A three-person deterministic graphical game without Nash equilibria
Authors:
Endre Boros,
Vladimir Gurvich,
Martin Milanič,
Vladimir Oudalov,
Jernej Vičič
Abstract:
We give an example of a three-person deterministic graphical game that has no Nash equilibrium in pure stationary strategies. The game has seven positions, four outcomes (a unique cycle and three terminal positions), and its normal form is of size 2 x 2 x 4 only. Thus, our example strengthens significantly the one obtained in 2014 by Gurvich and Oudalov; the latter has four players, five terminals…
▽ More
We give an example of a three-person deterministic graphical game that has no Nash equilibrium in pure stationary strategies. The game has seven positions, four outcomes (a unique cycle and three terminal positions), and its normal form is of size 2 x 2 x 4 only. Thus, our example strengthens significantly the one obtained in 2014 by Gurvich and Oudalov; the latter has four players, five terminals, and a 2 x 4 x 6 x 8 normal form. Furthermore, our example is minimal with respect to the number of players. Both examples are tight but not Nash-solvable. Such examples were known since 1975, but they were not related to deterministic graphical games. Moreover, due to the small size of our example, we can strengthen it further by showing that it has no Nash equilibrium not only in pure but also in independently mixed strategies, for both Markovian and a priori evaluations.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2017; v1 submitted 24 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
A four-person chess-like game without Nash equilibria in pure stationary strategies
Authors:
Vladimir Gurvich,
Vladimir Oudalov
Abstract:
In this short note we give an example of a four-person finite positional game with perfect information that has no positions of chance and no Nash equilibria in pure stationary strategies. The corresponding directed graph has only one directed cycle and only five terminal positions.
It remains open: (i) if the number $n$ of the players can be reduced from $4$ to $3$, (ii) if the number $p$ of th…
▽ More
In this short note we give an example of a four-person finite positional game with perfect information that has no positions of chance and no Nash equilibria in pure stationary strategies. The corresponding directed graph has only one directed cycle and only five terminal positions.
It remains open: (i) if the number $n$ of the players can be reduced from $4$ to $3$, (ii) if the number $p$ of the terminals can be reduced from $5$ to $4$, and most important, (iii) whether it is possible to get a similar example in which the outcome $c$ corresponding to all (possibly, more than one) directed cycles is worse than every terminal for each player.
Yet, it is known that (j) $n$ cannot be reduced to $2$, (jj) $p$ cannot be reduced to $3$, and (jjj) there can be no similar example in which each player makes a decision in a unique position.
Keywords: stochastic, positional, chess-like, transition-free games with perfect information and without moves of chance; Nash equilibrium, directed cycles (dicycles), terminal position.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
