-
Data-driven methods for computational mechanics: A fair comparison between neural networks based and model-free approaches
Authors:
Martin Zlatić,
Felipe Rocha,
Laurent Stainier,
Marko Čanađija
Abstract:
We present a comparison between two approaches to modelling hyperelastic material behaviour using data. The first approach is a novel approach based on Data-driven Computational Mechanics (DDCM) that completely bypasses the definition of a material model by using only data from simulations or real-life experiments to perform computations. The second is a neural network (NN) based approach, where a…
▽ More
We present a comparison between two approaches to modelling hyperelastic material behaviour using data. The first approach is a novel approach based on Data-driven Computational Mechanics (DDCM) that completely bypasses the definition of a material model by using only data from simulations or real-life experiments to perform computations. The second is a neural network (NN) based approach, where a neural network is used as a constitutive model. It is trained on data to learn the underlying material behaviour and is implemented in the same way as conventional models. The DDCM approach has been extended to include strategies for recovering isotropic behaviour and local smoothing of data. These have proven to be critical in certain cases and increase accuracy in most cases. The NN approach contains certain elements to enforce principles such as material symmetry, thermodynamic consistency, and convexity. In order to provide a fair comparison between the approaches, they use the same data and solve the same numerical problems with a selection of problems highlighting the advantages and disadvantages of each approach. Both the DDCM and the NNs have shown acceptable performance. The DDCM performed better when applied to cases similar to those from which the data is gathered from, albeit at the expense of generality, whereas NN models were more advantageous when applied to wider range of applications.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2024; v1 submitted 27 August, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Efficient Data Structures for Model-free Data-Driven Computational Mechanics
Authors:
Robert Eggersmann,
Laurent Stainier,
Michael Ortiz,
Stefanie Reese
Abstract:
The data-driven computing paradigm initially introduced by Kirchdoerfer and Ortiz (2016) enables finite element computations in solid mechanics to be performed directly from material data sets, without an explicit material model. From a computational effort point of view, the most challenging task is the projection of admissible states at material points onto their closest states in the material d…
▽ More
The data-driven computing paradigm initially introduced by Kirchdoerfer and Ortiz (2016) enables finite element computations in solid mechanics to be performed directly from material data sets, without an explicit material model. From a computational effort point of view, the most challenging task is the projection of admissible states at material points onto their closest states in the material data set. In this study, we compare and develop several possible data structures for solving the nearest-neighbor problem. We show that approximate nearest-neighbor (ANN) algorithms can accelerate material data searches by several orders of magnitude relative to exact searching algorithms. The approximations are suggested by--and adapted to--the structure of the data-driven iterative solver and result in no significant loss of solution accuracy. We assess the performance of the ANN algorithm with respect to material data set size with the aid of a 3D elasticity test case. We show that computations on a single processor with up to one billion material data points are feasible within a few seconds execution time with a speedup of more than 106 with respect to exact k-d trees.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Data-driven fracture mechanics
Authors:
Pietro Carrara,
Laura De Lorenzis,
Laurent Stainier,
Michael Ortiz
Abstract:
We present a new data-driven paradigm for variational brittle fracture mechanics. The fracture-related material modeling assumptions are removed and the governing equations stemming from variational principles are combined with a set of discrete data points, leading to a model-free data-driven method of solution. The solution at a given load step is identified as the point within the data set that…
▽ More
We present a new data-driven paradigm for variational brittle fracture mechanics. The fracture-related material modeling assumptions are removed and the governing equations stemming from variational principles are combined with a set of discrete data points, leading to a model-free data-driven method of solution. The solution at a given load step is identified as the point within the data set that best satisfies either the Kuhn-Tucker conditions stemming from the variational fracture problem or global minimization of a suitable energy functional, leading to data-driven counterparts of both the local and the global minimization approaches of variational fracture mechanics. Both formulations are tested on different test configurations with and without noise and for Griffith and R-curve type fracture behavior.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2020; v1 submitted 3 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Model-free Data-Driven Computational Mechanics Enhanced by Tensor Voting
Authors:
Robert Eggersmann,
Laurent Stainier,
Michael Ortiz,
Stefanie Reese
Abstract:
The data-driven computing paradigm initially introduced by Kirchdoerfer & Ortiz (2016) is extended by incorporating locally linear tangent spaces into the data set. These tangent spaces are constructed by means of the tensor voting method introduced by Mordohai & Medioni (2010) which improves the learning of the underlying structure of a data set. Tensor voting is an instance-based machine learnin…
▽ More
The data-driven computing paradigm initially introduced by Kirchdoerfer & Ortiz (2016) is extended by incorporating locally linear tangent spaces into the data set. These tangent spaces are constructed by means of the tensor voting method introduced by Mordohai & Medioni (2010) which improves the learning of the underlying structure of a data set. Tensor voting is an instance-based machine learning technique which accumulates votes from the nearest neighbors to build up second-order tensors encoding tangents and normals to the underlying data structure. The here proposed second-order data-driven paradigm is a plug-in method for distance-minimizing as well as entropy-maximizing data-driven schemes. Like its predecessor, the resulting method aims to minimize a suitably defined free energy over phase space subject to compatibility and equilibrium constraints. The method's implementation is straightforward and numerically efficient since the data structure analysis is performed in an offline step. Selected numerical examples are presented that establish the higher-order convergence properties of the data-driven solvers enhanced by tensor voting for ideal and noisy data sets.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2020; v1 submitted 6 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Model-Free Data-Driven Methods in Mechanics: Material Data Identification and Solvers
Authors:
Laurent Stainier,
Adrien Leygue,
Michael Ortiz
Abstract:
This paper presents an integrated model-free data-driven approach to solid mechanics, allowing to perform numerical simulations on structures on the basis of measures of displacement fields on representative samples, without postulating a specific constitutive model. A material data identification procedure, allowing to infer strain-stress pairs from displacement fields and boundary conditions, is…
▽ More
This paper presents an integrated model-free data-driven approach to solid mechanics, allowing to perform numerical simulations on structures on the basis of measures of displacement fields on representative samples, without postulating a specific constitutive model. A material data identification procedure, allowing to infer strain-stress pairs from displacement fields and boundary conditions, is used to build a material database from a set of mutiaxial tests on a non-conventional sample. This database is in turn used by a data-driven solver, based on an algorithm minimizing the distance between manifolds of compatible and balanced mechanical states and the given database, to predict the response of structures of the same material, with arbitrary geometry and boundary conditions. Examples illustrate this modelling cycle and demonstrate how the data-driven identification method allows importance sampling of the material state space, yielding faster convergence of simulation results with increasing database size, when compared to synthetic material databases with regular sampling patterns.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2019; v1 submitted 15 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Model-Free Data-Driven Inelasticity
Authors:
Robert Eggersmann,
Trenton Kirchdoerfer,
Stefanie Reese,
Laurent Stainier,
Michael Ortiz
Abstract:
We extend the Data-Driven formulation of problems in elasticity of Kirchdoerfer and Ortiz (2016) to inelasticity. This extension differs fundamentally from Data-Driven problems in elasticity in that the material data set evolves in time as a consequence of the history dependence of the material. We investigate three representational paradigms for the evolving material data sets: i) materials with…
▽ More
We extend the Data-Driven formulation of problems in elasticity of Kirchdoerfer and Ortiz (2016) to inelasticity. This extension differs fundamentally from Data-Driven problems in elasticity in that the material data set evolves in time as a consequence of the history dependence of the material. We investigate three representational paradigms for the evolving material data sets: i) materials with memory, i.e., conditioning the material data set to the past history of deformation; ii) differential materials, i.e., conditioning the material data set to short histories of stress and strain; and iii) history variables, i.e., conditioning the material data set to ad hoc variables encoding partial information about the history of stress and strain. We also consider combinations of the three paradigms thereof and investigate their ability to represent the evolving data sets of different classes of inelastic materials, including viscoelasticity, viscoplasticity and plasticity. We present selected numerical examples that demonstrate the range and scope of Data-Driven inelasticity and the numerical performance of implementations thereof.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2018; v1 submitted 31 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
