-
GraphSAT -- a decision problem connecting satisfiability and graph theory
Authors:
Vaibhav Karve,
Anil N. Hirani
Abstract:
Satisfiability of boolean formulae (SAT) has been a topic of research in logic and computer science for a long time. In this paper we are interested in understanding the structure of satisfiable and unsatisfiable sentences. In previous work we initiated a new approach to SAT by formulating a mapping from propositional logic sentences to graphs, allowing us to find structural obstructions to 2SAT (…
▽ More
Satisfiability of boolean formulae (SAT) has been a topic of research in logic and computer science for a long time. In this paper we are interested in understanding the structure of satisfiable and unsatisfiable sentences. In previous work we initiated a new approach to SAT by formulating a mapping from propositional logic sentences to graphs, allowing us to find structural obstructions to 2SAT (clauses with exactly 2 literals) in terms of graphs. Here we generalize these ideas to multi-hypergraphs in which the edges can have more than 2 vertices and can have multiplicity. This is needed for understanding the structure of SAT for sentences made of clauses with 3 or more literals (3SAT), which is a building block of NP-completeness theory. We introduce a decision problem that we call GraphSAT, as a first step towards a structural view of SAT. Each propositional logic sentence can be mapped to a multi-hypergraph by associating each variable with a vertex (ignoring the negations) and each clause with a hyperedge. Such a graph then becomes a representative of a collection of possible sentences and we can then formulate the notion of satisfiability of such a graph. With this coarse representation of classes of sentences one can then investigate structural obstructions to SAT. To make the problem tractable, we prove a local graph rewriting theorem which allows us to simplify the neighborhood of a vertex without knowing the rest of the graph. We use this to deduce several reduction rules, allowing us to modify a graph without changing its satisfiability status which can then be used in a program to simplify graphs. We study a subclass of 3SAT by examining sentences living on triangulations of surfaces and show that for any compact surface there exists a triangulation that can support unsatisfiable sentences, giving specific examples of such triangulations for various surfaces.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
The complete set of minimal simple graphs that support unsatisfiable 2-CNFs
Authors:
Vaibhav Karve,
Anil N. Hirani
Abstract:
A propositional logic sentence in conjunctive normal form that has clauses of length two (a 2-CNF) can be associated with a multigraph in which the vertices correspond to the variables and edges to clauses. We first show that every such sentence that has been reduced, that is, which is unchanged under application of certain tautologies, is equisatisfiable to a 2-CNF whose associated multigraph is,…
▽ More
A propositional logic sentence in conjunctive normal form that has clauses of length two (a 2-CNF) can be associated with a multigraph in which the vertices correspond to the variables and edges to clauses. We first show that every such sentence that has been reduced, that is, which is unchanged under application of certain tautologies, is equisatisfiable to a 2-CNF whose associated multigraph is, in fact, a simple graph. Our main result is a complete characterization of graphs that can support unsatisfiable 2-CNF sentences. We show that a simple graph can support an unsatisfiable reduced 2-CNF sentence if and only if it contains any one of four specific small graphs as a topological minor. Equivalently, all reduced 2-CNF sentences supported on a given simple graph are satisfiable if and only if all subdivisions of those four graphs are forbidden as subgraphs of of the original graph. We conclude with a discussion of why the Robertson-Seymour graph minor theorem does not apply in our approach.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2019; v1 submitted 27 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Edge Contractions and Simplicial Homology
Authors:
Tamal K. Dey,
Anil N. Hirani,
Bala Krishnamoorthy,
Gavin Smith
Abstract:
We study the effect of edge contractions on simplicial homology because these contractions have turned to be useful in various applications involving topology. It was observed previously that contracting edges that satisfy the so called link condition preserves homeomorphism in low dimensional complexes, and homotopy in general. But, checking the link condition involves computation in all dimensio…
▽ More
We study the effect of edge contractions on simplicial homology because these contractions have turned to be useful in various applications involving topology. It was observed previously that contracting edges that satisfy the so called link condition preserves homeomorphism in low dimensional complexes, and homotopy in general. But, checking the link condition involves computation in all dimensions, and hence can be costly, especially in high dimensional complexes. We define a weaker and more local condition called the p-link condition for each dimension p, and study its effect on edge contractions. We prove the following: (i) For homology groups, edges satisfying the p- and (p-1)-link conditions can be contracted without disturbing the p-dimensional homology group. (ii) For relative homology groups, the (p-1)-, and the (p-2)-link conditions suffice to guarantee that the contraction does not introduce any new class in any of the resulting relative homology groups, though some of the existing classes can be destroyed. Unfortunately, the surjection in relative homolgy groups does not guarantee that no new relative torsion is created. (iii) For torsions, edges satisfying the p-link condition alone can be contracted without creating any new relative torsion and the p-link condition cannot be avoided. The results on relative homology and relative torsion are motivated by recent results on computing optimal homologous chains, which state that such problems can be solved by linear programming if the complex has no relative torsion. Edge contractions that do not introduce new relative torsions, can safely be availed in these contexts.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Delaunay Hodge Star
Authors:
Anil N. Hirani,
Kaushik Kalyanaraman,
Evan B. VanderZee
Abstract:
We define signed dual volumes at all dimensions for circumcentric dual meshes. We show that for pairwise Delaunay triangulations with mild boundary assumptions these signed dual volumes are positive. This allows the use of such Delaunay meshes for Discrete Exterior Calculus (DEC) because the discrete Hodge star operator can now be correctly defined for such meshes. This operator is crucial for DEC…
▽ More
We define signed dual volumes at all dimensions for circumcentric dual meshes. We show that for pairwise Delaunay triangulations with mild boundary assumptions these signed dual volumes are positive. This allows the use of such Delaunay meshes for Discrete Exterior Calculus (DEC) because the discrete Hodge star operator can now be correctly defined for such meshes. This operator is crucial for DEC and is a diagonal matrix with the ratio of primal and dual volumes along the diagonal. A correct definition requires that all entries be positive. DEC is a framework for numerically solving differential equations on meshes and for geometry processing tasks and has had considerable impact in computer graphics and scientific computing. Our result allows the use of DEC with a much larger class of meshes than was previously considered possible.
△ Less
Submitted 9 August, 2017; v1 submitted 3 April, 2012;
originally announced April 2012.
-
Numerical Experiments for Darcy Flow on a Surface Using Mixed Exterior Calculus Methods
Authors:
Anil N. Hirani,
Kaushik Kalyanaraman
Abstract:
There are very few results on mixed finite element methods on surfaces. A theory for the study of such methods was given recently by Holst and Stern, using a variational crimes framework in the context of finite element exterior calculus. However, we are not aware of any numerical experiments where mixed finite elements derived from discretizations of exterior calculus are used for a surface domai…
▽ More
There are very few results on mixed finite element methods on surfaces. A theory for the study of such methods was given recently by Holst and Stern, using a variational crimes framework in the context of finite element exterior calculus. However, we are not aware of any numerical experiments where mixed finite elements derived from discretizations of exterior calculus are used for a surface domain. This short note shows results of our preliminary experiments using mixed methods for Darcy flow (hence scalar Poisson's equation in mixed form) on surfaces. We demonstrate two numerical methods. One is derived from the primal-dual Discrete Exterior Calculus and the other from lowest order finite element exterior calculus. The programming was done in the language Python, using the PyDEC package which makes the code very short and easy to read. The qualitative convergence studies seem to be promising.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2011;
originally announced March 2011.
-
PyDEC: Software and Algorithms for Discretization of Exterior Calculus
Authors:
Nathan Bell,
Anil N. Hirani
Abstract:
This paper describes the algorithms, features and implementation of PyDEC, a Python library for computations related to the discretization of exterior calculus. PyDEC facilitates inquiry into both physical problems on manifolds as well as purely topological problems on abstract complexes. We describe efficient algorithms for constructing the operators and objects that arise in discrete exterior ca…
▽ More
This paper describes the algorithms, features and implementation of PyDEC, a Python library for computations related to the discretization of exterior calculus. PyDEC facilitates inquiry into both physical problems on manifolds as well as purely topological problems on abstract complexes. We describe efficient algorithms for constructing the operators and objects that arise in discrete exterior calculus, lowest order finite element exterior calculus and in related topological problems. Our algorithms are formulated in terms of high-level matrix operations which extend to arbitrary dimension. As a result, our implementations map well to the facilities of numerical libraries such as NumPy and SciPy. The availability of such libraries makes Python suitable for prototyping numerical methods. We demonstrate how PyDEC is used to solve physical and topological problems through several concise examples.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2012; v1 submitted 15 March, 2011;
originally announced March 2011.
-
The Least Spanning Area of a Knot and the Optimal Bounding Chain Problem
Authors:
Nathan M. Dunfield,
Anil N. Hirani
Abstract:
Two fundamental objects in knot theory are the minimal genus surface and the least area surface bounded by a knot in a 3-dimensional manifold. When the knot is embedded in a general 3-manifold, the problems of finding these surfaces were shown to be NP-complete and NP-hard respectively. However, there is evidence that the special case when the ambient manifold is R^3, or more generally when the se…
▽ More
Two fundamental objects in knot theory are the minimal genus surface and the least area surface bounded by a knot in a 3-dimensional manifold. When the knot is embedded in a general 3-manifold, the problems of finding these surfaces were shown to be NP-complete and NP-hard respectively. However, there is evidence that the special case when the ambient manifold is R^3, or more generally when the second homology is trivial, should be considerably more tractable. Indeed, we show here that a natural discrete version of the least area surface can be found in polynomial time. The precise setting is that the knot is a 1-dimensional subcomplex of a triangulation of the ambient 3-manifold. The main tool we use is a linear programming formulation of the Optimal Bounding Chain Problem (OBCP), where one is required to find the smallest norm chain with a given boundary. While the decision variant of OBCP is NP-complete in general, we give conditions under which it can be solved in polynomial time. We then show that the least area surface can be constructed from the optimal bounding chain using a standard desingularization argument from 3-dimensional topology. We also prove that the related Optimal Homologous Chain Problem is NP-complete for homology with integer coefficients, complementing the corresponding result of Chen and Freedman for mod 2 homology.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2011; v1 submitted 13 December, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
-
Cohomologous Harmonic Cochains
Authors:
Anil N. Hirani,
Kaushik Kalyanaraman,
Han Wang,
Seth Watts
Abstract:
We describe algorithms for finding harmonic cochains, an essential ingredient for solving elliptic partial differential equations in exterior calculus. Harmonic cochains are also useful in computational topology and computer graphics. We focus on finding harmonic cochains cohomologous to a given cocycle. Amongst other things, this allows localization near topological features of interest. We deriv…
▽ More
We describe algorithms for finding harmonic cochains, an essential ingredient for solving elliptic partial differential equations in exterior calculus. Harmonic cochains are also useful in computational topology and computer graphics. We focus on finding harmonic cochains cohomologous to a given cocycle. Amongst other things, this allows localization near topological features of interest. We derive a weighted least squares method by proving a discrete Hodge-deRham theorem on the isomorphism between the space of harmonic cochains and cohomology. The solution obtained either satisfies the Whitney form finite element exterior calculus equations or the discrete exterior calculus equations for harmonic cochains, depending on the discrete Hodge star used.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2011; v1 submitted 13 December, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
-
Least Squares Ranking on Graphs
Authors:
Anil N. Hirani,
Kaushik Kalyanaraman,
Seth Watts
Abstract:
Given a set of alternatives to be ranked, and some pairwise comparison data, ranking is a least squares computation on a graph. The vertices are the alternatives, and the edge values comprise the comparison data. The basic idea is very simple and old: come up with values on vertices such that their differences match the given edge data. Since an exact match will usually be impossible, one settles…
▽ More
Given a set of alternatives to be ranked, and some pairwise comparison data, ranking is a least squares computation on a graph. The vertices are the alternatives, and the edge values comprise the comparison data. The basic idea is very simple and old: come up with values on vertices such that their differences match the given edge data. Since an exact match will usually be impossible, one settles for matching in a least squares sense. This formulation was first described by Leake in 1976 for rankingfootball teams and appears as an example in Professor Gilbert Strang's classic linear algebra textbook. If one is willing to look into the residual a little further, then the problem really comes alive, as shown effectively by the remarkable recent paper of Jiang et al. With or without this twist, the humble least squares problem on graphs has far-reaching connections with many current areas ofresearch. These connections are to theoretical computer science (spectral graph theory, and multilevel methods for graph Laplacian systems); numerical analysis (algebraic multigrid, and finite element exterior calculus); other mathematics (Hodge decomposition, and random clique complexes); and applications (arbitrage, and ranking of sports teams). Not all of these connections are explored in this paper, but many are. The underlying ideas are easy to explain, requiring only the four fundamental subspaces from elementary linear algebra. One of our aims is to explain these basic ideas and connections, to get researchers in many fields interested in this topic. Another aim is to use our numerical experiments for guidance on selecting methods and exposing the need for further development.
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2011; v1 submitted 8 November, 2010;
originally announced November 2010.
-
Optimal Homologous Cycles, Total Unimodularity, and Linear Programming
Authors:
Tamal K. Dey,
Anil N. Hirani,
Bala Krishnamoorthy
Abstract:
Given a simplicial complex with weights on its simplices, and a nontrivial cycle on it, we are interested in finding the cycle with minimal weight which is homologous to the given one. Assuming that the homology is defined with integer coefficients, we show the following : For a finite simplicial complex $K$ of dimension greater than $p$, the boundary matrix $[\partial_{p+1}]$ is totally unimodula…
▽ More
Given a simplicial complex with weights on its simplices, and a nontrivial cycle on it, we are interested in finding the cycle with minimal weight which is homologous to the given one. Assuming that the homology is defined with integer coefficients, we show the following : For a finite simplicial complex $K$ of dimension greater than $p$, the boundary matrix $[\partial_{p+1}]$ is totally unimodular if and only if $H_p(L, L_0)$ is torsion-free, for all pure subcomplexes $L_0, L$ in $K$ of dimensions $p$ and $p+1$ respectively, where $L_0$ is a subset of $L$. Because of the total unimodularity of the boundary matrix, we can solve the optimization problem, which is inherently an integer programming problem, as a linear program and obtain integer solution. Thus the problem of finding optimal cycles in a given homology class can be solved in polynomial time. This result is surprising in the backdrop of a recent result which says that the problem is NP-hard under $\mathbb{Z}_2$ coefficients which, being a field, is in general easier to deal with. One consequence of our result, among others, is that one can compute in polynomial time an optimal 2-cycle in a given homology class for any finite simplicial complex embedded in $\mathbb{R}^3$. Our optimization approach can also be used for various related problems, such as finding an optimal chain homologous to a given one when these are not cycles.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2011; v1 submitted 2 January, 2010;
originally announced January 2010.
-
Geometric and Combinatorial Properties of Well-Centered Triangulations in Three and Higher Dimensions
Authors:
Evan VanderZee,
Anil N. Hirani,
Damrong Guoy,
Vadim Zharnitsky,
Edgar Ramos
Abstract:
An n-simplex is said to be n-well-centered if its circumcenter lies in its interior. We introduce several other geometric conditions and an algebraic condition that can be used to determine whether a simplex is n-well-centered. These conditions, together with some other observations, are used to describe restrictions on the local combinatorial structure of simplicial meshes in which every simple…
▽ More
An n-simplex is said to be n-well-centered if its circumcenter lies in its interior. We introduce several other geometric conditions and an algebraic condition that can be used to determine whether a simplex is n-well-centered. These conditions, together with some other observations, are used to describe restrictions on the local combinatorial structure of simplicial meshes in which every simplex is well-centered. In particular, it is shown that in a 3-well-centered (2-well-centered) tetrahedral mesh there are at least 7 (9) edges incident to each interior vertex, and these bounds are sharp. Moreover, it is shown that, in stark contrast to the 2-dimensional analog, where there are exactly two vertex links that prevent a well-centered triangle mesh in R^2, there are infinitely many vertex links that prohibit a well-centered tetrahedral mesh in R^3.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2009;
originally announced December 2009.
-
A Dihedral Acute Triangulation of the Cube
Authors:
Evan VanderZee,
Anil N. Hirani,
Vadim Zharnitsky,
Damrong Guoy
Abstract:
It is shown that there exists a dihedral acute triangulation of the three-dimensional cube. The method of constructing the acute triangulation is described, and symmetries of the triangulation are discussed.
It is shown that there exists a dihedral acute triangulation of the three-dimensional cube. The method of constructing the acute triangulation is described, and symmetries of the triangulation are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 11 August, 2009; v1 submitted 22 May, 2009;
originally announced May 2009.
-
Triangulation of Simple 3D Shapes with Well-Centered Tetrahedra
Authors:
Evan VanderZee,
Anil N. Hirani,
Damrong Guoy
Abstract:
A completely well-centered tetrahedral mesh is a triangulation of a three dimensional domain in which every tetrahedron and every triangle contains its circumcenter in its interior. Such meshes have applications in scientific computing and other fields. We show how to triangulate simple domains using completely well-centered tetrahedra. The domains we consider here are space, infinite slab, infi…
▽ More
A completely well-centered tetrahedral mesh is a triangulation of a three dimensional domain in which every tetrahedron and every triangle contains its circumcenter in its interior. Such meshes have applications in scientific computing and other fields. We show how to triangulate simple domains using completely well-centered tetrahedra. The domains we consider here are space, infinite slab, infinite rectangular prism, cube and regular tetrahedron. We also demonstrate single tetrahedra with various combinations of the properties of dihedral acuteness, 2-well-centeredness and 3-well-centeredness.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2008; v1 submitted 13 June, 2008;
originally announced June 2008.
-
Well-Centered Triangulation
Authors:
Evan VanderZee,
Anil N. Hirani,
Damrong Guoy,
Edgar Ramos
Abstract:
Meshes composed of well-centered simplices have nice orthogonal dual meshes (the dual Voronoi diagram). This is useful for certain numerical algorithms that prefer such primal-dual mesh pairs. We prove that well-centered meshes also have optimality properties and relationships to Delaunay and minmax angle triangulations. We present an iterative algorithm that seeks to transform a given triangula…
▽ More
Meshes composed of well-centered simplices have nice orthogonal dual meshes (the dual Voronoi diagram). This is useful for certain numerical algorithms that prefer such primal-dual mesh pairs. We prove that well-centered meshes also have optimality properties and relationships to Delaunay and minmax angle triangulations. We present an iterative algorithm that seeks to transform a given triangulation in two or three dimensions into a well-centered one by minimizing a cost function and moving the interior vertices while keeping the mesh connectivity and boundary vertices fixed. The cost function is a direct result of a new characterization of well-centeredness in arbitrary dimensions that we present. Ours is the first optimization-based heuristic for well-centeredness, and the first one that applies in both two and three dimensions. We show the results of applying our algorithm to small and large two-dimensional meshes, some with a complex boundary, and obtain a well-centered tetrahedralization of the cube. We also show numerical evidence that our algorithm preserves gradation and that it improves the maximum and minimum angles of acute triangulations created by the best known previous method.
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 2009; v1 submitted 14 February, 2008;
originally announced February 2008.
