-
A Nontrivial Interplay between Triadic Closure, Preferential, and Anti-Preferential Attachment: New Insights from Online Data
Authors:
Ivan V. Kozitsin,
Eduard R. Sayfulin,
Vyacheslav L. Goiko
Abstract:
This paper presents an analysis of a temporal network that describes the social connections of a large-scale (~ 30,000) sample of online social network users, inhabitants of a fixed city. We tested how the main network formation determinants - transitivity, preferential attachment, and social selection - contribute to network evolution. Among other things, we found that opinion social selection do…
▽ More
This paper presents an analysis of a temporal network that describes the social connections of a large-scale (~ 30,000) sample of online social network users, inhabitants of a fixed city. We tested how the main network formation determinants - transitivity, preferential attachment, and social selection - contribute to network evolution. Among other things, we found that opinion social selection does affect tie appearing whereas its impact on tie removing is rather unclear. We report that transitivity displayed the strongest effect on network dynamics. Surprisingly, a closer look revealed an intriguing and complex interplay between the transitivity, preferential attachment, and anti-preferential attachment mechanisms. For a given pair of unconnected nodes, if they have no mutual connections, then the probability of tie creation goes up with the sum of node degrees - that is exactly what the preferential attachment mechanism is assumed to do. Instead, if the nodes have at least one common friend, then the highest probability of tie appearing is achieved if both the nodes have only a few friends - a phenomenon that is called anti-preferential attachment. We attempted to explain this finding by appealing to the notions of social communities and leaders.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Modeling Opinion Dynamics: Ranking Algorithms on Heterogeneous Populations
Authors:
Ivan V. Kozitsin
Abstract:
The heterogeneity of the influence processes is an important feature of social systems: how we perceive social influence and how we influence other individuals is heavily influenced by our opinion and non-opinion attributes. The latter include demographic, cultural, and structural (how we are embedded in social networks) characteristics. Furthermore, the results of the influence processes may also…
▽ More
The heterogeneity of the influence processes is an important feature of social systems: how we perceive social influence and how we influence other individuals is heavily influenced by our opinion and non-opinion attributes. The latter include demographic, cultural, and structural (how we are embedded in social networks) characteristics. Furthermore, the results of the influence processes may also depend on how similar the interacting individuals are in terms of their features. This paper addresses this issue and elaborates on an agent-based model that is sensitive to the individual characteristics, both opinion and non-opinion ones. The model is fortified with a ranking algorithm that mimics the ranking algorithms widely adopted in real-world online social networks. For the resulting model, I elaborate a mean-field approximation that describes the behavior of the model at the macroscopic level via an autonomous system of ordinary differential equations. The properties of this system are thoroughly studied.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Aggression and "hate speech" in communication of media users: analysis of control capabilities
Authors:
Varvara Kazhberova,
Alexander Chkhartishvili,
Dmitry Gubanov,
Ivan Kozitsin,
Evgeny Belyavsky,
Denis Fedyanin,
Sergey Cherkasov,
Dmitry Meshkov
Abstract:
Analyzing the possibilities of mutual influence of users in new media, the researchers found a high level of aggression and hate speech when discussing an urgent social problem - measures for COVID-19 fighting. This fact determined the central aspect of the research at the next stage and the central topic of the proposed article. The first chapter of the article is devoted to the characteristics o…
▽ More
Analyzing the possibilities of mutual influence of users in new media, the researchers found a high level of aggression and hate speech when discussing an urgent social problem - measures for COVID-19 fighting. This fact determined the central aspect of the research at the next stage and the central topic of the proposed article. The first chapter of the article is devoted to the characteristics of the prerequisites of the undertaken research, its main features. The following chapters include methodological features of the study, theoretical substantiation of the concepts of aggression and hate speech, identification of systemic connections of these concepts with other characteristics of messages. The result was the creating of a mathematical aggression growth model and the analysis of its manageability using basic social media strategies. The results can be useful for developing media content in a modern digital environment.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Linking theory and empirics: a general framework to model opinion formation processes
Authors:
Ivan V. Kozitsin
Abstract:
We introduce a minimal opinion formation model, which is quite flexible and can reproduce a broad variety of the existing micro-influence assumptions and models. At the same time, the model can be easily calibrated on real data, upon which it imposes only a few requirements. From this perspective, our model can be considered as a bridge, connecting theoretical studies on opinion formation models a…
▽ More
We introduce a minimal opinion formation model, which is quite flexible and can reproduce a broad variety of the existing micro-influence assumptions and models. At the same time, the model can be easily calibrated on real data, upon which it imposes only a few requirements. From this perspective, our model can be considered as a bridge, connecting theoretical studies on opinion formation models and empirical research on social dynamics. We investigate the model analytically by using mean-field approximation and numerically. Our analysis is exemplified by recently reported empirical data drawn from an online social network. Employing these data for the model calibration, we demonstrate that the model may reproduce fragmented and polarizing social systems. Furthermore, we manage to generate an artificial society that features properties quantitatively and qualitatively similar to those observed empirically at the macro scale. This ability became possible after we had advanced the model with two important communication features: selectivity and personalization algorithms.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2022; v1 submitted 1 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Mutual cooperation and tolerance to defection in the context of socialization: the theoretical model and experimental evidence
Authors:
Tatiana Kozitsina,
Ivan Kozitsin,
Ivan Menshikov
Abstract:
The study of the nature of human cooperation still contains gaps needing investigation. Previous findings reveal that socialization effectively promotes cooperation in the well-known Prisoner's dilemma (PD) game. However, theoretical concepts fail to describe high levels of cooperation (probability higher than 50%) that were observed empirically. In this paper, we derive a symmetrical quantal resp…
▽ More
The study of the nature of human cooperation still contains gaps needing investigation. Previous findings reveal that socialization effectively promotes cooperation in the well-known Prisoner's dilemma (PD) game. However, theoretical concepts fail to describe high levels of cooperation (probability higher than 50%) that were observed empirically. In this paper, we derive a symmetrical quantal response equilibrium (QRE) in PD in Markov strategies and test it against experimental data. Our results indicate that for low levels of rationality, QRE manages to describe high cooperation. In contrast, for high rationality QRE converges to the Nash equilibrium and describes low-cooperation behavior of participants. In the area of middle rationality, QRE matches the curve that represents the set of Nash equilibrium in Markov strategies. Further, we find that QRE serves as a dividing line between behavior before and after socialization, according to the experimental data. Finally, we successfully highlight the theoretically-predicted intersection of the set of Nash equilibrium in Markov strategies and the QRE curve.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2022; v1 submitted 11 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Face mask perception during the COVID-19 pandemic: an observational study of Russian online social network VKontakte
Authors:
Alexander G. Chkhartishvili,
Dmitry A. Gubanov,
Ivan V. Kozitsin
Abstract:
This cross-sectional study characterizes users' attitudes towards the face mask requirements introduced by the Russian government as a response to the COVID-19 pandemic. We study how they relate to other users' characteristics such as age, gender, and political attitudes. Our results indicate that men and elder individuals - demographic groups that are most vulnerable to COVID-19 -- underestimate…
▽ More
This cross-sectional study characterizes users' attitudes towards the face mask requirements introduced by the Russian government as a response to the COVID-19 pandemic. We study how they relate to other users' characteristics such as age, gender, and political attitudes. Our results indicate that men and elder individuals - demographic groups that are most vulnerable to COVID-19 -- underestimate the benefits of wearing face masks. We also discovered that users in opposition to the Russian government highly approve of this anti-COVID-19 measure -- an oppositionist will approve of the face mask requirements with the probability of 0.95. For those who support the Russian government, the odds of approval are merely 0.45.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2022; v1 submitted 16 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Opinion Dynamics of Online Social Network Users: A Micro-Level Analysis
Authors:
Ivan V. Kozitsin
Abstract:
In this paper, we present an empirical study of the opinion dynamics of a large-scale sample of online social network users. We estimate opinions of users as continuous scalars based on their subscriptions to information sources and analyze how friendship connections affect the dynamics of these estimations. Distinguishing between positive (toward opinions of friends) and negative (away from opini…
▽ More
In this paper, we present an empirical study of the opinion dynamics of a large-scale sample of online social network users. We estimate opinions of users as continuous scalars based on their subscriptions to information sources and analyze how friendship connections affect the dynamics of these estimations. Distinguishing between positive (toward opinions of friends) and negative (away from opinions of friends) opinion shifts, we find that the existence and magnitude of opinion shifts are positively related (largely through a linear form or an inverted U-shaped form) to the degree of divergence in opinions between user and their friends. Additionally, we moderate the balance between positive and negative shifts using opinion divergence: if the opinions of the focal user and their friends are too similar or dissimilar, there is a relatively low chance of a positive shift.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2022; v1 submitted 2 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
