-
Exploring the dynamics of self-citations and their role in shaping scientific impact
Authors:
Maciej J. Mrowinski,
Aleksandra Buczek,
Agata Fronczak
Abstract:
Understanding the mechanisms driving the distribution of scientific citations is a key challenge in assessing the scientific impact of authors. We investigate the influence of the preferential attachment rule (PAR) in this process by analyzing individual citation events from the DBLP dataset, enabling us to estimate the probability of citations being assigned preferentially. Our findings reveal th…
▽ More
Understanding the mechanisms driving the distribution of scientific citations is a key challenge in assessing the scientific impact of authors. We investigate the influence of the preferential attachment rule (PAR) in this process by analyzing individual citation events from the DBLP dataset, enabling us to estimate the probability of citations being assigned preferentially. Our findings reveal that, for the aggregated dataset, PAR dominates the citation distribution process, with approximately 70% of citations adhering to this mechanism. However, analysis at the individual level shows significant variability, with some authors experiencing a greater prevalence of preferential citations, particularly in the context of external citations. In contrast, self-citations exhibit notably different behaviour, with only 20% following PAR. We also demonstrate that the prominence of PAR increases with an author's citability (average citations per paper), suggesting that more citable authors are preferentially cited, while less-cited authors experience more random citation patterns. Furthermore, we show that self-citations may influence bibliometric indexes. Our results emphasise the distinct dynamics of self-citations compared to external citations, raising questions about the mechanisms driving self-citation patterns. These findings provide new insights into citation behaviours and highlight the limitations of existing approaches in capturing the nuances of scientific impact.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Interplay between tie strength and neighbourhood topology in complex networks: Granovetter's theory and beyond
Authors:
Maciej J Mrowinski,
Kamil P. Orzechowski,
Agata Fronczak,
Piotr Fronczak
Abstract:
Granovetter's weak ties theory is a very important sociological theory according to which a correlation between edge weight and the network's topology should exist. More specifically, the neighbourhood overlap of two nodes connected by an edge should be positively correlated with edge weight (tie strength). However, some real social networks exhibit a negative correlation - the most prominent exam…
▽ More
Granovetter's weak ties theory is a very important sociological theory according to which a correlation between edge weight and the network's topology should exist. More specifically, the neighbourhood overlap of two nodes connected by an edge should be positively correlated with edge weight (tie strength). However, some real social networks exhibit a negative correlation - the most prominent example is the scientific collaboration network, for which overlap decreases with edge weight. It has been demonstrated that the aforementioned inconsistency with Granovetter's theory can be alleviated in the scientific collaboration network through the use of asymmetric measures. In this paper, we explain that while asymmetric measures are often necessary to describe complex networks and to confirm Granovetter's theory, their interpretation is not simple, and there are pitfalls that one must be wary of. The definitions of asymmetric weights and overlaps introduce structural correlations that must be filtered out. We show that correlation profiles can be used to overcome this problem. Using this technique, not only do we confirm Granovetter's theory in various real and artificial social networks, but we also show that Granovetter-like weight-topology correlations are present in other complex networks (e.g. metabolic and neural networks). Our results suggest that Granovetter's theory is a sociological manifestation of more general principles governing various types of complex networks.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Asymmetry of social interactions and its role in link predictability: the case of coauthorship networks
Authors:
Kamil P. Orzechowski,
Maciej J. Mrowinski,
Agata Fronczak,
Piotr Fronczak
Abstract:
The paper provides important insights into understanding the factors that influence tie strength in social networks. Using local network measures that take into account asymmetry of social interactions we show that the observed tie strength is a kind of compromise, which depends on the relative strength of the tie as seen from its both ends. This statement is supported by the Granovetter-like, str…
▽ More
The paper provides important insights into understanding the factors that influence tie strength in social networks. Using local network measures that take into account asymmetry of social interactions we show that the observed tie strength is a kind of compromise, which depends on the relative strength of the tie as seen from its both ends. This statement is supported by the Granovetter-like, strongly positive weight-topology correlations, in the form of a power-law relationship between the asymmetric tie strength and asymmetric neighbourhood overlap, observed in three different real coauthorship networks and in a synthetic model of scientific collaboration. This observation is juxtaposed against the current misconception that coauthorship networks, being the proxy of scientific collaboration networks, contradict the Granovetter's strength of weak ties hypothesis, and the reasons for this misconception are explained. Finally, by testing various link similarity scores, it is shown that taking into account the asymmetry of social ties can remarkably increase the efficiency of link prediction methods. The perspective outlined also allows us to comment on the surprisingly high performance of the resource allocation index -- one of the most recognizable and effective local similarity scores -- which can be rationalized by the strong triadic closure property, assuming that the property takes into account the asymmetry of social ties.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Artificial intelligence in peer review: How can evolutionary computation support journal editors?
Authors:
Maciej J. Mrowinski,
Piotr Fronczak,
Agata Fronczak,
Marcel Ausloos,
Olgica Nedic
Abstract:
With the volume of manuscripts submitted for publication growing every year, the deficiencies of peer review (e.g. long review times) are becoming more apparent. Editorial strategies, sets of guidelines designed to speed up the process and reduce editors workloads, are treated as trade secrets by publishing houses and are not shared publicly. To improve the effectiveness of their strategies, edito…
▽ More
With the volume of manuscripts submitted for publication growing every year, the deficiencies of peer review (e.g. long review times) are becoming more apparent. Editorial strategies, sets of guidelines designed to speed up the process and reduce editors workloads, are treated as trade secrets by publishing houses and are not shared publicly. To improve the effectiveness of their strategies, editors in small publishing groups are faced with undertaking an iterative trial-and-error approach. We show that Cartesian Genetic Programming, a nature-inspired evolutionary algorithm, can dramatically improve editorial strategies. The artificially evolved strategy reduced the duration of the peer review process by 30%, without increasing the pool of reviewers (in comparison to a typical human-developed strategy). Evolutionary computation has typically been used in technological processes or biological ecosystems. Our results demonstrate that genetic programs can improve real-world social systems that are usually much harder to understand and control than physical systems.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Day of the week effect in paper submission/acceptance/rejection to/in/by peer review journals. II. An ARCH econometric-like modeling
Authors:
Marcel Ausloos,
Olgica Nedic,
Aleksandar Dekanski,
Maciej J. Mrowinski,
Piotr Fronczak,
Agata Fronczak
Abstract:
This paper aims at providing a statistical model for the preferred behavior of authors submitting a paper to a scientific journal. The electronic submission of (about 600) papers to the Journal of the Serbian Chemical Society has been recorded for every day from Jan. 01, 2013 till Dec. 31, 2014, together with the acceptance or rejection paper fate. Seasonal effects and editor roles (through desk r…
▽ More
This paper aims at providing a statistical model for the preferred behavior of authors submitting a paper to a scientific journal. The electronic submission of (about 600) papers to the Journal of the Serbian Chemical Society has been recorded for every day from Jan. 01, 2013 till Dec. 31, 2014, together with the acceptance or rejection paper fate. Seasonal effects and editor roles (through desk rejection and subfield editors) are examined. An ARCH-like econometric model is derived stressing the main determinants of the favorite day-of-week process.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Review times in peer review: quantitative analysis of editorial workflows
Authors:
Maciej J. Mrowinski,
Agata Fronczak,
Piotr Fronczak,
Olgica Nedic,
Marcel Ausloos
Abstract:
We examine selected aspects of peer review and suggest possible improvements. To this end, we analyse a dataset containing information about 300 papers submitted to the Biochemistry and Biotechnology section of the Journal of the Serbian Chemical Society. After separating the peer review process into stages that each review has to go through, we use a weighted directed graph to describe it in a pr…
▽ More
We examine selected aspects of peer review and suggest possible improvements. To this end, we analyse a dataset containing information about 300 papers submitted to the Biochemistry and Biotechnology section of the Journal of the Serbian Chemical Society. After separating the peer review process into stages that each review has to go through, we use a weighted directed graph to describe it in a probabilistic manner and test the impact of some modifications of the editorial policy on the efficiency of the whole process.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
