-
Exploring trends in audio mixes and masters: Insights from a dataset analysis
Authors:
Angeliki Mourgela,
Elio Quinton,
Spyridon Bissas,
Joshua D. Reiss,
David Ronan
Abstract:
We present an analysis of a dataset of audio metrics and aesthetic considerations about mixes and masters provided by the web platform MixCheck studio. The platform is designed for educational purposes, primarily targeting amateur music producers, and aimed at analysing their recordings prior to them being released. The analysis focuses on the following data points: integrated loudness, mono compa…
▽ More
We present an analysis of a dataset of audio metrics and aesthetic considerations about mixes and masters provided by the web platform MixCheck studio. The platform is designed for educational purposes, primarily targeting amateur music producers, and aimed at analysing their recordings prior to them being released. The analysis focuses on the following data points: integrated loudness, mono compatibility, presence of clipping and phase issues, compression and tonal profile across 30 user-specified genres. Both mixed (mixes) and mastered audio (masters) are included in the analysis, where mixes refer to the initial combination and balance of individual tracks, and masters refer to the final refined version optimized for distribution. Results show that loudness-related issues along with dynamics issues are the most prevalent, particularly in mastered audio. However mastered audio presents better results in compression than just mixed audio. Additionally, results show that mastered audio has a lower percentage of stereo field and phase issues.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
An empirical approach to the relationship between emotion and music production quality
Authors:
David Ronan,
Joshua D. Reiss,
Hatice Gunes
Abstract:
In music production, the role of the mix engineer is to take recorded music and convey the expressed emotions as professionally sounding as possible. We investigated the relationship between music production quality and musically induced and perceived emotions. A listening test was performed where 10 critical listeners and 10 non-critical listeners evaluated 10 songs. There were two mixes of each…
▽ More
In music production, the role of the mix engineer is to take recorded music and convey the expressed emotions as professionally sounding as possible. We investigated the relationship between music production quality and musically induced and perceived emotions. A listening test was performed where 10 critical listeners and 10 non-critical listeners evaluated 10 songs. There were two mixes of each song, the low quality mix and the high quality mix. Each participant's subjective experience was measured directly through questionnaire and indirectly by examining peripheral physiological changes, change in facial expressions and the number of head nods and shakes they made as they listened to each mix. We showed that music production quality had more of an emotional impact on critical listeners. Also, critical listeners had significantly different emotional responses to non-critical listeners for the high quality mixes and to a lesser extent the low quality mixes. The findings suggest that having a high level of skill in mix engineering only seems to matter in an emotional context to a subset of music listeners.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Automatic Minimisation of Masking in Multitrack Audio using Subgroups
Authors:
David Ronan,
Zheng Ma,
Paul Mc Namara,
Hatice Gunes,
Joshua D. Reiss
Abstract:
The iterative process of masking minimisation when mixing multitrack audio is a challenging optimisation problem, in part due to the complexity and non-linearity of auditory perception. In this article, we first propose a multitrack masking metric inspired by the MPEG psychoacoustic model. We investigate different audio processing techniques to manipulate the frequency and dynamic characteristics…
▽ More
The iterative process of masking minimisation when mixing multitrack audio is a challenging optimisation problem, in part due to the complexity and non-linearity of auditory perception. In this article, we first propose a multitrack masking metric inspired by the MPEG psychoacoustic model. We investigate different audio processing techniques to manipulate the frequency and dynamic characteristics of the signal in order to reduce masking based on the proposed metric. We also investigate whether or not automatically mixing using subgrouping is beneficial or not to perceived quality and clarity of a mix. Evaluation results suggest that our proposed masking metric when used in an automatic mixing framework can be used to reduce inter-channel auditory masking as well as improve the perceived quality and perceived clarity of a mix. Furthermore, our results suggest that using subgrouping in an automatic mixing framework can be used to improve the perceived quality and perceived clarity of a mix.
△ Less
Submitted 5 January, 2021; v1 submitted 27 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
