"A cold, technical decision-maker": Can AI provide explainability, negotiability, and humanity?
Authors:
Allison Woodruff,
Yasmin Asare Anderson,
Katherine Jameson Armstrong,
Marina Gkiza,
Jay Jennings,
Christopher Moessner,
Fernanda Viegas,
Martin Wattenberg,
and Lynette Webb,
Fabian Wrede,
Patrick Gage Kelley
Abstract:
Algorithmic systems are increasingly deployed to make decisions in many areas of people's lives. The shift from human to algorithmic decision-making has been accompanied by concern about potentially opaque decisions that are not aligned with social values, as well as proposed remedies such as explainability. We present results of a qualitative study of algorithmic decision-making, comprised of fiv…
▽ More
Algorithmic systems are increasingly deployed to make decisions in many areas of people's lives. The shift from human to algorithmic decision-making has been accompanied by concern about potentially opaque decisions that are not aligned with social values, as well as proposed remedies such as explainability. We present results of a qualitative study of algorithmic decision-making, comprised of five workshops conducted with a total of 60 participants in Finland, Germany, the United Kingdom, and the United States. We invited participants to reason about decision-making qualities such as explainability and accuracy in a variety of domains. Participants viewed AI as a decision-maker that follows rigid criteria and performs mechanical tasks well, but is largely incapable of subjective or morally complex judgments. We discuss participants' consideration of humanity in decision-making, and introduce the concept of 'negotiability,' the ability to go beyond formal criteria and work flexibly around the system.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
Exciting, Useful, Worrying, Futuristic: Public Perception of Artificial Intelligence in 8 Countries
Authors:
Patrick Gage Kelley,
Yongwei Yang,
Courtney Heldreth,
Christopher Moessner,
Aaron Sedley,
Andreas Kramm,
David T. Newman,
Allison Woodruff
Abstract:
As the influence and use of artificial intelligence (AI) have grown and its transformative potential has become more apparent, many questions have been raised regarding the economic, political, social, and ethical implications of its use. Public opinion plays an important role in these discussions, influencing product adoption, commercial development, research funding, and regulation. In this pape…
▽ More
As the influence and use of artificial intelligence (AI) have grown and its transformative potential has become more apparent, many questions have been raised regarding the economic, political, social, and ethical implications of its use. Public opinion plays an important role in these discussions, influencing product adoption, commercial development, research funding, and regulation. In this paper we present results of an in-depth survey of public opinion of artificial intelligence conducted with 10,005 respondents spanning eight countries and six continents. We report widespread perception that AI will have significant impact on society, accompanied by strong support for the responsible development and use of AI, and also characterize the public's sentiment towards AI with four key themes (exciting, useful, worrying, and futuristic) whose prevalence distinguishes response to AI in different countries.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2021; v1 submitted 27 December, 2019;
originally announced January 2020.
