-
SpotLess: Concurrent Rotational Consensus Made Practical through Rapid View Synchronization
Authors:
Dakai Kang,
Sajjad Rahnama,
Jelle Hellings,
Mohammad Sadoghi
Abstract:
The emergence of blockchain technology has renewed the interest in consensus-based data management systems that are resilient to failures. To maximize the throughput of these systems, we have recently seen several prototype consensus solutions that optimize for throughput at the expense of overall implementation complexity, high costs, and reliability. Due to this, it remains unclear how these pro…
▽ More
The emergence of blockchain technology has renewed the interest in consensus-based data management systems that are resilient to failures. To maximize the throughput of these systems, we have recently seen several prototype consensus solutions that optimize for throughput at the expense of overall implementation complexity, high costs, and reliability. Due to this, it remains unclear how these prototypes will perform in real-world environments. In this paper, we present SPOTLESS, a novel concurrent rotational consensus protocol made practical. Central to SPOTLESS is the combination of (1) a chained rotational consensus design for replicating requests with a reduced message cost and low-cost failure recovery that eliminates the traditional complex, error-prone view-change protocol; (2) the novel Rapid View Synchronization protocol that enables SPOTLESS to work in more general network assumptions, without a need for a Global Synchronization Time to synchronize view, and recover valid earlier views with the aid of non-faulty replicas without the need to rely on the primary; (3) a high-performance concurrent consensus architecture in which independent instances of the chained consensus operate concurrently to process requests with high throughput, thereby avoiding the bottlenecks seen in other rotational protocols. Due to the concurrent consensus architecture, SPOTLESS greatly outperforms traditional primary-backup consensus protocols such as PBFT (by up to 430%), NARWHAL-HS (by up to 137%), and HOTSTUFF (by up to 3803%). Due to its reduced message cost, SPOTLESS is even able to outperform RCC, a state-of-the-art high-throughput concurrent consensus protocol, by up to 23%. Furthermore, SPOTLESS is able to maintain a stable and low latency and consistently high throughput even during failures.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2023; v1 submitted 4 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
On the Correctness of Speculative Consensus
Authors:
Jelle Hellings,
Suyash Gupta,
Sajjad Rahnama,
Mohammad Sadoghi
Abstract:
The introduction of Bitcoin fueled the development of blockchain-based resilient data management systems that are resilient against failures, enable federated data management, and can support data provenance. The key factor determining the performance of such resilient data management systems is the consensus protocol used by the system to replicate client transactions among all participants. Unfo…
▽ More
The introduction of Bitcoin fueled the development of blockchain-based resilient data management systems that are resilient against failures, enable federated data management, and can support data provenance. The key factor determining the performance of such resilient data management systems is the consensus protocol used by the system to replicate client transactions among all participants. Unfortunately, existing high-throughput consensus protocols are costly and impose significant latencies on transaction processing, which rules out their usage in responsive high-performance data management systems.
In this work, we improve on this situation by introducing the Proof-of-Execution consensus protocol (PoE), a consensus protocol designed for high-performance low-latency resilient data management. PoE introduces speculative execution, which minimizes latencies by starting execution before consensus is reached, and PoE introduces proof-of-executions to guarantee successful execution to clients. Furthermore, PoE introduces a single-round check-commit protocol to reduce the overall communication costs of consensus. Hence, we believe that PoE is a promising step towards flexible general-purpose low-latency resilient data management systems.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Dissecting BFT Consensus: In Trusted Components we Trust!
Authors:
Suyash Gupta,
Sajjad Rahnama,
Shubham Pandey,
Natacha Crooks,
Mohammad Sadoghi
Abstract:
The growing interest in reliable multi-party applications has fostered widespread adoption of Byzantine Fault-Tolerant (BFT) consensus protocols. Existing BFT protocols need f more replicas than Paxos-style protocols to prevent equivocation attacks. Trust-BFT protocols instead seek to minimize this cost by making use of trusted components at replicas. This paper makes two contributions. First, we…
▽ More
The growing interest in reliable multi-party applications has fostered widespread adoption of Byzantine Fault-Tolerant (BFT) consensus protocols. Existing BFT protocols need f more replicas than Paxos-style protocols to prevent equivocation attacks. Trust-BFT protocols instead seek to minimize this cost by making use of trusted components at replicas. This paper makes two contributions. First, we analyze the design of existing Trust-BFT protocols and uncover three fundamental limitations that preclude most practical deployments. Some of these limitations are fundamental, while others are linked to the state of trusted components today. Second, we introduce a novel suite of consensus protocols, FlexiTrust, that attempts to sidestep these issues. We show that our FlexiTrust protocols achieve up to 185% more throughput than their Trust-BFT counterparts.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2022; v1 submitted 2 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Reliable Transactions in Serverless-Edge Architecture
Authors:
Suyash Gupta,
Sajjad Rahnama,
Erik Linsenmayer,
Faisal Nawab,
Mohammad Sadoghi
Abstract:
Modern edge applications demand novel solutions where edge applications do not have to rely on a single cloud provider (which cannot be in the vicinity of every edge device) or dedicated edge servers (which cannot scale as clouds) for processing compute-intensive tasks. A recent computing philosophy, Sky computing, proposes giving each user ability to select between available cloud providers.
In…
▽ More
Modern edge applications demand novel solutions where edge applications do not have to rely on a single cloud provider (which cannot be in the vicinity of every edge device) or dedicated edge servers (which cannot scale as clouds) for processing compute-intensive tasks. A recent computing philosophy, Sky computing, proposes giving each user ability to select between available cloud providers.
In this paper, we present our serverless-edge co-design, which extends the Sky computing vision. In our serverless-edge co-design, we expect edge devices to collaborate and spawn required number of serverless functions. This raises several key challenges: (1) how will this collaboration take place, (2) what if some edge devices are compromised, and (3) what if a selected cloud provider is malicious. Hence, we design ServerlessBFT, the first protocol to guarantee Byzantine fault-tolerant (BFT) transactional flow between edge devices and serverless functions. We present an exhaustive list of attacks and their solutions on our serverless-edge co-design. Further, we extensively benchmark our architecture on a variety of parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2022; v1 submitted 4 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
RingBFT: Resilient Consensus over Sharded Ring Topology
Authors:
Sajjad Rahnama,
Suyash Gupta,
Rohan Sogani,
Dhruv Krishnan,
Mohammad Sadoghi
Abstract:
The recent surge in federated data management applications has brought forth concerns about the security of underlying data and the consistency of replicas in the presence of malicious attacks. A prominent solution in this direction is to employ a permissioned blockchain framework that is modeled around traditional Byzantine Fault-Tolerant (BFT) consensus protocols. Any federated application expec…
▽ More
The recent surge in federated data management applications has brought forth concerns about the security of underlying data and the consistency of replicas in the presence of malicious attacks. A prominent solution in this direction is to employ a permissioned blockchain framework that is modeled around traditional Byzantine Fault-Tolerant (BFT) consensus protocols. Any federated application expects its data to be globally scattered to achieve faster access. But, prior works have shown that traditional BFT protocols are slow. This has led to the rise of sharded-replicated blockchains. Existing BFT protocols for these sharded blockchains are efficient if client transactions require access to a single-shard, but face performance degradation if there is a cross-shard transaction that requires access to multiple shards. As cross-shard transactions are common, to resolve this dilemma, we present RingBFT, a novel meta-BFT protocol for sharded blockchains. RingBFT requires shards to adhere to the ring order, and follow the principle of process, forward, and re-transmit while ensuring the communication between shards is linear. Our evaluation of RingBFT against state-of-the-art sharding BFT protocols illustrates that RingBFT achieves up to 18x higher throughput, gracefully scales to nearly 500 globally distributed nodes, and achieves a peak throughput of 1.2 million transactions per second.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2022; v1 submitted 27 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
ResilientDB: Global Scale Resilient Blockchain Fabric
Authors:
Suyash Gupta,
Sajjad Rahnama,
Jelle Hellings,
Mohammad Sadoghi
Abstract:
Recent developments in blockchain technology have inspired innovative new designs in resilient distributed and database systems. At their core, these blockchain applications typically use Byzantine fault-tolerant consensus protocols to maintain a common state across all replicas, even if some replicas are faulty or malicious. Unfortunately, existing consensus protocols are not designed to deal wit…
▽ More
Recent developments in blockchain technology have inspired innovative new designs in resilient distributed and database systems. At their core, these blockchain applications typically use Byzantine fault-tolerant consensus protocols to maintain a common state across all replicas, even if some replicas are faulty or malicious. Unfortunately, existing consensus protocols are not designed to deal with geo-scale deployments in which many replicas spread across a geographically large area participate in consensus. To address this, we present the Geo-Scale Byzantine FaultTolerant consensus protocol (GeoBFT). GeoBFT is designed for excellent scalability by using a topological-aware grouping of replicas in local clusters, by introducing parallelization of consensus at the local level, and by minimizing communication between clusters. To validate our vision of high-performance geo-scale resilient distributed systems, we implement GeoBFT in our efficient ResilientDB permissioned blockchain fabric. We show that GeoBFT is not only sound and provides great scalability, but also outperforms state-of-the-art consensus protocols by a factor of six in geo-scale deployments.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2020; v1 submitted 1 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Permissioned Blockchain Through the Looking Glass: Architectural and Implementation Lessons Learned
Authors:
Suyash Gupta,
Sajjad Rahnama,
Mohammad Sadoghi
Abstract:
Since the inception of Bitcoin, the distributed systems community has shown interest in the design of efficient blockchain systems. However, initial blockchain applications (like Bitcoin) attain very low throughput, which has promoted the design of permissioned blockchain systems. These permissioned blockchain systems employ classical Byzantine-Fault Tolerant (BFT) protocols to reach consensus. Ho…
▽ More
Since the inception of Bitcoin, the distributed systems community has shown interest in the design of efficient blockchain systems. However, initial blockchain applications (like Bitcoin) attain very low throughput, which has promoted the design of permissioned blockchain systems. These permissioned blockchain systems employ classical Byzantine-Fault Tolerant (BFT) protocols to reach consensus. However, existing permissioned blockchain systems still attain low throughputs (of the order 10K txns/s). As a result, existing works blame this low throughput on the associated BFT protocol and expend resources in developing optimized protocols. We believe such blames only depict a one-sided story. In specific, we raise a simple question: can a well-crafted system based on a classical BFT protocol outperform a modern protocol? We show that designing such a well-crafted system is possible and illustrate that even if such a system employs a three-phase protocol, it can outperform another system utilizing a single-phase protocol. This endeavor requires us to dissect a permissioned blockchain system and highlight different factors that affect its performance. Based on our insights, we present the design of our enterprise-grade, high-throughput yielding permissioned blockchain system, ResilientDB, that employs multi-threaded deep pipelines, to balance tasks at a replica, and provides guidelines for future designs.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2020; v1 submitted 20 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Proof-of-Execution: Reaching Consensus through Fault-Tolerant Speculation
Authors:
Suyash Gupta,
Jelle Hellings,
Sajjad Rahnama,
Mohammad Sadoghi
Abstract:
Multi-party data management and blockchain systems require data sharing among participants. To provide resilient and consistent data sharing, transactions engines rely on Byzantine FaultTolerant consensus (BFT), which enables operations during failures and malicious behavior. Unfortunately, existing BFT protocols are unsuitable for high-throughput applications due to their high computational costs…
▽ More
Multi-party data management and blockchain systems require data sharing among participants. To provide resilient and consistent data sharing, transactions engines rely on Byzantine FaultTolerant consensus (BFT), which enables operations during failures and malicious behavior. Unfortunately, existing BFT protocols are unsuitable for high-throughput applications due to their high computational costs, high communication costs, high client latencies, and/or reliance on twin-paths and non-faulty clients. In this paper, we present the Proof-of-Execution consensus protocol (PoE) that alleviates these challenges. At the core of PoE are out-of-order processing and speculative execution, which allow PoE to execute transactions before consensus is reached among the replicas. With these techniques, PoE manages to reduce the costs of BFT in normal cases, while guaranteeing reliable consensus for clients in all cases. We envision the use of PoE in high-throughput multi-party data-management and blockchain systems. To validate this vision, we implement PoE in our efficient ResilientDB fabric and extensively evaluate PoE against several state-of-the-art BFT protocols. Our evaluation showcases that PoE achieves up-to-80% higher throughputs than existing BFT protocols in the presence of failures.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2021; v1 submitted 3 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
