-
Regulating Next-Generation Implantable Brain-Computer Interfaces: Recommendations for Ethical Development and Implementation
Authors:
Renee Sirbu,
Jessica Morley,
Tyler Schroder,
Mariarosaria Taddeo,
Raghavendra Pradyumna Pothukuchi,
Muhammed Ugur,
Abhishek Bhattacharjee,
Luciano Floridi
Abstract:
Brain-computer interfaces offer significant therapeutic opportunities for a variety of neurophysiological and neuropsychiatric disorders and may perhaps one day lead to augmenting the cognition and decision-making of the healthy brain. However, existing regulatory frameworks designed for implantable medical devices are inadequate to address the unique ethical, legal, and social risks associated wi…
▽ More
Brain-computer interfaces offer significant therapeutic opportunities for a variety of neurophysiological and neuropsychiatric disorders and may perhaps one day lead to augmenting the cognition and decision-making of the healthy brain. However, existing regulatory frameworks designed for implantable medical devices are inadequate to address the unique ethical, legal, and social risks associated with next-generation networked brain-computer interfaces. In this article, we make nine recommendations to support developers in the design of BCIs and nine recommendations to support policymakers in the application of BCIs, drawing insights from the regulatory history of IMDs and principles from AI ethics. We begin by outlining the historical development of IMDs and the regulatory milestones that have shaped their oversight. Next, we summarize similarities between IMDs and emerging implantable BCIs, identifying existing provisions for their regulation. We then use two case studies of emerging cutting-edge BCIs, the HALO and SCALO computer systems, to highlight distinctive features in the design and application of next-generation BCIs arising from contemporary chip architectures, which necessitate reevaluating regulatory approaches. We identify critical ethical considerations for these BCIs, including unique conceptions of autonomy, identity, and mental privacy. Based on these insights, we suggest potential avenues for the ethical regulation of BCIs, emphasizing the importance of interdisciplinary collaboration and proactive mitigation of potential harms. The goal is to support the responsible design and application of new BCIs, ensuring their safe and ethical integration into medical practice.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
Swapping-Centric Neural Recording Systems
Authors:
Muhammed Ugur,
Raghavendra Pradyumna Pothukuchi,
Abhishek Bhattacharjee
Abstract:
Neural interfaces read the activity of biological neurons to help advance the neurosciences and offer treatment options for severe neurological diseases. The total number of neurons that are now being recorded using multi-electrode interfaces is doubling roughly every 4-6 years \cite{Stevenson2011}. However, processing this exponentially-growing data in real-time under strict power-constraints put…
▽ More
Neural interfaces read the activity of biological neurons to help advance the neurosciences and offer treatment options for severe neurological diseases. The total number of neurons that are now being recorded using multi-electrode interfaces is doubling roughly every 4-6 years \cite{Stevenson2011}. However, processing this exponentially-growing data in real-time under strict power-constraints puts an exorbitant amount of pressure on both compute and storage within traditional neural recording systems. Existing systems deploy various accelerators for better performance-per-watt while also integrating NVMs for data querying and better treatment decisions. These accelerators have direct access to a limited amount of fast SRAM-based memory that is unable to manage the growing data rates. Swapping to the NVM becomes inevitable; however, naive approaches are unable to complete during the refractory period of a neuron -- i.e., a few milliseconds -- which disrupts timely disease treatment. We propose co-designing accelerators and storage, with swapping as a primary design goal, using theoretical and practical models of compute and storage respectively to overcome these limitations.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Towards Forever Access for Implanted Brain-Computer Interfaces
Authors:
Muhammed Ugur,
Raghavendra Pradyumna Pothukuchi,
Abhishek Bhattacharjee
Abstract:
Designs for implanted brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) have increased significantly in recent years. Each device promises better clinical outcomes and quality-of-life improvements, yet due to severe and inflexible safety constraints, progress requires tight co-design from materials to circuits and all the way up the stack to applications and algorithms. This trend has become more aggressive over t…
▽ More
Designs for implanted brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) have increased significantly in recent years. Each device promises better clinical outcomes and quality-of-life improvements, yet due to severe and inflexible safety constraints, progress requires tight co-design from materials to circuits and all the way up the stack to applications and algorithms. This trend has become more aggressive over time, forcing clinicians and patients to rely on vendor-specific hardware and software for deployment, maintenance, upgrades, and replacement. This over-reliance is ethically problematic, especially if companies go out-of-business or business objectives diverge from clinical promises. Device heterogeneity additionally burdens clinicians and healthcare facilities, adding complexity and costs for in-clinic visits, monitoring, and continuous access.
Reliability, interoperability, portability, and future-proofed design is needed, but this unfortunately comes at a cost. These system features sap resources that would have otherwise been allocated to reduce power/energy and improve performance. Navigating this trade-off in a systematic way is critical to providing patients with forever access to their implants and reducing burdens placed on healthcare providers and caretakers. We study the integration of on-device storage to highlight the sensitivity of this trade-off and establish other points of interest within BCI design that require careful investigation. In the process, we revisit relevant problems in computer architecture and medical devices from the current era of hardware specialization and modern neurotechnology.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
The Interplay of Computing, Ethics, and Policy in Brain-Computer Interface Design
Authors:
Muhammed Ugur,
Raghavendra Pradyumna Pothukuchi,
Abhishek Bhattacharjee
Abstract:
Brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) connect biological neurons in the brain with external systems like prosthetics and computers. They are increasingly incorporating processing capabilities to analyze and stimulate neural activity, and consequently, pose unique design challenges related to ethics, law, and policy. For the first time, this paper articulates how ethical, legal, and policy consideration…
▽ More
Brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) connect biological neurons in the brain with external systems like prosthetics and computers. They are increasingly incorporating processing capabilities to analyze and stimulate neural activity, and consequently, pose unique design challenges related to ethics, law, and policy. For the first time, this paper articulates how ethical, legal, and policy considerations can shape BCI architecture design, and how the decisions that architects make constrain or expand the ethical, legal, and policy frameworks that can be applied to them.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
A Multi-Site Accelerator-Rich Processing Fabric for Scalable Brain-Computer Interfacing
Authors:
Karthik Sriram,
Raghavendra Pradyumna Pothukuchi,
Michał Gerasimiuk,
Oliver Ye,
Muhammed Ugur,
Rajit Manohar,
Anurag Khandelwal,
Abhishek Bhattacharjee
Abstract:
Hull is an accelerator-rich distributed implantable Brain-Computer Interface (BCI) that reads biological neurons at data rates that are 2-3 orders of magnitude higher than the prior state of art, while supporting many neuroscientific applications. Prior approaches have restricted brain interfacing to tens of megabits per second in order to meet two constraints necessary for effective operation and…
▽ More
Hull is an accelerator-rich distributed implantable Brain-Computer Interface (BCI) that reads biological neurons at data rates that are 2-3 orders of magnitude higher than the prior state of art, while supporting many neuroscientific applications. Prior approaches have restricted brain interfacing to tens of megabits per second in order to meet two constraints necessary for effective operation and safe long-term implantation -- power dissipation under tens of milliwatts and response latencies in the tens of milliseconds. Hull also adheres to these constraints, but is able to interface with the brain at much higher data rates, thereby enabling, for the first time, BCI-driven research on and clinical treatment of brain-wide behaviors and diseases that require reading and stimulating many brain locations. Central to Hull's power efficiency is its realization as a distributed system of BCI nodes with accelerator-rich compute. Hull balances modular system layering with aggressive cross-layer hardware-software co-design to integrate compute, networking, and storage. The result is a lesson in designing networked distributed systems with hardware accelerators from the ground up.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
