properties of quantum circuits. Our main contribution is to propose k-inductive barrier certificates over complex variables and show how to compute them using Hermitian Sum of Squares optimization. We apply this new technique to verify properties of different quantum circuits.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
T-Count Optimizing Genetic Algorithm for Quantum State Preparation
Authors:
Andrew Wright,
Marco Lewis,
Paolo Zuliani,
Sadegh Soudjani
Abstract:
Quantum state preparation is a crucial process within numerous quantum algorithms, and the need for efficient initialization of quantum registers is ever increasing as demand for useful quantum computing grows. The problem arises as the number of qubits to be initialized grows, the circuits required to implement the desired state also exponentially increase in size leading to loss of fidelity to n…
▽ More
Quantum state preparation is a crucial process within numerous quantum algorithms, and the need for efficient initialization of quantum registers is ever increasing as demand for useful quantum computing grows. The problem arises as the number of qubits to be initialized grows, the circuits required to implement the desired state also exponentially increase in size leading to loss of fidelity to noise. This is mainly due to the susceptibility to environmental effects of the non-Clifford T gate, whose use should thus be reduced as much as possible. In this paper, we present and utilize a genetic algorithm for state preparation circuits consisting of gates from the Clifford + T gate set and optimize them in T-Count as to reduce the impact of noise. Whilst the method presented here does not always produce the most accurate circuits in terms of fidelity, it can generate high-fidelity, non-trivial quantum states such as quantum Fourier transform states. In addition, our algorithm does automatically generate fault tolerantly implementable solutions where the number of the most error prone components is reduced. We present an evaluation of the algorithm when trialed against preparing random, Poisson probability distribution, W, GHZ, and quantum Fourier transform states. We also experimentally demonstrate the scalability issues as qubit count increases, which highlights the need for further optimization of the search process.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Automated Verification of Silq Quantum Programs using SMT Solvers
Authors:
Marco Lewis,
Paolo Zuliani,
Sadegh Soudjani
Abstract:
We present SilVer (Silq Verification), an automated tool for verifying behaviors of quantum programs written in Silq, which is a high-level programming language for quantum computing. The goal of the verification is to ensure correctness of the Silq quantum program against user-defined specifications using SMT solvers. We introduce a programming model that is based on a quantum RAM-style computer…
▽ More
We present SilVer (Silq Verification), an automated tool for verifying behaviors of quantum programs written in Silq, which is a high-level programming language for quantum computing. The goal of the verification is to ensure correctness of the Silq quantum program against user-defined specifications using SMT solvers. We introduce a programming model that is based on a quantum RAM-style computer as an interface between Silq programs and SMT proof obligations, allowing for control of quantum operations using both classical and quantum conditions. Additionally, users can employ measurement flags within the specification to easily specify conditions that measurement results require to satisfy for being a valid behavior. We provide case studies on the verification of generating entangled states and multiple oracle-based algorithms.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Safe Reach Set Computation via Neural Barrier Certificates
Authors:
Alessandro Abate,
Sergiy Bogomolov,
Alec Edwards,
Kostiantyn Potomkin,
Sadegh Soudjani,
Paolo Zuliani
Abstract:
We present a novel technique for online safety verification of autonomous systems, which performs reachability analysis efficiently for both bounded and unbounded horizons by employing neural barrier certificates. Our approach uses barrier certificates given by parameterized neural networks that depend on a given initial set, unsafe sets, and time horizon. Such networks are trained efficiently off…
▽ More
We present a novel technique for online safety verification of autonomous systems, which performs reachability analysis efficiently for both bounded and unbounded horizons by employing neural barrier certificates. Our approach uses barrier certificates given by parameterized neural networks that depend on a given initial set, unsafe sets, and time horizon. Such networks are trained efficiently offline using system simulations sampled from regions of the state space. We then employ a meta-neural network to generalize the barrier certificates to state space regions that are outside the training set. These certificates are generated and validated online as sound over-approximations of the reachable states, thus either ensuring system safety or activating appropriate alternative actions in unsafe scenarios. We demonstrate our technique on case studies from linear models to nonlinear control-dependent models for online autonomous driving scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Formal Verification of Quantum Programs: Theory, Tools and Challenges
Authors:
Marco Lewis,
Sadegh Soudjani,
Paolo Zuliani
Abstract:
Over the past 27 years, quantum computing has seen a huge rise in interest from both academia and industry. At the current rate, quantum computers are growing in size rapidly backed up by the increase of research in the field. Significant efforts are being made to improve the reliability of quantum hardware and to develop suitable software to program quantum computers. In contrast, the verificatio…
▽ More
Over the past 27 years, quantum computing has seen a huge rise in interest from both academia and industry. At the current rate, quantum computers are growing in size rapidly backed up by the increase of research in the field. Significant efforts are being made to improve the reliability of quantum hardware and to develop suitable software to program quantum computers. In contrast, the verification of quantum programs has received relatively less attention. Verifying programs is especially important in the quantum setting due to how difficult it is to program complex algorithms correctly on resource-constrained and error-prone quantum hardware. Research into creating verification frameworks for quantum programs has seen recent development, with a variety of tools implemented using a collection of theoretical ideas. This survey aims to be a short introduction into the area of formal verification of quantum programs, bringing together theory and tools developed to date. Further, this survey examines some of the challenges that the field may face in the future, namely the development of complex quantum algorithms.
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2022; v1 submitted 4 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Automated Synthesis of Safe Digital Controllers for Sampled-Data Stochastic Nonlinear Systems
Authors:
Fedor Shmarov,
Sadegh Soudjani,
Nicola Paoletti,
Ezio Bartocci,
Shan Lin,
Scott A. Smolka,
Paolo Zuliani
Abstract:
We present a new method for the automated synthesis of digital controllers with formal safety guarantees for systems with nonlinear dynamics, noisy output measurements, and stochastic disturbances. Our method derives digital controllers such that the corresponding closed-loop system, modeled as a sampled-data stochastic control system, satisfies a safety specification with probability above a give…
▽ More
We present a new method for the automated synthesis of digital controllers with formal safety guarantees for systems with nonlinear dynamics, noisy output measurements, and stochastic disturbances. Our method derives digital controllers such that the corresponding closed-loop system, modeled as a sampled-data stochastic control system, satisfies a safety specification with probability above a given threshold. The proposed synthesis method alternates between two steps: generation of a candidate controller pc, and verification of the candidate. pc is found by maximizing a Monte Carlo estimate of the safety probability, and by using a non-validated ODE solver for simulating the system. Such a candidate is therefore sub-optimal but can be generated very rapidly. To rule out unstable candidate controllers, we prove and utilize Lyapunov's indirect method for instability of sampled-data nonlinear systems. In the subsequent verification step, we use a validated solver based on SMT (Satisfiability Modulo Theories) to compute a numerically and statistically valid confidence interval for the safety probability of pc. If the probability so obtained is not above the threshold, we expand the search space for candidates by increasing the controller degree. We evaluate our technique on three case studies: an artificial pancreas model, a powertrain control model, and a quadruple-tank process.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Full version: An evaluation of estimation techniques for probabilistic reachability
Authors:
Mariia Vasileva,
Paolo Zuliani
Abstract:
We evaluate numerically-precise Monte Carlo (MC), Quasi-Monte Carlo (QMC) and Randomised Quasi-Monte Carlo (RQMC) methods for computing probabilistic reachability in hybrid systems with random parameters. Computing reachability probability amounts to computing (multidimensional) integrals. In particular, we pay attention to QMC methods due to their theoretical benefits in convergence speed with re…
▽ More
We evaluate numerically-precise Monte Carlo (MC), Quasi-Monte Carlo (QMC) and Randomised Quasi-Monte Carlo (RQMC) methods for computing probabilistic reachability in hybrid systems with random parameters. Computing reachability probability amounts to computing (multidimensional) integrals. In particular, we pay attention to QMC methods due to their theoretical benefits in convergence speed with respect to the MC method. The Koksma-Hlawka inequality is a standard result that bounds the approximation of an integral by QMC techniques. However, it is not useful in practice because it depends on the variation of the integrand function, which is in general difficult to compute. The question arises whether it is possible to apply statistical or empirical methods for estimating the approximation error. In this paper we compare a number of interval estimation techniques based on the Central Limit Theorem (CLT), and we also introduce a new approach based on the CLT for computing confidence intervals for probability near the borders of the [0,1] interval. Based on our analysis, we provide justification for the use of the developed approach and suggest usage guidelines for probability estimation techniques.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2018; v1 submitted 9 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Verifying Quantum Programs: From Quipper to QPMC
Authors:
Linda Anticoli,
Carla Piazza,
Leonardo Taglialegne,
Paolo Zuliani
Abstract:
In this paper we present a translation from the quantum programming language Quipper to the QPMC model checker, with the main aim of verifying Quipper programs. Quipper is an embedded functional programming language for quantum computation. It is above all a circuit description language, for this reason it uses the vector state formalism and its main purpose is to make circuit implementation easy…
▽ More
In this paper we present a translation from the quantum programming language Quipper to the QPMC model checker, with the main aim of verifying Quipper programs. Quipper is an embedded functional programming language for quantum computation. It is above all a circuit description language, for this reason it uses the vector state formalism and its main purpose is to make circuit implementation easy providing high level operations for circuit manipulation. Quipper provides both an high-level circuit building interface and a simulator. QPMC is a model checker for quantum protocols based on the density matrix formalism. QPMC extends the probabilistic model checker IscasMC allowing to formally verify properties specified in the temporal logic QCTL on Quantum Markov Chains. We implemented and tested our translation on several quantum algorithms, including Grover's quantum search.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Automated Synthesis of Safe and Robust PID Controllers for Stochastic Hybrid Systems
Authors:
Fedor Shmarov,
Nicola Paoletti,
Ezio Bartocci,
Shan Lin,
Scott A. Smolka,
Paolo Zuliani
Abstract:
We present a new method for the automated synthesis of safe and robust Proportional-Integral-Derivative (PID) controllers for stochastic hybrid systems. Despite their widespread use in industry, no automated method currently exists for deriving a PID controller (or any other type of controller, for that matter) with safety and performance guarantees for such a general class of systems. In particul…
▽ More
We present a new method for the automated synthesis of safe and robust Proportional-Integral-Derivative (PID) controllers for stochastic hybrid systems. Despite their widespread use in industry, no automated method currently exists for deriving a PID controller (or any other type of controller, for that matter) with safety and performance guarantees for such a general class of systems. In particular, we consider hybrid systems with nonlinear dynamics (Lipschitz-continuous ordinary differential equations) and random parameters, and we synthesize PID controllers such that the resulting closed-loop systems satisfy safety and performance constraints given as probabilistic bounded reachability properties. Our technique leverages SMT solvers over the reals and nonlinear differential equations to provide formal guarantees that the synthesized controllers satisfy such properties. These controllers are also robust by design since they minimize the probability of reaching an unsafe state in the presence of random disturbances. We apply our approach to the problem of insulin regulation for type 1 diabetes, synthesizing controllers with robust responses to large random meal disturbances, thereby enabling them to maintain blood glucose levels within healthy, safe ranges.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2017; v1 submitted 17 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
ProbReach: Verified Probabilistic Delta-Reachability for Stochastic Hybrid Systems
Authors:
Fedor Shmarov,
Paolo Zuliani
Abstract:
We present ProbReach, a tool for verifying probabilistic reachability for stochastic hybrid systems, i.e., computing the probability that the system reaches an unsafe region of the state space. In particular, ProbReach will compute an arbitrarily small interval which is guaranteed to contain the required probability. Standard (non-probabilistic) reachability is undecidable even for linear hybrid s…
▽ More
We present ProbReach, a tool for verifying probabilistic reachability for stochastic hybrid systems, i.e., computing the probability that the system reaches an unsafe region of the state space. In particular, ProbReach will compute an arbitrarily small interval which is guaranteed to contain the required probability. Standard (non-probabilistic) reachability is undecidable even for linear hybrid systems. In ProbReach we adopt the weaker notion of delta-reachability, in which the unsafe region is overapproximated by a user-defined parameter (delta). This choice leads to false alarms, but also makes the reachability problem decidable for virtually any hybrid system. In ProbReach we have implemented a probabilistic version of delta-reachability that is suited for hybrid systems whose stochastic behaviour is given in terms of random initial conditions. In this paper we introduce the capabilities of ProbReach, give an overview of the parallel implementation, and present results for several benchmarks involving highly non-linear hybrid systems.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2015; v1 submitted 29 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Towards Personalized Prostate Cancer Therapy Using Delta-Reachability Analysis
Authors:
Bing Liu,
Soonho Kong,
Sicun Gao,
Paolo Zuliani,
Edmund M. Clarke
Abstract:
Recent clinical studies suggest that the efficacy of hormone therapy for prostate cancer depends on the characteristics of individual patients. In this paper, we develop a computational framework for identifying patient-specific androgen ablation therapy schedules for postponing the potential cancer relapse. We model the population dynamics of heterogeneous prostate cancer cells in response to and…
▽ More
Recent clinical studies suggest that the efficacy of hormone therapy for prostate cancer depends on the characteristics of individual patients. In this paper, we develop a computational framework for identifying patient-specific androgen ablation therapy schedules for postponing the potential cancer relapse. We model the population dynamics of heterogeneous prostate cancer cells in response to androgen suppression as a nonlinear hybrid automaton. We estimate personalized kinetic parameters to characterize patients and employ $δ$-reachability analysis to predict patient-specific therapeutic strategies. The results show that our methods are promising and may lead to a prognostic tool for personalized cancer therapy.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2015; v1 submitted 27 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Parameter Synthesis for Cardiac Cell Hybrid Models Using Delta-Decisions
Authors:
Bing Liu,
Soonho Kong,
Sicun Gao,
Paolo Zuliani,
Edmund M. Clarke
Abstract:
A central problem in systems biology is to identify parameter values such that a biological model satisfies some behavioral constraints (\eg, time series). In this paper we focus on parameter synthesis for hybrid (continuous/discrete) models, as many biological systems can possess multiple operational modes with specific continuous dynamics in each mode. These biological systems are naturally mode…
▽ More
A central problem in systems biology is to identify parameter values such that a biological model satisfies some behavioral constraints (\eg, time series). In this paper we focus on parameter synthesis for hybrid (continuous/discrete) models, as many biological systems can possess multiple operational modes with specific continuous dynamics in each mode. These biological systems are naturally modeled as hybrid automata, most often with nonlinear continuous dynamics. However, hybrid automata are notoriously hard to analyze --- even simple reachability for hybrid systems with linear differential dynamics is an undecidable problem. In this paper we present a parameter synthesis framework based on $δ$-complete decision procedures that sidesteps undecidability. We demonstrate our method on two highly nonlinear hybrid models of the cardiac cell action potential. The results show that our parameter synthesis framework is convenient and efficient, and it enabled us to select a suitable model to study and identify crucial parameter ranges related to cardiac disorders.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2014; v1 submitted 6 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Probabilistic bounded reachability for hybrid systems with continuous nondeterministic and probabilistic parameters
Authors:
Fedor Shmarov,
Paolo Zuliani
Abstract:
We develop an algorithm for computing bounded reachability probability for hybrid systems, i.e., the probability that the system reaches an unsafe region within a finite number of discrete transitions. In particular, we focus on hybrid systems with continuous dynamics given by solutions of nonlinear ordinary differential equations (with possibly nondeterministic initial conditions and parameters),…
▽ More
We develop an algorithm for computing bounded reachability probability for hybrid systems, i.e., the probability that the system reaches an unsafe region within a finite number of discrete transitions. In particular, we focus on hybrid systems with continuous dynamics given by solutions of nonlinear ordinary differential equations (with possibly nondeterministic initial conditions and parameters), and probabilistic behaviour given by initial parameters distributed as continuous (with possibly infinite support) and discrete random variables. Our approach is to define an appropriate relaxation of the (undecidable) reachability problem, so that it can be solved by $δ$-complete decision procedures. In particular, for systems with continuous random parameters only, we develop a validated integration procedure which computes an arbitrarily small interval that is guaranteed to contain the reachability probability. In the more general case of systems with both nondeterministic and probabilistic parameters, our procedure computes a guaranteed enclosure for the range of reachability probabilities. We have applied our approach to a number of nonlinear hybrid models and validated the results by comparison with Monte Carlo simulation.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2015; v1 submitted 7 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
Statistical Model Checking for Biological Applications
Authors:
Paolo Zuliani
Abstract:
In this paper we survey recent work on the use of statistical model checking techniques for biological applications. We begin with an overview of the basic modelling techniques for biochemical reactions and their corresponding stochastic simulation algorithm - the Gillespie algorithm. We continue by giving a brief description of the relation between stochastic models and continuous (ordinary diffe…
▽ More
In this paper we survey recent work on the use of statistical model checking techniques for biological applications. We begin with an overview of the basic modelling techniques for biochemical reactions and their corresponding stochastic simulation algorithm - the Gillespie algorithm. We continue by giving a brief description of the relation between stochastic models and continuous (ordinary differential equation) models. Next we present a literature survey, divided in two general areas. In the first area we focus on works addressing verification of biological models, while in the second area we focus on papers tackling the parameter synthesis problem. We conclude with some open problems and directions for further research.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2014; v1 submitted 12 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
SReach: A Bounded Model Checker for Stochastic Hybrid Systems
Authors:
Qinsi Wang,
Paolo Zuliani,
Soonho Kong,
Sicun Gao,
Edmund M. Clarke
Abstract:
In this paper we describe a new tool, SReach, which solves probabilistic bounded reachability problems for two classes of stochastic hybrid systems. The first one is (nonlinear) hybrid automata with parametric uncertainty. The second one is probabilistic hybrid automata with additional randomness for both transition probabilities and variable resets. Standard approaches to reachability problems fo…
▽ More
In this paper we describe a new tool, SReach, which solves probabilistic bounded reachability problems for two classes of stochastic hybrid systems. The first one is (nonlinear) hybrid automata with parametric uncertainty. The second one is probabilistic hybrid automata with additional randomness for both transition probabilities and variable resets. Standard approaches to reachability problems for linear hybrid systems require numerical solutions for large optimization problems, and become infeasible for systems involving both nonlinear dynamics over the reals and stochasticity. Our approach encodes stochastic information by using random variables, and combines the randomized sampling, a $δ$-complete decision procedure, and statistical tests. SReach utilizes the $δ$-complete decision procedure to solve reachability problems in a sound manner, i.e., it always decides correctly if, for a given assignment to all random variables, the system actually reaches the unsafe region. The statistical tests adapted guarantee arbitrary small error bounds between probabilities estimated by SReach and real ones. Compared to standard simulation-based methods, our approach supports non-deterministic branching, increases the coverage of simulation, and avoids the zero-crossing problem. We demonstrate our method's feasibility by applying SReach to three representative biological models and to additional benchmarks for nonlinear hybrid systems with multiple probabilistic system parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2014; v1 submitted 28 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
