-
Rational Economic Behaviours in the Bitcoin Lightning Network
Authors:
Andrea Carotti,
Cosimo Sguanci,
Anastasios Sidiropoulos
Abstract:
The Bitcoin Lightning Network (LN) is designed to improve the scalability of blockchain systems by using off-chain payment paths to settle transactions in a faster, cheaper, and more private manner. This work aims to empirically study LN's fee revenue for network participants. Under realistic assumptions on payment amounts, routing algorithms and traffic distribution, we analyze the economic retur…
▽ More
The Bitcoin Lightning Network (LN) is designed to improve the scalability of blockchain systems by using off-chain payment paths to settle transactions in a faster, cheaper, and more private manner. This work aims to empirically study LN's fee revenue for network participants. Under realistic assumptions on payment amounts, routing algorithms and traffic distribution, we analyze the economic returns of the network's largest routing nodes which currently hold the network together, and assess whether the centralizing tendency is incentive-compatible from an economic viewpoint. Moreover, since recent literature has proved that participation is economically irrational for the majority of large nodes, we evaluate the long-term impact on the network topology when participants start behaving rationally.
△ Less
Submitted 27 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Mass Exit Attacks on the Lightning Network
Authors:
Cosimo Sguanci,
Anastasios Sidiropoulos
Abstract:
The Lightning Network (LN) has enjoyed rapid growth over recent years, and has become the most popular scaling solution for the Bitcoin blockchain. The security of the LN relies on the ability of the nodes to close a channel by settling their balances, which requires confirming a transaction on the Bitcoin blockchain within a pre-agreed time period. We study the susceptibility of the LN to mass ex…
▽ More
The Lightning Network (LN) has enjoyed rapid growth over recent years, and has become the most popular scaling solution for the Bitcoin blockchain. The security of the LN relies on the ability of the nodes to close a channel by settling their balances, which requires confirming a transaction on the Bitcoin blockchain within a pre-agreed time period. We study the susceptibility of the LN to mass exit attacks in case of high transaction congestion, in the presence of a small coalition of adversarial nodes that forces a large set of honest users to interact with the blockchain. We focus on two types of attacks: (i) The first is a zombie attack, where a set of k nodes become unresponsive with the goal of locking the funds of many channels for a period of time longer than what the LN protocol dictates. (ii) The second is a mass double-spend attack, where a set of k nodes attempt to steal funds by submitting many closing transactions that settle channels using expired protocol states; this causes many honest nodes to have to quickly respond by submitting invalidating transactions. We show via simulations that, under historically plausible congestion conditions, with mild statistical assumptions on channel balances, both attacks can be performed by a very small coalition. To perform our simulations, we formulate the problem of finding a worst-case coalition of k adversarial nodes as a graph cut problem. Our experimental findings are supported by theoretical justifications based on the scale-free topology of the LN.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2024; v1 submitted 3 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Layer 2 Blockchain Scaling: a Survey
Authors:
Cosimo Sguanci,
Roberto Spatafora,
Andrea Mario Vergani
Abstract:
Blockchain technology is affected by massive limitations in scalability with consequent repercussions on performance. This discussion aims at analyzing the state of the art of current available Layer II solutions to overcome these limitations, both focusing on theoretical and practical aspects and highlighting the main differences among the examined frameworks. The structure of the work is based o…
▽ More
Blockchain technology is affected by massive limitations in scalability with consequent repercussions on performance. This discussion aims at analyzing the state of the art of current available Layer II solutions to overcome these limitations, both focusing on theoretical and practical aspects and highlighting the main differences among the examined frameworks. The structure of the work is based on three major sections. In particular, the first one is an introductory part about the technology, the scalability issue and Layer II as a solution. The second section represents the core of the discussion and consists of three different subsections, each with a detailed examination of the respective solution (Lightning Network, Plasma, Rollups); the analysis of each solution is based on how it affects five key aspects of blockchain technology and Layer II: scalability, security, decentralization, privacy, fees and micropayments (the last two are analyzed together given their high correlation). Finally, the third section includes a tabular summary, followed by a detailed description of a use-case specifically thought for a practical evaluation of the presented frameworks. The results of the work met expectations: all solutions effectively contribute to increasing scalability. A crucial clarification is that none of the three dominates the others in all possible fields of application, and the consequences in adopting each, are different. Therefore, the choice depends on the application context, and a trade-off must be found between the aspects previously mentioned.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
