-
Automating Reformulation of Essence Specifications via Graph Rewriting
Authors:
Ian Miguel,
András Z. Salamon,
Christopher Stone
Abstract:
Formulating an effective constraint model of a parameterised problem class is crucial to the efficiency with which instances of the class can subsequently be solved. It is difficult to know beforehand which of a set of candidate models will perform best in practice. This paper presents a system that employs graph rewriting to reformulate an input model for improved performance automatically. By si…
▽ More
Formulating an effective constraint model of a parameterised problem class is crucial to the efficiency with which instances of the class can subsequently be solved. It is difficult to know beforehand which of a set of candidate models will perform best in practice. This paper presents a system that employs graph rewriting to reformulate an input model for improved performance automatically. By situating our work in the Essence abstract constraint specification language, we can use the structure in its high level variable types to trigger rewrites directly. We implement our system via rewrite rules expressed in the Graph Programs 2 language, applied to the abstract syntax tree of an input specification. We show how to automatically translate the solution of the reformulated problem into a solution of the original problem for verification and presentation. We demonstrate the efficacy of our system with a detailed case study.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
Towards Exploratory Reformulation of Constraint Models
Authors:
Ian Miguel,
András Z. Salamon,
Christopher Stone
Abstract:
It is well established that formulating an effective constraint model of a problem of interest is crucial to the efficiency with which it can subsequently be solved. Following from the observation that it is difficult, if not impossible, to know a priori which of a set of candidate models will perform best in practice, we envisage a system that explores the space of models through a process of ref…
▽ More
It is well established that formulating an effective constraint model of a problem of interest is crucial to the efficiency with which it can subsequently be solved. Following from the observation that it is difficult, if not impossible, to know a priori which of a set of candidate models will perform best in practice, we envisage a system that explores the space of models through a process of reformulation from an initial model, guided by performance on a set of training instances from the problem class under consideration. We plan to situate this system in a refinement-based approach, where a user writes a constraint specification describing a problem above the level of abstraction at which many modelling decisions are made. In this position paper we set out our plan for an exploratory reformulation system, and discuss progress made so far.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Towards a Model of Puzznic
Authors:
Joan Espasa,
Ian P. Gent,
Ian Miguel,
Peter Nightingale,
András Z. Salamon,
Mateu Villaret
Abstract:
We report on progress in modelling and solving Puzznic, a video game requiring the player to plan sequences of moves to clear a grid by matching blocks. We focus here on levels with no moving blocks. We compare a planning approach and three constraint programming approaches on a small set of benchmark instances. The planning approach is at present superior to the constraint programming approaches,…
▽ More
We report on progress in modelling and solving Puzznic, a video game requiring the player to plan sequences of moves to clear a grid by matching blocks. We focus here on levels with no moving blocks. We compare a planning approach and three constraint programming approaches on a small set of benchmark instances. The planning approach is at present superior to the constraint programming approaches, but we outline proposals for improving the constraint models.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Challenges in Modelling and Solving Plotting with PDDL
Authors:
Joan Espasa,
Ian Miguel,
Peter Nightingale,
András Z. Salamon,
Mateu Villaret
Abstract:
We study a planning problem based on Plotting, a tile-matching puzzle video game published by Taito in 1989. The objective of this game is to remove a target number of coloured blocks from a grid by sequentially shooting blocks into the grid. Plotting features complex transitions after every shot: various blocks are affected directly, while others can be indirectly affected by gravity. We highligh…
▽ More
We study a planning problem based on Plotting, a tile-matching puzzle video game published by Taito in 1989. The objective of this game is to remove a target number of coloured blocks from a grid by sequentially shooting blocks into the grid. Plotting features complex transitions after every shot: various blocks are affected directly, while others can be indirectly affected by gravity. We highlight the challenges of modelling Plotting with PDDL and of solving it with a grounding-based state-of-the-art planner.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
TabID: Automatic Identification and Tabulation of Subproblems in Constraint Models
Authors:
Özgür Akgün,
Ian P. Gent,
Christopher Jefferson,
Zeynep Kiziltan,
Ian Miguel,
Peter Nightingale,
András Z. Salamon,
Felix Ulrich-Oltean
Abstract:
The performance of a constraint model can often be improved by converting a subproblem into a single table constraint (referred to as tabulation). Finding subproblems to tabulate is traditionally a manual and time-intensive process, even for expert modellers. This paper presents TabID, an entirely automated method to identify promising subproblems for tabulation in constraint programming. We intro…
▽ More
The performance of a constraint model can often be improved by converting a subproblem into a single table constraint (referred to as tabulation). Finding subproblems to tabulate is traditionally a manual and time-intensive process, even for expert modellers. This paper presents TabID, an entirely automated method to identify promising subproblems for tabulation in constraint programming. We introduce a diverse set of heuristics designed to identify promising candidates for tabulation, aiming to improve solver performance. These heuristics are intended to encapsulate various factors that contribute to useful tabulation. We also present additional checks to limit the potential drawbacks of suboptimal tabulation.
We comprehensively evaluate our approach using benchmark problems from existing literature that previously relied on manual identification by constraint programming experts of constraints to tabulate. We demonstrate that our automated identification and tabulation process achieves comparable, and in some cases improved results. We empirically evaluate the efficacy of our approach on a variety of solvers, including standard CP (Minion and Gecode), clause-learning CP (Chuffed and OR-Tools) and SAT solvers (Kissat).
Our findings highlight the substantial potential of fully automated tabulation, suggesting its integration into automated model reformulation tools.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2025; v1 submitted 26 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Effective Guessing Has Unlikely Consequences
Authors:
András Z. Salamon,
Michael Wehar
Abstract:
A classic result of Paul, Pippenger, Szemerédi and Trotter states that DTIME(n) is strictly contained in NTIME(n). The natural question then arises: could DTIME(t(n)) be contained in NTIME(n) for some superlinear time-constructible function t(n)? If such a function t(n) does exist, then there also exist effective nondeterministic guessing strategies to speed up deterministic computations. In this…
▽ More
A classic result of Paul, Pippenger, Szemerédi and Trotter states that DTIME(n) is strictly contained in NTIME(n). The natural question then arises: could DTIME(t(n)) be contained in NTIME(n) for some superlinear time-constructible function t(n)? If such a function t(n) does exist, then there also exist effective nondeterministic guessing strategies to speed up deterministic computations. In this work, we prove limitations on the effectiveness of nondeterministic guessing to speed up deterministic computations by showing that the existence of effective nondeterministic guessing strategies would have unlikely consequences. In particular, we show that if a subpolynomial amount of nondeterministic guessing could be used to speed up deterministic computation by a polynomial factor, then P is strictly contained in NTIME(n). Furthermore, even achieving a logarithmic speedup at the cost of making every step nondeterministic would show that SAT is in NTIME(n) under appropriate encodings. Of possibly independent interest, under such encodings we also show that SAT can be decided in O(n lg n) steps on a nondeterministic multitape Turing machine, improving on the well-known O(n(lg n)^c) bound for some constant but undetermined exponent c which is at least 1.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2022; v1 submitted 3 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Towards Reformulating Essence Specifications for Robustness
Authors:
Özgür Akgün,
Alan M. Frisch,
Ian P. Gent,
Christopher Jefferson,
Ian Miguel,
Peter Nightingale,
András Z. Salamon
Abstract:
The Essence language allows a user to specify a constraint problem at a level of abstraction above that at which constraint modelling decisions are made. Essence specifications are refined into constraint models using the Conjure automated modelling tool, which employs a suite of refinement rules. However, Essence is a rich language in which there are many equivalent ways to specify a given proble…
▽ More
The Essence language allows a user to specify a constraint problem at a level of abstraction above that at which constraint modelling decisions are made. Essence specifications are refined into constraint models using the Conjure automated modelling tool, which employs a suite of refinement rules. However, Essence is a rich language in which there are many equivalent ways to specify a given problem. A user may therefore omit the use of domain attributes or abstract types, resulting in fewer refinement rules being applicable and therefore a reduced set of output models from which to select. This paper addresses the problem of recovering this information automatically to increase the robustness of the quality of the output constraint models in the face of variation in the input Essence specification. We present reformulation rules that can change the type of a decision variable or add attributes that shrink its domain. We demonstrate the efficacy of this approach in terms of the quantity and quality of models Conjure can produce from the transformed specification compared with the original.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Exploring Instance Generation for Automated Planning
Authors:
Özgür Akgün,
Nguyen Dang,
Joan Espasa,
Ian Miguel,
András Z. Salamon,
Christopher Stone
Abstract:
Many of the core disciplines of artificial intelligence have sets of standard benchmark problems well known and widely used by the community when developing new algorithms. Constraint programming and automated planning are examples of these areas, where the behaviour of a new algorithm is measured by how it performs on these instances. Typically the efficiency of each solving method varies not onl…
▽ More
Many of the core disciplines of artificial intelligence have sets of standard benchmark problems well known and widely used by the community when developing new algorithms. Constraint programming and automated planning are examples of these areas, where the behaviour of a new algorithm is measured by how it performs on these instances. Typically the efficiency of each solving method varies not only between problems, but also between instances of the same problem. Therefore, having a diverse set of instances is crucial to be able to effectively evaluate a new solving method. Current methods for automatic generation of instances for Constraint Programming problems start with a declarative model and search for instances with some desired attributes, such as hardness or size. We first explore the difficulties of adapting this approach to generate instances starting from problem specifications written in PDDL, the de-facto standard language of the automated planning community. We then propose a new approach where the whole planning problem description is modelled using Essence, an abstract modelling language that allows expressing high-level structures without committing to a particular low level representation in PDDL.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Superlinear Lower Bounds Based on ETH
Authors:
András Z. Salamon,
Michael Wehar
Abstract:
We introduce techniques for proving superlinear conditional lower bounds for polynomial time problems. In particular, we show that CircuitSAT for circuits with m gates and log(m) inputs (denoted by log-CircuitSAT) is not decidable in essentially-linear time unless the exponential time hypothesis (ETH) is false and k-Clique is decidable in essentially-linear time in terms of the graph's size for al…
▽ More
We introduce techniques for proving superlinear conditional lower bounds for polynomial time problems. In particular, we show that CircuitSAT for circuits with m gates and log(m) inputs (denoted by log-CircuitSAT) is not decidable in essentially-linear time unless the exponential time hypothesis (ETH) is false and k-Clique is decidable in essentially-linear time in terms of the graph's size for all fixed k. Such conditional lower bounds have previously only been demonstrated relative to the strong exponential time hypothesis (SETH). Our results therefore offer significant progress towards proving unconditional superlinear time complexity lower bounds for natural problems in polynomial time.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2022; v1 submitted 15 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Macroscopes: models for collective decision making
Authors:
Subramanian Ramamoorthy,
András Z. Salamon,
Rahul Santhanam
Abstract:
We introduce a new model of collective decision making, when a global decision needs to be made but the parties only possess partial information, and are unwilling (or unable) to first create a globalcomposite of their local views. Our macroscope model captures two key features of many real-world problems: allotment structure (how access to local information is apportioned between parties, includi…
▽ More
We introduce a new model of collective decision making, when a global decision needs to be made but the parties only possess partial information, and are unwilling (or unable) to first create a globalcomposite of their local views. Our macroscope model captures two key features of many real-world problems: allotment structure (how access to local information is apportioned between parties, including overlaps between the parties) and the possible presence of meta-information (what each party knows about the allotment structure of the overall problem). Using the framework of communication complexity, we formalize the efficient solution of a macroscope. We present general results about the macroscope model, and also results that abstract the essential computational operations underpinning practical applications, including in financial markets and decentralized sensor networks. We illustrate the computational problem inherent in real-world collective decision making processes using results for specific functions, involving detecting a change in state (constant and step functions), and computing statistical properties (the mean).
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2012;
originally announced April 2012.
-
The tractability of CSP classes defined by forbidden patterns
Authors:
David A. Cohen,
Martin C. Cooper,
Páidí Creed,
András Z. Salamon
Abstract:
The constraint satisfaction problem (CSP) is a general problem central to computer science and artificial intelligence. Although the CSP is NP-hard in general, considerable effort has been spent on identifying tractable subclasses. The main two approaches consider structural properties (restrictions on the hypergraph of constraint scopes) and relational properties (restrictions on the language of…
▽ More
The constraint satisfaction problem (CSP) is a general problem central to computer science and artificial intelligence. Although the CSP is NP-hard in general, considerable effort has been spent on identifying tractable subclasses. The main two approaches consider structural properties (restrictions on the hypergraph of constraint scopes) and relational properties (restrictions on the language of constraint relations). Recently, some authors have considered hybrid properties that restrict the constraint hypergraph and the relations simultaneously.
Our key contribution is the novel concept of a CSP pattern and classes of problems defined by forbidden patterns (which can be viewed as forbidding generic subproblems). We describe the theoretical framework which can be used to reason about classes of problems defined by forbidden patterns. We show that this framework generalises relational properties and allows us to capture known hybrid tractable classes.
Although we are not close to obtaining a dichotomy concerning the tractability of general forbidden patterns, we are able to make some progress in a special case: classes of problems that arise when we can only forbid binary negative patterns (generic subproblems in which only inconsistent tuples are specified). In this case we are able to characterise very large classes of tractable and NP-hard forbidden patterns. This leaves the complexity of just one case unresolved and we conjecture that this last case is tractable.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2014; v1 submitted 8 March, 2011;
originally announced March 2011.
-
Bounds on series-parallel slowdown
Authors:
András Z. Salamon,
Vashti Galpin
Abstract:
We use activity networks (task graphs) to model parallel programs and consider series-parallel extensions of these networks. Our motivation is two-fold: the benefits of series-parallel activity networks and the modelling of programming constructs, such as those imposed by current parallel computing environments. Series-parallelisation adds precedence constraints to an activity network, usually i…
▽ More
We use activity networks (task graphs) to model parallel programs and consider series-parallel extensions of these networks. Our motivation is two-fold: the benefits of series-parallel activity networks and the modelling of programming constructs, such as those imposed by current parallel computing environments. Series-parallelisation adds precedence constraints to an activity network, usually increasing its makespan (execution time). The slowdown ratio describes how additional constraints affect the makespan. We disprove an existing conjecture positing a bound of two on the slowdown when workload is not considered. Where workload is known, we conjecture that 4/3 slowdown is always achievable, and prove our conjecture for small networks using max-plus algebra. We analyse a polynomial-time algorithm showing that achieving 4/3 slowdown is in exp-APX. Finally, we discuss the implications of our results.
△ Less
Submitted 28 April, 2009;
originally announced April 2009.
