Waveform for Next Generation Communication Systems: Comparing Zak-OTFS with OFDM
Authors:
Imran Ali Khan,
Saif Khan Mohammed,
Ronny Hadani,
Ananthanarayanan Chockalingam,
Robert Calderbank,
Anton Monk,
Shachar Kons,
Shlomo Rakib,
Yoav Hebron
Abstract:
Across the world, there is growing interest in new waveforms, Zak-OTFS in particular, and over-the-air implementations are starting to appear. The choice between OFDM and Zak-OTFS is not so much a choice between waveforms as it is an architectural choice between preventing inter-carrier interference (ICI) and embracing ICI. In OFDM, once the Input-Output (I/O) relation is known, equalization is re…
▽ More
Across the world, there is growing interest in new waveforms, Zak-OTFS in particular, and over-the-air implementations are starting to appear. The choice between OFDM and Zak-OTFS is not so much a choice between waveforms as it is an architectural choice between preventing inter-carrier interference (ICI) and embracing ICI. In OFDM, once the Input-Output (I/O) relation is known, equalization is relatively simple, at least when there is no ICI. However, in the presence of ICI the I/O relation is non-predictable and its acquisition is non-trivial. In contrast, equalization is more involved in Zak-OTFS due to inter-symbol-interference (ISI), however the I/O relation is predictable and its acquisition is simple. {Zak-OTFS exhibits superior performance in doubly-spread 6G use cases with high delay/Doppler channel spreads (i.e., high mobility and/or large cells), but architectural choice is governed by the typical use case, today and in the future. What is typical depends to some degree on geography, since large delay spread is a characteristic of large cells which are the rule rather than the exception in many important wireless markets.} This paper provides a comprehensive performance comparison of cyclic prefix OFDM (CP-OFDM) and Zak-OTFS across the full range of 6G propagation environments. The performance results provide insights into the fundamental architectural choice.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
Orthogonal Time Frequency Space Modulation
Authors:
Ronny Hadani,
Shlomo Rakib,
Shachar Kons,
Michael Tsatsanis,
Anton Monk,
Christian Ibars,
Jim Delfeld,
Yoav Hebron,
Andrea J. Goldsmith,
Andreas F. Molisch,
Robert Calderbank
Abstract:
This paper introduces a new two-dimensional modulation technique called Orthogonal Time Frequency Space (OTFS) modulation. OTFS has the novel and important feature of being designed in the delay-Doppler domain. When coupled with a suitable equalizer, OTFS modulation is able to exploit the full channel diversity over both time and frequency. Moreover, it converts the fading, time-varying wireless c…
▽ More
This paper introduces a new two-dimensional modulation technique called Orthogonal Time Frequency Space (OTFS) modulation. OTFS has the novel and important feature of being designed in the delay-Doppler domain. When coupled with a suitable equalizer, OTFS modulation is able to exploit the full channel diversity over both time and frequency. Moreover, it converts the fading, time-varying wireless channel experienced by modulated signals such as OFDM into a time-independent channel with a complex channel gain that is essentially constant for all symbols.
This design obviates the need for transmitter adaptation, and greatly simplifies system operation. The paper describes the basic operating principles of OTFS as well as a possible implementation as an overlay to current or anticipated standardized systems. OTFS is shown to provide significant performance improvement in systems with high Doppler, short packets, and/or large antenna array. In particular, simulation results indicate at least several dB of block error rate performance improvement for OTFS over OFDM in all of these settings.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
