-
Optimizing Layout of Recursive Datatypes with Marmoset
Authors:
Vidush Singhal,
Chaitanya Koparkar,
Joseph Zullo,
Artem Pelenitsyn,
Michael Vollmer,
Mike Rainey,
Ryan Newton,
Milind Kulkarni
Abstract:
While programmers know that the low-level memory representation of data structures can have significant effects on performance, compiler support to optimize the layout of those structures is an under-explored field. Prior work has optimized the layout of individual, non-recursive structures without considering how collections of those objects in linked or recursive data structures are laid out. Th…
▽ More
While programmers know that the low-level memory representation of data structures can have significant effects on performance, compiler support to optimize the layout of those structures is an under-explored field. Prior work has optimized the layout of individual, non-recursive structures without considering how collections of those objects in linked or recursive data structures are laid out. This work introduces Marmoset, a compiler that optimizes the layouts of algebraic datatypes, with a special focus on producing highly optimized, packed data layouts where recursive structures can be traversed with minimal pointer chasing. Marmoset performs an analysis of how a recursive ADT is used across functions to choose a global layout that promotes simple, strided access for that ADT in memory. It does so by building and solving a constraint system to minimize an abstract cost model, yielding a predicted efficient layout for the ADT. Marmoset then builds on top of Gibbon, a prior compiler for packed, mostly-serial representations, to synthesize optimized ADTs. We show experimentally that Marmoset is able to choose optimal layouts across a series of microbenchmarks and case studies, outperforming both Gibbons baseline approach, as well as MLton, a Standard ML compiler that uses traditional pointer-heavy representations.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2024; v1 submitted 27 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
The best multicore-parallelization refactoring you've never heard of
Authors:
Mike Rainey
Abstract:
In this short paper, we explore a new way to refactor a simple but tricky-to-parallelize tree-traversal algorithm to harness multicore parallelism. Crucially, the refactoring draws from some classic techniques from programming-languages research, such as the continuation-passing-style transform and defunctionalization. The algorithm we consider faces a particularly acute granularity-control challe…
▽ More
In this short paper, we explore a new way to refactor a simple but tricky-to-parallelize tree-traversal algorithm to harness multicore parallelism. Crucially, the refactoring draws from some classic techniques from programming-languages research, such as the continuation-passing-style transform and defunctionalization. The algorithm we consider faces a particularly acute granularity-control challenge, owing to the wide range of inputs it has to deal with. Our solution achieves efficiency from heartbeat scheduling, a recent approach to automatic granularity control. We present our solution in a series of individually simple refactoring steps, starting from a high-level, recursive specification of the algorithm. As such, our approach may prove useful as a teaching tool, and perhaps be used for one-off parallelizations, as the technique requires no special compiler support.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Efficient Tree-Traversals: Reconciling Parallelism and Dense Data Representations
Authors:
Chaitanya Koparkar,
Mike Rainey,
Michael Vollmer,
Milind Kulkarni,
Ryan R. Newton
Abstract:
Recent work showed that compiling functional programs to use dense, serialized memory representations for recursive algebraic datatypes can yield significant constant-factor speedups for sequential programs. But serializing data in a maximally dense format consequently serializes the processing of that data, yielding a tension between density and parallelism. This paper shows that a disciplined, p…
▽ More
Recent work showed that compiling functional programs to use dense, serialized memory representations for recursive algebraic datatypes can yield significant constant-factor speedups for sequential programs. But serializing data in a maximally dense format consequently serializes the processing of that data, yielding a tension between density and parallelism. This paper shows that a disciplined, practical compromise is possible. We present Parallel Gibbon, a compiler that obtains the benefits of dense data formats and parallelism. We formalize the semantics of the parallel location calculus underpinning this novel implementation strategy, and show that it is type-safe. Parallel Gibbon exceeds the parallel performance of existing compilers for purely functional programs that use recursive algebraic datatypes, including, notably, abstract-syntax-tree traversals as in compilers.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Parallel Work Inflation, Memory Effects, and their Empirical Analysis
Authors:
Umut A. Acar,
Arthur Charguéraud,
Mike Rainey
Abstract:
In this paper, we propose an empirical method for evaluating the performance of parallel code. Our method is based on a simple idea that is surprisingly effective in helping to identify causes of poor performance, such as high parallelization overheads, lack of adequate parallelism, and memory effects. Our method relies on only the measurement of the run time of a baseline sequential program, the…
▽ More
In this paper, we propose an empirical method for evaluating the performance of parallel code. Our method is based on a simple idea that is surprisingly effective in helping to identify causes of poor performance, such as high parallelization overheads, lack of adequate parallelism, and memory effects. Our method relies on only the measurement of the run time of a baseline sequential program, the run time of the parallel program, the single-processor run time of the parallel program, and the total amount of time processors spend idle, waiting for work.
In our proposed approach, we establish an equality between the observed parallel speedups and three terms that we call parallel work, idle time, and work-inflation, where all terms except work inflation can be measured empirically, with precision. We then use the equality to calculate the difficult-to-measure work-inflation term, which includes increased communication costs and memory effects due to parallel execution. By isolating the main factors of poor performance, our method enables the programmer to assign blame to certain properties of the code, such as parallel grain size, amount of parallelism, and memory usage.
We present a mathematical model, inspired by the work-span model, that enables us to justify the interpretation of our measurements. We also introduce a method to help the programmer to visualize both the relative impact of the various causes of poor performance and the scaling trends in the causes of poor performance. Our method fits in a sweet spot in between state-of-the-art profiling and visualization tools. We illustrate our method by several empirical studies and we describe a few experiments that emphasize the care that is required to accurately interpret speedup plots.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2017; v1 submitted 12 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
