-
A Preliminary Framework for Intersectionality in ML Pipelines
Authors:
Michelle Nashla Turcios,
Alicia E. Boyd,
Angela D. R. Smith,
Brittany Johnson
Abstract:
Machine learning (ML) has become a go-to solution for improving how we use, experience, and interact with technology (and the world around us). Unfortunately, studies have repeatedly shown that machine learning technologies may not provide adequate support for societal identities and experiences. Intersectionality is a sociological framework that provides a mechanism for explicitly considering com…
▽ More
Machine learning (ML) has become a go-to solution for improving how we use, experience, and interact with technology (and the world around us). Unfortunately, studies have repeatedly shown that machine learning technologies may not provide adequate support for societal identities and experiences. Intersectionality is a sociological framework that provides a mechanism for explicitly considering complex social identities, focusing on social justice and power. While the framework of intersectionality can support the development of technologies that acknowledge and support all members of society, it has been adopted and adapted in ways that are not always true to its foundations, thereby weakening its potential for impact. To support the appropriate adoption and use of intersectionality for more equitable technological outcomes, we amplify the foundational intersectionality scholarship--Crenshaw, Combahee, and Collins (three C's), to create a socially relevant preliminary framework in developing machine-learning solutions. We use this framework to evaluate and report on the (mis)alignments of intersectionality application in machine learning literature.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
Exploring Culturally Informed AI Assistants: A Comparative Study of ChatBlackGPT and ChatGPT
Authors:
Lisa Egede,
Ebtesam Al Haque,
Gabriella Thompson,
Alicia Boyd,
Angela D. R. Smith,
Brittany Johnson
Abstract:
In recent years, we have seen an influx in reliance on AI assistants for information seeking. Given this widespread use and the known challenges AI poses for Black users, recent efforts have emerged to identify key considerations needed to provide meaningful support. One notable effort is the development of ChatBlackGPT, a culturally informed AI assistant designed to provide culturally relevant re…
▽ More
In recent years, we have seen an influx in reliance on AI assistants for information seeking. Given this widespread use and the known challenges AI poses for Black users, recent efforts have emerged to identify key considerations needed to provide meaningful support. One notable effort is the development of ChatBlackGPT, a culturally informed AI assistant designed to provide culturally relevant responses. Despite the existence of ChatBlackGPT, there is no research on when and how Black communities might engage with culturally informed AI assistants and the distinctions between engagement with general purpose tools like ChatGPT. To fill this gap, we propose a research agenda grounded in results from a preliminary comparative analysis of outputs provided by ChatGPT and ChatBlackGPT for travel-related inquiries. Our efforts thus far emphasize the need to consider Black communities' values, perceptions, and experiences when designing AI assistants that acknowledge the Black lived experience.
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
From Regulation to Support: Centering Humans in Technology-Mediated Emotion Intervention in Care Contexts
Authors:
Jiaying "Lizzy" Liu,
Shuer Zhuo,
Xingyu Li,
Andrew Dillon,
Noura Howell,
Angela D. R. Smith,
Yan Zhang
Abstract:
Enhancing emotional well-being has become a significant focus in HCI and CSCW, with technologies increasingly designed to track, visualize, and manage emotions. However, these approaches have faced criticism for potentially suppressing certain emotional experiences. Through a scoping review of 53 empirical studies from ACM proceedings implementing Technology-Mediated Emotion Intervention (TMEI), w…
▽ More
Enhancing emotional well-being has become a significant focus in HCI and CSCW, with technologies increasingly designed to track, visualize, and manage emotions. However, these approaches have faced criticism for potentially suppressing certain emotional experiences. Through a scoping review of 53 empirical studies from ACM proceedings implementing Technology-Mediated Emotion Intervention (TMEI), we critically examine current practices through lenses drawn from HCI critical theories. Our analysis reveals emotion intervention mechanisms that extend beyond traditional emotion regulation paradigms, identifying care-centered goals that prioritize non-judgmental emotional support and preserve users' identities. The findings demonstrate how researchers design technologies for generating artificial care, intervening in power dynamics, and nudging behavioral changes. We contribute the concept of "emotion support" as an alternative approach to "emotion regulation," emphasizing human-centered approaches to emotional well-being. This work advances the understanding of diverse human emotional needs beyond individual and cognitive perspectives, offering design implications that critically reimagine how technologies can honor emotional complexity, preserve human agency, and transform power dynamics in care contexts.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2025; v1 submitted 16 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
An Investigation of Experiences Engaging the Margins in Data-Centric Innovation
Authors:
Gabriella Thompson,
Ebtesam Al Haque,
Paulette Blanc,
Meme Styles,
Denae Ford,
Angela D. R. Smith,
Brittany Johnson
Abstract:
Data-centric technologies provide exciting opportunities, but recent research has shown how lack of representation in datasets, often as a result of systemic inequities and socioeconomic disparities, can produce inequitable outcomes that can exclude or harm certain demographics. In this paper, we discuss preliminary insights from an ongoing effort aimed at better understanding barriers to equitabl…
▽ More
Data-centric technologies provide exciting opportunities, but recent research has shown how lack of representation in datasets, often as a result of systemic inequities and socioeconomic disparities, can produce inequitable outcomes that can exclude or harm certain demographics. In this paper, we discuss preliminary insights from an ongoing effort aimed at better understanding barriers to equitable data-centric innovation. We report findings from a survey of 261 technologists and researchers who use data in their work regarding their experiences seeking adequate, representative datasets. Our findings suggest that age and identity play a significant role in the seeking and selection of representative datasets, warranting further investigation into these aspects of data-centric research and development.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
Envisioning New Futures of Positive Social Technology: Beyond Paradigms of Fixing, Protecting, and Preventing
Authors:
JaeWon Kim,
Lindsay Popowski,
Anna Fang,
Cassidy Pyle,
Guo Freeman,
Ryan M. Kelly,
Angela Y. Lee,
Fannie Liu,
Angela D. R. Smith,
Alexandra To,
Amy X. Zhang
Abstract:
Social technology research today largely focuses on mitigating the negative impacts of technology and, therefore, often misses the potential of technology to enhance human connections and well-being. However, we see a potential to shift towards a holistic view of social technology's impact on human flourishing. We introduce Positive Social Technology (Positech), a framework that shifts emphasis to…
▽ More
Social technology research today largely focuses on mitigating the negative impacts of technology and, therefore, often misses the potential of technology to enhance human connections and well-being. However, we see a potential to shift towards a holistic view of social technology's impact on human flourishing. We introduce Positive Social Technology (Positech), a framework that shifts emphasis toward leveraging social technologies to support and augment human flourishing. This workshop is organized around three themes relevant to Positech: 1) "Exploring Relevant and Adjacent Research" to define and widen the Positech scope with insights from related fields, 2) "Projecting the Landscape of Positech" for participants to outline the domain's key aspects and 3) "Envisioning the Future of Positech," anchored around strategic planning towards a sustainable research community. Ultimately, this workshop will serve as a platform to shift the narrative of social technology research towards a more positive, human-centric approach. It will foster research that goes beyond fixing technologies to protect humans from harm, to also pursue enriching human experiences and connections through technology.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2024; v1 submitted 24 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
(Re)Defining Expertise in Machine Learning Development
Authors:
Mark Díaz,
Angela D. R. Smith
Abstract:
Domain experts are often engaged in the development of machine learning systems in a variety of ways, such as in data collection and evaluation of system performance. At the same time, who counts as an 'expert' and what constitutes 'expertise' is not always explicitly defined. In this project, we conduct a systematic literature review of machine learning research to understand 1) the bases on whic…
▽ More
Domain experts are often engaged in the development of machine learning systems in a variety of ways, such as in data collection and evaluation of system performance. At the same time, who counts as an 'expert' and what constitutes 'expertise' is not always explicitly defined. In this project, we conduct a systematic literature review of machine learning research to understand 1) the bases on which expertise is defined and recognized and 2) the roles experts play in ML development. Our goal is to produce a high-level taxonomy to highlight limits and opportunities in how experts are identified and engaged in ML research.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
