-
On the Performance Analysis of Underlay Cognitive Radio Systems: A Deployment Perspective
Authors:
Ankit Kaushik,
Shree Krishna Sharma,
Symeon Chatzinotas,
Björn Ottersten,
Friedrich K. Jondral
Abstract:
We study the performance of cognitive Underlay System (US) that employ power control mechanism at the Secondary Transmitter (ST) from a deployment perspective. Existing baseline models considered for performance analysis either assume the knowledge of involved channels at the ST or retrieve this information by means of a band manager or a feedback channel, however, such situations rarely exist in…
▽ More
We study the performance of cognitive Underlay System (US) that employ power control mechanism at the Secondary Transmitter (ST) from a deployment perspective. Existing baseline models considered for performance analysis either assume the knowledge of involved channels at the ST or retrieve this information by means of a band manager or a feedback channel, however, such situations rarely exist in practice. Motivated by this fact, we propose a novel approach that incorporates estimation of the involved channels at the ST, in order to characterize the performance of the US in terms of interference power received at the primary receiver and throughput at the secondary receiver (or \textit{secondary throughput}). Moreover, we apply an outage constraint that captures the impact of imperfect channel knowledge, particularly on the uncertain interference. Besides this, we employ a transmit power constraint at the ST to classify the operation of the US in terms of an interference-limited regime and a power-limited regime. In addition, we characterize the expressions of the uncertain interference and the secondary throughput for the case where the involved channels encounter Nakagami-$m$ fading. Finally, we investigate a fundamental tradeoff between the estimation time and the secondary throughput depicting an optimized performance of the US.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Performance Analysis of Underlay Cognitive Radio Systems: Estimation-Throughput Tradeoff
Authors:
Ankit Kaushik,
Shree Krishna Sharma,
Symeon Chatzinotas,
Björn Ottersten,
Friedrich K. Jondral
Abstract:
In this letter, we study the performance of cognitive Underlay Systems (USs) that employ power control mechanism at the Secondary Transmitter (ST). Existing baseline models considered for the performance analysis either assume the knowledge of involved channels at the ST or retrieve this information by means of a feedback channel, however, such situations hardly exist in practice. Motivated by thi…
▽ More
In this letter, we study the performance of cognitive Underlay Systems (USs) that employ power control mechanism at the Secondary Transmitter (ST). Existing baseline models considered for the performance analysis either assume the knowledge of involved channels at the ST or retrieve this information by means of a feedback channel, however, such situations hardly exist in practice. Motivated by this fact, we propose a novel approach that incorporates the estimation of the involved channels at the ST, in order to characterize the performance of USs under realistic scenarios. Moreover, we apply an outage constraint that captures the impact of imperfect channel knowledge, particularly on the interference power received at the primary receiver. Besides this, we employ a transmit power constraint at the ST to determine an operating regime for the US. Finally, we analyze an interesting tradeoff between the estimation time and the secondary throughput allowing an optimized performance of the US.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Sensing-Throughput Tradeoff for Interweave Cognitive Radio System: A Deployment-Centric Viewpoint
Authors:
Ankit Kaushik,
Shree Krishna Sharma,
Symeon Chatzinotas,
Björn Ottersten,
Friedrich K. Jondral
Abstract:
Secondary access to the licensed spectrum is viable only if interference is avoided at the primary system. In this regard, different paradigms have been conceptualized in the existing literature. Of these, Interweave Systems (ISs) that employ spectrum sensing have been widely investigated. Baseline models investigated in the literature characterize the performance of IS in terms of a sensing-throu…
▽ More
Secondary access to the licensed spectrum is viable only if interference is avoided at the primary system. In this regard, different paradigms have been conceptualized in the existing literature. Of these, Interweave Systems (ISs) that employ spectrum sensing have been widely investigated. Baseline models investigated in the literature characterize the performance of IS in terms of a sensing-throughput tradeoff, however, this characterization assumes the knowledge of the involved channels at the secondary transmitter, which is unavailable in practice. Motivated by this fact, we establish a novel approach that incorporates channel estimation in the system model, and consequently investigate the impact of imperfect channel estimation on the performance of the IS. More particularly, the variation induced in the detection probability affects the detector's performance at the secondary transmitter, which may result in severe interference at the primary users. In this view, we propose to employ average and outage constraints on the detection probability, in order to capture the performance of the IS. Our analysis reveals that with an appropriate choice of the estimation time determined by the proposed model, the degradation in performance of the IS can be effectively controlled, and subsequently the achievable secondary throughput can be significantly enhanced.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2016; v1 submitted 6 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Analysis of Joint Transmit-Receive Diversity in Downlink MIMO Heterogeneous Cellular Networks
Authors:
Ralph Tanbourgi,
Harpreet S. Dhillon,
Friedrich K. Jondral
Abstract:
We study multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) based downlink heterogeneous cellular network (HetNets) with joint transmit-receive diversity using orthogonal space-time block codes at the base stations (BSs) and maximal-ratio combining (MRC) at the users. MIMO diversity with MRC is especially appealing in cellular networks due to the relatively low hardware complexity at both the BS and user devic…
▽ More
We study multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) based downlink heterogeneous cellular network (HetNets) with joint transmit-receive diversity using orthogonal space-time block codes at the base stations (BSs) and maximal-ratio combining (MRC) at the users. MIMO diversity with MRC is especially appealing in cellular networks due to the relatively low hardware complexity at both the BS and user device. Using stochastic geometry, we develop a tractable stochastic model for analyzing such HetNets taking into account the irregular and multi-tier BS deployment. We derive the coverage probability for both interference-blind (IB) and interference-aware (IA) MRC as a function of the relevant tier-specific system parameters such as BS density and power, path loss law, and number of transmit (Tx) antennas. Important insights arising from our analysis for typical HetNets are for instance: (i) IA-MRC becomes less favorable than IB-MRC with Tx diversity due to the smaller interference variance and increased interference correlation across Rx antennas; (ii) ignoring spatial interference correlation significantly overestimates the performance of IA-MRC; (iii) for small number of Rx antennas, selection combining may offer a better complexity-performance trade-off than MRC.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2015; v1 submitted 23 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Analysis of Heterogeneous Cellular Networks under Frequency Diversity and Interference Correlation
Authors:
Ralph Tanbourgi,
Friedrich K. Jondral
Abstract:
Analyzing heterogeneous cellular networks (HCNs) has become increasingly complex, particularly due to irregular base station locations, massive deployment of small cells, and flexible resource allocation. The latter is usually not captured by existing stochastic models for analytical tractability. In this work, we develop a more realistic stochastic model for a generic $K$-tier HCN, where users ar…
▽ More
Analyzing heterogeneous cellular networks (HCNs) has become increasingly complex, particularly due to irregular base station locations, massive deployment of small cells, and flexible resource allocation. The latter is usually not captured by existing stochastic models for analytical tractability. In this work, we develop a more realistic stochastic model for a generic $K$-tier HCN, where users are served in the downlink under frequency diversity. We derive the rate coverage probability for this case, taking into account the interference correlation across different parts of the allocated spectrum. Our results indicate that ignoring this type of correlation may considerably overestimate the offered date rate. Furthermore, the gain of spectrum diversification is significant, particularly at low to moderate target data rates.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2014; v1 submitted 13 August, 2014;
originally announced August 2014.
-
On the Deployment of Cognitive Relay as Underlay Systems
Authors:
Ankit Kaushik,
M. Rehan Raza,
Friedrich K. Jondral
Abstract:
The objective of this paper is to extend the idea of Cognitive Relay (CR). CR, as a secondary user, follows an underlay paradigm to endorse secondary usage of the spectrum to the indoor devices. To seek a spatial opportunity, i.e., deciding its transmission over the primary user channels, CR models its deployment scenario and the movements of the primary receivers and indoor devices. Modeling is b…
▽ More
The objective of this paper is to extend the idea of Cognitive Relay (CR). CR, as a secondary user, follows an underlay paradigm to endorse secondary usage of the spectrum to the indoor devices. To seek a spatial opportunity, i.e., deciding its transmission over the primary user channels, CR models its deployment scenario and the movements of the primary receivers and indoor devices. Modeling is beneficial for theoretical analysis, however it is also important to ensure the performance of CR in a real scenario. We consider briefly, the challenges involved while deploying a hardware prototype of such a system.
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
On the Estimation of Channel State Transitions for Cognitive Radio Systems
Authors:
Ankit Kaushik,
Friedrich K. Jondral
Abstract:
Coexistence by means of shared access is a cognitive radio application. The secondary user models the slotted primary users channel access as a Markov process. The model parameters, i.e, the state transition probabilities (alpha,beta) help secondary user to determine the channel occupancy, thereby enables secondary user to rank the primary user channels. These parameters are unknown and need to be…
▽ More
Coexistence by means of shared access is a cognitive radio application. The secondary user models the slotted primary users channel access as a Markov process. The model parameters, i.e, the state transition probabilities (alpha,beta) help secondary user to determine the channel occupancy, thereby enables secondary user to rank the primary user channels. These parameters are unknown and need to be estimated by secondary users for each channel. To do so, the secondary users have to sense all the primary user channels in every time slot, which is unrealistic for a large and sparsely allocated primary user spectrum. With no other choice left, the secondary user has to sense a channel at random time intervals and estimate the parametric information for all the channels using the observed slots.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
Analysis of Non-Coherent Joint-Transmission Cooperation in Heterogeneous Cellular Networks
Authors:
Ralph Tanbourgi,
Sarabjot Singh,
Jeffrey G. Andrews,
Friedrich K. Jondral
Abstract:
Base station (BS) cooperation is set to play a key role in managing interference in dense heterogeneous cellular networks (HCNs). Non-coherent joint transmission (JT) is particularly appealing due to its low complexity, smaller overhead, and ability for load balancing. However, a general analysis of this technique is difficult mostly due to the lack of tractable models. This paper addresses this g…
▽ More
Base station (BS) cooperation is set to play a key role in managing interference in dense heterogeneous cellular networks (HCNs). Non-coherent joint transmission (JT) is particularly appealing due to its low complexity, smaller overhead, and ability for load balancing. However, a general analysis of this technique is difficult mostly due to the lack of tractable models. This paper addresses this gap and presents a tractable model for analyzing non-coherent JT in HCNs, while incorporating key system parameters such as user-centric BS clustering and channel-dependent cooperation activation. Assuming all BSs of each tier follow a stationary Poisson point process, the coverage probability for non-coherent JT is derived. Using the developed model, it is shown that for small cooperative clusters of small-cell BSs, non-coherent JT by small cells provides spectral efficiency gains without significantly increasing cell load. Further, when cooperation is aggressively triggered intra-cluster frequency reuse within small cells is favorable over intra-cluster coordinated scheduling.
△ Less
Submitted 17 February, 2014; v1 submitted 11 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
Dual-Branch MRC Receivers under Spatial Interference Correlation and Nakagami Fading
Authors:
Ralph Tanbourgi,
Harpreet S. Dhillon,
Jeffrey G. Andrews,
Friedrich K. Jondral
Abstract:
Despite being ubiquitous in practice, the performance of maximal-ratio combining (MRC) in the presence of interference is not well understood. Because the interference received at each antenna originates from the same set of interferers, but partially de-correlates over the fading channel, it possesses a complex correlation structure. This work develops a realistic analytic model that accurately a…
▽ More
Despite being ubiquitous in practice, the performance of maximal-ratio combining (MRC) in the presence of interference is not well understood. Because the interference received at each antenna originates from the same set of interferers, but partially de-correlates over the fading channel, it possesses a complex correlation structure. This work develops a realistic analytic model that accurately accounts for the interference correlation using stochastic geometry. Modeling interference by a Poisson shot noise process with independent Nakagami fading, we derive the link success probability for dual-branch interference-aware MRC. Using this result, we show that the common assumption that all receive antennas experience equal interference power underestimates the true performance, although this gap rapidly decays with increasing the Nakagami parameter $m_{\text{I}}$ of the interfering links. In contrast, ignoring interference correlation leads to a highly optimistic performance estimate for MRC, especially for large $m_{\text{I}}$. In the low outage probability regime, our success probability expression can be considerably simplified. Observations following from the analysis include: (i) for small path loss exponents, MRC and minimum mean square error combining exhibit similar performance, and (ii) the gains of MRC over selection combining are smaller in the interference-limited case than in the well-studied noise-limited case.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2014; v1 submitted 20 December, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
-
A Tractable Model for Non-Coherent Joint-Transmission Base Station Cooperation
Authors:
Ralph Tanbourgi,
Sarabjot Singh,
Jeffrey G. Andrews,
Friedrich K. Jondral
Abstract:
This paper presents a tractable model for analyzing non-coherent joint transmission base station (BS) cooperation, taking into account the irregular BS deployment typically encountered in practice. Besides cellular-network specific aspects such as BS density, channel fading, average path loss and interference, the model also captures relevant cooperation mechanisms including user-centric BS cluste…
▽ More
This paper presents a tractable model for analyzing non-coherent joint transmission base station (BS) cooperation, taking into account the irregular BS deployment typically encountered in practice. Besides cellular-network specific aspects such as BS density, channel fading, average path loss and interference, the model also captures relevant cooperation mechanisms including user-centric BS clustering and channel-dependent cooperation activation. The locations of all BSs are modeled by a Poisson point process. Using tools from stochastic geometry, the signal-to-interference-plus-noise ratio ($\mathtt{SINR}$) distribution with cooperation is precisely characterized in a generality-preserving form. The result is then applied to practical design problems of recent interest. We find that increasing the network-wide BS density improves the $\mathtt{SINR}$, while the gains increase with the path loss exponent. For pilot-based channel estimation, the average spectral efficiency saturates at cluster sizes of around $7$ BSs for typical values, irrespective of backhaul quality. Finally, it is shown that intra-cluster frequency reuse is favorable in moderately loaded cells with generous cooperation activation, while intra-cluster coordinated scheduling may be better in lightly loaded cells with conservative cooperation activation.
△ Less
Submitted 16 July, 2014; v1 submitted 31 July, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
Effect of Spatial Interference Correlation on the Performance of Maximum Ratio Combining
Authors:
Ralph Tanbourgi,
Harpreet S. Dhillon,
Jeffrey G. Andrews,
Friedrich K. Jondral
Abstract:
While the performance of maximum ratio combining (MRC) is well understood for a single isolated link, the same is not true in the presence of interference, which is typically correlated across antennas due to the common locations of interferers. For tractability, prior work focuses on the two extreme cases where the interference power across antennas is either assumed to be fully correlated or ful…
▽ More
While the performance of maximum ratio combining (MRC) is well understood for a single isolated link, the same is not true in the presence of interference, which is typically correlated across antennas due to the common locations of interferers. For tractability, prior work focuses on the two extreme cases where the interference power across antennas is either assumed to be fully correlated or fully uncorrelated. In this paper, we address this shortcoming and characterize the performance of MRC in the presence of spatially-correlated interference across antennas. Modeling the interference field as a Poisson point process, we derive the exact distribution of the signal-to-interference ratio (SIR) for the case of two receive antennas, and upper and lower bounds for the general case. Using these results, we study the diversity behavior of MRC and characterize the critical density of simultaneous transmissions for a given outage constraint. The exact SIR distribution is also useful in benchmarking simpler correlation models. We show that the full-correlation assumption is considerably pessimistic (up to 30% higher outage probability for typical values) and the no-correlation assumption is significantly optimistic compared to the true performance.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2014; v1 submitted 24 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Cooperative Relaying in a Poisson Field of Interferers: A Diversity Order Analysis
Authors:
Ralph Tanbourgi,
Holger Jäkel,
Friedrich K. Jondral
Abstract:
This work analyzes the gains of cooperative relaying in interference-limited networks, in which outages can be due to interference and fading. A stochastic model based on point process theory is used to capture the spatial randomness present in contemporary wireless networks. Using a modification of the diversity order metric, the reliability gain of selection decode-and-forward is studied for sev…
▽ More
This work analyzes the gains of cooperative relaying in interference-limited networks, in which outages can be due to interference and fading. A stochastic model based on point process theory is used to capture the spatial randomness present in contemporary wireless networks. Using a modification of the diversity order metric, the reliability gain of selection decode-and-forward is studied for several cases. The main results are as follows: the achievable \emph{spatial-contention} diversity order (SC-DO) is equal to one irrespective of the type of channel which is due to the ineffectiveness of the relay in the MAC-phase (transmit diversity). In the BC-phase (receive diversity), the SC-DO depends on the amount of fading and spatial interference correlation. In the absence of fading, there is a hard transition between SC-DO of either one or two, depending on the system parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Interference in Poisson Networks with Isotropically Distributed Nodes
Authors:
Ralph Tanbourgi,
Holger Jäkel,
Friedrich K. Jondral
Abstract:
Practical wireless networks are finite, and hence non-stationary with nodes typically non-homo-geneously deployed over the area. This leads to a location-dependent performance and to boundary effects which are both often neglected in network modeling. In this work, interference in networks with nodes distributed according to an isotropic but not necessarily stationary Poisson point process (PPP) a…
▽ More
Practical wireless networks are finite, and hence non-stationary with nodes typically non-homo-geneously deployed over the area. This leads to a location-dependent performance and to boundary effects which are both often neglected in network modeling. In this work, interference in networks with nodes distributed according to an isotropic but not necessarily stationary Poisson point process (PPP) are studied. The resulting link performance is precisely characterized as a function of (i) an arbitrary receiver location and of (ii) an arbitrary isotropic shape of the spatial distribution. Closed-form expressions for the first moment and the Laplace transform of the interference are derived for the path loss exponents $α=2$ and $α=4$, and simple bounds are derived for other cases. The developed model is applied to practical problems in network analysis: for instance, the accuracy loss due to neglecting border effects is shown to be undesirably high within transition regions of certain deployment scenarios. Using a throughput metric not relying on the stationarity of the spatial node distribution, the spatial throughput locally around a given node is characterized.
△ Less
Submitted 2 January, 2014; v1 submitted 20 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Interference and Throughput in Aloha-based Ad Hoc Networks with Isotropic Node Distribution
Authors:
Ralph Tanbourgi,
Holger Jäkel,
Leonid Chaichenets,
Friedrich K. Jondral
Abstract:
We study the interference and outage statistics in a slotted Aloha ad hoc network, where the spatial distribution of nodes is non-stationary and isotropic. In such a network, outage probability and local throughput depend on both the particular location in the network and the shape of the spatial distribution. We derive in closed-form certain distributional properties of the interference that are…
▽ More
We study the interference and outage statistics in a slotted Aloha ad hoc network, where the spatial distribution of nodes is non-stationary and isotropic. In such a network, outage probability and local throughput depend on both the particular location in the network and the shape of the spatial distribution. We derive in closed-form certain distributional properties of the interference that are important for analyzing wireless networks as a function of the location and the spatial shape. Our results focus on path loss exponents 2 and 4, the former case not being analyzable before due to the stationarity assumption of the spatial node distribution. We propose two metrics for measuring local throughput in non-stationary networks and discuss how our findings can be applied to both analysis and optimization.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
-
Resolving the Connectivity-Throughput Trade-Off in Random Networks
Authors:
Ralph Tanbourgi,
Holger Jäkel,
Friedrich K. Jondral
Abstract:
The discrepancy between the upper bound on throughput in wireless networks and the throughput scaling in random networks which is also known as the connectivity-throughput trade-off is analyzed. In a random network with $λ$ nodes per unit area, throughput is found to scale by a factor of $\sqrt{\logλ}$ worse compared to the upper bound which is due to the uncertainty in the nodes' location. In the…
▽ More
The discrepancy between the upper bound on throughput in wireless networks and the throughput scaling in random networks which is also known as the connectivity-throughput trade-off is analyzed. In a random network with $λ$ nodes per unit area, throughput is found to scale by a factor of $\sqrt{\logλ}$ worse compared to the upper bound which is due to the uncertainty in the nodes' location. In the present model, nodes are assumed to know their geographical location and to employ power control, which we understand as an additional degree of freedom to improve network performance. The expected throughput-progress and the expected packet delay normalized to the one-hop progress are chosen as performance metrics. These metrics are investigated for a nearest neighbor forwarding strategy, which benefits from power control by reducing transmission power and, hence spatial contention. It is shown that the connectivity-throughput trade-off can be resolved if nodes employ a nearest neighbor forwarding strategy, achieving the upper bound on throughput on average also in a random network while ensuring asymptotic connectivity. In this case, the optimal throughput-delay scaling trade-off is also achieved.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2010; v1 submitted 19 July, 2010;
originally announced July 2010.
-
Outage Regions and Optimal Power Allocation for Wireless Relay Networks
Authors:
Tobias Renk,
Holger Jaekel,
Friedrich K. Jondral
Abstract:
We study outage regions for energy-constrained multi-hop and adaptive multi-route networks with an arbitrary number of relay nodes. Optimal power allocation strategies in the sense that outage probability is minimized are derived depending on the distances between the transmit nodes. We further investigate the rate gain of adaptive multi-route and multi-hop over direct transmission. It is shown…
▽ More
We study outage regions for energy-constrained multi-hop and adaptive multi-route networks with an arbitrary number of relay nodes. Optimal power allocation strategies in the sense that outage probability is minimized are derived depending on the distances between the transmit nodes. We further investigate the rate gain of adaptive multi-route and multi-hop over direct transmission. It is shown that a combined strategy of direct transmission and adaptive multi-route outperforms multi-hop for all values of rate R. It can be stated that cooperation strategies are beneficial for low-rate systems where the main goal is a very low outage probability of the network. As the rate is increased, direct transmission becomes more and more attractive.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2009;
originally announced August 2009.
-
Outage Capacity of Incremental Relaying at Low Signal-to-Noise Ratios
Authors:
Tobias Renk,
Holger Jaekel,
Friedrich K. Jondral,
Deniz Gunduz,
Andrea Goldsmith
Abstract:
We present the ε-outage capacity of incremental relaying at low signal-to-noise ratios (SNR) in a wireless cooperative network with slow Rayleigh fading channels. The relay performs decode-and-forward and repetition coding is employed in the network, which is optimal in the low SNR regime. We derive an expression on the optimal relay location that maximizes the ε-outage capacity. It is shown tha…
▽ More
We present the ε-outage capacity of incremental relaying at low signal-to-noise ratios (SNR) in a wireless cooperative network with slow Rayleigh fading channels. The relay performs decode-and-forward and repetition coding is employed in the network, which is optimal in the low SNR regime. We derive an expression on the optimal relay location that maximizes the ε-outage capacity. It is shown that this location is independent of the outage probability and SNR but only depends on the channel conditions represented by a path-loss factor. We compare our results to the ε-outage capacity of the cut-set bound and demonstrate that the ratio between the ε-outage capacity of incremental relaying and the cut-set bound lies within 1/\sqrt{2} and 1. Furthermore, we derive lower bounds on the ε-outage capacity for the case of K relays.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2009;
originally announced August 2009.
