-
Fact-Controlled Diagnosis of Hallucinations in Medical Text Summarization
Authors:
Suhas BN,
Han-Chin Shing,
Lei Xu,
Mitch Strong,
Jon Burnsky,
Jessica Ofor,
Jordan R. Mason,
Susan Chen,
Sundararajan Srinivasan,
Chaitanya Shivade,
Jack Moriarty,
Joseph Paul Cohen
Abstract:
Hallucinations in large language models (LLMs) during summarization of patient-clinician dialogues pose significant risks to patient care and clinical decision-making. However, the phenomenon remains understudied in the clinical domain, with uncertainty surrounding the applicability of general-domain hallucination detectors. The rarity and randomness of hallucinations further complicate their inve…
▽ More
Hallucinations in large language models (LLMs) during summarization of patient-clinician dialogues pose significant risks to patient care and clinical decision-making. However, the phenomenon remains understudied in the clinical domain, with uncertainty surrounding the applicability of general-domain hallucination detectors. The rarity and randomness of hallucinations further complicate their investigation. In this paper, we conduct an evaluation of hallucination detection methods in the medical domain, and construct two datasets for the purpose: A fact-controlled Leave-N-out dataset -- generated by systematically removing facts from source dialogues to induce hallucinated content in summaries; and a natural hallucination dataset -- arising organically during LLM-based medical summarization. We show that general-domain detectors struggle to detect clinical hallucinations, and that performance on fact-controlled hallucinations does not reliably predict effectiveness on natural hallucinations. We then develop fact-based approaches that count hallucinations, offering explainability not available with existing methods. Notably, our LLM-based detectors, which we developed using fact-controlled hallucinations, generalize well to detecting real-world clinical hallucinations. This research contributes a suite of specialized metrics supported by expert-annotated datasets to advance faithful clinical summarization systems.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
Entity Anchored ICD Coding
Authors:
Jay DeYoung,
Han-Chin Shing,
Luyang Kong,
Christopher Winestock,
Chaitanya Shivade
Abstract:
Medical coding is a complex task, requiring assignment of a subset of over 72,000 ICD codes to a patient's notes. Modern natural language processing approaches to these tasks have been challenged by the length of the input and size of the output space. We limit our model inputs to a small window around medical entities found in our documents. From those local contexts, we build contextualized repr…
▽ More
Medical coding is a complex task, requiring assignment of a subset of over 72,000 ICD codes to a patient's notes. Modern natural language processing approaches to these tasks have been challenged by the length of the input and size of the output space. We limit our model inputs to a small window around medical entities found in our documents. From those local contexts, we build contextualized representations of both ICD codes and entities, and aggregate over these representations to form document-level predictions. In contrast to existing methods which use a representation fixed either in size or by codes seen in training, we represent ICD codes by encoding the code description with local context. We discuss metrics appropriate to deploying coding systems in practice. We show that our approach is superior to existing methods in both standard and deployable measures, including performance on rare and unseen codes.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Learning to Revise References for Faithful Summarization
Authors:
Griffin Adams,
Han-Chin Shing,
Qing Sun,
Christopher Winestock,
Kathleen McKeown,
Noémie Elhadad
Abstract:
In real-world scenarios with naturally occurring datasets, reference summaries are noisy and may contain information that cannot be inferred from the source text. On large news corpora, removing low quality samples has been shown to reduce model hallucinations. Yet, for smaller, and/or noisier corpora, filtering is detrimental to performance. To improve reference quality while retaining all data,…
▽ More
In real-world scenarios with naturally occurring datasets, reference summaries are noisy and may contain information that cannot be inferred from the source text. On large news corpora, removing low quality samples has been shown to reduce model hallucinations. Yet, for smaller, and/or noisier corpora, filtering is detrimental to performance. To improve reference quality while retaining all data, we propose a new approach: to selectively re-write unsupported reference sentences to better reflect source data. We automatically generate a synthetic dataset of positive and negative revisions by corrupting supported sentences and learn to revise reference sentences with contrastive learning. The intensity of revisions is treated as a controllable attribute so that, at inference, diverse candidates can be over-generated-then-rescored to balance faithfulness and abstraction. To test our methods, we extract noisy references from publicly available MIMIC-III discharge summaries for the task of hospital-course summarization, and vary the data on which models are trained. According to metrics and human evaluation, models trained on revised clinical references are much more faithful, informative, and fluent than models trained on original or filtered data.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2022; v1 submitted 13 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Towards Clinical Encounter Summarization: Learning to Compose Discharge Summaries from Prior Notes
Authors:
Han-Chin Shing,
Chaitanya Shivade,
Nima Pourdamghani,
Feng Nan,
Philip Resnik,
Douglas Oard,
Parminder Bhatia
Abstract:
The records of a clinical encounter can be extensive and complex, thus placing a premium on tools that can extract and summarize relevant information. This paper introduces the task of generating discharge summaries for a clinical encounter. Summaries in this setting need to be faithful, traceable, and scale to multiple long documents, motivating the use of extract-then-abstract summarization casc…
▽ More
The records of a clinical encounter can be extensive and complex, thus placing a premium on tools that can extract and summarize relevant information. This paper introduces the task of generating discharge summaries for a clinical encounter. Summaries in this setting need to be faithful, traceable, and scale to multiple long documents, motivating the use of extract-then-abstract summarization cascades. We introduce two new measures, faithfulness and hallucination rate for evaluation in this task, which complement existing measures for fluency and informativeness. Results across seven medical sections and five models show that a summarization architecture that supports traceability yields promising results, and that a sentence-rewriting approach performs consistently on the measure used for faithfulness (faithfulness-adjusted $F_3$) over a diverse range of generated sections.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Assigning Medical Codes at the Encounter Level by Paying Attention to Documents
Authors:
Han-Chin Shing,
Guoli Wang,
Philip Resnik
Abstract:
The vast majority of research in computer assisted medical coding focuses on coding at the document level, but a substantial proportion of medical coding in the real world involves coding at the level of clinical encounters, each of which is typically represented by a potentially large set of documents. We introduce encounter-level document attention networks, which use hierarchical attention to e…
▽ More
The vast majority of research in computer assisted medical coding focuses on coding at the document level, but a substantial proportion of medical coding in the real world involves coding at the level of clinical encounters, each of which is typically represented by a potentially large set of documents. We introduce encounter-level document attention networks, which use hierarchical attention to explicitly take the hierarchical structure of encounter documentation into account. Experimental evaluation demonstrates improvements in coding accuracy as well as facilitation of human reviewers in their ability to identify which documents within an encounter play a role in determining the encounter level codes.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
