-
Online Weighted Paging with Unknown Weights
Authors:
Orin Levy,
Noam Touitou,
Aviv Rosenberg
Abstract:
Online paging is a fundamental problem in the field of online algorithms, in which one maintains a cache of $k$ slots as requests for fetching pages arrive online. In the weighted variant of this problem, each page has its own fetching cost; a substantial line of work on this problem culminated in an (optimal) $O(\log k)$-competitive randomized algorithm, due to Bansal, Buchbinder and Naor (FOCS'0…
▽ More
Online paging is a fundamental problem in the field of online algorithms, in which one maintains a cache of $k$ slots as requests for fetching pages arrive online. In the weighted variant of this problem, each page has its own fetching cost; a substantial line of work on this problem culminated in an (optimal) $O(\log k)$-competitive randomized algorithm, due to Bansal, Buchbinder and Naor (FOCS'07).
Existing work for weighted paging assumes that page weights are known in advance, which is not always the case in practice. For example, in multi-level caching architectures, the expected cost of fetching a memory block is a function of its probability of being in a mid-level cache rather than the main memory. This complex property cannot be predicted in advance; over time, however, one may glean information about page weights through sampling their fetching cost multiple times.
We present the first algorithm for online weighted paging that does not know page weights in advance, but rather learns from weight samples. In terms of techniques, this requires providing (integral) samples to a fractional solver, requiring a delicate interface between this solver and the randomized rounding scheme; we believe that our work can inspire online algorithms to other problems that involve cost sampling.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Improved and Deterministic Online Service with Deadlines or Delay
Authors:
Noam Touitou
Abstract:
We consider the problem of online service with delay on a general metric space, first presented by Azar, Ganesh, Ge and Panigrahi (STOC 2017). The best known randomized algorithm for this problem, by Azar and Touitou (FOCS 2019), is $O(\log^2 n)$-competitive, where $n$ is the number of points in the metric space. This is also the best known result for the special case of online service with deadli…
▽ More
We consider the problem of online service with delay on a general metric space, first presented by Azar, Ganesh, Ge and Panigrahi (STOC 2017). The best known randomized algorithm for this problem, by Azar and Touitou (FOCS 2019), is $O(\log^2 n)$-competitive, where $n$ is the number of points in the metric space. This is also the best known result for the special case of online service with deadlines, which is of independent interest.
In this paper, we present $O(\log n)$-competitive deterministic algorithms for online service with deadlines or delay, improving upon the results from FOCS 2019. Furthermore, our algorithms are the first deterministic algorithms for online service with deadlines or delay which apply to general metric spaces and have sub-polynomial competitiveness.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Online Graph Algorithms with Predictions
Authors:
Yossi Azar,
Debmalya Panigrahi,
Noam Touitou
Abstract:
Online algorithms with predictions is a popular and elegant framework for bypassing pessimistic lower bounds in competitive analysis. In this model, online algorithms are supplied with future predictions, and the goal is for the competitive ratio to smoothly interpolate between the best offline and online bounds as a function of the prediction error. In this paper, we study online graph problems w…
▽ More
Online algorithms with predictions is a popular and elegant framework for bypassing pessimistic lower bounds in competitive analysis. In this model, online algorithms are supplied with future predictions, and the goal is for the competitive ratio to smoothly interpolate between the best offline and online bounds as a function of the prediction error. In this paper, we study online graph problems with predictions. Our contributions are the following:
* The first question is defining prediction error. For graph/metric problems, there can be two types of error, locations that are not predicted, and locations that are predicted but the predicted and actual locations do not coincide exactly. We design a novel definition of prediction error called metric error with outliers to simultaneously capture both types of errors, which thereby generalizes previous definitions of error that only capture one of the two error types.
* We give a general framework for obtaining online algorithms with predictions that combines, in a "black box" fashion, existing online and offline algorithms, under certain technical conditions. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first general-purpose tool for obtaining online algorithms with predictions.
* Using our framework, we obtain tight bounds on the competitive ratio of several classical graph problems as a function of metric error with outliers: Steiner tree, Steiner forest, priority Steiner tree/forest, and uncapacitated/capacitated facility location.
Both the definition of metric error with outliers and the general framework for combining offline and online algorithms are not specific to the problems that we consider in this paper. We hope that these will be useful for future work in this domain.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Distortion-Oblivious Algorithms for Minimizing Flow Time
Authors:
Yossi Azar,
Stefano Leonardi,
Noam Touitou
Abstract:
We consider the classic online problem of scheduling on a single machine to minimize total flow time. In STOC 2021, the concept of robustness to distortion in processing times was introduced: for every distortion factor $μ$, an $O(μ^2)$-competitive algorithm $\operatorname{ALG}_μ$ which handles distortions up to $μ$ was presented. However, using that result requires one to know the distortion of t…
▽ More
We consider the classic online problem of scheduling on a single machine to minimize total flow time. In STOC 2021, the concept of robustness to distortion in processing times was introduced: for every distortion factor $μ$, an $O(μ^2)$-competitive algorithm $\operatorname{ALG}_μ$ which handles distortions up to $μ$ was presented. However, using that result requires one to know the distortion of the input in advance, which is impractical.
We present the first \emph{distortion-oblivious} algorithms: algorithms which are competitive for \emph{every} input of \emph{every} distortion, and thus do not require knowledge of the distortion in advance. Moreover, the competitive ratios of our algorithms are $\tilde{O}(μ)$, which is a quadratic improvement over the algorithm from STOC 2021, and is nearly optimal (we show a randomized lower bound of $Ω(μ)$ on competitiveness).
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Flow Time Scheduling with Uncertain Processing Time
Authors:
Yossi Azar,
Stefano Leonardi,
Noam Touitou
Abstract:
We consider the problem of online scheduling on a single machine in order to minimize weighted flow time. The existing algorithms for this problem (STOC '01, SODA '03, FOCS '18) all require exact knowledge of the processing time of each job. This assumption is crucial, as even a slight perturbation of the processing time would lead to polynomial competitive ratio. However, this assumption very rar…
▽ More
We consider the problem of online scheduling on a single machine in order to minimize weighted flow time. The existing algorithms for this problem (STOC '01, SODA '03, FOCS '18) all require exact knowledge of the processing time of each job. This assumption is crucial, as even a slight perturbation of the processing time would lead to polynomial competitive ratio. However, this assumption very rarely holds in real-life scenarios.
In this paper, we present the first algorithm for weighted flow time which do not require exact knowledge of the processing times of jobs. Specifically, we introduce the Scheduling with Predicted Processing Time (SPPT) problem, where the algorithm is given a prediction for the processing time of each job, instead of its real processing time. For the case of a constant factor distortion between the predictions and the real processing time, our algorithms match all the best known competitiveness bounds for weighted flow time -- namely $O(\log P), O(\log D)$ and $O(\log W)$, where $P,D,W$ are the maximum ratios of processing times, densities, and weights, respectively. For larger errors, the competitiveness of our algorithms degrades gracefully.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Beyond Tree Embeddings -- a Deterministic Framework for Network Design with Deadlines or Delay
Authors:
Yossi Azar,
Noam Touitou
Abstract:
We consider network design problems with deadline or delay. All previous results for these models are based on randomized embedding of the graph into a tree (HST) and then solving the problem on this tree. We show that this is not necessary. In particular, we design a deterministic framework for these problems which is not based on embedding. This enables us to provide deterministic…
▽ More
We consider network design problems with deadline or delay. All previous results for these models are based on randomized embedding of the graph into a tree (HST) and then solving the problem on this tree. We show that this is not necessary. In particular, we design a deterministic framework for these problems which is not based on embedding. This enables us to provide deterministic $\text{poly-log}(n)$-competitive algorithms for Steiner tree, generalized Steiner tree, node weighted Steiner tree, (non-uniform) facility location and directed Steiner tree with deadlines or with delay (where $n$ is the number of nodes). Our deterministic algorithms also give improved guarantees over some previous randomized results. In addition, we show a lower bound of $\text{poly-log}(n)$ for some of these problems, which implies that our framework is optimal up to the power of the poly-log. Our algorithms and techniques differ significantly from those in all previous considerations of these problems.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
General Framework for Metric Optimization Problems with Delay or with Deadlines
Authors:
Yossi Azar,
Noam Touitou
Abstract:
In this paper, we present a framework used to construct and analyze algorithms for online optimization problems with deadlines or with delay over a metric space. Using this framework, we present algorithms for several different problems. We present an $O(D^{2})$-competitive deterministic algorithm for online multilevel aggregation with delay on a tree of depth $D$, an exponential improvement over…
▽ More
In this paper, we present a framework used to construct and analyze algorithms for online optimization problems with deadlines or with delay over a metric space. Using this framework, we present algorithms for several different problems. We present an $O(D^{2})$-competitive deterministic algorithm for online multilevel aggregation with delay on a tree of depth $D$, an exponential improvement over the $O(D^{4}2^{D})$-competitive algorithm of Bienkowski et al. (ESA '16), where the only previously-known improvement was for the special case of deadlines by Buchbinder et al. (SODA '17). We also present an $O(\log^{2}n)$-competitive randomized algorithm for online service with delay over any general metric space of $n$ points, improving upon the $O(\log^{4}n)$-competitive algorithm by Azar et al. (STOC '17). In addition, we present the problem of online facility location with deadlines. In this problem, requests arrive over time in a metric space, and need to be served until their deadlines by facilities that are opened momentarily for some cost. We also consider the problem of facility location with delay, in which the deadlines are replaced with arbitrary delay functions. For those problems, we present $O(\log^{2}n)$-competitive algorithms, with $n$ the number of points in the metric space. The algorithmic framework we present includes techniques for the design of algorithms as well as techniques for their analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Set Cover with Delay -- Clairvoyance is not Required
Authors:
Yossi Azar,
Ashish Chiplunkar,
Shay Kutten,
Noam Touitou
Abstract:
In most online problems with delay, clairvoyance (i.e. knowing the future delay of a request upon its arrival) is required for polylogarithmic competitiveness. In this paper, we show that this is not the case for set cover with delay (SCD) -- specifically, we present the first non-clairvoyant algorithm, which is $O(\log n \log m)$-competitive, where $n$ is the number of elements and $m$ is the num…
▽ More
In most online problems with delay, clairvoyance (i.e. knowing the future delay of a request upon its arrival) is required for polylogarithmic competitiveness. In this paper, we show that this is not the case for set cover with delay (SCD) -- specifically, we present the first non-clairvoyant algorithm, which is $O(\log n \log m)$-competitive, where $n$ is the number of elements and $m$ is the number of sets. This matches the best known result for the classic online set cover (a special case of non-clairvoyant SCD). Moreover, clairvoyance does not allow for significant improvement - we present lower bounds of $Ω(\sqrt{\log n})$ and $Ω(\sqrt{\log m})$ for SCD which apply for the clairvoyant case. In addition, the competitiveness of our algorithm does not depend on the number of requests. Such a guarantee on the size of the universe alone was not previously known even for the clairvoyant case - the only previously-known algorithm (due to Carrasco et al.) is clairvoyant, with competitiveness that grows with the number of requests. For the special case of vertex cover with delay, we show a simpler, deterministic algorithm which is $3$-competitive (and also non-clairvoyant).
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2020; v1 submitted 23 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Improved Online Algorithm for Weighted Flow Time
Authors:
Yossi Azar,
Noam Touitou
Abstract:
We discuss one of the most fundamental scheduling problem of processing jobs on a single machine to minimize the weighted flow time (weighted response time). Our main result is a $O(\log P)$-competitive algorithm, where $P$ is the maximum-to-minimum processing time ratio, improving upon the $O(\log^{2}P)$-competitive algorithm of Chekuri, Khanna and Zhu (STOC 2001). We also design a $O(\log D)$-co…
▽ More
We discuss one of the most fundamental scheduling problem of processing jobs on a single machine to minimize the weighted flow time (weighted response time). Our main result is a $O(\log P)$-competitive algorithm, where $P$ is the maximum-to-minimum processing time ratio, improving upon the $O(\log^{2}P)$-competitive algorithm of Chekuri, Khanna and Zhu (STOC 2001). We also design a $O(\log D)$-competitive algorithm, where $D$ is the maximum-to-minimum density ratio of jobs. Finally, we show how to combine these results with the result of Bansal and Dhamdhere (SODA 2003) to achieve a $O(\log(\min(P,D,W)))$-competitive algorithm (where $W$ is the maximum-to-minimum weight ratio), without knowing $P,D,W$ in advance. As shown by Bansal and Chan (SODA 2009), no constant-competitive algorithm is achievable for this problem.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2018; v1 submitted 29 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
