Towards a Quality Indicator for Research Data publications and Research Software publications -- A vision from the Helmholtz Association
Authors:
Wolfgang zu Castell,
Doris Dransch,
Guido Juckeland,
Marcel Meistring,
Bernadette Fritzsch,
Ronny Gey,
Britta Höpfner,
Martin Köhler,
Christian Meeßen,
Hela Mehrtens,
Felix Mühlbauer,
Sirko Schindler,
Thomas Schnicke,
Roland Bertelmann
Abstract:
Research data and software are widely accepted as an outcome of scientific work. However, in comparison to text-based publications, there is not yet an established process to assess and evaluate quality of research data and research software publications. This paper presents an attempt to fill this gap. Initiated by the Working Group Open Science of the Helmholtz Association the Task Group Helmhol…
▽ More
Research data and software are widely accepted as an outcome of scientific work. However, in comparison to text-based publications, there is not yet an established process to assess and evaluate quality of research data and research software publications. This paper presents an attempt to fill this gap. Initiated by the Working Group Open Science of the Helmholtz Association the Task Group Helmholtz Quality Indicators for Data and Software Publications currently develops a quality indicator for research data and research software publications to be used within the Association. This report summarizes the vision of the group of what all contributes to such an indicator. The proposed approach relies on generic well-established concepts for quality criteria, such as the FAIR Principles and the COBIT Maturity Model. It does - on purpose - not limit itself to technical implementation possibilities to avoid using an existing metric for a new purpose. The intention of this paper is to share the current state for further discussion with all stakeholders, particularly with other groups also working on similar metrics but also with entities that use the metrics.
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2024; v1 submitted 16 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
Enhancing Flood Impact Analysis using Interactive Retrieval of Social Media Images
Authors:
Björn Barz,
Kai Schröter,
Moritz Münch,
Bin Yang,
Andrea Unger,
Doris Dransch,
Joachim Denzler
Abstract:
The analysis of natural disasters such as floods in a timely manner often suffers from limited data due to a coarse distribution of sensors or sensor failures. This limitation could be alleviated by leveraging information contained in images of the event posted on social media platforms, so-called "Volunteered Geographic Information (VGI)". To save the analyst from the need to inspect all images p…
▽ More
The analysis of natural disasters such as floods in a timely manner often suffers from limited data due to a coarse distribution of sensors or sensor failures. This limitation could be alleviated by leveraging information contained in images of the event posted on social media platforms, so-called "Volunteered Geographic Information (VGI)". To save the analyst from the need to inspect all images posted online manually, we propose to use content-based image retrieval with the possibility of relevance feedback for retrieving only relevant images of the event to be analyzed. To evaluate this approach, we introduce a new dataset of 3,710 flood images, annotated by domain experts regarding their relevance with respect to three tasks (determining the flooded area, inundation depth, water pollution). We compare several image features and relevance feedback methods on that dataset, mixed with 97,085 distractor images, and are able to improve the precision among the top 100 retrieval results from 55% with the baseline retrieval to 87% after 5 rounds of feedback.
△ Less
Submitted 9 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
