Iso-Quality of Service: Fairly Ranking Servers for Real-Time Data Analytics
Authors:
Giorgis Georgakoudis,
Charles J. Gillan,
Ahmed Sayed,
Ivor Spence,
Richard Faloon,
Dimitrios S. Nikolopoulos
Abstract:
We present a mathematically rigorous Quality-of-Service (QoS) metric which relates the achievable quality of service metric (QoS) for a real-time analytics service to the server energy cost of offering the service. Using a new iso-QoS evaluation methodology, we scale server resources to meet QoS targets and directly rank the servers in terms of their energy-efficiency and by extension cost of owne…
▽ More
We present a mathematically rigorous Quality-of-Service (QoS) metric which relates the achievable quality of service metric (QoS) for a real-time analytics service to the server energy cost of offering the service. Using a new iso-QoS evaluation methodology, we scale server resources to meet QoS targets and directly rank the servers in terms of their energy-efficiency and by extension cost of ownership. Our metric and method are platform-independent and enable fair comparison of datacenter compute servers with significant architectural diversity, including micro-servers. We deploy our metric and methodology to compare three servers running financial option pricing workloads on real-life market data. We find that server ranking is sensitive to data inputs and desired QoS level and that although scale-out micro-servers can be up to two times more energy-efficient than conventional heavyweight servers for the same target QoS, they are still six times less energy efficient than high-performance computational accelerators.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
Methods and Metrics for Fair Server Assessment under Real-Time Financial Workloads
Authors:
Giorgis Georgakoudis,
Charles J. Gillan,
Ahmed Sayed,
Ivor Spence,
Richard Faloon,
Dimitrios S. Nikolopoulos
Abstract:
Energy efficiency has been a daunting challenge for datacenters. The financial industry operates some of the largest datacenters in the world. With increasing energy costs and the financial services sector growth, emerging financial analytics workloads may incur extremely high operational costs, to meet their latency targets. Microservers have recently emerged as an alternative to high-end servers…
▽ More
Energy efficiency has been a daunting challenge for datacenters. The financial industry operates some of the largest datacenters in the world. With increasing energy costs and the financial services sector growth, emerging financial analytics workloads may incur extremely high operational costs, to meet their latency targets. Microservers have recently emerged as an alternative to high-end servers, promising scalable performance and low energy consumption in datacenters via scale-out. Unfortunately, stark differences in architectural features, form factor and design considerations make a fair comparison between servers and microservers exceptionally challenging. In this paper we present a rigorous methodology and new metrics for fair comparison of server and microserver platforms. We deploy our methodology and metrics to compare a microserver with ARM cores against two servers with x86 cores, running the same real-time financial analytics workload. We define workload-specific but platform-independent performance metrics for platform comparison, targeting both datacenter operators and end users. Our methodology establishes that a server based the Xeon Phi processor delivers the highest performance and energy-efficiency. However, by scaling out energy-efficient microservers, we achieve competitive or better energy-efficiency than a power-equivalent server with two Sandy Bridge sockets despite the microserver's slower cores. Using a new iso-QoS (iso-Quality of Service) metric, we find that the ARM microserver scales enough to meet market throughput demand, i.e. a 100% QoS in terms of timely option pricing, with as little as 55% of the energy consumed by the Sandy Bridge server.
△ Less
Submitted 30 December, 2014;
originally announced January 2015.
