-
Safety with Agency: Human-Centered Safety Filter with Application to AI-Assisted Motorsports
Authors:
Donggeon David Oh,
Justin Lidard,
Haimin Hu,
Himani Sinhmar,
Elle Lazarski,
Deepak Gopinath,
Emily S. Sumner,
Jonathan A. DeCastro,
Guy Rosman,
Naomi Ehrich Leonard,
Jaime Fernández Fisac
Abstract:
We propose a human-centered safety filter (HCSF) for shared autonomy that significantly enhances system safety without compromising human agency. Our HCSF is built on a neural safety value function, which we first learn scalably through black-box interactions and then use at deployment to enforce a novel state-action control barrier function (Q-CBF) safety constraint. Since this Q-CBF safety filte…
▽ More
We propose a human-centered safety filter (HCSF) for shared autonomy that significantly enhances system safety without compromising human agency. Our HCSF is built on a neural safety value function, which we first learn scalably through black-box interactions and then use at deployment to enforce a novel state-action control barrier function (Q-CBF) safety constraint. Since this Q-CBF safety filter does not require any knowledge of the system dynamics for both synthesis and runtime safety monitoring and intervention, our method applies readily to complex, black-box shared autonomy systems. Notably, our HCSF's CBF-based interventions modify the human's actions minimally and smoothly, avoiding the abrupt, last-moment corrections delivered by many conventional safety filters. We validate our approach in a comprehensive in-person user study using Assetto Corsa-a high-fidelity car racing simulator with black-box dynamics-to assess robustness in "driving on the edge" scenarios. We compare both trajectory data and drivers' perceptions of our HCSF assistance against unassisted driving and a conventional safety filter. Experimental results show that 1) compared to having no assistance, our HCSF improves both safety and user satisfaction without compromising human agency or comfort, and 2) relative to a conventional safety filter, our proposed HCSF boosts human agency, comfort, and satisfaction while maintaining robustness.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2025; v1 submitted 15 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Shared Autonomy for Proximal Teaching
Authors:
Megha Srivastava,
Reihaneh Iranmanesh,
Yuchen Cui,
Deepak Gopinath,
Emily Sumner,
Andrew Silva,
Laporsha Dees,
Guy Rosman,
Dorsa Sadigh
Abstract:
Motor skill learning often requires experienced professionals who can provide personalized instruction. Unfortunately, the availability of high-quality training can be limited for specialized tasks, such as high performance racing. Several recent works have leveraged AI-assistance to improve instruction of tasks ranging from rehabilitation to surgical robot tele-operation. However, these works oft…
▽ More
Motor skill learning often requires experienced professionals who can provide personalized instruction. Unfortunately, the availability of high-quality training can be limited for specialized tasks, such as high performance racing. Several recent works have leveraged AI-assistance to improve instruction of tasks ranging from rehabilitation to surgical robot tele-operation. However, these works often make simplifying assumptions on the student learning process, and fail to model how a teacher's assistance interacts with different individuals' abilities when determining optimal teaching strategies. Inspired by the idea of scaffolding from educational psychology, we leverage shared autonomy, a framework for combining user inputs with robot autonomy, to aid with curriculum design. Our key insight is that the way a student's behavior improves in the presence of assistance from an autonomous agent can highlight which sub-skills might be most ``learnable'' for the student, or within their Zone of Proximal Development. We use this to design Z-COACH, a method for using shared autonomy to provide personalized instruction targeting interpretable task sub-skills. In a user study (n=50), where we teach high performance racing in a simulated environment of the Thunderhill Raceway Park with the CARLA Autonomous Driving simulator, we show that Z-COACH helps identify which skills each student should first practice, leading to an overall improvement in driving time, behavior, and smoothness. Our work shows that increasingly available semi-autonomous capabilities (e.g. in vehicles, robots) can not only assist human users, but also help *teach* them.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Dreaming to Assist: Learning to Align with Human Objectives for Shared Control in High-Speed Racing
Authors:
Jonathan DeCastro,
Andrew Silva,
Deepak Gopinath,
Emily Sumner,
Thomas M. Balch,
Laporsha Dees,
Guy Rosman
Abstract:
Tight coordination is required for effective human-robot teams in domains involving fast dynamics and tactical decisions, such as multi-car racing. In such settings, robot teammates must react to cues of a human teammate's tactical objective to assist in a way that is consistent with the objective (e.g., navigating left or right around an obstacle). To address this challenge, we present Dream2Assi…
▽ More
Tight coordination is required for effective human-robot teams in domains involving fast dynamics and tactical decisions, such as multi-car racing. In such settings, robot teammates must react to cues of a human teammate's tactical objective to assist in a way that is consistent with the objective (e.g., navigating left or right around an obstacle). To address this challenge, we present Dream2Assist, a framework that combines a rich world model able to infer human objectives and value functions, and an assistive agent that provides appropriate expert assistance to a given human teammate. Our approach builds on a recurrent state space model to explicitly infer human intents, enabling the assistive agent to select actions that align with the human and enabling a fluid teaming interaction. We demonstrate our approach in a high-speed racing domain with a population of synthetic human drivers pursuing mutually exclusive objectives, such as "stay-behind" and "overtake". We show that the combined human-robot team, when blending its actions with those of the human, outperforms the synthetic humans alone as well as several baseline assistance strategies, and that intent-conditioning enables adherence to human preferences during task execution, leading to improved performance while satisfying the human's objective.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Computational Teaching for Driving via Multi-Task Imitation Learning
Authors:
Deepak Gopinath,
Xiongyi Cui,
Jonathan DeCastro,
Emily Sumner,
Jean Costa,
Hiroshi Yasuda,
Allison Morgan,
Laporsha Dees,
Sheryl Chau,
John Leonard,
Tiffany Chen,
Guy Rosman,
Avinash Balachandran
Abstract:
Learning motor skills for sports or performance driving is often done with professional instruction from expert human teachers, whose availability is limited. Our goal is to enable automated teaching via a learned model that interacts with the student similar to a human teacher. However, training such automated teaching systems is limited by the availability of high-quality annotated datasets of e…
▽ More
Learning motor skills for sports or performance driving is often done with professional instruction from expert human teachers, whose availability is limited. Our goal is to enable automated teaching via a learned model that interacts with the student similar to a human teacher. However, training such automated teaching systems is limited by the availability of high-quality annotated datasets of expert teacher and student interactions that are difficult to collect at scale. To address this data scarcity problem, we propose an approach for training a coaching system for complex motor tasks such as high performance driving via a Multi-Task Imitation Learning (MTIL) paradigm. MTIL allows our model to learn robust representations by utilizing self-supervised training signals from more readily available non-interactive datasets of humans performing the task of interest. We validate our approach with (1) a semi-synthetic dataset created from real human driving trajectories, (2) a professional track driving instruction dataset, (3) a track-racing driving simulator human-subject study, and (4) a system demonstration on an instrumented car at a race track. Our experiments show that the right set of auxiliary machine learning tasks improves performance in predicting teaching instructions. Moreover, in the human subjects study, students exposed to the instructions from our teaching system improve their ability to stay within track limits, and show favorable perception of the model's interaction with them, in terms of usefulness and satisfaction.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Personalizing Driver Safety Interfaces via Driver Cognitive Factors Inference
Authors:
Emily S Sumner,
Jonathan DeCastro,
Jean Costa,
Deepak E Gopinath,
Everlyne Kimani,
Shabnam Hakimi,
Allison Morgan,
Andrew Best,
Hieu Nguyen,
Daniel J Brooks,
Bassam ul Haq,
Andrew Patrikalakis,
Hiroshi Yasuda,
Kate Sieck,
Avinash Balachandran,
Tiffany Chen,
Guy Rosman
Abstract:
Recent advances in AI and intelligent vehicle technology hold promise to revolutionize mobility and transportation, in the form of advanced driving assistance (ADAS) interfaces. Although it is widely recognized that certain cognitive factors, such as impulsivity and inhibitory control, are related to risky driving behavior, play a significant role in on-road risk-taking, existing systems fail to l…
▽ More
Recent advances in AI and intelligent vehicle technology hold promise to revolutionize mobility and transportation, in the form of advanced driving assistance (ADAS) interfaces. Although it is widely recognized that certain cognitive factors, such as impulsivity and inhibitory control, are related to risky driving behavior, play a significant role in on-road risk-taking, existing systems fail to leverage such factors. Varying levels of these cognitive factors could influence the effectiveness and acceptance of driver safety interfaces.
We demonstrate an approach for personalizing driver interaction via driver safety interfaces that are triggered based on a learned recurrent neural network. The network is trained from a population of human drivers to infer impulsivity and inhibitory control from recent driving behavior. Using a high-fidelity vehicle motion simulator, we demonstrate the ability to deduce these factors from driver behavior. We then use these inferred factors to make instantaneous determinations on whether or not to engage a driver safety interface. This interface aims to decrease a driver's speed during yellow lights and reduce their inclination to run through them.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
MAVERIC: A Data-Driven Approach to Personalized Autonomous Driving
Authors:
Mariah L. Schrum,
Emily Sumner,
Matthew C. Gombolay,
Andrew Best
Abstract:
Personalization of autonomous vehicles (AV) may significantly increase trust, use, and acceptance. In particular, we hypothesize that the similarity of an AV's driving style compared to the end-user's driving style will have a major impact on end-user's willingness to use the AV. To investigate the impact of driving style on user acceptance, we 1) develop a data-driven approach to personalize driv…
▽ More
Personalization of autonomous vehicles (AV) may significantly increase trust, use, and acceptance. In particular, we hypothesize that the similarity of an AV's driving style compared to the end-user's driving style will have a major impact on end-user's willingness to use the AV. To investigate the impact of driving style on user acceptance, we 1) develop a data-driven approach to personalize driving style and 2) demonstrate that personalization significantly impacts attitudes towards AVs. Our approach learns a high-level model that tunes low-level controllers to ensure safe and personalized control of the AV. The key to our approach is learning an informative, personalized embedding that represents a user's driving style. Our framework is capable of calibrating the level of aggression so as to optimize driving style based upon driver preference. Across two human subject studies (n = 54), we first demonstrate our approach mimics the driving styles of end-users and can tune attributes of style (e.g., aggressiveness). Second, we investigate the factors (e.g., trust, personality etc.) that impact homophily, i.e. an individual's preference for a driving style similar to their own. We find that our approach generates driving styles consistent with end-user styles (p<.001) and participants rate our approach as more similar to their level of aggressiveness (p=.002). We find that personality (p<.001), perceived similarity (p<.001), and high-velocity driving style (p=.0031) significantly modulate the effect of homophily.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2023; v1 submitted 20 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Learning Latent Traits for Simulated Cooperative Driving Tasks
Authors:
Jonathan A. DeCastro,
Deepak Gopinath,
Guy Rosman,
Emily Sumner,
Shabnam Hakimi,
Simon Stent
Abstract:
To construct effective teaming strategies between humans and AI systems in complex, risky situations requires an understanding of individual preferences and behaviors of humans. Previously this problem has been treated in case-specific or data-agnostic ways. In this paper, we build a framework capable of capturing a compact latent representation of the human in terms of their behavior and preferen…
▽ More
To construct effective teaming strategies between humans and AI systems in complex, risky situations requires an understanding of individual preferences and behaviors of humans. Previously this problem has been treated in case-specific or data-agnostic ways. In this paper, we build a framework capable of capturing a compact latent representation of the human in terms of their behavior and preferences based on data from a simulated population of drivers. Our framework leverages, to the extent available, knowledge of individual preferences and types from samples within the population to deploy interaction policies appropriate for specific drivers. We then build a lightweight simulation environment, HMIway-env, for modelling one form of distracted driving behavior, and use it to generate data for different driver types and train intervention policies. We finally use this environment to quantify both the ability to discriminate drivers and the effectiveness of intervention policies.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Understanding and Shifting Preferences for Battery Electric Vehicles
Authors:
Nikos Arechiga,
Francine Chen,
Rumen Iliev,
Emily Sumner,
Scott Carter,
Alex Filipowicz,
Nayeli Bravo,
Monica Van,
Kate Glazko,
Kalani Murakami,
Laurent Denoue,
Candice Hogan,
Katharine Sieck,
Charlene Wu,
Kent Lyons
Abstract:
Identifying personalized interventions for an individual is an important task. Recent work has shown that interventions that do not consider the demographic background of individual consumers can, in fact, produce the reverse effect, strengthening opposition to electric vehicles. In this work, we focus on methods for personalizing interventions based on an individual's demographics to shift the pr…
▽ More
Identifying personalized interventions for an individual is an important task. Recent work has shown that interventions that do not consider the demographic background of individual consumers can, in fact, produce the reverse effect, strengthening opposition to electric vehicles. In this work, we focus on methods for personalizing interventions based on an individual's demographics to shift the preferences of consumers to be more positive towards Battery Electric Vehicles (BEVs). One of the constraints in building models to suggest interventions for shifting preferences is that each intervention can influence the effectiveness of later interventions. This, in turn, requires many subjects to evaluate effectiveness of each possible intervention. To address this, we propose to identify personalized factors influencing BEV adoption, such as barriers and motivators. We present a method for predicting these factors and show that the performance is better than always predicting the most frequent factors. We then present a Reinforcement Learning (RL) model that learns the most effective interventions, and compare the number of subjects required for each approach.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Machine learning reveals how personalized climate communication can both succeed and backfire
Authors:
Totte Harinen,
Alexandre Filipowicz,
Shabnam Hakimi,
Rumen Iliev,
Matthew Klenk,
Emily Sumner
Abstract:
Different advertising messages work for different people. Machine learning can be an effective way to personalise climate communications. In this paper we use machine learning to reanalyse findings from a recent study, showing that online advertisements increased some people's belief in climate change while resulting in decreased belief in others. In particular, we show that the effect of the adve…
▽ More
Different advertising messages work for different people. Machine learning can be an effective way to personalise climate communications. In this paper we use machine learning to reanalyse findings from a recent study, showing that online advertisements increased some people's belief in climate change while resulting in decreased belief in others. In particular, we show that the effect of the advertisements could change depending on people's age and ethnicity.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
