-
Brief Announcement: Minimizing Energy Solves Relative Majority with a Cubic Number of States in Population Protocols
Authors:
Tom-Lukas Breitkopf,
Julien Dallot,
Antoine El-Hayek,
Stefan Schmid
Abstract:
This paper revisits a fundamental distributed computing problem in the population protocol model.
Provided $n$ agents each starting with an input color in $[k]$, the relative majority problem asks to find the predominant color.
In the population protocol model, at each time step, a scheduler selects two agents that first learn each other's states and then update their states based on what they…
▽ More
This paper revisits a fundamental distributed computing problem in the population protocol model.
Provided $n$ agents each starting with an input color in $[k]$, the relative majority problem asks to find the predominant color.
In the population protocol model, at each time step, a scheduler selects two agents that first learn each other's states and then update their states based on what they learned.
We present the \textsc{Circles} protocol that solves the relative majority problem with $k^3$ states. It is always-correct under weakly fair scheduling.
Not only does it improve upon the best known upper bound of $O(k^7)$, but it also shows a strikingly simpler design inspired by energy minimization in chemical settings.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
An Almost Tight Lower Bound for Plurality Consensus with Undecided State Dynamics in the Population Protocol Model
Authors:
Antoine El-Hayek,
Robert Elsässer,
Stefan Schmid
Abstract:
We revisit the majority problem in the population protocol communication model, as first studied by Angluin et al. (Distributed Computing 2008). We consider a more general version of this problem known as plurality consensus, which has already been studied intensively in the literature. In this problem, each node in a system of $n$ nodes, has initially one of $k$ different opinions, and they need…
▽ More
We revisit the majority problem in the population protocol communication model, as first studied by Angluin et al. (Distributed Computing 2008). We consider a more general version of this problem known as plurality consensus, which has already been studied intensively in the literature. In this problem, each node in a system of $n$ nodes, has initially one of $k$ different opinions, and they need to agree on the (relative) majority opinion. In particular, we consider the important and intensively studied model of Undecided State Dynamics.
Our main contribution is an almost tight lower bound on the stabilization time: we prove that there exists an initial configuration, even with bias $Δ= ω(\sqrt{n\log n})$, where stabilization requires $Ω(kn\log \frac {\sqrt n} {k \log n})$ interactions, or equivalently, $Ω(k\log \frac {\sqrt n} {k \log n})$ parallel time for any $k = o\left(\frac {\sqrt n}{\log n}\right)$. This bound is tight for any $ k \le n^{\frac 1 2 - ε}$, where $ε>0$ can be any small constant, as Amir et al.~(PODC'23) gave a $O(k\log n)$ parallel time upper bound for $k = O\left(\frac {\sqrt n} {\log ^2 n}\right)$.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
Fully Dynamic Approximate Minimum Cut in Subpolynomial Time per Operation
Authors:
Antoine El-Hayek,
Monika Henzinger,
Jason Li
Abstract:
Dynamically maintaining the minimum cut in a graph $G$ under edge insertions and deletions is a fundamental problem in dynamic graph algorithms for which no conditional lower bound on the time per operation exists. In an $n$-node graph the best known $(1+o(1))$-approximate algorithm takes $\tilde O(\sqrt{n})$ update time [Thorup 2007]. If the minimum cut is guaranteed to be $(\log n)^{o(1)}$, a de…
▽ More
Dynamically maintaining the minimum cut in a graph $G$ under edge insertions and deletions is a fundamental problem in dynamic graph algorithms for which no conditional lower bound on the time per operation exists. In an $n$-node graph the best known $(1+o(1))$-approximate algorithm takes $\tilde O(\sqrt{n})$ update time [Thorup 2007]. If the minimum cut is guaranteed to be $(\log n)^{o(1)}$, a deterministic exact algorithm with $n^{o(1)}$ update time exists [Jin, Sun, Thorup 2024]. We present the first fully dynamic algorithm for $(1+o(1))$-approximate minimum cut with $n^{o(1)}$ update time. Our main technical contribution is to show that it suffices to consider small-volume cuts in suitably contracted graphs.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2025; v1 submitted 19 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
On $b$-Matching and Fully-Dynamic Maximum $k$-Edge Coloring
Authors:
Antoine El-Hayek,
Kathrin Hanauer,
Monika Henzinger
Abstract:
Given a graph $G$ that is modified by a sequence of edge insertions and deletions, we study the Maximum $k$-Edge Coloring problem Having access to $k$ colors, how can we color as many edges of $G$ as possible such that no two adjacent edges share the same color? While this problem is different from simply maintaining a $b$-matching with $b=k$, the two problems are closely related: a maximum $k$-ma…
▽ More
Given a graph $G$ that is modified by a sequence of edge insertions and deletions, we study the Maximum $k$-Edge Coloring problem Having access to $k$ colors, how can we color as many edges of $G$ as possible such that no two adjacent edges share the same color? While this problem is different from simply maintaining a $b$-matching with $b=k$, the two problems are closely related: a maximum $k$-matching always contains a $\frac{k+1}k$-approximate maximum $k$-edge coloring. However, maximum $b$-matching can be solved efficiently in the static setting, whereas the Maximum $k$-Edge Coloring problem is NP-hard and even APX-hard for $k \ge 2$.
We present new results on both problems: For $b$-matching, we show a new integrality gap result and for the case where $b$ is a constant, we adapt Wajc's matching sparsification scheme~[STOC20].
Using these as basis, we give three new algorithms for the dynamic Maximum $k$-Edge Coloring problem: Our MatchO algorithm builds on the dynamic $(2+ε)$-approximation algorithm of Bhattacharya, Gupta, and Mohan~[ESA17] for $b$-matching and achieves a $(2+ε)\frac{k+1} k$-approximation in $O(poly(\log n, ε^{-1}))$ update time against an oblivious adversary. Our MatchA algorithm builds on the dynamic $8$-approximation algorithm by Bhattacharya, Henzinger, and Italiano~[SODA15] for fractional $b$-matching and achieves a $(8+ε)\frac{3k+3}{3k-1}$-approximation in $O(poly(\log n, ε^{-1}))$ update time against an adaptive adversary. Moreover, our reductions use the dynamic $b$-matching algorithm as a black box, so any future improvement in the approximation ratio for dynamic $b$-matching will automatically translate into a better approximation ratio for our algorithms. Finally, we present a greedy algorithm that runs in $O(Δ+k)$ update time, while guaranteeing a $2.16$~approximation factor.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2025; v1 submitted 2 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Time Complexity of Broadcast and Consensus for Randomized Oblivious Message Adversaries
Authors:
Antoine El-Hayek,
Monika Henzinger,
Stefan Schmid
Abstract:
Broadcast and consensus are most fundamental tasks in distributed computing. These tasks are particularly challenging in dynamic networks where communication across the network links may be unreliable, e.g., due to mobility or failures. Indeed, over the last years, researchers have derived several impossibility results and high time complexity lower bounds (i.e., linear in the number of nodes $n$)…
▽ More
Broadcast and consensus are most fundamental tasks in distributed computing. These tasks are particularly challenging in dynamic networks where communication across the network links may be unreliable, e.g., due to mobility or failures. Indeed, over the last years, researchers have derived several impossibility results and high time complexity lower bounds (i.e., linear in the number of nodes $n$) for these tasks, even for oblivious message adversaries where communication networks are rooted trees. However, such deterministic adversarial models may be overly conservative, as many processes in real-world settings are stochastic in nature rather than worst case.
This paper initiates the study of broadcast and consensus on stochastic dynamic networks, introducing a randomized oblivious message adversary. Our model is reminiscent of the SI model in epidemics, however, revolving around trees (which renders the analysis harder due to the apparent lack of independence). In particular, we show that if information dissemination occurs along random rooted trees, broadcast and consensus complete fast with high probability, namely in logarithmic time. Our analysis proves the independence of a key variable, which enables a formal understanding of the dissemination process.
More formally, for a network with $n$ nodes, we first consider the completely random case where in each round the communication network is chosen uniformly at random among rooted trees. We then introduce the notion of randomized oblivious message adversary, where in each round, an adversary can choose $k$ edges to appear in the communication network, and then a rooted tree is chosen uniformly at random among the set of all rooted trees that include these edges. We show that broadcast completes in $O(k+\log n)$ rounds, and that this it is also the case for consensus as long as $k \le 0.1n$.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2024; v1 submitted 23 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Brief Announcement: Broadcasting Time in Dynamic Rooted Trees is Linear
Authors:
Antoine El-Hayek,
Monika Henzinger,
Stefan Schmid
Abstract:
We study the broadcast problem on dynamic networks with $n$ processes. The processes communicate in synchronous rounds along an arbitrary rooted tree. The sequence of trees is given by an adversary whose goal is to maximize the number of rounds until at least one process reaches all other processes. Previous research has shown a $\lceil{\frac{3n-1}{2}}\rceil-2$ lower bound and an $O(n\log\log n)$…
▽ More
We study the broadcast problem on dynamic networks with $n$ processes. The processes communicate in synchronous rounds along an arbitrary rooted tree. The sequence of trees is given by an adversary whose goal is to maximize the number of rounds until at least one process reaches all other processes. Previous research has shown a $\lceil{\frac{3n-1}{2}}\rceil-2$ lower bound and an $O(n\log\log n)$ upper bound. We show the first linear upper bound for this problem, namely $\lceil{(1 + \sqrt 2) n-1}\rceil \approx 2.4n$. Our result follows from a detailed analysis of the evolution of the adjacency matrix of the network over time.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2023; v1 submitted 21 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Asymptotically Tight Bounds on the Time Complexity of Broadcast and its Variants in Dynamic Networks
Authors:
Antoine El-Hayek,
Monika Henzinger,
Stefan Schmid
Abstract:
Data dissemination is a fundamental task in distributed computing. This paper studies broadcast problems in various innovative models where the communication network connecting $n$ processes is dynamic (e.g., due to mobility or failures) and controlled by an adversary.
In the first model, the processes transitively communicate their ids in synchronous rounds along a rooted tree given in each rou…
▽ More
Data dissemination is a fundamental task in distributed computing. This paper studies broadcast problems in various innovative models where the communication network connecting $n$ processes is dynamic (e.g., due to mobility or failures) and controlled by an adversary.
In the first model, the processes transitively communicate their ids in synchronous rounds along a rooted tree given in each round by the adversary whose goal is to maximize the number of rounds until at least one id is known by all processes.
Previous research has shown a $\lceil{\frac{3n-1}{2}}\rceil-2$ lower bound and an $O(n\log\log n)$ upper bound. We show the first linear upper bound for this problem, namely $\lceil{(1 + \sqrt 2) n-1}\rceil \approx 2.4n$.
We extend these results to the setting where the adversary gives in each round $k$-disjoint forests and their goal is to maximize the number of rounds until there is a set of $k$ ids such that each process knows of at least one of them. We give a $\left\lceil{\frac{3(n-k)}{2}}\right\rceil-1$ lower bound and a $\frac{π^2+6}{6}n+1 \approx 2.6n$ upper bound for this problem.
Finally, we study the setting where the adversary gives in each round a directed graph with $k$ roots and their goal is to maximize the number of rounds until there exist $k$ ids that are known by all processes. We give a $\left\lceil{\frac{3(n-3k)}{2}}\right\rceil+2$ lower bound and a $\lceil { (1+\sqrt{2})n}\rceil+k-1 \approx 2.4n+k$ upper bound for this problem.
For the two latter problems no upper or lower bounds were previously known.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2023; v1 submitted 18 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
