-
The Decision Problem for Regular First-Order Theories
Authors:
Umang Mathur,
David Mestel,
Mahesh Viswanathan
Abstract:
The \emph{Entscheidungsproblem}, or the classical decision problem, asks whether a given formula of first-order logic is satisfiable. In this work, we consider an extension of this problem to regular first-order \emph{theories}, i.e., (infinite) regular sets of formulae. Building on the elegant classification of syntactic classes as decidable or undecidable for the classical decision problem, we s…
▽ More
The \emph{Entscheidungsproblem}, or the classical decision problem, asks whether a given formula of first-order logic is satisfiable. In this work, we consider an extension of this problem to regular first-order \emph{theories}, i.e., (infinite) regular sets of formulae. Building on the elegant classification of syntactic classes as decidable or undecidable for the classical decision problem, we show that some classes (specifically, the EPR and Gurevich classes), which are decidable in the classical setting, become undecidable for regular theories. On the other hand, for each of these classes, we identify a subclass that remains decidable in our setting, leaving a complete classification as a challenge for future work. Finally, we observe that our problem generalises prior work on automata-theoretic verification of uninterpreted programs and propose a semantic class of existential formulae for which the problem is decidable.
△ Less
Submitted 28 December, 2024; v1 submitted 22 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Split-or-decompose: Improved FPT branching algorithms for maximum agreement forests
Authors:
David Mestel,
Steven Chaplick,
Steven Kelk,
Ruben Meuwese
Abstract:
Phylogenetic trees are leaf-labelled trees used to model the evolution of species. In practice it is not uncommon to obtain two topologically distinct trees for the same set of species, and this motivates the use of distance measures to quantify dissimilarity. A well-known measure is the maximum agreement forest (MAF): a minimum-size partition of the leaf labels which splits both trees into the sa…
▽ More
Phylogenetic trees are leaf-labelled trees used to model the evolution of species. In practice it is not uncommon to obtain two topologically distinct trees for the same set of species, and this motivates the use of distance measures to quantify dissimilarity. A well-known measure is the maximum agreement forest (MAF): a minimum-size partition of the leaf labels which splits both trees into the same set of disjoint, leaf-labelled subtrees (up to isomorphism after suppressing degree-2 vertices). Computing such a MAF is NP-hard and so considerable effort has been invested in finding FPT algorithms, parameterised by $k$, the number of components of a MAF. The state of the art has been unchanged since 2015, with running times of $O^*(3^k)$ for unrooted trees and $O^*(2.3431^k)$ for rooted trees. In this work we present improved algorithms for both the unrooted and rooted cases, with runtimes $O^*(2.846^k)$ and $O^*(2.3391^k)$ respectively. The key to our improvement is a novel branching strategy in which we show that any overlapping components obtained on the way to a MAF can be `split' by a branching rule with favourable branching factor, and then the problem can be decomposed into disjoint subproblems to be solved separately. We expect that this technique may be more widely applicable to other problems in algorithmic phylogenetics.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Beware of Greeks bearing entanglement? Quantum covert channels, information flow and non-local games
Authors:
David Mestel
Abstract:
Can quantum entanglement increase the capacity of (classical) covert channels? To one familiar with Holevo's Theorem it is tempting to think that the answer is obviously no. However, in this work we show: quantum entanglement can in fact increase the capacity of a classical covert channel, in the presence of an active adversary; on the other hand, a zero-capacity channel is not improved by entangl…
▽ More
Can quantum entanglement increase the capacity of (classical) covert channels? To one familiar with Holevo's Theorem it is tempting to think that the answer is obviously no. However, in this work we show: quantum entanglement can in fact increase the capacity of a classical covert channel, in the presence of an active adversary; on the other hand, a zero-capacity channel is not improved by entanglement, so entanglement cannot create `purely quantum' covert channels; the problem of determining the capacity of a given channel in the presence of entanglement is undecidable; but there is an algorithm to bound the entangled capacity of a channel from above, adapted from the semi-definite hierarchy from the theory of non-local games, whose close connection to channel capacity is at the core of all of our results.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
A Survey of Requirements for COVID-19 Mitigation Strategies. Part I: Newspaper Clips
Authors:
Wojciech Jamroga,
David Mestel,
Peter B. Roenne,
Peter Y. A. Ryan,
Marjan Skrobot
Abstract:
The COVID-19 pandemic has influenced virtually all aspects of our lives. Across the world, countries have applied various mitigation strategies for the epidemic, based on social, political, and technological instruments. We postulate that one should {identify the relevant requirements} before committing to a particular mitigation strategy. One way to achieve it is through an overview of what is co…
▽ More
The COVID-19 pandemic has influenced virtually all aspects of our lives. Across the world, countries have applied various mitigation strategies for the epidemic, based on social, political, and technological instruments. We postulate that one should {identify the relevant requirements} before committing to a particular mitigation strategy. One way to achieve it is through an overview of what is considered relevant by the general public, and referred to in the media. To this end, we have collected a number of news clips that mention the possible goals and requirements for a mitigation strategy. The snippets are sorted thematically into several categories, such as health-related goals, social and political impact, civil rights, ethical requirements, and so on.
In a forthcoming companion paper, we will present a digest of the requirements, derived from the news clips, and a preliminary take on their formal specification.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2023; v1 submitted 16 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Robust ambiguity for contact tracing
Authors:
David Mestel
Abstract:
A known drawback of `decentralised' contact tracing architectures is that users who have been in contact with an infected person are able to precisely identify the relevant contact, and thereby perhaps identify the infected person. In their proposal, the PACT team discuss a simple DH-based protocol to mitigate this problem, but dismiss it because it is vulnerable to a malicious user who may deviat…
▽ More
A known drawback of `decentralised' contact tracing architectures is that users who have been in contact with an infected person are able to precisely identify the relevant contact, and thereby perhaps identify the infected person. In their proposal, the PACT team discuss a simple DH-based protocol to mitigate this problem, but dismiss it because it is vulnerable to a malicious user who may deviate from the specified behaviour. This note presents a modified protocol which achieves robustness against a fully malicious user, and establishes some simple security properties.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Quantifying information flow in interactive systems
Authors:
David Mestel
Abstract:
We consider the problem of quantifying information flow in interactive systems, modelled as finite-state transducers in the style of Goguen and Meseguer. Our main result is that if the system is deterministic then the information flow is either logarithmic or linear, and there is a polynomial-time algorithm to distinguish the two cases and compute the rate of logarithmic flow. To achieve this we f…
▽ More
We consider the problem of quantifying information flow in interactive systems, modelled as finite-state transducers in the style of Goguen and Meseguer. Our main result is that if the system is deterministic then the information flow is either logarithmic or linear, and there is a polynomial-time algorithm to distinguish the two cases and compute the rate of logarithmic flow. To achieve this we first extend the theory of information leakage through channels to the case of interactive systems, and establish a number of results which greatly simplify computation. We then show that for deterministic systems the information flow corresponds to the growth rate of antichains inside a certain regular language, a property called the width of the language. In a companion work we have shown that there is a dichotomy between polynomial and exponential antichain growth, and a polynomial time algorithm to distinguish the two cases and to compute the order of polynomial growth. We observe that these two cases correspond to logarithmic and linear information flow respectively. Finally, we formulate several attractive open problems, covering the cases of probabilistic systems, systems with more than two users and nondeterministic systems where the nondeterminism is assumed to be innocent rather than demonic.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Translating between models of concurrency
Authors:
David Mestel,
A. W. Roscoe
Abstract:
Hoare's Communicating Sequential Processes (CSP) admits a rich universe of semantic models closely related to the van Glabbeek spectrum. In this paper we study finite observational models, of which at least six have been identified for CSP, namely traces, stable failures, revivals, acceptances, refusal testing and finite linear observations. We show how to use the recently-introduced \emph{priorit…
▽ More
Hoare's Communicating Sequential Processes (CSP) admits a rich universe of semantic models closely related to the van Glabbeek spectrum. In this paper we study finite observational models, of which at least six have been identified for CSP, namely traces, stable failures, revivals, acceptances, refusal testing and finite linear observations. We show how to use the recently-introduced \emph{priority} operator to transform refinement questions in these models into trace refinement (language inclusion) tests. Furthermore, we are able to generalise this to any (rational) finite observational model. As well as being of theoretical interest, this is of practical significance since the state-of-the-art refinement checking tool FDR4 currently only supports two such models. In particular we study how it is possible to check refinement in a discrete version of the Timed Failures model that supports Timed CSP.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
A Proof of Entropy Minimization for Outputs in Deletion Channels via Hidden Word Statistics
Authors:
Arash Atashpendar,
David Mestel,
A. W. Roscoe,
Peter Y. A. Ryan
Abstract:
From the output produced by a memoryless deletion channel from a uniformly random input of known length $n$, one obtains a posterior distribution on the channel input. The difference between the Shannon entropy of this distribution and that of the uniform prior measures the amount of information about the channel input which is conveyed by the output of length $m$, and it is natural to ask for whi…
▽ More
From the output produced by a memoryless deletion channel from a uniformly random input of known length $n$, one obtains a posterior distribution on the channel input. The difference between the Shannon entropy of this distribution and that of the uniform prior measures the amount of information about the channel input which is conveyed by the output of length $m$, and it is natural to ask for which outputs this is extremized. This question was posed in a previous work, where it was conjectured on the basis of experimental data that the entropy of the posterior is minimized and maximized by the constant strings $\texttt{000}\ldots$ and $\texttt{111}\ldots$ and the alternating strings $\texttt{0101}\ldots$ and $\texttt{1010}\ldots$ respectively. In the present work we confirm the minimization conjecture in the asymptotic limit using results from hidden word statistics. We show how the analytic-combinatorial methods of Flajolet, Szpankowski and Vallée for dealing with the hidden pattern matching problem can be applied to resolve the case of fixed output length and $n\rightarrow\infty$, by obtaining estimates for the entropy in terms of the moments of the posterior distribution and establishing its minimization via a measure of autocorrelation.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
From Clustering Supersequences to Entropy Minimizing Subsequences for Single and Double Deletions
Authors:
Arash Atashpendar,
Marc Beunardeau,
Aisling Connolly,
Rémi Géraud,
David Mestel,
A. W. Roscoe,
Peter Y. A. Ryan
Abstract:
A binary string transmitted via a memoryless i.i.d. deletion channel is received as a subsequence of the original input. From this, one obtains a posterior distribution on the channel input, corresponding to a set of candidate supersequences weighted by the number of times the received subsequence can be embedded in them. In a previous work it is conjectured on the basis of experimental data that…
▽ More
A binary string transmitted via a memoryless i.i.d. deletion channel is received as a subsequence of the original input. From this, one obtains a posterior distribution on the channel input, corresponding to a set of candidate supersequences weighted by the number of times the received subsequence can be embedded in them. In a previous work it is conjectured on the basis of experimental data that the entropy of the posterior is minimized and maximized by the constant and the alternating strings, respectively. In this work, in addition to revisiting the entropy minimization conjecture, we also address several related combinatorial problems. We present an algorithm for counting the number of subsequence embeddings using a run-length encoding of strings. We then describe methods for clustering the space of supersequences such that the cardinality of the resulting sets depends only on the length of the received subsequence and its Hamming weight, but not its exact form. Then, we consider supersequences that contain a single embedding of a fixed subsequence, referred to as singletons, and provide a closed form expression for enumerating them using the same run-length encoding. We prove an analogous result for the minimization and maximization of the number of singletons, by the alternating and the uniform strings, respectively. Next, we prove the original minimal entropy conjecture for the special cases of single and double deletions using similar clustering techniques and the same run-length encoding, which allow us to characterize the distribution of the number of subsequence embeddings in the space of compatible supersequences to demonstrate the effect of an entropy decreasing operation.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2019; v1 submitted 2 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Widths of regular and context-free languages
Authors:
David Mestel
Abstract:
Given a partially-ordered finite alphabet $Σ$ and a language $L\subseteq Σ^*$, how large can an antichain in $L$ be (where $L$ is given the lexicographic ordering)? More precisely, since $L$ will in general be infinite, we should ask about the rate of growth of maximum antichains consisting of words of length $n$. This fundamental property of partial orders is known as the width, and in a companio…
▽ More
Given a partially-ordered finite alphabet $Σ$ and a language $L\subseteq Σ^*$, how large can an antichain in $L$ be (where $L$ is given the lexicographic ordering)? More precisely, since $L$ will in general be infinite, we should ask about the rate of growth of maximum antichains consisting of words of length $n$. This fundamental property of partial orders is known as the width, and in a companion work we show that the problem of computing the information leakage permitted by a deterministic interactive system modeled as a finite-state transducer can be reduced to the problem of computing the width of a certain regular language. In this paper, we show that if $L$ is regular then there is a dichotomy between polynomial and exponential antichain growth. We give a polynomial-time algorithm to distinguish the two cases, and to compute the order of polynomial growth, with the language specified as an NFA. For context-free languages we show that there is a similar dichotomy, but now the problem of distinguishing the two cases is undecidable. Finally, we generalise the lexicographic order to tree languages, and show that for regular tree languages there is a trichotomy between polynomial, exponential and doubly exponential antichain growth.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2019; v1 submitted 25 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
