-
Diversity Aware Relevance Learning for Argument Search
Authors:
Michael Fromm,
Max Berrendorf,
Sandra Obermeier,
Thomas Seidl,
Evgeniy Faerman
Abstract:
In this work, we focus on the problem of retrieving relevant arguments for a query claim covering diverse aspects. State-of-the-art methods rely on explicit mappings between claims and premises, and thus are unable to utilize large available collections of premises without laborious and costly manual annotation. Their diversity approach relies on removing duplicates via clustering which does not d…
▽ More
In this work, we focus on the problem of retrieving relevant arguments for a query claim covering diverse aspects. State-of-the-art methods rely on explicit mappings between claims and premises, and thus are unable to utilize large available collections of premises without laborious and costly manual annotation. Their diversity approach relies on removing duplicates via clustering which does not directly ensure that the selected premises cover all aspects. This work introduces a new multi-step approach for the argument retrieval problem. Rather than relying on ground-truth assignments, our approach employs a machine learning model to capture semantic relationships between arguments. Beyond that, it aims to cover diverse facets of the query, instead of trying to identify duplicates explicitly. Our empirical evaluation demonstrates that our approach leads to a significant improvement in the argument retrieval task even though it requires less data.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2021; v1 submitted 4 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Memory-Efficient RkNN Retrieval by Nonlinear k-Distance Approximation
Authors:
Sandra Obermeier,
Max Berrendorf,
Peer Kröger
Abstract:
The reverse k-nearest neighbor (RkNN) query is an established query type with various applications reaching from identifying highly influential objects over incrementally updating kNN graphs to optimizing sensor communication and outlier detection. State-of-the-art solutions exploit that the k-distances in real-world datasets often follow the power-law distribution, and bound them with linear line…
▽ More
The reverse k-nearest neighbor (RkNN) query is an established query type with various applications reaching from identifying highly influential objects over incrementally updating kNN graphs to optimizing sensor communication and outlier detection. State-of-the-art solutions exploit that the k-distances in real-world datasets often follow the power-law distribution, and bound them with linear lines in log-log space. In this work, we investigate this assumption and uncover that it is violated in regions of changing density, which we show are typical for real-life datasets. Towards a generic solution, we pose the estimation of k-distances as a regression problem. Thereby, we enable harnessing the power of the abundance of available Machine Learning models and profiting from their advancement. We propose a flexible approach which allows steering the performance-memory consumption trade-off, and in particular to find good solutions with a fixed memory budget crucial in the context of edge computing. Moreover, we show how to obtain and improve guaranteed bounds essential to exact query processing. In experiments on real-world datasets, we demonstrate how this framework can significantly reduce the index memory consumption, and strongly reduce the candidate set size. We publish our code at https://github.com/sobermeier/nonlinear-kdist.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
When Can a Distributed Ledger Replace a Trusted Third Party?
Authors:
Thomas Locher,
Sebastian Obermeier,
Yvonne-Anne Pignolet
Abstract:
The functionality that distributed ledger technology provides, i.e., an immutable and fraud-resistant registry with validation and verification mechanisms, has traditionally been implemented with a trusted third party. Due to the distributed nature of ledger technology, there is a strong recent trend towards using ledgers to implement novel decentralized applications for a wide range of use cases,…
▽ More
The functionality that distributed ledger technology provides, i.e., an immutable and fraud-resistant registry with validation and verification mechanisms, has traditionally been implemented with a trusted third party. Due to the distributed nature of ledger technology, there is a strong recent trend towards using ledgers to implement novel decentralized applications for a wide range of use cases, e.g., in the financial sector and sharing economy. While there can be several arguments for the use of a ledger, the key question is whether it can fully replace any single trusted party in the system as otherwise a (potentially simpler) solution can be built around the trusted party. In this paper, we introduce an abstract view on ledger use cases and present two fundamental criteria that must be met for any use case to be implemented using a ledger-based approach without having to rely on any particular party in the system. Moreover, we evaluate several ledger use cases that have recently received considerable attention according to these criteria, revealing that often participants need to trust each other despite using a distributed ledger. Consequently, the potential of using a ledger as a replacement for a trusted party is limited for these use cases.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
