-
Survey of Active Learning Hyperparameters: Insights from a Large-Scale Experimental Grid
Authors:
Julius Gonsior,
Tim Rieß,
Anja Reusch,
Claudio Hartmann,
Maik Thiele,
Wolfgang Lehner
Abstract:
Annotating data is a time-consuming and costly task, but it is inherently required for supervised machine learning. Active Learning (AL) is an established method that minimizes human labeling effort by iteratively selecting the most informative unlabeled samples for expert annotation, thereby improving the overall classification performance. Even though AL has been known for decades, AL is still r…
▽ More
Annotating data is a time-consuming and costly task, but it is inherently required for supervised machine learning. Active Learning (AL) is an established method that minimizes human labeling effort by iteratively selecting the most informative unlabeled samples for expert annotation, thereby improving the overall classification performance. Even though AL has been known for decades, AL is still rarely used in real-world applications. As indicated in the two community web surveys among the NLP community about AL, two main reasons continue to hold practitioners back from using AL: first, the complexity of setting AL up, and second, a lack of trust in its effectiveness. We hypothesize that both reasons share the same culprit: the large hyperparameter space of AL. This mostly unexplored hyperparameter space often leads to misleading and irreproducible AL experiment results. In this study, we first compiled a large hyperparameter grid of over 4.6 million hyperparameter combinations, second, recorded the performance of all combinations in the so-far biggest conducted AL study, and third, analyzed the impact of each hyperparameter in the experiment results. In the end, we give recommendations about the influence of each hyperparameter, demonstrate the surprising influence of the concrete AL strategy implementation, and outline an experimental study design for reproducible AL experiments with minimal computational effort, thus contributing to more reproducible and trustworthy AL research in the future.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
Graph Visualization for Blockchain Data
Authors:
Marcell Dietl,
Andre Gemünd,
Daniel Oeltz,
Felix M. Thiele,
Christian Werner
Abstract:
In this report, we introduce a novel approach to visualize extremely large graphs efficiently. Our method combines two force-directed algorithms, Kamada-Kawai and ForceAtlas2, to handle different graph components based on their node count. Additionally, we suggest utilizing the Fast Multipole method to enhance the speed of ForceAtlas2. Although initially designed for analyzing bitcoin transaction…
▽ More
In this report, we introduce a novel approach to visualize extremely large graphs efficiently. Our method combines two force-directed algorithms, Kamada-Kawai and ForceAtlas2, to handle different graph components based on their node count. Additionally, we suggest utilizing the Fast Multipole method to enhance the speed of ForceAtlas2. Although initially designed for analyzing bitcoin transaction graphs, for which we present results here, this algorithm can also be applied to other crypto currency transaction graphs or graphs from diverse domains.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
To Softmax, or not to Softmax: that is the question when applying Active Learning for Transformer Models
Authors:
Julius Gonsior,
Christian Falkenberg,
Silvio Magino,
Anja Reusch,
Maik Thiele,
Wolfgang Lehner
Abstract:
Despite achieving state-of-the-art results in nearly all Natural Language Processing applications, fine-tuning Transformer-based language models still requires a significant amount of labeled data to work. A well known technique to reduce the amount of human effort in acquiring a labeled dataset is \textit{Active Learning} (AL): an iterative process in which only the minimal amount of samples is l…
▽ More
Despite achieving state-of-the-art results in nearly all Natural Language Processing applications, fine-tuning Transformer-based language models still requires a significant amount of labeled data to work. A well known technique to reduce the amount of human effort in acquiring a labeled dataset is \textit{Active Learning} (AL): an iterative process in which only the minimal amount of samples is labeled. AL strategies require access to a quantified confidence measure of the model predictions. A common choice is the softmax activation function for the final layer. As the softmax function provides misleading probabilities, this paper compares eight alternatives on seven datasets. Our almost paradoxical finding is that most of the methods are too good at identifying the true most uncertain samples (outliers), and that labeling therefore exclusively outliers results in worse performance. As a heuristic we propose to systematically ignore samples, which results in improvements of various methods compared to the softmax function.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
ImitAL: Learned Active Learning Strategy on Synthetic Data
Authors:
Julius Gonsior,
Maik Thiele,
Wolfgang Lehner
Abstract:
Active Learning (AL) is a well-known standard method for efficiently obtaining annotated data by first labeling the samples that contain the most information based on a query strategy. In the past, a large variety of such query strategies has been proposed, with each generation of new strategies increasing the runtime and adding more complexity. However, to the best of our our knowledge, none of t…
▽ More
Active Learning (AL) is a well-known standard method for efficiently obtaining annotated data by first labeling the samples that contain the most information based on a query strategy. In the past, a large variety of such query strategies has been proposed, with each generation of new strategies increasing the runtime and adding more complexity. However, to the best of our our knowledge, none of these strategies excels consistently over a large number of datasets from different application domains. Basically, most of the the existing AL strategies are a combination of the two simple heuristics informativeness and representativeness, and the big differences lie in the combination of the often conflicting heuristics. Within this paper, we propose ImitAL, a domain-independent novel query strategy, which encodes AL as a learning-to-rank problem and learns an optimal combination between both heuristics. We train ImitAL on large-scale simulated AL runs on purely synthetic datasets. To show that ImitAL was successfully trained, we perform an extensive evaluation comparing our strategy on 13 different datasets, from a wide range of domains, with 7 other query strategies.
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
ImitAL: Learning Active Learning Strategies from Synthetic Data
Authors:
Julius Gonsior,
Maik Thiele,
Wolfgang Lehner
Abstract:
One of the biggest challenges that complicates applied supervised machine learning is the need for huge amounts of labeled data. Active Learning (AL) is a well-known standard method for efficiently obtaining labeled data by first labeling the samples that contain the most information based on a query strategy. Although many methods for query strategies have been proposed in the past, no clear supe…
▽ More
One of the biggest challenges that complicates applied supervised machine learning is the need for huge amounts of labeled data. Active Learning (AL) is a well-known standard method for efficiently obtaining labeled data by first labeling the samples that contain the most information based on a query strategy. Although many methods for query strategies have been proposed in the past, no clear superior method that works well in general for all domains has been found yet. Additionally, many strategies are computationally expensive which further hinders the widespread use of AL for large-scale annotation projects.
We, therefore, propose ImitAL, a novel query strategy, which encodes AL as a learning-to-rank problem. For training the underlying neural network we chose Imitation Learning. The required demonstrative expert experience for training is generated from purely synthetic data.
To show the general and superior applicability of \ImitAL{}, we perform an extensive evaluation comparing our strategy on 15 different datasets, from a wide range of domains, with 10 different state-of-the-art query strategies. We also show that our approach is more runtime performant than most other strategies, especially on very large datasets.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Revisiting the Arguments for Edge Computing Research
Authors:
Blesson Varghese,
Eyal de Lara,
Aaron Ding,
Cheol-Ho Hong,
Flavio Bonomi,
Schahram Dustdar,
Paul Harvey,
Peter Hewkin,
Weisong Shi,
Mark Thiele,
Peter Willis
Abstract:
This article argues that low latency, high bandwidth, device proliferation, sustainable digital infrastructure, and data privacy and sovereignty continue to motivate the need for edge computing research even though its initial concepts were formulated more than a decade ago.
This article argues that low latency, high bandwidth, device proliferation, sustainable digital infrastructure, and data privacy and sovereignty continue to motivate the need for edge computing research even though its initial concepts were formulated more than a decade ago.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Accurate and Efficient Time Series Matching by Season- and Trend-aware Symbolic Approximation -- Extended Version Including Additional Evaluation and Proofs
Authors:
Lars Kegel,
Claudio Hartmann,
Maik Thiele,
Wolfgang Lehner
Abstract:
Processing and analyzing time series data\-sets have become a central issue in many domains requiring data management systems to support time series as a native data type. A crucial prerequisite of these systems is time series matching, which still is a challenging problem. A time series is a high-dimensional data type, its representation is storage-, and its comparison is time-consuming. Among th…
▽ More
Processing and analyzing time series data\-sets have become a central issue in many domains requiring data management systems to support time series as a native data type. A crucial prerequisite of these systems is time series matching, which still is a challenging problem. A time series is a high-dimensional data type, its representation is storage-, and its comparison is time-consuming. Among the representation techniques that tackle these challenges, the symbolic aggregate approximation (SAX) is the current state of the art. This technique reduces a time series to a low-dimensional space by segmenting it and discretizing each segment into a small symbolic alphabet. However, SAX ignores the deterministic behavior of time series such as cyclical repeating patterns or trend component affecting all segments and leading to a distortion of the symbolic distribution. In this paper, we present a season- and a trend-aware symbolic approximation. We show that this improves the symbolic distribution and increase the representation accuracy without increasing its memory footprint. Most importantly, this enables a more efficient time series matching by providing a match up to three orders of magnitude faster than SAX.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2021; v1 submitted 31 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
RETRO: Relation Retrofitting For In-Database Machine Learning on Textual Data
Authors:
Michael Günther,
Maik Thiele,
Wolfgang Lehner
Abstract:
There are massive amounts of textual data residing in databases, valuable for many machine learning (ML) tasks. Since ML techniques depend on numerical input representations, word embeddings are increasingly utilized to convert symbolic representations such as text into meaningful numbers. However, a naive one-to-one mapping of each word in a database to a word embedding vector is not sufficient a…
▽ More
There are massive amounts of textual data residing in databases, valuable for many machine learning (ML) tasks. Since ML techniques depend on numerical input representations, word embeddings are increasingly utilized to convert symbolic representations such as text into meaningful numbers. However, a naive one-to-one mapping of each word in a database to a word embedding vector is not sufficient and would lead to poor accuracies in ML tasks. Thus, we argue to additionally incorporate the information given by the database schema into the embedding, e.g. which words appear in the same column or are related to each other. In this paper, we propose RETRO (RElational reTROfitting), a novel approach to learn numerical representations of text values in databases, capturing the best of both worlds, the rich information encoded by word embeddings and the relational information encoded by database tables. We formulate relation retrofitting as a learning problem and present an efficient algorithm solving it. We investigate the impact of various hyperparameters on the learning problem and derive good settings for all of them. Our evaluation shows that the proposed embeddings are ready-to-use for many ML tasks such as classification and regression and even outperform state-of-the-art techniques in integration tasks such as null value imputation and link prediction.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2020; v1 submitted 28 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
A Cost-based Storage Format Selector for Materialization in Big Data Frameworks
Authors:
Rana Faisal Munir,
Alberto Abelló,
Oscar Romero,
Maik Thiele,
Wolfgang Lehner
Abstract:
Modern big data frameworks (such as Hadoop and Spark) allow multiple users to do large-scale analysis simultaneously. Typically, users deploy Data-Intensive Workflows (DIWs) for their analytical tasks. These DIWs of different users share many common parts (i.e, 50-80%), which can be materialized to reuse them in future executions. The materialization improves the overall processing time of DIWs an…
▽ More
Modern big data frameworks (such as Hadoop and Spark) allow multiple users to do large-scale analysis simultaneously. Typically, users deploy Data-Intensive Workflows (DIWs) for their analytical tasks. These DIWs of different users share many common parts (i.e, 50-80%), which can be materialized to reuse them in future executions. The materialization improves the overall processing time of DIWs and also saves computational resources. Current solutions for materialization store data on Distributed File Systems (DFS) by using a fixed data format. However, a fixed choice might not be the optimal one for every situation. For example, it is well-known that different data fragmentation strategies (i.e., horizontal, vertical or hybrid) behave better or worse according to the access patterns of the subsequent operations.
In this paper, we present a cost-based approach which helps deciding the most appropriate storage format in every situation. A generic cost-based storage format selector framework considering the three fragmentation strategies is presented. Then, we use our framework to instantiate cost models for specific Hadoop data formats (namely SequenceFile, Avro and Parquet), and test it with realistic use cases. Our solution gives on average 33% speedup over SequenceFile, 11% speedup over Avro, 32% speedup over Parquet, and overall, it provides upto 25% performance gain.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Identifying And Weighting Integration Hypotheses On Open Data Platforms
Authors:
Julian Eberius,
Katrin Braunschweig,
Maik Thiele,
Wolfgang Lehner
Abstract:
Open data platforms such as data.gov or opendata.socrata. com provide a huge amount of valuable information. Their free-for-all nature, the lack of publishing standards and the multitude of domains and authors represented on these platforms lead to new integration and standardization problems. At the same time, crowd-based data integration techniques are emerging as new way of dealing with these p…
▽ More
Open data platforms such as data.gov or opendata.socrata. com provide a huge amount of valuable information. Their free-for-all nature, the lack of publishing standards and the multitude of domains and authors represented on these platforms lead to new integration and standardization problems. At the same time, crowd-based data integration techniques are emerging as new way of dealing with these problems. However, these methods still require input in form of specific questions or tasks that can be passed to the crowd. This paper discusses integration problems on Open Data Platforms, and proposes a method for identifying and ranking integration hypotheses in this context. We will evaluate our findings by conducting a comprehensive evaluation using on one of the largest Open Data platforms.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
