-
Exploring Reasoning Biases in Large Language Models Through Syllogism: Insights from the NeuBAROCO Dataset
Authors:
Kentaro Ozeki,
Risako Ando,
Takanobu Morishita,
Hirohiko Abe,
Koji Mineshima,
Mitsuhiro Okada
Abstract:
This paper explores the question of how accurately current large language models can perform logical reasoning in natural language, with an emphasis on whether these models exhibit reasoning biases similar to humans. Specifically, our study focuses on syllogistic reasoning, a form of deductive reasoning extensively studied in cognitive science as a natural form of human reasoning. We present a syl…
▽ More
This paper explores the question of how accurately current large language models can perform logical reasoning in natural language, with an emphasis on whether these models exhibit reasoning biases similar to humans. Specifically, our study focuses on syllogistic reasoning, a form of deductive reasoning extensively studied in cognitive science as a natural form of human reasoning. We present a syllogism dataset called NeuBAROCO, which consists of syllogistic reasoning problems in English and Japanese. This dataset was originally designed for psychological experiments to assess human reasoning capabilities using various forms of syllogisms. Our experiments with leading large language models indicate that these models exhibit reasoning biases similar to humans, along with other error tendencies. Notably, there is significant room for improvement in reasoning problems where the relationship between premises and hypotheses is neither entailment nor contradiction. We also present experimental results and in-depth analysis using a new Chain-of-Thought prompting method, which asks LLMs to translate syllogisms into abstract logical expressions and then explain their reasoning process. Our analysis using this method suggests that the primary limitations of LLMs lie in the reasoning process itself rather than the interpretation of syllogisms.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Reconfiguration of Independent Transversals
Authors:
Pjotr Buys,
Ross J. Kang,
Kenta Ozeki
Abstract:
Given integers $Δ\ge 2$ and $t\ge 2Δ$, suppose there is a graph of maximum degree $Δ$ and a partition of its vertices into blocks of size at least $t$. By a seminal result of Haxell, there must be some independent set of the graph that is transversal to the blocks, a so-called independent transversal. We show that, if moreover $t\ge2Δ+1$, then every independent transversal can be transformed withi…
▽ More
Given integers $Δ\ge 2$ and $t\ge 2Δ$, suppose there is a graph of maximum degree $Δ$ and a partition of its vertices into blocks of size at least $t$. By a seminal result of Haxell, there must be some independent set of the graph that is transversal to the blocks, a so-called independent transversal. We show that, if moreover $t\ge2Δ+1$, then every independent transversal can be transformed within the space of independent transversals to any other through a sequence of one-vertex modifications, showing connectivity of the so-called reconfigurability graph of independent transversals.
This is sharp in that for $t=2Δ$ (and $Δ\ge 2$) the connectivity conclusion can fail. In this case we show furthermore that in an essential sense it can only fail for the disjoint union of copies of the complete bipartite graph $K_{Δ,Δ}$. This constitutes a qualitative strengthening of Haxell's theorem.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
A necessary and sufficient condition for the existence of a properly coloured $f$-factor in an edge-coloured graph
Authors:
Roman Čada,
Michitaka Furuya,
Kenji Kimura,
Kenta Ozeki,
Christopher Purcell,
Takamasa Yashima
Abstract:
The main result of this paper is an edge-coloured version of Tutte's $f$-factor theorem. We give a necessary and sufficient condition for an edge-coloured graph $G^c$ to have a properly coloured $f$-factor. We state and prove our result in terms of an auxiliary graph $G_f^c$ which has a 1-factor if and only if $G^c$ has a properly coloured $f$-factor; this is analogous to the "short proof" of the…
▽ More
The main result of this paper is an edge-coloured version of Tutte's $f$-factor theorem. We give a necessary and sufficient condition for an edge-coloured graph $G^c$ to have a properly coloured $f$-factor. We state and prove our result in terms of an auxiliary graph $G_f^c$ which has a 1-factor if and only if $G^c$ has a properly coloured $f$-factor; this is analogous to the "short proof" of the $f$-factor theorem given by Tutte in 1954. An alternative statement, analogous to the original $f$-factor theorem, is also given. We show that our theorem generalises the $f$-factor theorem; that is, the former implies the latter. We consider other properties of edge-coloured graphs, and show that similar results are unlikely for $f$-factors with rainbow components and distance-$d$-coloured $f$-factors, even when $d=2$ and the number of colours used is asymptotically minimal.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Reconfiguration of colorings in triangulations of the sphere
Authors:
Takehiro Ito,
Yuni Iwamasa,
Yusuke Kobayashi,
Shun-ichi Maezawa,
Yuta Nozaki,
Yoshio Okamoto,
Kenta Ozeki
Abstract:
In 1973, Fisk proved that any $4$-coloring of a $3$-colorable triangulation of the $2$-sphere can be obtained from any $3$-coloring by a sequence of Kempe-changes. On the other hand, in the case where we are only allowed to recolor a single vertex in each step, which is a special case of a Kempe-change, there exists a $4$-coloring that cannot be obtained from any $3$-coloring. In this paper, we pr…
▽ More
In 1973, Fisk proved that any $4$-coloring of a $3$-colorable triangulation of the $2$-sphere can be obtained from any $3$-coloring by a sequence of Kempe-changes. On the other hand, in the case where we are only allowed to recolor a single vertex in each step, which is a special case of a Kempe-change, there exists a $4$-coloring that cannot be obtained from any $3$-coloring. In this paper, we present a characterization of a $4$-coloring of a $3$-colorable triangulation of the $2$-sphere that can be obtained from a $3$-coloring by a sequence of recoloring operations at single vertices, and a criterion for a $3$-colorable triangulation of the $2$-sphere that all $4$-colorings can be obtained from a $3$-coloring by such a sequence. Moreover, our first result can be generalized to a high-dimensional case, in which ``$4$-coloring,'' ``$3$-colorable,'' and ``$2$-sphere'' above are replaced with ``$k$-coloring,'' ``$(k-1)$-colorable,'' and ``$(k-2)$-sphere'' for $k \geq 4$, respectively. In addition, we show that the problem of deciding whether, for given two $(k+1)$-colorings, one can be obtained from the other by such a sequence is PSPACE-complete for any fixed $k \geq 4$. Our results above can be rephrased as new results on the computational problems named {\sc $k$-Recoloring} and {\sc Connectedness of $k$-Coloring Reconfiguration Graph}, which are fundamental problems in the field of combinatorial reconfiguration.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Rerouting Planar Curves and Disjoint Paths
Authors:
Takehiro Ito,
Yuni Iwamasa,
Naonori Kakimura,
Yusuke Kobayashi,
Shun-ichi Maezawa,
Yuta Nozaki,
Yoshio Okamoto,
Kenta Ozeki
Abstract:
In this paper, we consider a transformation of $k$ disjoint paths in a graph. For a graph and a pair of $k$ disjoint paths $\mathcal{P}$ and $\mathcal{Q}$ connecting the same set of terminal pairs, we aim to determine whether $\mathcal{P}$ can be transformed to $\mathcal{Q}$ by repeatedly replacing one path with another path so that the intermediates are also $k$ disjoint paths. The problem is cal…
▽ More
In this paper, we consider a transformation of $k$ disjoint paths in a graph. For a graph and a pair of $k$ disjoint paths $\mathcal{P}$ and $\mathcal{Q}$ connecting the same set of terminal pairs, we aim to determine whether $\mathcal{P}$ can be transformed to $\mathcal{Q}$ by repeatedly replacing one path with another path so that the intermediates are also $k$ disjoint paths. The problem is called Disjoint Paths Reconfiguration. We first show that Disjoint Paths Reconfiguration is PSPACE-complete even when $k=2$. On the other hand, we prove that, when the graph is embedded on a plane and all paths in $\mathcal{P}$ and $\mathcal{Q}$ connect the boundaries of two faces, Disjoint Paths Reconfiguration can be solved in polynomial time. The algorithm is based on a topological characterization for rerouting curves on a plane using the algebraic intersection number. We also consider a transformation of disjoint $s$-$t$ paths as a variant. We show that the disjoint $s$-$t$ paths reconfiguration problem in planar graphs can be determined in polynomial time, while the problem is PSPACE-complete in general.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
On Reachable Assignments under Dichotomous Preferences
Authors:
Takehiro Ito,
Naonori Kakimura,
Naoyuki Kamiyama,
Yusuke Kobayashi,
Yuta Nozaki,
Yoshio Okamoto,
Kenta Ozeki
Abstract:
We consider the problem of determining whether a target item assignment can be reached from an initial item assignment by a sequence of pairwise exchanges of items between agents. In particular, we consider the situation where each agent has a dichotomous preference over the items, that is, each agent evaluates each item as acceptable or unacceptable. Furthermore, we assume that communication betw…
▽ More
We consider the problem of determining whether a target item assignment can be reached from an initial item assignment by a sequence of pairwise exchanges of items between agents. In particular, we consider the situation where each agent has a dichotomous preference over the items, that is, each agent evaluates each item as acceptable or unacceptable. Furthermore, we assume that communication between agents is limited, and the relationship is represented by an undirected graph. Then, a pair of agents can exchange their items only if they are connected by an edge and the involved items are acceptable. We prove that this problem is PSPACE-complete even when the communication graph is complete (that is, every pair of agents can exchange their items), and this problem can be solved in polynomial time if an input graph is a tree.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Reforming an Envy-Free Matching
Authors:
Takehiro Ito,
Yuni Iwamasa,
Naonori Kakimura,
Naoyuki Kamiyama,
Yusuke Kobayashi,
Yuta Nozaki,
Yoshio Okamoto,
Kenta Ozeki
Abstract:
We consider the problem of reforming an envy-free matching when each agent is assigned a single item. Given an envy-free matching, we consider an operation to exchange the item of an agent with an unassigned item preferred by the agent that results in another envy-free matching. We repeat this operation as long as we can. We prove that the resulting envy-free matching is uniquely determined up to…
▽ More
We consider the problem of reforming an envy-free matching when each agent is assigned a single item. Given an envy-free matching, we consider an operation to exchange the item of an agent with an unassigned item preferred by the agent that results in another envy-free matching. We repeat this operation as long as we can. We prove that the resulting envy-free matching is uniquely determined up to the choice of an initial envy-free matching, and can be found in polynomial time. We call the resulting matching a reformist envy-free matching, and then we study a shortest sequence to obtain the reformist envy-free matching from an initial envy-free matching. We prove that a shortest sequence is computationally hard to obtain even when each agent accepts at most four items and each item is accepted by at most three agents. On the other hand, we give polynomial-time algorithms when each agent accepts at most three items or each item is accepted by at most two agents. Inapproximability and fixed-parameter (in)tractability are also discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Monotone edge flips to an orientation of maximum edge-connectivity à la Nash-Williams
Authors:
Takehiro Ito,
Yuni Iwamasa,
Naonori Kakimura,
Naoyuki Kamiyama,
Yusuke Kobayashi,
Shun-ichi Maezawa,
Yuta Nozaki,
Yoshio Okamoto,
Kenta Ozeki
Abstract:
We initiate the study of $k$-edge-connected orientations of undirected graphs through edge flips for $k \geq 2$. We prove that in every orientation of an undirected $2k$-edge-connected graph, there exists a sequence of edges such that flipping their directions one by one does not decrease the edge-connectivity, and the final orientation is $k$-edge-connected. This yields an ``edge-flip based'' new…
▽ More
We initiate the study of $k$-edge-connected orientations of undirected graphs through edge flips for $k \geq 2$. We prove that in every orientation of an undirected $2k$-edge-connected graph, there exists a sequence of edges such that flipping their directions one by one does not decrease the edge-connectivity, and the final orientation is $k$-edge-connected. This yields an ``edge-flip based'' new proof of Nash-Williams' theorem: an undirected graph $G$ has a $k$-edge-connected orientation if and only if $G$ is $2k$-edge-connected. As another consequence of the theorem, we prove that the edge-flip graph of $k$-edge-connected orientations of an undirected graph $G$ is connected if $G$ is $(2k+2)$-edge-connected. This has been known to be true only when $k=1$.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
On the minimum leaf number of cubic graphs
Authors:
Jan Goedgebeur,
Kenta Ozeki,
Nico Van Cleemput,
Gábor Wiener
Abstract:
The \emph{minimum leaf number} $\hbox{ml} (G)$ of a connected graph $G$ is defined as the minimum number of leaves of the spanning trees of $G$. We present new results concerning the minimum leaf number of cubic graphs: we show that if $G$ is a connected cubic graph of order $n$, then $\mathrm{ml}(G) \leq \frac{n}6 + \frac13$, improving on the best known result in [Inf. Process. Lett. 105 (2008) 1…
▽ More
The \emph{minimum leaf number} $\hbox{ml} (G)$ of a connected graph $G$ is defined as the minimum number of leaves of the spanning trees of $G$. We present new results concerning the minimum leaf number of cubic graphs: we show that if $G$ is a connected cubic graph of order $n$, then $\mathrm{ml}(G) \leq \frac{n}6 + \frac13$, improving on the best known result in [Inf. Process. Lett. 105 (2008) 164-169] and proving the conjecture in [Electron. J. Graph Theory and Applications 5 (2017) 207-211]. We further prove that if $G$ is also 2-connected, then $\mathrm{ml}(G) \leq \frac{n}{6.53}$, improving on the best known bound in [Math. Program., Ser. A 144 (2014) 227-245]. We also present new conjectures concerning the minimum leaf number of several types of cubic graphs and examples showing that the bounds of the conjectures are best possible.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Single-conflict colouring
Authors:
Zdeněk Dvořák,
Louis Esperet,
Ross J. Kang,
Kenta Ozeki
Abstract:
Given a multigraph, suppose that each vertex is given a local assignment of $k$ colours to its incident edges. We are interested in whether there is a choice of one local colour per vertex such that no edge has both of its local colours chosen. The least $k$ for which this is always possible given any set of local assignments we call the {\em single-conflict chromatic number} of the graph. This pa…
▽ More
Given a multigraph, suppose that each vertex is given a local assignment of $k$ colours to its incident edges. We are interested in whether there is a choice of one local colour per vertex such that no edge has both of its local colours chosen. The least $k$ for which this is always possible given any set of local assignments we call the {\em single-conflict chromatic number} of the graph. This parameter is closely related to separation choosability and adaptable choosability. We show that single-conflict chromatic number of simple graphs embeddable on a surface of Euler genus $g$ is $O(g^{1/4}\log g)$ as $g\to\infty$. This is sharp up to the logarithmic factor.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2020; v1 submitted 29 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
