Showing 1–39 of 39 results for author: Zakharyaschev, M

Separation and Definability in Fragments of Two-Variable First-Order Logic with Counting

Authors: Louwe Kuijer, Tony Tan, Frank Wolter, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: For fragments L of first-order logic (FO) with counting quantifiers, we consider the definability problem, which asks whether a given L-formula can be equivalently expressed by a formula in some fragment of L without counting, and the more general separation problem asking whether two mutually exclusive L-formulas can be separated in some counting-free fragment of L. We show that separation is und… ▽ More For fragments L of first-order logic (FO) with counting quantifiers, we consider the definability problem, which asks whether a given L-formula can be equivalently expressed by a formula in some fragment of L without counting, and the more general separation problem asking whether two mutually exclusive L-formulas can be separated in some counting-free fragment of L. We show that separation is undecidable for the two-variable fragment of FO extended with counting quantifiers and for the graded modal logic with inverse, nominals and universal modality. On the other hand, if inverse or nominals are dropped, separation becomes coNExpTime- or 2ExpTime-complete, depending on whether the universal modality is present. In contrast, definability can often be reduced in polynomial time to validity in L. We also consider uniform separation and show that it often behaves similarly to definability. △ Less

Submitted 30 April, 2025; v1 submitted 29 April, 2025; originally announced April 2025.

Comments: The article has been accepted for LICS 2025

MSC Class: 03B45 (Primary) 03C40 (Secondary)

On Deciding the Data Complexity of Answering Linear Monadic Datalog Queries with LTL Operators(Extended Version)

Authors: Alessandro Artale, Anton Gnatenko, Vladislav Ryzhikov, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: Our concern is the data complexity of answering linear monadic datalog queries whose atoms in the rule bodies can be prefixed by operators of linear temporal logic LTL. We first observe that, for data complexity, answering any connected query with operators $\bigcirc/\bigcirc^-$ (at the next/previous moment) is either in AC0, or in $ACC0\!\setminus\!AC0$, or $NC^1$-complete, or LogSpace-hard and i… ▽ More Our concern is the data complexity of answering linear monadic datalog queries whose atoms in the rule bodies can be prefixed by operators of linear temporal logic LTL. We first observe that, for data complexity, answering any connected query with operators $\bigcirc/\bigcirc^-$ (at the next/previous moment) is either in AC0, or in $ACC0\!\setminus\!AC0$, or $NC^1$-complete, or LogSpace-hard and in NLogSpace. Then we show that the problem of deciding LogSpace-hardness of answering such queries is PSpace-complete, while checking membership in the classes AC0 and ACC0 as well as $NC^1$-completeness can be done in ExpSpace. Finally, we prove that membership in AC0 or in ACC0, $NC^1$-completeness, and LogSpace-hardness are undecidable for queries with operators $\Diamond_f/\Diamond_p$ (sometime in the future/past) provided that $NC^1 \ne NLogSpace$, and $LogSpace \ne NLogSpace$. △ Less

Submitted 23 January, 2025; originally announced January 2025.

Comments: Extended version of a paper accepted at ICDT'2025

Extremal Separation Problems for Temporal Instance Queries

Authors: Jean Christoph Jung, Vladislav Ryzhikov, Frank Wolter, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: The separation problem for a class Q of database queries is to find a query in Q that distinguishes between a given set of `positive' and `negative' data examples. Separation provides explanations of examples and underpins the query-by-example paradigm to support database users in constructing and refining queries. As the space of all separating queries can be large, it is helpful to succinctly re… ▽ More The separation problem for a class Q of database queries is to find a query in Q that distinguishes between a given set of `positive' and `negative' data examples. Separation provides explanations of examples and underpins the query-by-example paradigm to support database users in constructing and refining queries. As the space of all separating queries can be large, it is helpful to succinctly represent this space by means of its most specific (logically strongest) and general (weakest) members. We investigate this extremal separation problem for classes of instance queries formulated in linear temporal logic LTL with the operators conjunction, next, and eventually. Our results range from tight complexity bounds for verifying and counting extremal separators to algorithms computing them. △ Less

Submitted 7 June, 2024; v1 submitted 6 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: Accepted for IJCAI 2024

ACM Class: I.2.4; F.2.2

Interpolant Existence is Undecidable for Two-Variable First-Order Logic with Two Equivalence Relations

Authors: Frank Wolter, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: The interpolant existence problem (IEP) for a logic L is to decide, given formulas P and Q, whether there exists a formula I, built from the shared symbols of P and Q, such that P entails I and I entails Q in L. If L enjoys the Craig interpolation property (CIP), then the IEP reduces to validity in L. Recently, the IEP has been studied for logics without the CIP. The results obtained so far indica… ▽ More The interpolant existence problem (IEP) for a logic L is to decide, given formulas P and Q, whether there exists a formula I, built from the shared symbols of P and Q, such that P entails I and I entails Q in L. If L enjoys the Craig interpolation property (CIP), then the IEP reduces to validity in L. Recently, the IEP has been studied for logics without the CIP. The results obtained so far indicate that even though the IEP can be computationally harder than validity, it is decidable when L is decidable. Here, we give the first examples of decidable fragments of first-order logic for which the IEP is undecidable. Namely, we show that the IEP is undecidable for the two-variable fragment with two equivalence relations and for the two-variable guarded fragment with individual constants and two equivalence relations. We also determine the corresponding decidable Boolean description logics for which the IEP is undecidable. △ Less

Submitted 3 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

MSC Class: 03B45 (Primary) 03C40 (Secondary)

The interpolant existence problem for weak K4 and difference logic

Authors: Agi Kurucz, Frank Wolter, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: As well known, weak K4 and the difference logic DL do not enjoy the Craig interpolation property. Our concern here is the problem of deciding whether any given implication does have an interpolant in these logics. We show that the nonexistence of an interpolant can always be witnessed by a pair of bisimilar models of polynomial size for DL and of triple-exponential size for weak K4, and so the int… ▽ More As well known, weak K4 and the difference logic DL do not enjoy the Craig interpolation property. Our concern here is the problem of deciding whether any given implication does have an interpolant in these logics. We show that the nonexistence of an interpolant can always be witnessed by a pair of bisimilar models of polynomial size for DL and of triple-exponential size for weak K4, and so the interpolant existence problems for these logics are decidable in coNP and coN3ExpTime, respectively. We also establish coNExpTime-hardness of this problem for weak K4, which is higher than the PSpace-completeness of its decision problem. △ Less

Submitted 17 June, 2024; v1 submitted 17 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

A non-uniform view of Craig interpolation in modal logics with linear frames

Authors: Agi Kurucz, Frank Wolter, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: Normal modal logics extending the logic K4.3 of linear transitive frames are known to lack the Craig interpolation property, except some logics of bounded depth such as S5. We turn this `negative' fact into a research question and pursue a non-uniform approach to Craig interpolation by investigating the following interpolant existence problem: decide whether there exists a Craig interpolant betwee… ▽ More Normal modal logics extending the logic K4.3 of linear transitive frames are known to lack the Craig interpolation property, except some logics of bounded depth such as S5. We turn this `negative' fact into a research question and pursue a non-uniform approach to Craig interpolation by investigating the following interpolant existence problem: decide whether there exists a Craig interpolant between two given formulas in any fixed logic above K4.3. Using a bisimulation-based characterisation of interpolant existence for descriptive frames, we show that this problem is decidable and coNP-complete for all finitely axiomatisable normal modal logics containing K4.3. It is thus not harder than entailment in these logics, which is in sharp contrast to other recent non-uniform interpolation results. We also extend our approach to Priorean temporal logics (with both past and future modalities) over the standard time flows-the integers, rationals, reals, and finite strict linear orders-none of which is blessed with the Craig interpolation property. △ Less

Submitted 10 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

MSC Class: 03B45 (Primary) 03C40 (Secondary)

Unique Characterisability and Learnability of Temporal Queries Mediated by an Ontology

Authors: Jean Christoph Jung, Vladislav Ryzhikov, Frank Wolter, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: Algorithms for learning database queries from examples and unique characterisations of queries by examples are prominent starting points for developing automated support for query construction and explanation. We investigate how far recent results and techniques on learning and unique characterisations of atemporal queries mediated by an ontology can be extended to temporal data and queries. Based… ▽ More Algorithms for learning database queries from examples and unique characterisations of queries by examples are prominent starting points for developing automated support for query construction and explanation. We investigate how far recent results and techniques on learning and unique characterisations of atemporal queries mediated by an ontology can be extended to temporal data and queries. Based on a systematic review of the relevant approaches in the atemporal case, we obtain general transfer results identifying conditions under which temporal queries composed of atemporal ones are (polynomially) learnable and uniquely characterisable. △ Less

Submitted 28 July, 2024; v1 submitted 13 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: Full version of a KR'2024 paper

ACM Class: I.2.4; F.4.1

Reverse Engineering of Temporal Queries Mediated by LTL Ontologies

Authors: Marie Fortin, Boris Konev, Vladislav Ryzhikov, Yury Savateev, Frank Wolter, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: In reverse engineering of database queries, we aim to construct a query from a given set of answers and non-answers; it can then be used to explore the data further or as an explanation of the answers and non-answers. We investigate this query-by-example problem for queries formulated in positive fragments of linear temporal logic LTL over timestamped data, focusing on the design of suitable query… ▽ More In reverse engineering of database queries, we aim to construct a query from a given set of answers and non-answers; it can then be used to explore the data further or as an explanation of the answers and non-answers. We investigate this query-by-example problem for queries formulated in positive fragments of linear temporal logic LTL over timestamped data, focusing on the design of suitable query languages and the combined and data complexity of deciding whether there exists a query in the given language that separates the given answers from non-answers. We consider both plain LTL queries and those mediated by LTL-ontologies. △ Less

Submitted 4 May, 2023; v1 submitted 2 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: To be published in IJCAI 2023 proceedings

ACM Class: I.2.4

Deciding the Existence of Interpolants and Definitions in First-Order Modal Logic

Authors: Agi Kurucz, Frank Wolter, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: None of the first-order modal logics between $\mathsf{K}$ and $\mathsf{S5}$ under the constant domain semantics enjoys Craig interpolation or projective Beth definability, even in the language restricted to a single individual variable. It follows that the existence of a Craig interpolant for a given implication or of an explicit definition for a given predicate cannot be directly reduced to valid… ▽ More None of the first-order modal logics between $\mathsf{K}$ and $\mathsf{S5}$ under the constant domain semantics enjoys Craig interpolation or projective Beth definability, even in the language restricted to a single individual variable. It follows that the existence of a Craig interpolant for a given implication or of an explicit definition for a given predicate cannot be directly reduced to validity as in classical first-order and many other logics. Our concern here is the decidability and computational complexity of the interpolant and definition existence problems. We first consider two decidable fragments of first-order modal logic $\mathsf{S5}$: the one-variable fragment $\mathsf{Q^1S5}$ and its extension $\mathsf{S5}_{\mathcal{ALC}^u}$ that combines $\mathsf{S5}$ and the description logic$\mathcal{ALC}$ with the universal role. We prove that interpolant and definition existence in $\mathsf{Q^1S5}$ and $\mathsf{S5}_{\mathcal{ALC}^u}$ is decidable in coN2ExpTime, being 2ExpTime-hard, while uniform interpolant existence is undecidable. These results transfer to the two-variable fragment $\mathsf{FO^2}$ of classical first-order logic without equality. We also show that interpolant and definition existence in the one-variable fragment $\mathsf{Q^1K}$ of first-order modal logic $\mathsf{K}$ is non-elementary decidable, while uniform interpolant existence is again undecidable. △ Less

Submitted 5 June, 2024; v1 submitted 8 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Deciding FO-rewritability of regular languages and ontology-mediated queries in Linear Temporal Logic

Authors: Agi Kurucz, Vladislav Ryzhikov, Yury Savateev, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: Our concern is the problem of determining the data complexity of answering an ontology-mediated query (OMQ) formulated in linear temporal logic LTL over (Z,<) and deciding whether it is rewritable to an FO(<)-query, possibly with some extra predicates. First, we observe that, in line with the circuit complexity and FO-definability of regular languages, OMQ answering in AC^0, ACC^0 and NC^1 coincid… ▽ More Our concern is the problem of determining the data complexity of answering an ontology-mediated query (OMQ) formulated in linear temporal logic LTL over (Z,<) and deciding whether it is rewritable to an FO(<)-query, possibly with some extra predicates. First, we observe that, in line with the circuit complexity and FO-definability of regular languages, OMQ answering in AC^0, ACC^0 and NC^1 coincides with FO(<,\equiv)-rewritability using unary predicates x \equiv 0 (mod n), FO(<,MOD)-rewritability, and FO(RPR)-rewritability using relational primitive recursion, respectively. We prove that, similarly to known PSPACE-completeness of recognising FO(<)-definability of regular languages, deciding FO(<,\equiv)- and FO(<,MOD)-definability is also \PSPACE-complete (unless ACC^0 = NC^1). We then use this result to show that deciding FO(<)-, FO(<,\equiv)- and FO(<,MOD)-rewritability of LTL OMQs is EXPSPACE-complete, and that these problems become PSPACE-complete for OMQs with a linear Horn ontology and an atomic query, and also a positive query in the cases of FO(<)- and FO(<,\equiv)-rewritability. Further, we consider FO(<)-rewritability of OMQs with a binary-clause ontology and identify OMQ classes, for which deciding it is PSPACE-, Pi_2^p- and coNP-complete. △ Less

Submitted 9 January, 2023; v1 submitted 13 July, 2022; originally announced July 2022.

Comments: arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:2105.06202

Unique Characterisability and Learnability of Temporal Instance Queries

Authors: Marie Fortin, Boris Konev, Vladislav Ryzhikov, Yury Savateev, Frank Wolter, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: We aim to determine which temporal instance queries can be uniquely characterised by a (polynomial-size) set of positive and negative temporal data examples. We start by considering queries formulated in fragments of propositional linear temporal logic LTL that correspond to conjunctive queries (CQs) or extensions thereof induced by the until operator. Not all of these queries admit polynomial cha… ▽ More We aim to determine which temporal instance queries can be uniquely characterised by a (polynomial-size) set of positive and negative temporal data examples. We start by considering queries formulated in fragments of propositional linear temporal logic LTL that correspond to conjunctive queries (CQs) or extensions thereof induced by the until operator. Not all of these queries admit polynomial characterisations but by restricting them further to path-shaped queries we identify natural classes that do. We then investigate how far the obtained characterisations can be lifted to temporal knowledge graphs queried by 2D languages combining LTL with concepts in description logics EL or ELI (i.e., tree-shaped CQs). While temporal operators in the scope of description logic constructors can destroy polynomial characterisability, we obtain general transfer results for the case when description logic constructors are within the scope of temporal operators. Finally, we apply our characterisations to establish (polynomial) learnability of temporal instance queries using membership queries in the active learning framework. △ Less

Submitted 3 May, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

Comments: accepted for KR2022

ACM Class: I.2.4; F.2.2

First-Order Rewritability and Complexity of Two-Dimensional Temporal Ontology-Mediated Queries

Authors: Alessandro Artale, Roman Kontchakov, Alisa Kovtunova, Vladislav Ryzhikov, Frank Wolter, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: Aiming at ontology-based data access to temporal data, we design two-dimensional temporal ontology and query languages by combining logics from the (extended) DL-Lite family with linear temporal logic LTL over discrete time (Z,<). Our main concern is first-order rewritability of ontology-mediated queries (OMQs) that consist of a 2D ontology and a positive temporal instance query. Our target langua… ▽ More Aiming at ontology-based data access to temporal data, we design two-dimensional temporal ontology and query languages by combining logics from the (extended) DL-Lite family with linear temporal logic LTL over discrete time (Z,<). Our main concern is first-order rewritability of ontology-mediated queries (OMQs) that consist of a 2D ontology and a positive temporal instance query. Our target languages for FO-rewritings are two-sorted FO(<) - first-order logic with sorts for time instants ordered by the built-in precedence relation < and for the domain of individuals - its extension FOE with the standard congruence predicates t \equiv 0 mod n, for any fixed n > 1, and FO(RPR) that admits relational primitive recursion. In terms of circuit complexity, FOE- and FO(RPR)-rewritability guarantee answering OMQs in uniform AC0 and NC1, respectively. We proceed in three steps. First, we define a hierarchy of 2D DL-Lite/LTL ontology languages and investigate the FO-rewritability of OMQs with atomic queries by constructing projections onto 1D LTL OMQs and employing recent results on the FO-rewritability of propositional LTL OMQs. As the projections involve deciding consistency of ontologies and data, we also consider the consistency problem for our languages. While the undecidability of consistency for 2D ontology languages with expressive Boolean role inclusions might be expected, we also show that, rather surprisingly, the restriction to Krom and Horn role inclusions leads to decidability (and ExpSpace-completeness), even if one admits full Booleans on concepts. As a final step, we lift some of the rewritability results for atomic OMQs to OMQs with expressive positive temporal instance queries. The lifting results are based on an in-depth study of the canonical models and only concern Horn ontologies. △ Less

Submitted 21 October, 2022; v1 submitted 12 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Comments: Accepted for JAIR

ACM Class: I.2.4

Deciding boundedness of monadic sirups

Authors: Stanislav Kikot, Agi Kurucz, Vladimir Podolskii, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: We show that deciding boundedness (aka FO-rewritability) of monadic single rule datalog programs (sirups) is 2Exp-hard, which matches the upper bound known since 1988 and finally settles a long-standing open problem. We obtain this result as a byproduct of an attempt to classify monadic `disjunctive sirups' -- Boolean conjunctive queries q with unary and binary predicates mediated by a disjunctive… ▽ More We show that deciding boundedness (aka FO-rewritability) of monadic single rule datalog programs (sirups) is 2Exp-hard, which matches the upper bound known since 1988 and finally settles a long-standing open problem. We obtain this result as a byproduct of an attempt to classify monadic `disjunctive sirups' -- Boolean conjunctive queries q with unary and binary predicates mediated by a disjunctive rule T(x)vF(x) <- A(x) -- according to the data complexity of their evaluation. Apart from establishing that deciding FO-rewritability of disjunctive sirups with a dag-shaped q is also 2Exp-hard, we make substantial progress towards obtaining a complete FO/L-hardness dichotomy of disjunctive sirups with ditree-shaped q. △ Less

Submitted 1 August, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

Deciding FO-definability of regular languages

Authors: Agi Kurucz, Vladislav Ryzhikov, Yury Savateev, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: We prove that, similarly to known PSpace-completeness of recognising FO(<)-definability of the language L(A) of a DFA A, deciding both FO(<,C)- and FO(<,MOD)-definability are PSpace-complete. (Here, FO(<,C) extends the first-order logic FO(<) with the standard congruence modulo n relation, and FO(<,MOD) with the quantifiers checking whether the number of positions satisfying a given formula is div… ▽ More We prove that, similarly to known PSpace-completeness of recognising FO(<)-definability of the language L(A) of a DFA A, deciding both FO(<,C)- and FO(<,MOD)-definability are PSpace-complete. (Here, FO(<,C) extends the first-order logic FO(<) with the standard congruence modulo n relation, and FO(<,MOD) with the quantifiers checking whether the number of positions satisfying a given formula is divisible by a given n>1. These FO-languages are known to define regular languages that are decidable in AC0 and ACC0, respectively.) We obtain these results by first showing that known algebraic characterisations of FO-definability of L(A) can be captured by `localisable' properties of the transition monoid of A. Using our criterion, we then generalise the known proof of PSpace-hardness of FO(<)-definability, and establish the upper bounds not only for arbitrary DFAs but also for two-way NFAs. △ Less

Submitted 1 August, 2021; v1 submitted 13 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

A tetrachotomy of ontology-mediated queries with a covering axiom

Authors: Olga Gerasimova, Stanislav Kikot, Agi Kurucz, Vladimir Podolskii, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: Our concern is the problem of efficiently determining the data complexity of answering queries mediated by description logic ontologies and constructing their optimal rewritings to standard database queries. Originated in ontology-based data access and datalog optimisation, this problem is known to be computationally very complex in general, with no explicit syntactic characterisations available.… ▽ More Our concern is the problem of efficiently determining the data complexity of answering queries mediated by description logic ontologies and constructing their optimal rewritings to standard database queries. Originated in ontology-based data access and datalog optimisation, this problem is known to be computationally very complex in general, with no explicit syntactic characterisations available. In this article, aiming to understand the fundamental roots of this difficulty, we strip the problem to the bare bones and focus on Boolean conjunctive queries mediated by a simple covering axiom stating that one class is covered by the union of two other classes. We show that, on the one hand, these rudimentary ontology-mediated queries, called disjunctive sirups (or d-sirups), capture many features and difficulties of the general case. For example, answering d-sirups is Pi^p_2-complete for combined complexity and can be in AC0 or LogSpace-, NL-, P-, or coNP-complete for data complexity (with the problem of recognising FO-rewritability of d-sirups being 2ExpTime-hard); some d-sirups only have exponential-size resolution proofs, some only double-exponential-size positive existential FO-rewritings and single-exponential-size nonrecursive datalog rewritings. On the other hand, we prove a few partial sufficient and necessary conditions of FO- and (symmetric/linear-) datalog rewritability of d-sirups. Our main technical result is a complete and transparent syntactic AC0/NL/P/coNP tetrachotomy of d-sirups with disjoint covering classes and a path-shaped Boolean conjunctive query. To obtain this tetrachotomy, we develop new techniques for establishing P- and coNP-hardness of answering non-Horn ontology-mediated queries as well as showing that they can be answered in NL. △ Less

Submitted 5 May, 2022; v1 submitted 7 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

First-Order Rewritability of Ontology-Mediated Queries in Linear Temporal Logic

Authors: Alessandro Artale, Roman Kontchakov, Alisa Kovtunova, Vladislav Ryzhikov, Frank Wolter, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: We investigate ontology-based data access to temporal data. We consider temporal ontologies given in linear temporal logic LTL interpreted over discrete time (Z,<). Queries are given in LTL or MFO(<), monadic first-order logic with a built-in linear order. Our concern is first-order rewritability of ontology-mediated queries (OMQs) consisting of a temporal ontology and a query. By taking account o… ▽ More We investigate ontology-based data access to temporal data. We consider temporal ontologies given in linear temporal logic LTL interpreted over discrete time (Z,<). Queries are given in LTL or MFO(<), monadic first-order logic with a built-in linear order. Our concern is first-order rewritability of ontology-mediated queries (OMQs) consisting of a temporal ontology and a query. By taking account of the temporal operators used in the ontology and distinguishing between ontologies given in full LTL and its core, Krom and Horn fragments, we identify a hierarchy of OMQs with atomic queries by proving rewritability into either FO(<), first-order logic with the built-in linear order, or FO(<,E), which extends FO(<) with the standard arithmetic predicates saying that "x is equivalent to 0 modulo n", for any fixed n > 1, or FO(RPR), which extends FO(<) with relational primitive recursion. In terms of circuit complexity, FO(<,E)- and FO(RPR)-rewritability guarantee OMQ answering in uniform AC0 and, respectively, NC1. We obtain similar hierarchies for more expressive types of queries: positive LTL-formulas, monotone MFO(<)- and arbitrary MFO(<)-formulas. Our results are directly applicable if the temporal data to be accessed is one-dimensional; moreover, they lay foundations for investigating ontology-based access using combinations of temporal and description logics over two-dimensional temporal data. △ Less

Submitted 25 May, 2021; v1 submitted 15 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Data Complexity and Rewritability of Ontology-Mediated Queries in Metric Temporal Logic under the Event-Based Semantics (Full Version)

Authors: Vladislav Ryzhikov, Przemyslaw Andrzej Walega, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: We investigate the data complexity of answering queries mediated by metric temporal logic ontologies under the event-based semantics assuming that data instances are finite timed words timestamped with binary fractions. We identify classes of ontology-mediated queries answering which can be done in AC0, NC1, L, NL, P, and coNP for data complexity, provide their rewritings to first-order logic and… ▽ More We investigate the data complexity of answering queries mediated by metric temporal logic ontologies under the event-based semantics assuming that data instances are finite timed words timestamped with binary fractions. We identify classes of ontology-mediated queries answering which can be done in AC0, NC1, L, NL, P, and coNP for data complexity, provide their rewritings to first-order logic and its extensions with primitive recursion, transitive closure or datalog, and establish lower complexity bounds. △ Less

Submitted 1 July, 2019; v1 submitted 30 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

ACM Class: I.2.4; F.2.2

Model Comparison Games for Horn Description Logics

Authors: Jean Christoph Jung, Fabio Papacchini, Frank Wolter, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: Horn description logics are syntactically defined fragments of standard description logics that fall within the Horn fragment of first-order logic and for which ontology-mediated query answering is in PTime for data complexity. They were independently introduced in modal logic to capture the intersection of Horn first-order logic with modal logic. In this paper, we introduce model comparison games… ▽ More Horn description logics are syntactically defined fragments of standard description logics that fall within the Horn fragment of first-order logic and for which ontology-mediated query answering is in PTime for data complexity. They were independently introduced in modal logic to capture the intersection of Horn first-order logic with modal logic. In this paper, we introduce model comparison games for the basic Horn description logic hornALC (corresponding to the basic Horn modal logic) and use them to obtain an Ehrenfeucht-Fraïssé type definability result and a van Benthem style expressive completeness result for hornALC. We also establish a finite model theory version of the latter. The Ehrenfeucht-Fraïssé type definability result is used to show that checking hornALC indistinguishability of models is ExpTime-complete, which is in sharp contrast to ALC indistinguishability (i.e., bisimulation equivalence) checkable in PTime. In addition, we explore the behavior of Horn fragments of more expressive description and modal logics by defining a Horn guarded fragment of first-order logic and introducing model comparison games for it. △ Less

Submitted 15 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Comments: Full version of LICS'19 paper

ACM Class: F.4.1

Query Inseparability for ALC Ontologies

Authors: Elena Botoeva, Carsten Lutz, Vladislav Ryzhikov, Frank Wolter, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: We investigate the problem whether two ALC ontologies are indistinguishable (or inseparable) by means of queries in a given signature, which is fundamental for ontology engineering tasks such as ontology versioning, modularisation, update, and forgetting. We consider both knowledge base (KB) and TBox inseparability. For KBs, we give model-theoretic criteria in terms of (finite partial) homomorphis… ▽ More We investigate the problem whether two ALC ontologies are indistinguishable (or inseparable) by means of queries in a given signature, which is fundamental for ontology engineering tasks such as ontology versioning, modularisation, update, and forgetting. We consider both knowledge base (KB) and TBox inseparability. For KBs, we give model-theoretic criteria in terms of (finite partial) homomorphisms and products and prove that this problem is undecidable for conjunctive queries (CQs), but 2ExpTime-complete for unions of CQs (UCQs). The same results hold if (U)CQs are replaced by rooted (U)CQs, where every variable is connected to an answer variable. We also show that inseparability by CQs is still undecidable if one KB is given in the lightweight DL EL and if no restrictions are imposed on the signature of the CQs. We also consider the problem whether two ALC TBoxes give the same answers to any query over any ABox in a given signature and show that, for CQs, this problem is undecidable, too. We then develop model-theoretic criteria for Horn-ALC TBoxes and show using tree automata that, in contrast, inseparability becomes decidable and 2ExpTime-complete, even ExpTime-complete when restricted to (unions of) rooted CQs. △ Less

Submitted 31 January, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Comments: arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1604.04164

Inseparability and Conservative Extensions of Description Logic Ontologies: A Survey

Authors: Elena Botoeva, Boris Konev, Carsten Lutz, Vladislav Ryzhikov, Frank Wolter, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: The question whether an ontology can safely be replaced by another, possibly simpler, one is fundamental for many ontology engineering and maintenance tasks. It underpins, for example, ontology versioning, ontology modularization, forgetting, and knowledge exchange. What safe replacement means depends on the intended application of the ontology. If, for example, it is used to query data, then the… ▽ More The question whether an ontology can safely be replaced by another, possibly simpler, one is fundamental for many ontology engineering and maintenance tasks. It underpins, for example, ontology versioning, ontology modularization, forgetting, and knowledge exchange. What safe replacement means depends on the intended application of the ontology. If, for example, it is used to query data, then the answers to any relevant ontology-mediated query should be the same over any relevant data set; if, in contrast, the ontology is used for conceptual reasoning, then the entailed subsumptions between concept expressions should coincide. This gives rise to different notions of ontology inseparability such as query inseparability and concept inseparability, which generalize corresponding notions of conservative extensions. We survey results on various notions of inseparability in the context of description logic ontologies, discussing their applications, useful model-theoretic characterizations, algorithms for determining whether two ontologies are inseparable (and, sometimes, for computing the difference between them if they are not), and the computational complexity of this problem. △ Less

Submitted 20 April, 2018; originally announced April 2018.

Kripke Completeness of Strictly Positive Modal Logics over Meet-semilattices with Operators

Authors: Stanislav Kikot, Agi Kurucz, Yoshihito Tanaka, Frank Wolter, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: Our concern is the completeness problem for spi-logics, that is, sets of implications between strictly positive formulas built from propositional variables, conjunction and modal diamond operators. Originated in logic, algebra and computer science, spi-logics have two natural semantics: meet-semilattices with monotone operators providing Birkhoff-style calculi, and first-order relational structure… ▽ More Our concern is the completeness problem for spi-logics, that is, sets of implications between strictly positive formulas built from propositional variables, conjunction and modal diamond operators. Originated in logic, algebra and computer science, spi-logics have two natural semantics: meet-semilattices with monotone operators providing Birkhoff-style calculi, and first-order relational structures (aka Kripke frames) often used as the intended structures in applications. Here we lay foundations for a completeness theory that aims to answer the question whether the two semantics define the same consequence relations for a given spi-logic. △ Less

Submitted 22 March, 2019; v1 submitted 10 August, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Journal ref: Journal of Symbolic Logic, 84 (2019), pp.533-588

Querying Log Data with Metric Temporal Logic (Technical Report)

Authors: Sebastian Brandt, Elem Güzel Kalaycı, Vladislav Ryzhikov, Guohui Xiao, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: We propose a novel framework for ontology-based access to temporal log data using a datalog extension datalogMTL of a Horn fragment of the metric temporal logic MTL. We show that datalogMTL is ExpSpace-complete even with punctual intervals, in which case full MTL is known to be undecidable. We also prove that nonrecursive datalogMTL is PSpace-complete for combined complexity and in AC0 for data co… ▽ More We propose a novel framework for ontology-based access to temporal log data using a datalog extension datalogMTL of a Horn fragment of the metric temporal logic MTL. We show that datalogMTL is ExpSpace-complete even with punctual intervals, in which case full MTL is known to be undecidable. We also prove that nonrecursive datalogMTL is PSpace-complete for combined complexity and in AC0 for data complexity. We demonstrate by two real-world use cases that nonrecursive datalogMTL programs can express complex temporal concepts from typical user queries and thereby facilitate access to temporal log data. Our experiments with Siemens turbine data and MesoWest weather data show that datalogMTL ontology-mediated queries are efficient and scale on large datasets. △ Less

Submitted 16 August, 2018; v1 submitted 27 March, 2017; originally announced March 2017.

ACM Class: I.2.4; F.4.1

Journal ref: Journal of Artificial Intelligence Research (JAIR), vol. 62, 2018

The Complexity of Ontology-Based Data Access with OWL 2 QL and Bounded Treewidth Queries

Authors: Meghyn Bienvenu, Stanislav Kikot, Roman Kontchakov, Vladimir V. Podolskii, Vladislav Ryzhikov, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: Our concern is the overhead of answering OWL 2 QL ontology-mediated queries (OMQs) in ontology-based data access compared to evaluating their underlying tree-shaped and bounded treewidth conjunctive queries (CQs). We show that OMQs with bounded-depth ontologies have nonrecursive datalog (NDL) rewritings that can be constructed and evaluated in LOGCFL for combined complexity, even in NL if their CQ… ▽ More Our concern is the overhead of answering OWL 2 QL ontology-mediated queries (OMQs) in ontology-based data access compared to evaluating their underlying tree-shaped and bounded treewidth conjunctive queries (CQs). We show that OMQs with bounded-depth ontologies have nonrecursive datalog (NDL) rewritings that can be constructed and evaluated in LOGCFL for combined complexity, even in NL if their CQs are tree-shaped with a bounded number of leaves, and so incur no overhead in complexity-theoretic terms. For OMQs with arbitrary ontologies and bounded-leaf CQs, NDL-rewritings are constructed and evaluated in LOGCFL. We show experimentally feasibility and scalability of our rewritings compared to previously proposed NDL-rewritings. On the negative side, we prove that answering OMQs with tree-shaped CQs is not fixed-parameter tractable if the ontology depth or the number of leaves in the CQs is regarded as the parameter, and that answering OMQs with a fixed ontology (of infinite depth) is NP-complete for tree-shaped and LOGCFL for bounded-leaf CQs. △ Less

Submitted 24 September, 2020; v1 submitted 10 February, 2017; originally announced February 2017.

Comments: PODS 2017 long version. arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1604.05258

Metric Temporal Logic for Ontology-Based Data Access over Log Data

Authors: Diego Calvanese, Elem Güzel Kalaycı, Vladislav Ryzhikov, Guohui Xiao, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: We present a new metric temporal logic HornMTL over dense time and its datalog extension datalogMTL. The use of datalogMTL is demonstrated in the context of ontology-based data access over meteorological data. We show decidability of answering ontology-mediated queries for a practically relevant non-recursive fragment of datalogMTL. Finally, we discuss directions of the future work, including the… ▽ More We present a new metric temporal logic HornMTL over dense time and its datalog extension datalogMTL. The use of datalogMTL is demonstrated in the context of ontology-based data access over meteorological data. We show decidability of answering ontology-mediated queries for a practically relevant non-recursive fragment of datalogMTL. Finally, we discuss directions of the future work, including the potential use-cases in analyzing log data of engines and devices. △ Less

Submitted 4 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

ACM Class: I.2.4

Journal ref: In Proceedings of the 2nd International Workshop on Ontologies and Logic Programming for Query Answering (ONTOLP-16), 2016

Ontology-Mediated Queries: Combined Complexity and Succinctness of Rewritings via Circuit Complexity

Authors: Meghyn Bienvenu, Stanislav Kikot, Roman Kontchakov, Vladimir Podolskii, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: We give solutions to two fundamental computational problems in ontology-based data access with the W3C standard ontology language OWL 2 QL: the succinctness problem for first-order rewritings of ontology-mediated queries (OMQs), and the complexity problem for OMQ answering. We classify OMQs according to the shape of their conjunctive queries (treewidth, the number of leaves) and the existential de… ▽ More We give solutions to two fundamental computational problems in ontology-based data access with the W3C standard ontology language OWL 2 QL: the succinctness problem for first-order rewritings of ontology-mediated queries (OMQs), and the complexity problem for OMQ answering. We classify OMQs according to the shape of their conjunctive queries (treewidth, the number of leaves) and the existential depth of their ontologies. For each of these classes, we determine the combined complexity of OMQ answering, and whether all OMQs in the class have polynomial-size first-order, positive existential, and nonrecursive datalog rewritings. We obtain the succinctness results using hypergraph programs, a new computational model for Boolean functions, which makes it possible to connect the size of OMQ rewritings and circuit complexity. △ Less

Submitted 4 May, 2016; originally announced May 2016.

Theoretically Optimal Datalog Rewritings for OWL 2 QL Ontology-Mediated Queries

Authors: Meghyn Bienvenu, Stanislav Kikot, Roman Kontchakov, Vladimir V. Podolskii, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: We show that, for OWL 2 QL ontology-mediated queries with (i) ontologies of bounded depth and conjunctive queries of bounded treewidth, (ii) ontologies of bounded depth and bounded-leaf tree-shaped conjunctive queries, and (iii) arbitrary ontologies and bounded-leaf tree-shaped conjunctive queries, one can construct and evaluate nonrecursive datalog rewritings by, respectively, LOGCFL, NL and LOGC… ▽ More We show that, for OWL 2 QL ontology-mediated queries with (i) ontologies of bounded depth and conjunctive queries of bounded treewidth, (ii) ontologies of bounded depth and bounded-leaf tree-shaped conjunctive queries, and (iii) arbitrary ontologies and bounded-leaf tree-shaped conjunctive queries, one can construct and evaluate nonrecursive datalog rewritings by, respectively, LOGCFL, NL and LOGCFL algorithms, which matches the optimal combined complexity. △ Less

Submitted 18 April, 2016; originally announced April 2016.

Comments: full version of the paper in the Proc. of the 29th Int. Workshop on Description Logics (DL 2016)

Query-Based Entailment and Inseparability for ALC Ontologies (Full Version)

Authors: Elena Botoeva, Carsten Lutz, Vladislav Ryzhikov, Frank Wolter, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: We investigate the problem whether two ALC knowledge bases are indistinguishable by queries over a given vocabulary. We give model-theoretic criteria in terms of (partial) homomorphisms and products and prove that this problem is undecidable for conjunctive queries (CQs) but 2EXPTIME-complete for UCQs (unions of CQs). The same results hold if CQs are replaced by rooted CQs. We also consider the pr… ▽ More We investigate the problem whether two ALC knowledge bases are indistinguishable by queries over a given vocabulary. We give model-theoretic criteria in terms of (partial) homomorphisms and products and prove that this problem is undecidable for conjunctive queries (CQs) but 2EXPTIME-complete for UCQs (unions of CQs). The same results hold if CQs are replaced by rooted CQs. We also consider the problem whether two ALC TBoxes give the same answers to any query in a given vocabulary over all ABoxes, and show that for CQs this problem is undecidable, too, but becomes decidable and 2EXPTIME-complete in Horn-ALC, and even EXPTIME-complete in Horn-ALC when restricted to (unions of) rooted CQs. △ Less

Submitted 4 August, 2016; v1 submitted 14 April, 2016; originally announced April 2016.

Comments: The full version of the paper accepted at IJCAI 2016

Horn Fragments of the Halpern-Shoham Interval Temporal Logic (Technical Report)

Authors: Davide Bresolin, Agi Kurucz, Emilio Muñoz-Velasco, Vladislav Ryzhikov, Guido Sciavicco, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: We investigate the satisfiability problem for Horn fragments of the Halpern-Shoham interval temporal logic depending on the type (box or diamond) of the interval modal operators, the type of the underlying linear order (discrete or dense), and the type of semantics for the interval relations (reflexive or irreflexive). For example, we show that satisfiability of Horn formulas with diamonds is unde… ▽ More We investigate the satisfiability problem for Horn fragments of the Halpern-Shoham interval temporal logic depending on the type (box or diamond) of the interval modal operators, the type of the underlying linear order (discrete or dense), and the type of semantics for the interval relations (reflexive or irreflexive). For example, we show that satisfiability of Horn formulas with diamonds is undecidable for any type of linear orders and semantics. On the contrary, satisfiability of Horn formulas with boxes is tractable over both discrete and dense orders under the reflexive semantics and over dense orders under the irreflexive semantics, but becomes undecidable over discrete orders under the irreflexive semantics. Satisfiability of binary Horn formulas with both boxes and diamonds is always undecidable under the irreflexive semantics. △ Less

Submitted 28 August, 2017; v1 submitted 12 April, 2016; originally announced April 2016.

ACM Class: I.2.4; F.4.1; F.2.2

Journal ref: ACM Trans. Comput. Logic 18, 3, Article 22 (August 2017), 39 pages

On the Succinctness of Query Rewriting over OWL 2 QL Ontologies with Shallow Chases

Authors: Stanislav Kikot, Roman Kontchakov, Vladimir Podolskii, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: We investigate the size of first-order rewritings of conjunctive queries over OWL 2 QL ontologies of depth 1 and 2 by means of hypergraph programs computing Boolean functions. Both positive and negative results are obtained. Conjunctive queries over ontologies of depth 1 have polynomial-size nonrecursive datalog rewritings; tree-shaped queries have polynomial positive existential rewritings; howev… ▽ More We investigate the size of first-order rewritings of conjunctive queries over OWL 2 QL ontologies of depth 1 and 2 by means of hypergraph programs computing Boolean functions. Both positive and negative results are obtained. Conjunctive queries over ontologies of depth 1 have polynomial-size nonrecursive datalog rewritings; tree-shaped queries have polynomial positive existential rewritings; however, in the worst case, positive existential rewritings can only be of superpolynomial size. Positive existential and nonrecursive datalog rewritings of queries over ontologies of depth 2 suffer an exponential blowup in the worst case, while first-order rewritings are superpolynomial unless $\text{NP} \subseteq \text{P}/\text{poly}$. We also analyse rewritings of tree-shaped queries over arbitrary ontologies and observe that the query entailment problem for such queries is fixed-parameter tractable. △ Less

Submitted 22 January, 2014; v1 submitted 17 January, 2014; originally announced January 2014.

The DL-Lite Family and Relations

Authors: Alessandro Artale, Diego Calvanese, Roman Kontchakov, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: The recently introduced series of description logics under the common moniker DL-Lite has attracted attention of the description logic and semantic web communities due to the low computational complexity of inference, on the one hand, and the ability to represent conceptual modeling formalisms, on the other. The main aim of this article is to carry out a thorough and systematic investigation of… ▽ More The recently introduced series of description logics under the common moniker DL-Lite has attracted attention of the description logic and semantic web communities due to the low computational complexity of inference, on the one hand, and the ability to represent conceptual modeling formalisms, on the other. The main aim of this article is to carry out a thorough and systematic investigation of inference in extensions of the original DL-Lite logics along five axes: by (i) adding the Boolean connectives and (ii) number restrictions to concept constructs, (iii) allowing role hierarchies, (iv) allowing role disjointness, symmetry, asymmetry, reflexivity, irreflexivity and transitivity constraints, and (v) adopting or dropping the unique same assumption. We analyze the combined complexity of satisfiability for the resulting logics, as well as the data complexity of instance checking and answering positive existential queries. Our approach is based on embedding DL-Lite logics in suitable fragments of the one-variable first-order logic, which provides useful insights into their properties and, in particular, computational behavior. △ Less

Submitted 15 January, 2014; originally announced January 2014.

Journal ref: Journal Of Artificial Intelligence Research, Volume 36, pages 1-69, 2009

The Complexity of Clausal Fragments of LTL

Authors: A. Artale, R. Kontchakov, V. Ryzhikov, M. Zakharyaschev

Abstract: We introduce and investigate a number of fragments of propo- sitional temporal logic LTL over the flow of time (Z, <). The fragments are defined in terms of the available temporal operators and the structure of the clausal normal form of the temporal formulas. We determine the computational complexity of the satisfiability problem for each of the fragments, which ranges from NLogSpace to PTime, NP… ▽ More We introduce and investigate a number of fragments of propo- sitional temporal logic LTL over the flow of time (Z, <). The fragments are defined in terms of the available temporal operators and the structure of the clausal normal form of the temporal formulas. We determine the computational complexity of the satisfiability problem for each of the fragments, which ranges from NLogSpace to PTime, NP and PSpace. △ Less

Submitted 10 October, 2013; v1 submitted 21 June, 2013; originally announced June 2013.

Comments: arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1209.5571

Temporal Description Logic for Ontology-Based Data Access (Extended Version)

Authors: Alessandro Artale, Roman Kontchakov, Frank Wolter, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: Our aim is to investigate ontology-based data access over temporal data with validity time and ontologies capable of temporal conceptual modelling. To this end, we design a temporal description logic, TQL, that extends the standard ontology language OWL 2 QL, provides basic means for temporal conceptual modelling and ensures first-order rewritability of conjunctive queries for suitably defined dat… ▽ More Our aim is to investigate ontology-based data access over temporal data with validity time and ontologies capable of temporal conceptual modelling. To this end, we design a temporal description logic, TQL, that extends the standard ontology language OWL 2 QL, provides basic means for temporal conceptual modelling and ensures first-order rewritability of conjunctive queries for suitably defined data instances with validity time. △ Less

Submitted 30 April, 2013; v1 submitted 18 April, 2013; originally announced April 2013.

Comments: Full version of the IJCAI 2013 paper

A Cookbook for Temporal Conceptual Data Modelling with Description Logics

Authors: Alessandro Artale, Roman Kontchakov, Vladislav Ryzhikov, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: We design temporal description logics suitable for reasoning about temporal conceptual data models and investigate their computational complexity. Our formalisms are based on DL-Lite logics with three types of concept inclusions (ranging from atomic concept inclusions and disjointness to the full Booleans), as well as cardinality constraints and role inclusions. In the temporal dimension, they cap… ▽ More We design temporal description logics suitable for reasoning about temporal conceptual data models and investigate their computational complexity. Our formalisms are based on DL-Lite logics with three types of concept inclusions (ranging from atomic concept inclusions and disjointness to the full Booleans), as well as cardinality constraints and role inclusions. In the temporal dimension, they capture future and past temporal operators on concepts, flexible and rigid roles, the operators `always' and `some time' on roles, data assertions for particular moments of time and global concept inclusions. The logics are interpreted over the Cartesian products of object domains and the flow of time (Z,<), satisfying the constant domain assumption. We prove that the most expressive of our temporal description logics (which can capture lifespan cardinalities and either qualitative or quantitative evolution constraints) turn out to be undecidable. However, by omitting some of the temporal operators on concepts/roles or by restricting the form of concept inclusions we obtain logics whose complexity ranges between PSpace and NLogSpace. These positive results were obtained by reduction to various clausal fragments of propositional temporal logic, which opens a way to employ propositional or first-order temporal provers for reasoning about temporal data models. △ Less

Submitted 2 May, 2014; v1 submitted 25 September, 2012; originally announced September 2012.

Comments: Accepted for the ACM Transaction on Computational Logic, (TOCL)

Exponential Lower Bounds and Separation for Query Rewriting

Authors: Stanislav Kikot, Roman Kontchakov, Vladimir Podolskii, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: We establish connections between the size of circuits and formulas computing monotone Boolean functions and the size of first-order and nonrecursive Datalog rewritings for conjunctive queries over OWL 2 QL ontologies. We use known lower bounds and separation results from circuit complexity to prove similar results for the size of rewritings that do not use non-signature constants. For example, we… ▽ More We establish connections between the size of circuits and formulas computing monotone Boolean functions and the size of first-order and nonrecursive Datalog rewritings for conjunctive queries over OWL 2 QL ontologies. We use known lower bounds and separation results from circuit complexity to prove similar results for the size of rewritings that do not use non-signature constants. For example, we show that, in the worst case, positive existential and nonrecursive Datalog rewritings are exponentially longer than the original queries; nonrecursive Datalog rewritings are in general exponentially more succinct than positive existential rewritings; while first-order rewritings can be superpolynomially more succinct than positive existential rewritings. △ Less

Submitted 13 May, 2012; v1 submitted 19 February, 2012; originally announced February 2012.

Topological Logics with Connectedness over Euclidean Spaces

Authors: Roman Kontchakov, Yavor Nenov, Ian Pratt-Hartmann, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: We consider the quantifier-free languages, Bc and Bc0, obtained by augmenting the signature of Boolean algebras with a unary predicate representing, respectively, the property of being connected, and the property of having a connected interior. These languages are interpreted over the regular closed sets of n-dimensional Euclidean space (n greater than 1) and, additionally, over the regular closed… ▽ More We consider the quantifier-free languages, Bc and Bc0, obtained by augmenting the signature of Boolean algebras with a unary predicate representing, respectively, the property of being connected, and the property of having a connected interior. These languages are interpreted over the regular closed sets of n-dimensional Euclidean space (n greater than 1) and, additionally, over the regular closed polyhedral sets of n-dimensional Euclidean space. The resulting logics are examples of formalisms that have recently been proposed in the Artificial Intelligence literature under the rubric "Qualitative Spatial Reasoning." We prove that the satisfiability problem for Bc is undecidable over the regular closed polyhedra in all dimensions greater than 1, and that the satisfiability problem for both languages is undecidable over both the regular closed sets and the regular closed polyhedra in the Euclidean plane. However, we also prove that the satisfiability problem for Bc0 is NP-complete over the regular closed sets in all dimensions greater than 2, while the corresponding problem for the regular closed polyhedra is ExpTime-complete. Our results show, in particular, that spatial reasoning over Euclidean spaces is much harder than reasoning over arbitrary topological spaces. △ Less

Submitted 18 October, 2011; originally announced October 2011.

MSC Class: 68T30 (Primary) 03D15; 68Q17 (Secondary) ACM Class: I.2.4; F.4.3; F.2.2

Journal ref: ACM Transactions on Computational Logic, 14(2:13), 2013

Combining Spatial and Temporal Logics: Expressiveness vs. Complexity

Authors: D. Gabelaia, R. Kontchakov, A. Kurucz, F. Wolter, M. Zakharyaschev

Abstract: In this paper, we construct and investigate a hierarchy of spatio-temporal formalisms that result from various combinations of propositional spatial and temporal logics such as the propositional temporal logic PTL, the spatial logics RCC-8, BRCC-8, S4u and their fragments. The obtained results give a clear picture of the trade-off between expressiveness and computational realisability within the h… ▽ More In this paper, we construct and investigate a hierarchy of spatio-temporal formalisms that result from various combinations of propositional spatial and temporal logics such as the propositional temporal logic PTL, the spatial logics RCC-8, BRCC-8, S4u and their fragments. The obtained results give a clear picture of the trade-off between expressiveness and computational realisability within the hierarchy. We demonstrate how different combining principles as well as spatial and temporal primitives can produce NP-, PSPACE-, EXPSPACE-, 2EXPSPACE-complete, and even undecidable spatio-temporal logics out of components that are at most NP- or PSPACE-complete. △ Less

Submitted 12 October, 2011; originally announced October 2011.

Journal ref: Journal Of Artificial Intelligence Research, Volume 23, pages 167-243, 2005

On the Decidability of Connectedness Constraints in 2D and 3D Euclidean Spaces

Authors: Roman Kontchakov, Yavor Nenov, Ian Pratt-Hartmann, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: We investigate (quantifier-free) spatial constraint languages with equality, contact and connectedness predicates as well as Boolean operations on regions, interpreted over low-dimensional Euclidean spaces. We show that the complexity of reasoning varies dramatically depending on the dimension of the space and on the type of regions considered. For example, the logic with the interior-connectednes… ▽ More We investigate (quantifier-free) spatial constraint languages with equality, contact and connectedness predicates as well as Boolean operations on regions, interpreted over low-dimensional Euclidean spaces. We show that the complexity of reasoning varies dramatically depending on the dimension of the space and on the type of regions considered. For example, the logic with the interior-connectedness predicate (and without contact) is undecidable over polygons or regular closed sets in the Euclidean plane, NP-complete over regular closed sets in three-dimensional Euclidean space, and ExpTime-complete over polyhedra in three-dimensional Euclidean space. △ Less

Submitted 1 April, 2011; originally announced April 2011.

Comments: Accepted for publication in the IJCAI 2011 proceedings

Spatial logics with connectedness predicates

Authors: Roman Kontchakov, Ian Pratt-Hartmann, Frank Wolter, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: We consider quantifier-free spatial logics, designed for qualitative spatial representation and reasoning in AI, and extend them with the means to represent topological connectedness of regions and restrict the number of their connected components. We investigate the computational complexity of these logics and show that the connectedness constraints can increase complexity from NP to PSpace, Exp… ▽ More We consider quantifier-free spatial logics, designed for qualitative spatial representation and reasoning in AI, and extend them with the means to represent topological connectedness of regions and restrict the number of their connected components. We investigate the computational complexity of these logics and show that the connectedness constraints can increase complexity from NP to PSpace, ExpTime and, if component counting is allowed, to NExpTime. △ Less

Submitted 18 October, 2010; v1 submitted 28 March, 2010; originally announced March 2010.

Comments: Some results of the paper were presented at LPAR 2008 and ECAI 2000

ACM Class: F.4.1, I.2.4

Journal ref: Logical Methods in Computer Science, Volume 6, Issue 3 (August 18, 2010) lmcs:1229

Undecidability of the unification and admissibility problems for modal and description logics

Authors: Frank Wolter, Michael Zakharyaschev

Abstract: We show that the unification problem `is there a substitution instance of a given formula that is provable in a given logic?' is undecidable for basic modal logics K and K4 extended with the universal modality. It follows that the admissibility problem for inference rules is undecidable for these logics as well. These are the first examples of standard decidable modal logics for which the unific… ▽ More We show that the unification problem `is there a substitution instance of a given formula that is provable in a given logic?' is undecidable for basic modal logics K and K4 extended with the universal modality. It follows that the admissibility problem for inference rules is undecidable for these logics as well. These are the first examples of standard decidable modal logics for which the unification and admissibility problems are undecidable. We also prove undecidability of the unification and admissibility problems for K and K4 with at least two modal operators and nominals (instead of the universal modality), thereby showing that these problems are undecidable for basic hybrid logics. Recently, unification has been introduced as an important reasoning service for description logics. The undecidability proof for K with nominals can be used to show the undecidability of unification for boolean description logics with nominals (such as ALCO and SHIQO). The undecidability proof for K with the universal modality can be used to show that the unification problem relative to role boxes is undecidable for Boolean description logic with transitive roles, inverse roles, and role hierarchies (such as SHI and SHIQ). △ Less

Submitted 11 September, 2006; originally announced September 2006.