-
Describing Console I/O Behavior for Testing Student Submissions in Haskell
Authors:
Oliver Westphal,
Janis Voigtländer
Abstract:
We present a small, formal language for specifying the behavior of simple console I/O programs. The design is driven by the concrete application case of testing interactive Haskell programs written by students. Specifications are structurally similar to lexical analysis regular expressions, but are augmented with features like global variables that track state and history of program runs, enabling…
▽ More
We present a small, formal language for specifying the behavior of simple console I/O programs. The design is driven by the concrete application case of testing interactive Haskell programs written by students. Specifications are structurally similar to lexical analysis regular expressions, but are augmented with features like global variables that track state and history of program runs, enabling expression of an interesting range of dynamic behavior. We give a semantics for our specification language based on acceptance of execution traces. From this semantics we derive a definition of the set of all traces valid for a given specification. Sampling that set enables us to mechanically check program behavior against specifications in a probabilistic fashion. Beyond testing, other possible uses of the specification language in an education context include related activities like providing more helpful feedback, generating sample solutions, and even generating random exercise tasks.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2025; v1 submitted 20 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Free Theorems Simply, via Dinaturality
Authors:
Janis Voigtländer
Abstract:
Free theorems are a popular tool in reasoning about parametrically polymorphic code. They are also of instructive use in teaching. Their derivation, though, can be tedious, as it involves unfolding a lot of definitions, then hoping to be able to simplify the resulting logical formula to something nice and short. Even in a mechanised generator it is not easy to get the right heuristics in place to…
▽ More
Free theorems are a popular tool in reasoning about parametrically polymorphic code. They are also of instructive use in teaching. Their derivation, though, can be tedious, as it involves unfolding a lot of definitions, then hoping to be able to simplify the resulting logical formula to something nice and short. Even in a mechanised generator it is not easy to get the right heuristics in place to achieve good outcomes. Dinaturality is a categorical abstraction that captures many instances of free theorems. Arguably, its origins are more conceptually involved to explain, though, and generating useful statements from it also has its pitfalls. We present a simple approach for obtaining dinaturality-related free theorems from the standard formulation of relational parametricity in a rather direct way. It is conceptually appealing and easy to control and implement, as the provided Haskell code shows.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Proceedings 29th and 30th Workshops on (Constraint) Logic Programming and 24th International Workshop on Functional and (Constraint) Logic Programming
Authors:
Sibylle Schwarz,
Janis Voigtländer
Abstract:
The Workshops on (Constraint) Logic Programming (WLP) are the annual meeting of the German Society of Logic Programming (Gesellschaft für Logische Programmierung e.V., GLP) and bring together researchers interested in logic programming, constraint programming, answer set programming, and related areas like databases and artificial intelligence (not only from Germany).
The International Workshops…
▽ More
The Workshops on (Constraint) Logic Programming (WLP) are the annual meeting of the German Society of Logic Programming (Gesellschaft für Logische Programmierung e.V., GLP) and bring together researchers interested in logic programming, constraint programming, answer set programming, and related areas like databases and artificial intelligence (not only from Germany).
The International Workshops on Functional and (Constraint) Logic Programming (WFLP) aim at bringing together researchers, students, and practitioners interested in functional programming, logic programming, and their integration.
The workshops have a tradition of co-location to promote the cross-fertilizing exchange of ideas and experiences among and between the communities interested in the foundations, applications, and combinations of high-level, declarative programming languages and related areas.
△ Less
Submitted 31 December, 2016;
originally announced January 2017.
-
A Generic Scheme and Properties of Bidirectional Transformations
Authors:
Hugo Pacheco,
Nuno Macedo,
Alcino Cunha,
Janis Voigtländer
Abstract:
The recent rise of interest in bidirectional transformations (BXs) has led to the development of many BX frameworks, originating in diverse computer science disciplines. From a user perspective, these frameworks vary significantly in both interface and predictability of the underlying bidirectionalization technique. In this paper we start by presenting a generic BX scheme that can be instantiated…
▽ More
The recent rise of interest in bidirectional transformations (BXs) has led to the development of many BX frameworks, originating in diverse computer science disciplines. From a user perspective, these frameworks vary significantly in both interface and predictability of the underlying bidirectionalization technique. In this paper we start by presenting a generic BX scheme that can be instantiated to different concrete interfaces, by plugging-in the desired notion of update and traceability. Based on that scheme, we then present several desirable generic properties that may characterize a BX framework, and show how they can be instantiated to concrete interfaces. This generic presentation is useful when exploring the BX design space: it might help developers when designing new frameworks and end-users when comparing existing ones. We support the latter claim, by applying it in a comparative survey of popular existing BX frameworks.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2013; v1 submitted 19 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
Improvements for Free
Authors:
Daniel Seidel,
Janis Voigtländer
Abstract:
"Theorems for Free!" (Wadler, FPCA 1989) is a slogan for a technique that allows to derive statements about functions just from their types. So far, the statements considered have always had a purely extensional flavor: statements relating the value semantics of program expressions, but not statements relating their runtime (or other) cost. Here we study an extension of the technique that allows p…
▽ More
"Theorems for Free!" (Wadler, FPCA 1989) is a slogan for a technique that allows to derive statements about functions just from their types. So far, the statements considered have always had a purely extensional flavor: statements relating the value semantics of program expressions, but not statements relating their runtime (or other) cost. Here we study an extension of the technique that allows precisely statements of the latter flavor, by deriving quantitative theorems for free. After developing the theory, we walk through a number of example derivations. Probably none of the statements derived in those simple examples will be particularly surprising to most readers, but what is maybe surprising, and at the very least novel, is that there is a general technique for obtaining such results on a quantitative level in a principled way. Moreover, there is good potential to bring that technique to bear on more complex examples as well. We turn our attention to short-cut fusion (Gill et al., FPCA 1993) in particular.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2011;
originally announced July 2011.
